9 Ups & 4 Downs From Last Night's WWE NXT (Oct 9)
WWE show naked indifference towards The Wednesday Night War.
It's not been the best week be a part of the black-and-gold brand.
Last week's exceptional broadcast could be objectively considered one of the best single episodes of television in the history not just of NXT but WWE and modern era professional wrestling. Bursting with quality in-ring content, it boasted a major surprise, mammoth return and a series of tantalising teases for matches sure to come in the very near future.
It was trounced by its opposition.
Be it curiosity or undeniable quality, AEW Dynamite's maiden episode was the choice of the majority of the near-2.5million Americans that sought out wrestling last Wednesday night. It too was transcendent, but ahead of Week 2, WWE's damaging Hell In A Cell booking left plenty drawing lines between the catastrophe of Sunday night and the company within the company later in the week. It chased folk away from wanting to line Vince McMahon's pockets, which in turn could make for another strong week on TNT.
It's Triple H's job not to care about AEW's output just as much as it is deflect attention away from the main WWE product with NXT. How successful was this important second attempt?
Downs...
4. Unlimited Commercial Interruption
A price of NXT's move to television, commercial breaks didn't hamper all of last week's blockbusters because of WWE's agreement with USA Network. This week, the company paid the penalty for elevating the developmental brand to a much larger stage.
Most notable in the opener belter between Lio Rush and Drew Gulak, the commercials chopped or reduced the drama of matches in ways that couldn't be recaptured by picture-in-picture. This will leave fans of the black-and-gold brand with two choices, neither of them particularly favourable for the company. Given the choice, viewers can either invest less in the clash, or simply wait to watch the cleaner WWE Network version.
In both cases, the show won't keep people glued. As the product on the losing side of a ratings war, that's a worst case scenario.
3. Shooting The Breeze
The Forgotten Sons replacing Ever Rise via stage beating was good. Breezango coming to the ring as sexy workmen was great. The Forgotten Sons Vs Breezango was one giant down.
A television squash this might have been, but it wasn't a very good one, and there existed a prevailing sense of the wrong act were going over at the wrong time.
NXT's got a rich history for using former stars to prop up then promote newer acts, but this neither side suited those roles here. Steve Cutler and Wesley Blake have always been too believable as neglected goobers because that's exactly what they are, even if Jaxson Ryker is right out of Vince McMahon's fantasy airport. Conversely, Tyler Breeze and Fandango are still so good that they could easily be the solution to NXT Tag Team division problem, if only that seemed a priority to try and solve.
Skippable when nothing on the show should be, this was, lol, instantly forgettable.
2. Boa Constricted
Killian Dain may be beyond saving on the black-and-gold brand if the underwhelming post-squash beatdown on Boa was the best idea they had for him as a post-Matt Riddle rehabilitation. Mainly because it was so annoyingly similar to it.
Riddle/Dain felt like one of the bigger disappointments from the brand this year, but the former Sanity man hasn't yet flexed the fire in Full Sail that got him hired in the first place. Perhaps the most obvious victim of the formulaic approach to angles, Dain's fury feels extremely stage-managed and it comes at the expense of the big blusterous spots they book for him.
Neither bully or b*stard this week, he was simply a bore.
1. We Are Not Unkind...
...but this episode was simply not a fabulous episode of wrestling television.
Decent throughout and excellent at either end, there were at least two irrefutably excellent matches along with several foundational segments that were at their very least purpose-serving. But what purpose, exactly?
NXT has done a better job than AEW so far at hyping its matches for the following week, but a far inferior job of making those matches mean as much when they're actually happening. Admirable in that this week's episode clearly did nothing to try and win or steal a ratings point, this episode also clearly did nothing to try and win or steal a ratings point.
In a vacuum, it's all hot sh*t. But will any of it actually attract or keep the new eyes that might have only just discovered it?
Ups...
9. "24-YEAR-OLD PIECE OF GOLD!"

Worked at a blistering pace when it wasn't broken up by ad breaks, Lio Rush's cathartic victory over Drew Gulak furthered his brand new arc as one of the year's great comeback stories. He'll now be required to proffer the same proliferation for the rechristened NXT Cruiserweight Championship.
The outgoing Champion was magnificent on offence here, crisply calculating his cut-offs just as unlikely white meat face Rush appeared to be fighting back from underneath. As dynamic and explosive as any lightweight in the entire company, this was the perfect tale to tell, with Gulak looking tough enough to be the sort of pr*ck putting sparklers out with his fingers on bonfire night. Unfortunately for the titleholder, the fuse was already lit (AF).
Rush's final, decisive comeback saw his boy-popping bottom rope springboard stunner used as the set-up for his match winning Final Hour frog splash. That felt like a tribute to late Eddie Guerrero on what would have been 'Latino Heat's birthday, much like the victory itself.
8. Angels & Demons
Arguably the standout moment from a memorable broadcast last week, Finn Bálor's return to NXT immediately felt like the smartest exchange between Full Sail and the main roster in forever. It should come as little surprise that it involved a Raw and SmackDown wrestler going back to the former developmental brand, but Bálor's history on the show feeds brilliantly into his future.
Knowing this, NXT chose to split the hype train up into two separate carriages, with the best bits from his post-2016 career saved for the second half of the show. It was, predictably, less effective than the first video, but did at least capture the full circle nature of his return.
NXT isn't currently gifted with a loaded topline - but the brand's longest-serving Champion is an immediate, enormous addition to it.
And speaking of sh*thot video packages...
7. Nox'ed Out Of The Park
On a show that had promised to identify a challenger for unstoppable NXT Women's Champion Shayna Baszler, the episode built its first of three with yet another a phenomenal video presentation for returning babyface Tegan Nox.
Not to have this effusive praise diluted by Jon Moxley's brilliant impression of Vince McMahon, but this was such good sh*t. Really, really, f*cking good.
In many ways, this particular comeback story is a total tap-in for the brand, but they deserve credit all the same for ensuring that the peak will come upon her entrance next week. Nox really has gone through one of the worst two-year spells of any wrestling career, not least considering that rehab's virtually all she's known as a WWE Superstar.
All the right sympathy has been curated - it's now simply down the Welsh wizard to execute all the right moves.
6. Rhea View
With one challenger already established, the very next segment positioned another at the top table as Rhea Ripley made mincemeat of Aaliyah in a thoroughly satisfying squash.
The Australian's arrival just before NXT moved to USA Network resulted in a quickie TV match against the 'Queen Of Spades' that ended with a screwy finish to keep both women protected for a high profile rematch - one that may now not even make it to TakeOver if the company need a potential ratings-winner.
Mirror images of one another in terms of stature and status, the grand payoff feels certain to be one of the most dramatic matches of an upcoming Wednesday Night War. Unpredictability is currency currently, and it'd be a struggle to confidently pick the winner.
5. Strong And Stable
Cameron Grimes kept his match short, and in the spirit of that being very f*cking welcome, thanks, this entry will follow suit.
The more Grimes flattens dorks in seconds, the better he's likely to look. Strong, vintage character building WWE so rarely gamble on now, it's got more chance of getting him over than that hat everybody's being told to hide their hard-ons in.
4. Strong And Able
A wicked outing for Isaiah Scott in predictable defeat against Roderick Strong, the Undisputed Era man gave 'Swerve' everything before putting him away with the usual away sh*thot strikes and counter-proof back work.
It was the sort of wonderful showcase NXT's always been celebrated for, but it all felt so much more prestigious since the brand moved to television. A brilliant mid-show battle potentially lost to the stakes of the opener and main event, this was yet another sleeper hit for Strong in a year full of them. It speaks to the quality of The Undisputed Era that he may still not be the stable's MVP, thanks to the high drama/high banter quotient fulfilled by Kyle O'Reilly and the effortless immaculate cool exhibited by Adam Cole.
Cool he was scared into losing as one segment elegantly segued into the next...
3. The New Era?
Adam Cole tacitly put Isaiah Scott over in his brief appraisal of his stablemate's latest victim before moving on to Undisputed Era business. This in itself was welcome - there's been a distinct lack of the lads doing this in-ring patter stuff as well as they can since the big USA move. This particular one made up for it.
Getting over Velveteen Dream and Tommaso Ciampa not just as impending threats to the separate singles titles but also the very heart of Undisputed Era's recent dominance, the decision to place these two moments back-to-back was inspired.
Rattled by the hilarious photoshop Dream shamed Strong with in promoting their North American Title rematch in two weeks, the group weren't at all ready when "Daddy" came "home". The quartet looked sh*t scared of Ciampa and his simple mission statement. His repossession of "Goldie" felt believably inevitable - much like the murder he's going to commit against Angel Garza next week.
2. The bEST
Held back from singles action in the NXT on USA era so far, Bianca Belair went into this match with Dakota Kai as the favourite despite 'The Leader Of Team Kick's recent return.
'The EST of NXT' used the clash to remind everybody of exactly who she was, marking herself as the third realistic challenger to Shayna Baszler's Championship at the next available opportunity.
Strength, speed and charisma up to ceilings way higher than Full Sail, Belair was a TV-ready star long before the black-and-gold brand made the recent leap. Kai's time may come another day, but the fact that her defeat came with relative assuredness suggests she may not currently be in the plans.
The total opposite could be said for her opponent - the time for her to have one more crack at the Champion is yesterday.
1. No Push For Kush
Frustrating early doors as the pair of them went through the motions, the contest wonderfully came to life in its second half - not least because it had flown under the radar somewhat that the former NJPW man might actually win.
Without Walter's UK Championship on the line there existed a very real possibility that the the 'Time Splitter' could leave a crack in the Austrian's mighty shield, particularly when he resorted to returning the favour for all the wicked chops with about as many kicks.
"You're not dreaming Nigel, this match continues" was the Mauro Ranallo call that came just before Full Sail's "This Is Awesome" chant, highlighting how the two had found the peak of the heat at the exact right moment. Walter flattened Kushida with a ripcord lariat for the win to end his NXT undefeated streak and possibly this mini-feud in suitably grand fashion.
Where they both go from here (assuming they both stick around) remains a mystery. Which, considering how predictable their programme has been, is actually quite a welcome development.