8 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite: New Year's Smash (Jan 6)

Kenny Omega battles Rey Fenix, Bullet Club reforms, and Snoop Dogg guest stars.

Bullet Club AEW
AEW

A semblance of normality returned to All Elite Wrestling's weekly programming last night, as the promotion unleashed the first New Year's Smash show one week later than planned, though things will never be truly normal in this company ever again.

Rest in power, Jon Huber. Last week's Celebration of Life was as crushing and gutwrenching as it was cathartic. The organisers couldn't have done a better job of honouring a beloved 41-year-old taken from his wife, two children, friends, and fans entirely too soon. It hurt, but it was beautiful, and while the eternal hope is to never have to go through it again, Brodie Lee was done proud. Long live the 'Exalted One'.

Headlined by a potentially blistering AEW World Championship match between the incumbent Kenny Omega and Rey Fenix, this lineup was originally intended for 30 December. It ended up starting AEW's 2021 on an exciting note. While far from the best two hours the promotion has produced on TNT, New Year's Smash closed on one of the biggest angles in Dynamite history, welcomed Snoop Dogg into AEW, and delivered a calorific sugar rush of a main event.

Elsewhere, Hikaru Shida put the AEW Women's World Title on the line against Abadon, Darby Allin debuted his new TNT Title design, and Wardlow met Jake Hager in a big beefy battle.

Let's light the fuse...


Downs...

3. Let's Switch Sting Up

Sting Darby Allin
AEW

A pattern is already forming in Sting's AEW appearances.

Dude shows up with his dramatic entrance whenever Darby Allin is in a hairy situation, warding off Team Taz in the process. He and the TNT Champion will lock eyes, drawing closer each weak, giving the impression that 'The Icon' is aligned with his spiritual successor without showing every card in his hand, maintaining an element of ambiguity.

It's becoming repetitive. Week after week, we see a slight variation on the same thing, and it's time to switch it up a little. A more creative use for Sting must be found in order for the Allin parallels and Team Taz animosity to bloom.

Last night was more of the same, with Sting hitting the ring after Allin had challenged Team Taz's entire lineup to throw down after his weigh-in with Brian Cage. Fine, in a bubble, but the "save" spot is becoming cliché now.

That new TNT Championship design looks cool, though.


2. Dogg Splash

Snoop Dogg
AEW

Celebrity guests getting over on full-time, contracted talent is bad when WWE do it, and it was bad here as well, as Snoop Dogg hit the top rope for a shaky Five Star Dogg Splash on Serpentico after he and Luther had jumped Cody Rhodes following a win over Matt Sydal.

'Snakeman' was held down by Sydal and Rhodes and as an undercard wrestler, he doesn't need protection. This is no great burial. Still, the famous non-wrestler bloke getting moves in on somebody we are supposed to receive as a professional combatant is rarely a good look, as was that case here.

That being said, props to Snoop for actually doing it. His execution was endearingly messy.


1. Horror Show

Hikaru Shida
AEW

Hikaru Shida vs. Abadon was abject, and the worst possible start for a division that badly needs to rebuild in 2021, but at least it's over. 'The Full Metal Champion' beat the monster clean, in the middle of the ring, with her finisher, ending a useless rivalry that had blighted Dynamite for too long.

Goofy cartoon "violence" was the theme here. Abadon, who according to Jim Ross "lives a very unique lifestyle," kept trying to bite Shida throughout. Recovering from a kendo stick shot after a failed entrance ambush, Abadon went for Shida's flesh several times, succeeding only after dragging Hikaru under the ring, with Shida's neck bloodied when she emerged a few seconds later.

If this was a horror movie, it'd be straight-to-DVD and the bottom of the bargain bucket.

The zombie stuff would have been more palatable if the actual wrestling was any good, but it wasn't. Shida's intensity aside, this was sloppy and janky, particularly when Abadon was in control. While her gimmick is easily her most marketable aspect, it may be getting in the way of her work, which was all over the place even against a capable carrier in Shida.

Let's elevate a Britt Baker, Thunder Rosa, or Serena Deeb now that this tripe is out of the way.


Ups...

8. Wardlow Brings The Beef

Wardlow Jake Hager
AEW

There was just enough about Wardlow's performance for the Jake Hager match to finish on the positive side of the ledger.

MJF's heavy was excellent, here, shaking a sleepy match to life by leaping and rolling his way out of the corner, Lucha style, from the rushing Jake, before launching him around the ring with release suplexes. The ease with which 'Mr. Mayhem' controlled a 275lb man as if he was weightless was impressive and Wardlow's big comeback signalled an upturn in explosiveness and intensity. In the end, he scored a clean, decisive win via F10 - the right move.

Hager, unfortunately, entered the kind of performance his critics lap up. Slow, ponderous, and largely devoid of fire, this was a lame, second-gear effort from a decorated collegiate wrestler whose other job involves throwing his fists at peoples' faces for real. It shouldn't be this way.

MJF checked in on an angry Hager after the match, pouring cold water on his rage. "You're still undefeated in the Octagon!", MJF said, slipping in a glorious dig at Jake's failure on the night, though 'The Big Hurt' thanked him for coming in.


7. Young Boy Business

Miro Chuck Taylor
AEW

With Trent sidelined for four-to-five months, Miro vs. Chuck Taylor becomes the central focus of an ongoing storyline that took on a new theme at New Year's Smash.

AEW's Drip God interrupted Taylor and Orange Cassidy's interview with Dasha. Talking down to Chuck, he said it was time to stand up and be a man, not stand behind his allies like Trent's young boy. This clearly resonated with Taylor, who was goaded into committing to being Miro's own young boy until Kip Sabian and Penelope Ford's wedding if he loses to the former Rusev next week.

Simple, effective, and functional, this got us to a hook that should hopefully make this stuttering feud a tad more interesting, elevating it beyond material like "grown man gets upset over broken videogame."


6. Fiat vs. Ferrari

Marko Stunt FTR
AEW

This Jurassic Express/FTR interaction was similar to the Chuck Taylor/Miro segment in that the babyface side dug a hole for themselves that they might not be able to escape from.

Cash Wheeler and Dax Harwood were extremely patronising here, telling Marko Stunt he was a glorified mascot who brings nothing to the table, letting Luchasaurus and Jungle Boy do his dirty work. Brodie Lee Jr. was right about him, they said. In response, Marko stood up to FTR, announcing that he'd take Luchasaurus' spot in the upcoming match with Dax and Cash so he could "beat their *ass", sealing his own fate.

"It's like a Fiat vs. a Ferrari" Dax said before Tully literally petted Stunt's head, with the heels taking their leave.

Again, the babyface got insulted into accepting a situation that doesn't benefit them in any way at all. FTR will take a lopsided victory over an under-strength Jurassic Express team without Luchasaurus, which, as bullies, makes perfect sense.


5. Moxley's Perfect Explanation

Jon Moxley
AEW

Jon Moxley finally returned to AEW television last night, cutting a pitch-perfect promo that enhanced his status as a tough, gritty babyface in the wake of the Kenny Omega loss and gave a great explanation for him not interfering in 'The Cleaner's' match with Rey Fenix.

Though Mox has "zero tolerance for sh*tty people," he poured his heart and soul into protecting the integrity of the AEW World Championship for the best part of a year. Fenix had scratched and clawed his way to a title shot, getting there the right way, and Moxley, with his honour and integrity, wouldn't violate that. Striking during the match would have spoiled everything his title run was about and undermined Fenix in the process.

"One day, you are going to look into the eyes of the devil and realise you crossed the wrong guy," Moxley said, signing off after a typically strong promo that successfully built anticipation for what would come later in the evening.


4. Rhodes & Sydal Go Big

Cody Rhodes Matt Sydal
AEW

Yes, the Dogg Splash spot was rubbish, but Cody Rhodes vs. Matt Sydal was a fun television bout that began with Sydal setting a brisk pace, leaving 'The Prince of Pro Wrestling' struggling to keep up. A Meteora to the outside almost wiped Snoop out, an errant blow to Serpentico set up the post-match angle, and the action was tight and competitive throughout, with Cody hitting two Cross Rhodes to eventually put Sydal away.

Snoop was a lot of fun during the bout itself. His remixed version of Cody's ring entrance heralded 'The American Nightmare's' arrival and the idea of him playing the Arn Anderson role, calling Rhodes' wrestling plays, is too preposterous not to be entertaining. A hoot.

Elsewhere, Snoop was backstage with Private Party and Matt Hardy, bringing the juice for Isiah Kassidy's gin. A tidy gag to compliment a segment that saw Kassidy and Marq Quen sign 30% of their earnings over to Hardy in exchange for whatever he brings to the table.


3. A Ripping Opener

Young Bucks SoCal Uncensored
AEW

AEW's big multi-man tags are usually well-crafted, utilising their many moving parts strongly. This one was no different. Incorporating The Young Bucks' existing beefs with The Acclaimed and TH2, as well as their mutual respect for SoCal Uncensored (who have their own issues with the heel teams), we got a fast, popping opening match that moved from spike to spike effortlessly.

Things started hot with all eight wrestlers spiking the adrenaline. Things slowed down before the heels worked Christopher Daniels over, though the pace was picked up when Matt Jackson faked a Moonsault to dive to the outside. Risky Business scored a close two-count after this and as the match unfolded, it was peppered with each team's flavour, meaning it was about everything anyone could ask for in this spot.

Daniels and Matt collaborated on the Best Meltzer Ever for the finish. Frankie Kazarian grabbed the stick afterwards, holding onto his promise that he and Daniels would split after their next loss, but asserting that they'd have the Bucks' back any time they needed them.

Given what happened after the main event, put money on the Bucks defeating the sentimental veteran team, cruelly forcing them to split.


2. Omega & Fenix Shoot Fireworks

Kenny Omega Rey Fenix
AEW

This didn't come close to hitting Rey Fenix or Kenny Omega's ceiling. From their track records (together and apart), we know both are capable of hitting the MOTYC tier in the right spot - which this wasn't. This was a television main event with a four-week build.

Rather than going for a grander story, Fenix and Omega prioritised fireworks. This match was all about generating excitement through creative athletic spots, as the duo matched each other athletically and strategically, their spots progressively building in impressiveness.

Fenix flipping off the top rope to hit a move best described as a Sunset Flip German Suplex (?!) looked incredible. Later, he bounced straight up from a V-Trigger, clocked Omega with a kick, then collapsed in a heap, delaying his selling. A Cutter from the inside out had Kenny rocked but catching Rey's dive and dropping him with a modified Tiger Driver gave 'The Cleaner' the match's most impressive offensive burst.

More than anything else, this match was a playground for the wrestlers to perform cool, unique exchanges, some of which you may never have seen before, without sacrificing basic pro wrestling psychology. While not as substantial as their best work, it was pretty to look at - and pretty great on the whole.


1. The Band Gets Back Together

Bullet club AEW
AEW

The first big AEW angle of 2021 went down as an old version of Bullet Club seemingly reformed, with The Young Bucks feigning reluctance before joining Kenny Omega and the invading Good Brothers in an in-ring Too Sweet, closing New Year's Smash.

Jon Moxley was the most notable casualty here. He assaulted Omega with a barbed wire bat when Kenny tried to beat Fenix up after the bell, only to be felled by Karl Anderson and Doc Gallows, making their AEW debuts. Hordes of ringside AEW wrestlers were felled as they tried to interfere. The Bucks were peacekeepers at first, trying to talk their old allies down, before blasting Brian Pillman Jr. and Griff Garrison with Superkicks, cementing the apparent turn.

This fits together nicely, as Omega is set to team with The Good Brothers on next week's Impact Wrestling pay-per-view. It's a natural progression of the Impact/AEW storyline that has been bubbling away on AXS. Then, of course, is their vast shared history, with these five wrestlers spending over a year together in NJPW before Gallows and Anderson departed for WWE, which is a nice platform to build on.

That the announcers had to talk around the Too Sweet gesture means this group won't get the Bullet Club branding, though this matters little. An exciting new faction formed on Dynamite last night. Elite or otherwise, they're about to have AEW in a stranglehold.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.