Every CM Punk WWE WrestleMania Match Ranked From Worst To Best

The 'Best in the World' has had some truly spectacular matches on The Grandest Stage of Them All.

Cm Punk Wrestlemania
WWE.com

As we hurtle towards WrestleMania 42, all eyes are on one match. And it ain't Cody Rhodes vs. Randy Orton, no offence. 

Through a combination of a rich shared history, some dynamite recent promos, and a collective apathy towards most of the other storylines in WWE right now, Roman Reigns vs. CM Punk is by far and away the hottest programme in the company as it gears up for their biggest show of the year. 

This will be Punk's first singles match at a WrestleMania since his return to the company and his first time defending a World Title at the flagship event since 2012. A lot of eyes will be on the Straight Edge Superstar in Las Vegas, so now is the perfect time to look back at how we got here. At time of writing, Punk has competed at eight different WrestleManias. He's fought for titles, briefcases, and good old-fashioned pride, but which of his bouts has been the best? And where will his clash with Reigns end up when the final bell is rung? 

Only time will tell...

8. vs Rey Mysterio - WrestleMania XXVI

CM Punk Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

Though not his first match on the Grandest Stage of Them All, Punk's appearance at WrestleMania XXVI was his first outing in a singles match.

Unfortunately, it was also his most forgettable Mania clash.

His opponent was Rey Mysterio, who had become the target of the Straight Edge Society. Punk and his band of bald weirdos attempted to convert the lucha legend, but failed at every step. Even the creepiest ever rendition of 'Happy Birthday' wasn't enough to sway him. If Mysterio lost this match, then he would be forced to join the group. If Punk lost, then... well, nothing would happen. Rey really needed a different lawyer around this time. 

Mysterio won in just six-and-a-half minutes. The match was probably the best it could have been given the circumstances, as the two combatants had decent chemistry and were good workers. They simply weren't given the chance to get going. They would go on to have much better matches over the following months. This is one of those examples of WrestleMania being the start of a feud rather than the end, and it didn't do either of these guys any favours.


7. vs Randy Orton - WrestleMania XXVII

CM Punk Randy Orton
WWE.com

One year on from facing Mysterio, Punk found himself in a different, yet oddly familiar situation.

Once again, he was head of a midcard stable in a middle-of-the-show match against a former world champion. This time, the stable was The New Nexus - remember those guys? - and his opponent was Randy Orton. 

This rivalry had spun out of Orton costing Punk the World Heavyweight Championship three years earlier. Long term booking? Nope. This was the first time that incident had been mentioned since it happened. Clearly the writers were desperate for a reason for these two to fight. Once again, Punk came up short, falling to a midair RKO. Why he attempted a springboard move on Randy Orton of all people is beyond me. 

This is another example of a match guilty of nothing more than being average. It's only better than the Mysterio one because it was given more than twice as much time. It's still one of the highlights of WrestleMania XXVII. Although, if you know anything about this show, you'll know that isn't much of a compliment. 


6. The Money in the Bank Ladder Match - WrestleMania 25

Cm Punk Wrestlemania 25
WWE

Get ready to hear the words 'Bank', 'Money', 'in', and 'the' a lot throughout this list. Although possibly not in that order. 

Punk was one of eight men lined up to try and capture the magical briefcase at WrestleMania 25. He was in there with some good company; ladder match veterans Christian and Kane; athletic innovators Kofi Kingston and Shelton Benjamin; bruisers Mark Henry and Finlay; and MVP, who I couldn't think of an adjective for, but he seems like a nice bloke. 

Mania 25's Money in the Bank match is full of the chaos you'd expect from the format. The biggest moments don't have a great deal to do with Punk, with the exception of him taking an Unprettier off the top of a ladder bridge. 

The excitement of this gimmick - which was still relatively fresh at the time - is what carries it to a higher spot than the two singles bouts. It also has the novelty of Punk going back-to-back and winning his second briefcase in a row, the first and only time this has ever been done. 

Speaking of...


5. The Money in the Bank Ladder Match - WrestleMania XXIV

Cm Punk Wins WrestleMania 24
WWE

Punk had a point to prove walking into WrestleMania XXIV.

The previous year, he'd come within inches of winning Money in the Bank, denied at the last second by its eventual winner. This year, he had the chance to right that wrong. Did he? Well, yes... we said so in the last entry... keep up. 

A few familiar faces were part of this seven-man affair. MVP and Benjamin were joined by Mr. Kennedy, Carlito, John Morrison, and Chris Jericho to round out the pack. Similarly to our previous subject, Punk didn't really play a role in many of this match's most memorable moments. The real MVP (not that one) was Benjamin, who took a horrendous bump through a ladder to the floor after being dumped out of the ring. 

When compared with 25, this iteration of the ladder match has much more to offer in terms of thrills and spills. Punk's eventual victory also means a lot more because it was new and it made up for his failure the previous year. 

This is far from a top-tier Money in the Bank outing, but it's not a stinker either. 


4. vs Chris Jericho - WrestleMania XXVIII

CM Punk Chris Jericho
WWE.com

Punk's upcoming match against Roman Reigns will be only the second time he's walked into Mania as a defending champion. 

The previous time took place well over a decade ago and was against a very, very different foe.

Chris Jericho had set his sights on the Punkster ever since he returned to WWE in early 2012. The pair came to blows over their differing philosophies, their shared moniker of 'Best in the World', and the fact that Y2J was being a giant douchebag. Jericho taunted the WWE Champion over his family's history with alcohol. This is the feud that would give us the all-time great moment of the Canadian pouring booze over a prone Punk, only to then slip over and land ass-first in the drink. 

Their WWE Championship match at Mania XXVIII was well-worked and emotional. The two established a great back-and-forth, trading signature submission attempts in a bid to upend the other. Punk would eventually snatch victory via the Anaconda Vise, retaining the gold and cementing himself as a top babyface champion.

This was a strong showing, but ultimately just paved the way for their much better Chicago Street Fight at Extreme Rules.


3. The Money in the Bank Ladder Match - WrestleMania 23

WrestleMania 23 Orton Punk
WWE.com

Pepsi Phil had never been in a Money in the Bank or WrestleMania match prior to this one, but he had some top tier mentors to help him through it. Alongside fellow young stars Randy Orton and Mr. Kennedy, this encounter was packed with icons. Edge and both Hardy Boyz brought the ladder match experience, while Booker T and Finlay were no slouches either. 

Weird to think that Finlay is technically one of Punk's most storied WrestleMania rivals. 

If you want to talk about high spots, then this one has the biggest in MITB history. Jeff Hardy launching himself off a giant ladder to crush Edge beneath him is nothing short of spectacular. Elsewhere, Punk took a nasty fall off a ladder-assisted RKO and poor old Hornswoggle got absolutely wrecked by that mean old Kennedy.

Speaking of double K, he was the one who robbed Punk of the briefcase in the contest's dying embers. This was a fantastic match and a neat little start point for a three-year arc for our hero.


2. vs Roman Reigns vs Seth Rollins - WrestleMania 41

WWE WrestleMania 41 Night 1 Paul Heyman Seth Rollins Roman Reigns CM Punk
WWE

After being gone from the company for over a decade, CM Punk walked back into WWE just in time for WrestleMania XL. Then his body exploded.

Oh well, there's always next year...

WrestleMania 41 was a glorious time for Chicago's favourite son. Not only was he facing two huge stars - Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins - he was doing so in the main event... of Night 1! 

Something something, MJF promo - you know the gag by now. 

Anyway, Punk wasn't going to let a technicality get in the way of delivering a main event-worthy performance. Over a drama-filled half-an-hour, all three warriors gave it their all. The action was fantastic, but the main attraction was the bubbling tension between the trio which exploded in the bout's thrilling climax. Despite walking him down to the ring, Paul Heyman turned on his tattooed best friend, not to re-side with his Tribal Chief, but to form a new alliance with Rollins. 

This was the perfect capper to one of the best non-title closers in Mania history. It was certainly a lot better than the final match of Night 2, too.


1. vs The Undertaker - WrestleMania 29

CM Punk Undertaker
WWE

CM Punk has done a lot of things in his career, but one fact that often gets overlooked is that he was the final victim of The Streak. 

His rivalry with The Undertaker in the lead up to WrestleMania 29 was pure box office, and not always for the right reasons. The decision to incorporate the recent death of Paul Bearer into the story was heavily criticised, but you can't deny that it didn't make things more interesting. 

The Second City Saint was the perfect foil for Mean Mark. His smaller frame and more technical style meshed perfectly with the big bruiser. It also felt very plausible that he could win, especially as he'd been WWE Champion very recently.

A gruelling epic that ran the emotional gamut, Punk and Taker built seamlessly to an almighty crescendo. After kicking out of a shot from Bearer's urn, The Deadman powered up, dropped his agitator with a Tombstone, and sealed the victory for himself and his fallen friend. You could argue that Punk should have been involved in the Cena/Rock main event instead, but it's hard to push back on an alternative as strong as this.


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.