8 Ups And 9 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 31

WWE manages to make chicken salad out of poorly hyped event.

To say that WrestleMania Play Button was not the most eagerly anticipated Mania in history would be an understatement. Expectations were low for this event, with fans and critics alike having issues with just about every aspect of the direction of WWE lately. Very few angles and feuds since Royal Rumble have been well regarded €“ or in some cases, tolerated. Roman Reigns€™ big coronation at the Rumble blew up in WWE€™s face, while the fall of Daniel Bryan has been tragic for anyone who believed in him. Bray Wyatt has been wrestling with shadows, while seven men have traded the Intercontinental Championship €“ but not in matches. John Cena has been tasked with doing what Big E, Jack Swagger, Mark Henry, Big Show and Zach Ryder could not do: Stand up for America against the Evil Russian. All of this led to a WrestleMania that was poorly hyped and could have been a disaster. However, there was the potential that if certain things clicked well, WWE could still deliver a solid show. And surprisingly, enough things went well make this a watchable and enjoyable WrestleMania. No, it won€™t go down as one of the better Manias of all time, but a couple surprise developments certainly helped raise the bar for WrestleMania 31.


DOWNS€

9. Silence The Music

For some reason, WWE loves to have live musical performances at WrestleMania. Maybe it€™s because they are harkening back to the Rock €˜n Wrestling Connection. And Skylar Grey and Kid Ink performed the officials Mania themes, so at least they were there for a purpose. However, nearly every concert performance at WrestleMania deserves the same criticism of being woefully out of place and a waste of time. Basically, unless you€™re playing a wrestler down to the ring €“ such as Living Colour for CM Punk or Motorhead for Triple H €“ you really don€™t have much of a reason to be performing at WrestleMania. If WWE was so hellbent on having a musician perform at WrestleMania, have it at the tail end of the kick-off show to welcome fans to Mania, not right in the middle of the event to completely kill the momentum.

8. Way Past His Prime

When WWE shook up its announce teams a few months ago, it was a strange thing to not see or hear Jerry €œThe King€ Lawler on Raw. After all, he€™s been a constant voice on WWE€™s flagship program for nearly all of Raw€™s run. But his absence has only magnified what many fans have known for the past few years: Lawler has reached a point in his career where he should be put out to pasture. That fact was on full display during WrestleMania, with Lawler€™s bad jokes (€œIt€™s a good thing the Divas aren€™t mind-readers. If they were, I€™d get slapped.€), silly observations and high-pitched yelling detracting from the event rather than adding to it. The King will forever receive and deserve a great deal of respect from fans, but it€™s reached the point where tradition has to give way to progress. There are plenty of better color men in waiting €“ Booker T, William Regal, Corey Graves. It€™s time to give them a chance.

7. Rusev Gets Crushed

This was bound to happen at some point in the near future. Rusev could not stay undefeated forever, and once it turned into a Cold War-esque battle, it was pretty obvious that the Bulgarian Brute had to lose. The good news here is that Rusev is talented enough to still be a solid player even without his undefeated streak. This isn€™t one of those occasions where the streak defines the wrestler. But having John Cena end the streak is just a waste. Quite simply, Cena has accomplished everything there is to accomplish in between his first U.S. Championship title reign 11 years ago and this one. He€™s a 15-time world champion and two-time Royal Rumble winner. Cena defeating Rusev doesn€™t give him some new rub, and Rusev isn€™t stronger for losing to Cena (but he€™s also not weaker). The downside here is that WWE could have actually built someone up to take down Rusev. Instead of sticking Dolph Ziggler in the Intercontinental Championship ladder match, why couldn€™t he have been built up the past couple months? He was riding high after winning at Survivor Series and could have used that as a springboard to beat Rusev. Instead, we got Cena Rising Above Russia. At least the €œRocky IV€ motif is now complete.

6. WWE Network Programming

What in the blue hell is up with the WWE Network? And more importantly, who do the people who run it think they€™re appealing to with the new programs that were announced at WrestleMania? Jerry Springer? A cartoon of superstars as kids at camp? The 2015 Diva Search? This is not exactly instilling a feeling of confidence that WWE gets what the Network can be. The company owns the tape libraries of WCW, AWA, Memphis, Stampede, World Class and a host of old NWA territories. They have a litany of superstars and legends who can help contribute material for new programs. Instead, they advertise a Jerry Spring €œToo Hot for TV€ program and €œSwerved,€ which was described only as being a product of the makers of Jackass and Bad Grandpa€ as if that is supposed to mean something. The only show that has any direct relevance to WWE wrestling is the Diva Search, which isn€™t exactly a shining example of what is right with WWE. That program could run counter to the Give Divas a Chance movement if the description as being a mixture of €œAmerica€™s Next Top Model€ and €œReal Housewives.€

5. Big Buzzkill

It€™s tough to have hate for the Big Show, who by all means seems to be a decent human being. But as a character, Big Show is the absolute worst. His constant face-heel turns and poor booking has left him as a larger version of X-Pac €“ fans find it hard to care or get invested in him as a performer. So it€™s only natural that Big Show wins the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal. While it€™s a career achievement for the 20-year veteran, it€™s the manner in which Show did it that was so insanely frustrating. In the span of the match, Big Show eliminated Hideo Itami, Cesaro, Ryback and Damien Mizdow, all crowd favorites who really were the only ones in the match fans truly were invested in. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2YZyivfgfY It€™s as if Vince McMahon was reading Twitter and wrestling websites all week, figured out who the fans really like and then had his biggest heat vacuum eliminate all of them.

4. This Crossover Promotion Should Be Terminated

After all the buildup as a serious match, Triple H made his grand entrance €“ and came out accompanied by a series of terminators as part of a crossover promotion with the upcoming Terminator movie. Maybe it was the fact that it was broad daylight instead of nighttime, but the entire entrance just fell flat. The result was Sting standing there staring at Triple H as he rose from underneath the stage more confused than afraid. Compare Triple H€™s entrance with Rusev riding a Russian tank into battle. The entire thing was a forced crossover promotion that evoked memories of Robocop saving Sting in WCW. And that is not a good thing.

3. A Shell Of Himself

For 21 years, the Undertaker dominated WrestleMania. During most of the past decade, the Deadman€™s Mania matches have been one of the highlights of the event, as he seemed to turn back the clock each year and put on an incredible performance. That changed last year when Brock Lesnar defeated Undertaker and ended his WrestleMania streak. The match itself wasn€™t up to par, which fans learned later was due in part to Taker suffering a concussion during the match. But the defeat also sapped a lot of Undertaker€™s mystique, and it showed Sunday night. Fans still popped for Taker€™s entrance, his Old School ropewalk and of course the Tombstone Piledriver. But the majority of his match with Bray Wyatt left fans sitting in silence as Wyatt beat on a slow, staggering Undertaker. This was the first time where the fact that Taker is 50 years old really came crashing down. He looked dominated overmatched, not just by Bray, but by wrestling a physical match. The worst part is that after carrying this entire feud on his back the past two months, Bray lost his second straight WrestleMania match. Now, Taker will fade back into the shadows until next year (presumably), while Bray will have to show up on Raw and try to convince fans that he€™s still relevant and force to be reckoned with.

2. WCW Loses€ Again

Sting versus Triple H was painted as a major battle between two wrestling icons of the Monday Night Wars. Given the age of the two competitors, it was expected that there would be some shortcuts taken to prop up the match, but no one could have predicted the depths to which WWE would sink. WWE gave fans a poor man€™s revision of the Monday Night Wars, with D-Generation X and the New World Order coming out to back their respective standard-bearers as the match completely broke down. What could have been a classic battle that showed that Sting could still compete at a high level devolved into an absolute overbooked mess. It€™s really a shame. A DX-nWo feud is a dream for any longtime fan, but in 2015, it makes absolutely no sense. (And didn€™t the nWo spend most of its existence fighting against Sting?) Yes, there€™s the markout factor of seeing all these legends together and seeing DX and the nWo finally mix it up, but what a horrible, horrible booking decision. And of course, Triple H won the match by hitting Sting with a sledgehammer. All of the buildup of Sting for the past six months just evaporated into thin air as Sting failed to take down Triple H. All hail the King of Kings.

1. The Roman Empire Falls

For the second year in a row, WWE put its faith in a muscular superstar to march into WrestleMania as a conquering hero, and for the second straight year, a smaller, more athletic man emerged as the WWE World Heavyweight Champion. It has to be frustrating for the WWE brass to invest so heavily into Roman Reigns, only to see fans revolt at his Royal Rumble victory and every step along the way on the Road to WrestleMania. By the time we reached Mania, it was plainly obvious that the Roman Reigns experiment was a failure, regardless of Vince McMahon€™s wishes, will and ignorance. Once Brock re-signed with WWE, it was clear that Reigns wasn€™t leaving Mania with the title. And he didn€™t. But worse than that, Reigns didn€™t even reach John Cena levels of a 50-50 split of crowd reaction. The WrestleMania faithful were overwhelmingly anti-Roman, which might spell the end of his rocket push. We€™ll see if he€™s sent shuttling back down the card. Probably the best thing for him right now would be to team back up with Dean Ambrose (who€™s also lost his Shield luster) and try to rebuild their careers.

UPS€

8. IC Ladder Match Delivers

Disregard the title-snatching that created this feud, otherwise, you€™ll drive yourself crazy. Once WWE announced a seven-man ladder match for the Intercontinental Championship, it became clear that this was going to be a spectacular car crash, and an entertaining one at that. Thankfully, everyone delivered on that promise. The participants worked in several of their signature spots in different ways, which also added to the fun of the match: Daniel Bryan hitting his corner dropkicks with Bad News Barrett sandwiched by a ladder, Barrett pulling Ziggler off the ladder into a Bullhammer elbow, and Ziggler slapping a sleeper on Luke Harper while he climbed the ladder. Now that that€™s over, hopefully most of the participants can go on to real feuds and not fight over stealing a title.

7. YEStleMania, Part 2

Let€™s not pretend that Daniel Bryan€™s first Intercontinental Championship victory is a victory for Bryan and his legion of fans. It€™s really just a consolation prize for the fans and the man they propelled to the main event of WrestleMania 30 last year. Bryan has fallen from winning the WWE World Heavyweight Championship last year to curtain-jerking and winning a secondary title that was being stolen on a weekly basis. All that being said, Bryan€™s IC title victory at WrestleMania 31 is still a nice moment for him given how far he had fallen in recent months. Plus, maybe, just maybe, this will lead to the Intercontinental Championship being elevated to its former prominence. Doing that will take time, but if Bryan is booked as a fighting champion who actually defeats all comers, then this all will have been for something. The post-match rub from WWE legends (and former IC champs) Pat Patterson, €œRowdy€ Roddy Piper, Ricky €œThe Dragon€ Steamboat, Ric Flair and Bret €œHitman€ Hart was a nice tribute. Kudos to Flair for giving Steamboat a chop, calling back to their legendary NWA feud.

6. Mizdow Stands Up For Himself

Although things didn€™t work out in the end for Damien Mizdow, he still managed to get his WrestleMania moment, not only standing up to his boss, the Miz, but eliminating him from the battle royal. Fans were solidly behind Mizdow €“ as they have been for months €“ and they hate Miz, which bodes well for a feud between the two. It will be interesting to see how things shake out with this development, as the Miz/Mizdow storyline is one of the few that WWE has consistently done well, tweaking the original stunt double gimmick just when it was becoming stale and teasing just enough at Mizdow revolting until Sunday€™s eruption. But now that Mizdow is standing on his own, will he end up like former Miz protégé Alex Riley and land on the scrap heap, or will he finally break through?

5. Divas Shine In The Spotlight

Rebuilding the Divas division into a serious, competitive group is going to take some time. It€™s not going to happen overnight, but Sunday€™s tag team match between the Bella twins and AJ Lee and Paige was a good start in the right direction. In recent weeks, WWE has seemed to take the Give Divas a Chance movement to heart, giving the female wrestlers more time to develop real matches. That continued at WrestleMania, with the Bellas, AJ and Paige delivering a fast-paced match that featured some solid moves, along with a nice little story with the Bellas repeatedly knocking AJ off the apron. If WWE is indeed serious about giving the women wrestlers a chance, then this is a good first step, especially considering that the mixed tag match at WrestleMania 29 was bumped for time and the Vickie Guerrero Invitational at Mania last year was a 14-woman car crash.

4. The Future Will Have To Wait

Early in the Randy Orton-Seth Rollins match, the announcers commented that Orton was in the prime of his career. It might seem like Orton has been around forever, but he only turns 35 this week, so the announcers aren€™t blowing smoke. In recent months, Rollins has showed that he is one of the biggest stars of WWE€™s future. He€™s proven himself in main event matches over and over. He easily has been one of the brightest spots during a somewhat dark time. When the Authority refers to Rollins as the future, that also isn€™t hyperbole. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QBwXS5lxeU The two had an awesome match at WrestleMania. Orton showed that the teacher can top the student, suckering Rollins into going for a curbstomp, only to pop him up into a vicious, eye-catching RKO. Some might argue that Rollins should have won, but you can€™t argue with how the wily veteran used a little trickery to beat the young lion. Rollins will have his day €“ and probably sometime pretty soon €“ but Orton was the better man this day.

3. The Ultimate Crossover Promotion

Not all crossovers are created equal. While the Terminator looked horribly out of place during Triple H€™s entrance, bringing UFC Women€™s Bantamweight Champion Ronda Rousey out to help her €œFurious 7€ costar the Rock against the Authority was a deliciously perfect WrestleMania moment. That appearance made perfect sense, and it even had some symmetry given Rousey€™s appearance at SummerSlam to watch Stephanie McMahon€™s match against Brie Bella. Stephanie got in Rock€™s face and asked whether he€™d hit a woman, then kicked him out of her ring. The Great One spotted his costar, Rousey, and brought her into the ring, sending fans into a frenzy. The idea of Rousey stepping into a WWE ring has been the subject of much speculation for some time now, but seeing her and Rock squaring off against the Authority €“ and then sending them fleeing €“ was simply unreal. The question isn€™t one of €œWill they?€ but more of €œWhen will they?€ It€™s only a matter of time before Rousey steps into a WWE ring for a match, but whether that happens at SummerSlam, WrestleMania 32 or sometime down the line.

2. Slugfest In San Francisco

The WWE World Heavyweight Championship match between Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns had the potential to be an absolute trainwreck, but instead it became an old school, big match slugfest, with both wrestlers throwing bombs at each other right away. Reigns busted Lesnar open early on, while Brock threw Roman around the ring like a sack of potatoes. Brock yelling €œWelcome to Suplex City, b*tch!€ was gold. As much as the fans universally hated Reigns, his laughing as he got pounded was a nice touch. He absorbed as much of the onslaught as possible and found his opening (with the help of the ringpost) before delivering a series of Superman punches and spears to nearly topple the Beast. Throw in some hardway bleeding €“ which is really effective when it almost never happens in matches anymore €“ and you had a match deserving of the main event. The interesting thing about this match is that Lesnar carried it. Reigns had not really had a great singles match before this one, and Brock€™s methodical beating really worked well. Here€™s hoping he gets a bonus for every dozen suplexes he throws.

1. The Future Stars Now

So about that whole Randy Orton is the present and Seth Rollins€™ time will come€ Apparently, that time was only a matter of three hours later. With Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns down during their WWE World Heavyweight Championship, Rollins finally cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase to become world champ, pinning Reigns after a curbstomp. It was an absolutely brilliant move by WWE. What a perfect way to get the title off Lesnar without hurting him and without having the wildly unpopular Reigns win. Lesnar beat Reigns from pillar to post and looked dominant in defeat, while Reigns has a legit gripe about deserving a title shot (as do Lesnar and Orton). It also provided a great shock ending to WrestleMania that fans won€™t soon forget. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jy4g_eMkhHs Rollins has been perfecting his chicken heel persona, and now he has a world championship to go with it. At the same time, Rollins can back it up in the ring. The question is whether Brock comes right after him or if Reigns gets the first shot. Either way, Rollins will undoubtedly have the Authority to back him up, which will make this a fun storyline to follow. That future development, coupled with the memorable PPV ending, put an exclamation point on WrestleMania 31.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.