8 Ups And 5 Downs From WWE Raw (Feb 10)
Shayna gets primal, Orton gets sadistic, KO and Rollins get repetitive.
If you’re grading Monday Night Raw these days, it’s been earning a solid “B” or "B+" since the Royal Rumble, with some standout performances, but some areas that are still lagging.
This week’s show was similar, with an outstanding, visceral segment to really sell a new rivalry, while we saw a ongoing major storyline continue to tread water rather than churn forward.
Becky Lynch finally dispatched a great and tough rival, only to find a new challenger who really wants to sink her teeth into The Man – literally. However, we also endured objectively good promo and match segments involving Kevin Owens and Seth Rollins, but they could have been re-runs from previous episodes.
Rhea Ripley has been thrust into the spotlight, but it remains unclear whether she’s ready to shine against Charlotte Flair. But Drew McIntyre looked like a million bucks. Aleister Black delivered once again. And Randy Orton is sowing the seeds for a barnburner of a feud with Edge.
There’s plenty to be excited about on the Raw side heading into WrestleMania, but there still are several question marks. There’s plenty of time for things to work themselves out, or for things to fall apart. But Raw has been enjoyable recently, and it gets better than passing marks this week.
With that said, let’s get to it…
Downs...
5. Wooden Interviewer Needs To Go
The days of outstanding backstage interviewers like Mean Gene Okerlund or even notables like Kevin Kelly and a young Michael Cole are long gone, but that doesn’t mean we should just let the current crop become part of the scenery and ignore their performances.
While Charly Caruso has shown to be adept and more than capable of carrying a segment, her Raw colleague Sarah Schreiber is a nightmare. She’s wooden, unconvincing and almost cringeworthy every time she’s on camera. She sounds like she’s reading her question off a cue card that she’s just seen for the first time with all the conviction of a junior high understudy.
We’re not asking for the next Mean Gene, but when you could just put the mic on a stand and let wrestlers walk up to it and it feel more authentic, you need to reevaluate whether someone is adding to the product, or taking away from it.
In Schreiber’s case, she’s a detriment in nearly every segment she’s in.
4. Wait, Rusev’s Still Alive?
This is not a knock on WWE actually announcing a match ahead of a PPV, but when it causes you to stop and question things, it’s not a good thing.
During Raw, a graphic announced a Tuwaiq Trophy Gauntlet Match, pitting six wrestlers against each other for a new trophy. Among the six was Rusev, who has not been seen on WWE TV in three weeks. (Word going around is that Rusev is in contract negotiations/dispute with WWE, hence his absence.)
From a storyline perspective, this is just damn odd. Rusev hasn’t bothered to show up to continue the feud that was a centerpiece of Raw for months on end, but he’s randomly announced for a PPV match in two-plus weeks (which also involves Bobby Lashley).
Why? Just why? They could have handled this better. If they were planning on bringing Rusev back for Super Showdown, why take him completely off Raw without the storyline getting an ending?
3. Same Ol’, Same Ol’
If you missed the opening promo from Seth Rollins this week but caught any of his diatribes the past few weeks, you’re already up to speed.
Rollins chattered about being the Monday Night Messiah and then put down Kevin Owens, which drew KO out. Owens brought the Viking Raiders with him and a brawl ensued. This all felt very familiar, with the bonus of Samoa Joe sneak-attacking Rollins with a Coquina Clutch in the ring.
It can’t be a home run every week, but when you feel like you’re watching a variation on a theme for the third time, it’s not a good feeling. Something needs to move forward with this storyline, because if it’s just leading to KO versus Rollins at WrestleMania, it could be a long eight weeks.
2. Forward Motion Would Be Nice
To follow on the opening promo that felt like it was a repeat of recent weeks, we also once again got to see a match involving Kevin Owens (and some combination of cohorts) losing to Seth Rollins’ army in Monday’s main event.
The eight-man tag match was fine from an action standpoint, and Rollins stealing the victory yet again is to be expected, but when you look back and realize that KO and his buddies have been on the losing end of this feud every week for more than a month, you have to wonder where this is leading, if anywhere at all.
The Viking Raiders have lost their Raw Tag Team Championships. Samoa Joe got injured. Owens has been on the losing end of these matches in four of the last five weeks. If they were outnumbered, you could understand, but they just keep getting outfoxed.
This isn’t a huge negative – KO getting the drop next week and turning the corner would absolve a lot of this, but between the promos and match outcomes, it’s getting a little to repetitive and is in need of some forward motion.
1. Still Not Feeling Ripley
Watching NXT, there’s no doubt that Rhea Ripley is a big deal. Her title win over Shayna Baszler was a huge deal, and she’s been built up as a big star in the making.
But it still feels like too much too fast by having her show up on Raw and challenge Charlotte Flair to use her Royal Rumble title shot on the NXT Women’s Championship. Ripley just won the title a couple months ago and has defended it once, against Toni Storm (who’s beaten Rhea multiple times).
This doesn’t feel like a dominant champ from NXT challenging the best WWE has to offer. It feels like a young, brash champion trying to step to a Flair. And yet, that’s not how it’s being presented. Had Ripley held the title for a few months and defeated a series of challengers in NXT, this might be firing on all cylinders.
But as of right now, it’s hard to get overly invested in this storyline, aside from the fact it will probably be a good match, and it could make a major star if WWE goes all-in on Rhea.
Ups...
8. Every Man For Himself
Mojo Rawley looks like a goof, but he’s got no one to blame but himself.
The Street Profits made short work of Rawley and his “offensive lineman” Riddick Moss, but the real action came afterward, as the Profits celebrated in the crowd. Mojo leaned over to talk to Moss, but Riddick quickly grabbed a small package, allowing the referee to count to three, giving Moss the 24/7 Championship. (The 24/7 title defense had been waived for the duration of the match.)
That might be the first time a tag partner turned on the 24/7 champ after a bout ended, and it made Moss out to be smart, looking like he quickly took the fall and then lied in wait.
Rawley is no R-Truth, but it will be interesting to see if he can carry the division, even for the next few weeks as he tries to get the title back.
7. Black Is A Caged Animal
Aleister Black’s post-match promos have been intriguing, but they’ve been hit-or-miss with clarity of message.
Monday’s promo after kicking Akira Tozawa’s head off was pretty damn clear: He’s a caged animal, but if you get in the ring with him, you’re the one trapped in the metaphorical cage with him.
That’s a damn cool visual, and with a guy who has just been going out recently and beating the tar out of lower-tier wrestlers weekly, that promo rings true. It’s really a shame that there isn’t a title for him to fight for at this time, because if they wanted to start building him up to a United States Championship shot, that could work.
Hopefully, a door will open for Black, who has more than proven himself between NXT and WWE as an accomplished wrestler who has enough of an aura to him to be someone special on the main roster.
6. Garza Gets The Duke
After a scintillating Raw debut last week, Angel Garza needed to back it up with a nice performance Monday night.
We got just that when Garza cleanly defeated Cedric Alexander on Raw, hitting a Wing Clipper for the pin. But before the match could begin, Garza’s cousin Humberto Carrillo attacked him, leading to a pull-apart brawl that actually had the fans chanting, “Let them fight!”, which is always a great sign for a feud.
The reports from last week were all over the map as to whether Garza is permanently up on Raw or just filling time while Andrade serves his 30-day suspension. But if he continues to get reactions like Monday, there’s a good chance we could see a new star budding on the red brand.
5. Lynch, Asuka Throw Down One More Time
Becky Lynch and Asuka have chemistry, there’s just no denying it. Monday night was no excuse.
The Empress of Tomorrow and The Man hooked it up for their third women’s title match, with this being the rubber match (as it were). The two had a solid back-and-forth match in which Becky and Asuka kept battling for their submission finishers. Kairi Sane of course got involved a bit, but it wasn’t a distraction from the match. There was a really nice sequence toward the end with both women trading rollups while grabbing for each other’s arm.
But Lynch changed strategies, catching a charging Asuka with a Rock Bottom for the decisive pin, retaining her Raw Women’s Championship. Good match, good finish.
4. A Win Without Being The Lucky Underdog
WWE has a formula it loves to employ whenever they have a David versus Goliath match.
If the smaller wrestler is bound to win, s/he often gets pummeled on for the majority of the match and shows a ton of heart by overcoming the opposition and manages to eke out a victory, sometimes by pure luck.
It’s a hackneyed cliché, and it doesn’t do anything to help build up the smaller wrestler, as everyone knows s/he was lucky to get past the larger opponent. And oftentimes, it doesn’t lead to any great advancement.
Monday, Ricochet faced the larger Bobby Lashley in the lead-up to his WWE Championship match against Brock Lesnar. And while Lashley is much bigger and stronger, Ricochet controlled large portions of their match, hitting a series of high-impact moves, while Lashley took control with a couple big moves of his own but didn’t spend the whole match beating the #1 contender down.
It was good to see WWE resist its normal inclinations in this case. This doesn’t mean the WWE philosophy has changed, but it was good to see it ignored for at least a week.
3. MVP Gets The VIP Treatment
You knew things weren’t going to end well for the returning MVP the minute he took a swipe at the fans.
The former WWE superstar hosted the VIP Lounge and welcomed Drew McIntyre for a chat Monday night, but it was more of a desperate pitch to talk himself back into relevance (in storyline). MVP played up how proud he was of Drew, but noted that “some people” don’t think he’s ready to be world champion. He then suggested that McIntyre needed a business manager to handle the naysayers out there.
McIntyre immediately pounced, comparing the proposition to the relationship Brock Lesnar has with Paul Heyman before declaring he didn’t need an ass-kisser to talk and think for him. MVP made the mistake of grabbing Drew, which led to a Claymore upending the VIP Lounge set.
This worked just fine at letting Drew show a little more personality without pandering to the fans and kept the heat on his WrestleMania title match without Brock around.
2. Baszler Gets Primal
Some might say that Shayna Baszler’s official Raw debut was a bit campy, but let’s face it: We’ve seen wrestlers show up and jump a champ to get heat and set up a title feud.
But what we haven’t seen before is a wrestler jumping a champ and then biting them until they bled, leaving the ring with blood streaming from their mouth. That’s what Baszler did, removing her mouthguard and sinking her teeth into Becky Lynch’s neck, drawing “blood” and leaving to huge boos while Becky writhed on the mat.
If Lynch had been a blonde, this would have been more effective, as her already-red hair only got modestly darker due to the crimson liquid. But as far as a memorable debut, this worked just fine. It got Shayna over as an opportunistic thug who would stoop to any level to take down The Man.
This had the added benefit of Becky then cutting a scorching promo upon her return from the hospital, vowing to track her down, which is the kind of Man we need around WrestleMania season.
The question is, will they pull the trigger at Mania, or have Becky vanquish another challenger? Time will tell.
1. Hardy Makes Impassioned Plea
The moment Randy Orton was interrupted by Matt Hardy, you knew where the segment was going to end. But the journey to get there was still entertaining.
Orton was out to attempt once again to explain his despicable attack on Edge two weeks ago, but Hardy interjected, demanding to know why Randy did it. He then went down a path of tracing his and Edge’s long, storied history, but diving way back to the early days to show how close they were, revolutionizing the ladder match and creating the TLC match. Matt said he buried his hatred for Edge after the Rated-R Superstar was forced to retire in 2011 due to injury.
But then Hardy asked Orton, “What in the hell is wrong with you?”, prompting Randy to attack. Hardy fought back, but he quickly succumbed to an RKO, and then a one-man conchairto.
The Viper soaked in the boos that rained down before leaving. Man oh man, the roof is gonna blow off whatever arena where Edge returns to confront Orton.