8 Ways WWE Can Reinvent Seth Rollins
With Seth Rollins getting booed now more than ever, is it time to "burn it down" and start over?
What can be done with Seth Rollins?
The babyface turned arsonist is quickly becoming one of the most hated men in the company. And not on purpose, either. But Hell in a Cell just capped off a period of over six months of awful booking dating back to WrestleMania.
Unfortunately, the idea to make him Universal Champion seemed based more on short term milking of the final Shield reunion than his long term booking plans.
Despite a fantastic short program with AJ Styles for Money in the Bank, Rollins had a lackluster run with the belt thanks in no small part to Baron Corbin and Lacey Evans. This led to him dropping to Lesnar, only to win it again in a seemingly desperate attempt to reinvent Seth. And it almost worked.
He regained momentum fast, earning his rematch in a number one contender match, becoming the second ever two time Universal champion, and the only wrestler to beat Lesnar at WrestleMania and SummerSlam. The Beast Slayer became a fitting (albeit played out) nickname.
Seth even grabbed a record tying fifth Raw tag team championship with Braun to become double champion, and defeated Strowman the night they lost those belts at Clash of Champions. Despite Rollins' tone-deaf foot-in-mouth nature on social media, and boring promos throughout, this run felt more real. The proverbial ship, broken hull and all, was finally righting course. Until we got to Hell in a Cell. They just had to book that match.
Now they need to start rebuilding "The Architect" once again.
8. Let The Fiend Destroy Him
Apparently, WWE knows they really screwed up. So much so, they felt the need to address this concern in the name of the match at Crown Jewel. Yes, the first ever officially titled Falls Count Anywhere "Can't Be Stopped For Any Reason" match will take place in Saudi Arabia on the afternoon of Halloween. Don't screw this up this time, Vince.
The match booking here should be very simple: let The Fiend come as close to murdering Seth Rollins as will be allowed in Saudi Arabia. OK, bad choice of words admittedly. But the point remains: let him destroy Seth Rollins.
There really should be no other reason to book this match. Sure, if Bray does take the victory here then he will take the red belt to the blue brand, but that isn't what this is about anymore. Bray needs this to save his character, and so does Seth.
If WWE wants to avoid the title change here, they can still avoid a finish. Not the best outcome, but having The Fiend beat the piss out of him all around the arena until he can't stand on his own two stomping feet should suffice regardless.
The bell doesn't even need to ring: as long as the damage is done they can play this off as not being a "match" at all. Bray could then disappear, his point proven and his next victim claimed as he prophesied. No need for a pinfall or traditional contest, because very fittingly for Halloween, he is just a monster looking for blood.
Does it blatantly spit in the face of rules as if it were Carlito and the said rules weren't cool? Absolutely. But what stopped them before?
Most everyone will be satisfied by seeing Rollins destroyed, and The Fiend will be restored. But if Seth was smart he would be better off to...
7. Let The Fiend In
Leading into Seth burning down the Firefly Funhouse were some interesting moments. Bray popped up in the middle of Rollins beating him down and pleading with Seth. That may be more important than just making you question Wyatt's sanity. This could mean The Fiend got his first follower.
Constantly uttering the phrase "let me in" whilst donning the mask and Fiend persona, we have yet to see what that actually means. Many have fantasy booked Liv Morgan becoming a disciple of this philosophy. But what if that is already happening with Seth?
With Seth knowing the location of the Funhouse and hellbent on malicious intent, could Rollins have already (perhaps through no choice of his own) let him in? This would make sense as to why Seth ignored Bray's cries for him to stop, and his fixation with burning it down.
With the struggling dual personalities of Bray and his alter ego, it would make sense that the "evil side" would hate everything about the Funhouse. It represents all of Bray's former personas with his puppets and his lighter side. And it also broadcasts the darker intentions behind the other half. Eliminating that could help The Fiend lurk in the shadows a bit more, ready to claim victims unwillingly. And Seth could be the puppet for the Fiend starting his own "show".
If this turns out to be true, it could lead to a much more interesting and darker version of Seth. And that may be for the best, as we should probably...
6. Embrace Him As Heel
After the horrible reaction to him burning the Funhouse down, this may be the only option left. And there are signs this could be the case already.
Seth's match against Humberto Carrillo on Raw felt very much like he was playing the heel role. Spouting off remarks like "you're not ready" and "you have a long way to go" before (almost regrettably by his body language) shaking his hand afterwards. Could this be WWE finally leaning into his accidental heel turn?
It remains to be seen, but this could be the best move going forward. After all, he is certainly not getting any better at playing the face, as evidenced by recent comments about Kenny Omega and Will Ospreay. Fans are only going to let their opinions known more and more each day.
And besides his real life antics, Rollins has always been more entertaining and better suited as the bad guy anyway. Him pissing his pants at the sight of Wyatt every week after all the terrible Corbin feuds hasn't exactly painted him as the next Hulk Hogan.
Plus trying to be the good guy so badly and fighting this uphill battle has got to be driving Seth crazy. Which actually may be worth exploring.
In fact, if it is making him insane, then...
5. Let Him Go Insane
After a taxing run with The Fiend mentally, both in and out of character mind you, this may be just the thing Rollins needs. Just don't go full mental breakdown and turn him into a pyromaniac. Nobody needs that side of the Attitude Era back.
But remember when Seth went mad for a few weeks and started eliminating everybody who wanted to be Corbin's special guest referee with a chair? That was exactly the type of crazy badass that could help turn Seth back around. And it also allows WWE to keep him as one of their top babyfaces.
Returning this steel chair gimmick, you could start having Seth go on a bit of a downward spiral mentally. After ending his program with The Fiend at Crown Jewel, (assuming he leaves champion) have him start defending his belt every week. But rather than defend his belt cleanly, he can just beat the hell out of anybody who dares face him with his steel chair companion. Leaving all heel challengers to his belt unable to compete, he can finally start to feel strong again.
Think back to that "Seth Rollins is not cool" fan from Hell in a Cell. He is right currently, but WWE and Seth should be focused on proving those who believe that wrong. Getting his edge back by letting him have a badass run might be the best way to bring him back to the top.
4. Return To Tag Team Wrestling
Teased a bit with his brief run with Braun Strowman, a return to his tag team roots might be just the cure for this "Seth Rollins is not cool" disease.
By no means should this be an Ambrose-removed version of The Shield however. It's time they all officially leave that chapter of their career in the past. Instead, Rollins should be looking to help build the future.
With young stars like Humberto Carrillo, Cedric Alexander and Ricochet fighting for relevance on the three hour show now, having somebody like Rollins teaming with them could be a great launching point. We already saw what that title match did to catapult Humberto into quick (and mostly Power Ranger meme-induced) internet fame.
And if they do decide to make Rollins heel, the same effect could be given to somebody like Buddy Murphy, or to perhaps relaunch the newly heel Shelton Benjamin. The point is that rather than souring Seth's fall from grace further, make it a bit more... well graceful.
And being that they share the red brand, if Rollins does go full heel mode to coincide with this it even leads to a potential grouping with The O.C. A group boasting Rollins and Styles as their top two members to go with the (usually/supposedly) dominant Gallows and Anderson looks much more imposing than the iteration that WWE is slowly burying at the moment.
Or perhaps, Rollins creates a new "club" of his own...
3. Form A New Stable
Capitalizing on the same principle as pairing him with younger talent in a tag team, this has the added benefit of hiding Seth in a crowd until the fans stop hating him so much. Or until WWE decides to embrace that hatred and build upon it as mentioned before. Whichever comes first, really.
Either scenario could lead to a great shine for some newer stars making their way to Raw. And with Seth being the leader, the success of the group will naturally rub off on him as well. And with the nice bit of storytelling that stables lead to, (when done right) their inevitable separation could result in a great turn or feud in the future for Seth.
As seen with his exit from The Shield, ending a stable in a big way can lead to big things for all involved. Dean Ambrose used this launching point to she shed his cocoon, and went on to open his wings and reinvent himself as Jon Moxley. The now international star is better than ever in his new home main eventing for AEW. Roman Reigns went on to become one of WWE's cornerstones, and Rollins became a two time Universal champion.
It is safe to say when done right, a stable can be a great turning point or even launching point for a wrestler's career. And using Rollins' experience as "The Architect" this time in a leadership role might help him actually recover from this terrible Bray Wyatt nightmare.
2. Make Him The "New Triple H"
Or we could go a completely different direction with reinventing him. Ever since adopting the pedigree into his arsenal, the Triple H comparisons were always going to begin. And that was further cemented when he pinned The Game with his own finisher at WrestleMania 33. Why not lean into it even more?
Having Rollins become the new version of Triple H would mean taking victories even when controversial in nature. That is a big part of Hunter's history. Look to examples like Batista at WrestleMania 35, or the competitors at the 2016 Royal Rumble, or Sheamus at WrestleMania XXVI: the list goes on forever with these types of examples.
The point is that Seth defeating The Fiend was a very controversial decision, and one directly tied with Vince McMahon. Embracing that fan knowledge may be the best thing here. This can morph the narrative to being the McMahons protecting their new "golden child" in Seth and it might actually turn that bad booking around for the better.
This also gives a potential alternate ending at Crown Jewel, especially since Saudi Arabia always tends to bring older stars such as Triple H. Having them end the match in a controversial way once again at a controversial event with the help of Seth's old friend would draw a massive amount of heat. If pulled off correctly, there might be no better way to launch a brilliant heel run at the top than turning Rollins into the new Triple H in this sort of extraordinary fashion.
But really, any way is better than the current way.
1. Burn Him Down
The common theme throughout here is change. Some sort of reinvention to help save Seth Rollins and save WWE from themselves.
They managed to ruin what could've been two good Universal championship reigns with poor booking and overly scripted promos. And rather than listen to the bad reception, WWE seems to want to give us more of the same.
Repeatedly chanting "burn it down" has given heat to Rollins' promos in the worst ways. People are flaming him because he has come to represent a lot of the mistakes WWE continues to make. Forcing hot catchphrases that go on merchandise down our throats and booking strange finishes to potentially great contests has become as synonymous with Seth as it is with Vince. And none of that is his fault, he is being a good company guy. But that is where both WWE and Rollins are blind to the problem.
He is too much of what the company wants. The overcoming all odds babyface who manages to do nothing with the title because nobody is connecting to him. Because Seth Rollins feels nothing like a real person.
Rollins needs to come back refreshed to change that. Perhaps a new look, new haircut, new gimmick, new theme music. Whatever it needs to be, they need to "burn it down" and start anew.
Fire stimulates growth and allowing Rollins to rise from the ashes will hopefully lead to the type of phoenix-like rise that transformed Tyler Black the indy star into Seth Rollins the top WWE star.