8 Amazing Wrestlers That Flopped In WWE's Ruthless Aggression Era

'Ruthless Aggression' wasn't exactly kind to these otherwise-incredible WWE stars.

Vince McMahon Ruthless Aggression WWE Raw 2002
WWE

There was plenty of greatness to be found in WWE's 'Ruthless Aggression' era. It was rammed with unforgettable rivalries and superstars who will be remembered for generations. However, as is the case with much of Vince McMahon's 21st Century output, there was just as much in the way of bad creative and overlooked, mismanaged superstars.

From some of the biggest names in wrestling tanking their stock at McMahon's behest, to even some of Vince's best creations having the worst runs of their careers, the 'Ruthless Aggression' days had plenty of superstars with abilities that frankly deserved better. Not everything can be laid at the doorstep of WWE creative, naturally. Some of these wrestlers were simply unable to stand out next to the meteoric rise of future greats like John Cena, Edge, Randy Orton and Batista.

Whichever way you slice it, these superstars flopped during the RA era. Most of the ones included here had immense careers away from 'Ruthless Aggression', be that in a different time period or when performing for other companies that found a way to make the most of their talents.

These are just some of the performers who suffered in WWE during the 2000s post-'Attitude'.

8. Goldberg

Goldberg The Rock
WWE

Even though WCW had done significant damage to the aura of Goldberg in its final 2 years, the signing of one of the company's biggest ever homemade stars in the 'Ruthless Aggression' era was cause for excitement. His in-ring work was limited, but having a murderer’s row of villains to do battle with in WWE should have led to Goldberg having a run in WWE that was fun at the very least.

As it was, Goldberg was thrown headfirst into a feud with The Rock.

The gulf in class between their respective microphone abilities, plus Rocky’s enormous popularity, was an awful way of drumming up support for Bill in his new home. Instead of working against different opponents like Kane or Batista that may have been able to help him build momentum, he was fed to The Rock and Triple H in quick succession and things went as badly as you'd imagine. 

Despite holding the old World Title and being booked strongly, it was too much to ask of Bill to go from his turgid final months in WCW to conquering some of the most charismatic names in WWE. Ending with another middling feud opposite Brock Lesnar in a historically bad match at WrestleMania XX, Goldberg fell drastically below par during his year-long run during the post-'Attitude' days.


7. Sean O'Haire

Sean O'Haire Devil's Advocate
WWE.com

Again, the last days of WCW were a real slog, but the emergence of Sean O’Haire was one of the few bright spots. A big man with killer in-ring skills and a Swanton Bomb to die for (re-dubbed as the excellently named Sean-ton Bomb), O’Haire was one half of the final WCW Tag-Team Champs outside of Vince McMahon's clutches, and it felt like he had everything needed to succeed at the highest level.

It was heavily rumored that Eric Bischoff wanted to showcase O’Haire as his leading man if his WCW bid had been successful, but that wasn’t to be. Instead, O’Haire was signed to WWE, given a minimal part in the awful Invasion angle, and sent to OVW to become more accustomed to WWE’s in-house style. He was then handed a weak, American Psycho-lite 'Devil’s Advocate' gimmick, in which he tried to corrupt the audience and fellow superstars into succumbing to their vices. 

This failed and was dropped after a few weeks, after which O’Haire was put with a returning Roddy Piper.

When Piper was let go for giving a controversial interview away from WWE, O’Haire was left high and dry. With no replacement plan put in place, he was sent back to OVW before being released in April 2004. There were misdemeanors away from the ring, too, but O’Haire had talent far beyond what he showcased in the 'Ruthless Aggression' era.


6. 'Sheriff' Steve Austin

Eric Bischoff Steve Austin WWE Raw 2003
WWE

'Stone Cold' Steve Austin is rightfully heralded as one of the very best pro wrestlers of all time, but that doesn’t mean everything he did turned to gold. After his team lost to 'Team Bischoff' at Survivor Series 2003, Austin was supposed to be gone from WWE forever.

Just over a month later, he returned as 'Sheriff' Austin, essentially running Raw as a de facto GM.

It feels bananas to describe Austin as a hindrance, but his 'Sheriff' gimmick was essentially Steve just taking up airtime by driving an ATV around recklessly, doing little of note, and offering next to nothing to the shows he was booked on. He always got a great pop from the live audience, as it’s always nice to be in the presence of one of the all-time greats, but 'Stone Cold' was being shoehorned into angles where he wasn’t needed and not really affecting anything at all.

He did little to stop the devious doings of Evolution, and it was sad to see Austin as an ineffectual on-screen presence for the first and possibly only time in his career.


5. Gail Kim

Gail Kim Women's Championship
WWE

It’s worth remembering that WWE’s women’s division was in a very different place during the 'Ruthless Aggression' era compared to where it is today. The prospect of a totally new talent turning up on Monday Night Raw and winning the Women’s Title on her first night is virtually unfathomable in 2026, no matter how talented they may be. However, that is exactly what Gail Kim achieved when she won a women’s Battle Royal to claim the Women’s belts on the 30 June 2003 episode of the flagship.

This next statement shouldn’t downplay Kim’s talents whatsoever; as she’s proven wherever she has performed, Gail is a total badass, but this period in WWE’s history was largely about Trish Stratus and Lita. All roads usually led to or went through them. As such, Kim only ever felt like one of the other many talents propping up the division due to WWE’s formulaic and stale booking.

The 4-week reign she enjoyed with the title after her debut is the only run she ever had with that strap, this despite having 2 runs in the company. She returned to WWE between 2008-2011 after initially being released in November 2004. By contrast, the Canadian legend is a 7-time TNA Knockouts Champion and arguably the greatest female performer in that company's history. 

What could've been, eh?


4. Rikishi

Rikishi Usos 060215 01
www.wwe.com

Despite being one of the most recognisable faces of the 'Attitude Era', Rikishi had a topsy-turvy time of things in WWE. He's loved for his stink-facing, body-popping antics with Too Cool, and maligned for a heel run that never quite hit the way it should have. Nevertheless, he was an agile big man with an iconic look who should have thrived under Paul Heyman’s tutelage on SmackDown during the 'Ruthless Aggression' period.

That was not to be.

In truth, big Kish was nothing more than a peripheral figure in his final few years, finding himself involved in boring feuds like his spat with Roddy Piper that involved him seeking revenge for the volatile Scotsman’s famous coconut attack on Jimmy Snuka. Surely there had to be something better for the big man than harbouring a grudge for a coconut attack from 20 years before?!

After spending much of 2003 failing to grab fans’ attention, Rikishi eventually returned to his most popular gimmick, forming a tag team with Scotty 2 Hotty for another run as Too Cool. They had a 2-month reign with the tag team titles before Rikishi was released in July 2004.


3. Scott Steiner

WWE Survivor Series 2002 Scott Steiner Debut
WWE.com

Scott Steiner was one of the very few bright spots in the final years of WCW. His cartoonish physique and unfiltered personality made him one of the superstars that fans most wanted to see in WWE after Vince McMahon bought the company. The 'Attitude Era' might have been over, but Steiner’s over-the-top personality and unfiltered aggression should have been perfect for the maniacal billionaire, but it wasn’t to be.

After debuting inside the hallowed halls of Madison Square Garden at Survivor Series 2002 to a thunderous ovation and laying waste to Matt Hardy and Chris Nowinski, this 'Genetic Freak' went straight into a feud with Triple H. Again, this felt like a good fit on paper, but their matches at the Royal Rumble and No Way Out 2003 for the World Heavyweight Championship  went together like toothpaste and orange juice.

In other words, they bombed.

This misery led to Steiner not even having a match at WrestleMania XIX. His PPV appearances in 2003 largely included either teaming with or battling against Test in WWE's lower midcard, and he was gone from the company entirely shortly after competing in the 2004 Rumble.

His plight remains a criminal misuse of talent, but Scotty still has a place in fan hearts to this day. 


2. Ultimo Dragon

Ultimo Dragon WWE
WWE

Japanese wrestling royalty Ultimo Dragon could have been a superstar for WWE, especially given his pedigree in both WCW and in his homeland. A former IWGP Junior Heavyweight Champion who went on to have runs with both the Cruiserweight belt and Television Title in WCW (including high-profile matches with Dean Malenko, Steven Regal and Eddie Guerrero), things sadly never really got going for Ultimo Dragon after he signed with WWE in 2003.

Despite being an incredible in-ring technician, Dragon is best known for a series of slips at WrestleMania XX. Entering Madison Square Garden like a man with Castrol on his soles, Dragon slipped as he made his way to the entrance ramp, and did the same again as he went to pose on the turnbuckle.

It was mortifying.

That summed up his time in WWE's system in a microcosm. He was used largely in the television graveyards of Heat and Velocity, and WWE continually tried (and failed) to use Ultimo and other men of his size to recreate the cruiser scene that had been such a blast in ECW and WCW in the late 90s and early 2000s.


1. The Mexicools

Mexicools wwe
WWE.com

Let's get this out of the way from the start: There is no reality in which a team called The Mexicools could ever succeed. Mexican culture is filled with passion, vibrancy and creativity through all of the arts, food and culture, but if you were to ever call a God-like invention such as the burrito or breathtaking Mayan architecture as "Mexicool", you would instantly diminish its value.

Super Crazy was one of the cornerstones of ECW, Psicosis was a pioneer who introduced Lucha style to the American wrestling landscape, and Juventud Guerrera has held major titles in the world's most important wrestling markets. That trio placed in a stable was a mouth-watering prospect, especially when put into combat with the 'Ruthless Aggression' era's roster.

Calling them 'The Mexicools', however, ensured there was no way in which they could succeed. 

The group's presentation was insultingly stereotypical, riding lawnmowers and playing up to demeaning cliches. These 3 men have a body of work between them that could stun wrestling fans of any era. To be saddled with this ridiculous gimmick (that never even flirted with getting over) was so far beneath them it beggars belief. 


Contributor

Terry Bezer hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.