Every Edge Vs Randy Orton PPV Match Ranked From Worst To Best

Who is the King of Rated RKO?

Edge Randy Orton
WWE.com

After nine years out of the game, Edge is back in a WWE ring and on a compelling collision course with former friend/former enemy Randy Orton at WrestleMania 36.

The 11-time World Champions stunning, albeit mostly expected, return from retirement at the Royal Rumble was one of the most genuinely uplifting and exciting returns in company history. His fantastic 23-minute performance into the final four was more than enough to convince anyone that he was here to recapture his lost years.

With Orton by his side, it looked as though we were in store for a nostalgia-fuelled Rated RKO reunion. However, as he always does with such an impeccable heel touch, The Vpier turned on Edge and sowed the seeds for their own bout.

Despite both being at the top of the main event scene for more than a decade at the same time , Edge and Orton actually spent very little time together on pay-per-view. Often running parallel to each other in major story arcs without every really coming together too often.

Across hundreds of PPVs in their time, they only shared the same ring on 14 occasions. Three of those were as Rated RKO on the same team, a further two were Royal Rumble matches (of which I won't count for this list). In nine remaining matches where they were opposing each other, seven were multi-man matches, which means incredibly, they only fought TWICE in one-on-one competition despite being two of the biggest stars of the era.

9. Over The Limit - 2010

Edge Randy Orton Over the Limit 2010 Orton Injury
WWE.com

This match was afflicted by suffering a bad case of misfortune. Plain and simple.

In what was just their second ever pay-per-view singles contest, and first in six years, Orton and Edge were plonked in the middle of a generally underwhelming card while in the midst of a short feud that was yet to find its feet.

While the contents of the match aren't exactly terrible, piecing together a very solid opening ten minutes building towards a strong finish thanks to their their solid chemistry as a tag team, the abrupt end to the bout cost it big time.

Around the aforementioned 10-minute mark, Orton rolled into his trademark coil, setting up for the RKO and banging the mat with his fists. Then disaster struck.

While banging his arms down, as he always had, The Viper sensationally separated his shoulder, immediately pulling up and clutching at his dangling arm. The referee threw up the x symbol and the two rivals were forced to rush the finish. They took each other to the outside where Edge would attempt a spear on Orton who ducked out of harms way. Edge speared the barricade. Both men down. Double count-out result.

Interestingly, despite being a perennial heel for much of his career, Orton was a huge crowd favourite for this match, with the Detroit faithful chanting his name and cheering every little comeback and big move, while jeering Edge at every turn.


8. Fatal 4-Way - 2010

Randy Orton Edge
WWE.com

Another match marred by a strange finish, but unlike Orton's shoulder injury, this time it was the Nexus who derailed the match.

Edge and Orton continued their rivalry from the previous entry into the Fatal 4-Way pay-per-view, taking part in the titular match alongside defending WWE Champion John Cena, and Sheamus. At a bit over 15 minutes, the match was a solid outing in a multi-man format that is often hard to get right, with some near falls, teaming up, opportune plays and general cohesiveness.

One of the gripes of the opening 10 minutes though, was the concentration on the oft-trodden Orton vs Cena rivalry, making it feel like a match between those two and Edge and Sheamus just happened to be there.

Just as the match was building to an entertaining crescendo, the Nexus arrived, laying waste to anyone and anything in their path. They took out Cena and then Edge to the silence of no commentary, allowing Sheamus to sneak into the ring and pin Cena, before running out into the crowd to avoid being attacked next.

It was an odd way to kick off his second title reign and his immediate flee into the stands to escape did nothing to help solidify him as a legitimate main event player, something he struggled with in his first reign.

Orton and Edge did duke it out on a few occasions, but with so many other moving parts, this wasn't exactly a showcase for what was supposed to be an intense rivlary.


7. Night Of Champions - 2010

Night Of Champions - 2010 edge randy orton
WWE.com

Another Nexus-influenced WWE Championship match, Sheamus' second World Title reign that begun at the aforementioned Fatal 4-Way pap-per-view just a few months prior, was brought to an abrupt end in a 6-Pack Challenge also involving Randy Orton, Edge (surprise, surprise), John Cena, Wade Barrett and Chris Jericho.

The last name of that list was eliminated in just 85 seconds in what was written as basically his retirement from the WWE at the time.

It was a successful night for one of our two titular wrestlers, with Randy Orton winning his sixth WWE Title after all was said and done. The Viper eluded the invading Nexus to eliminate Wade Barrett from the match after the British Bull Hammer had done the same to Cena moments earlier.

Once the Nexus was out of the way, Orton made light work of Sheamus, picking up his third of a possible five eliminations to win the gold once again.

For Edge, the Ultimate Opportunist actually dominated much of the match, teaming up with Sheamus in an unlikely alliance to lay waste to the competition for the majority of the contest. He would last 15 of the 21 minutes before falling victim to a John Cena Attitude Adjustment.

While the match certainly picked up, firing off eliminations in the final three minutes, there was a lot of filler throughout much of the middle portions of the contest, dropping it down a few rungs on the ratings ladder.


6. Money In The Bank - 2010

Randy Orton Edge
WWE.com

In 2010, the Money In The Bank ladder match was still a relatively fresh concept leading into the inaugural PPV of the same name. With two of them being held on the same night for the very first time and a host of exciting talent entering the fray, there was cause for anticipation.

After Kane had already won and cashed in his briefcase withing the first hour and a half of the show, Edge and Randy Orton found themselves in the second ladder match of the evening for a WWE Championship opportunity.

With eight participants lined up for the incoming car crash, it was an interesting blend of old and new with the aforementioned Edge and Orton being joined by fellow veterans Chris Jericho and Mark Henry. On the other side of the coin were the perceived next generation of possible World Champions like Ted DiBiase, John Morrison, The Miz and Evan Bourne.

While there were patches of clumsiness and general miscommunication, especially among the younger competitors at times, the organised chaos delivered about as well as it could considering the absurdity that comes with a lot of these matches. Elaborate mutli-ladder set ups, four wrestlers all jostling across the one ladder, people recovering to save the day and of course a flood of teased briefcase grabs, keeping the winner up in the air.

The Miz would grab the case after a few thrilling false finishes - Evan Bourne's teased victory in particular - which of course led to his polarising WrestleMania main event.


5. Survivor Series - 2004

WWE Survivor Series 2004 Team Orton
WWE.com

While this one was really all about Triple H and Randy Orton, and their battle over the World Heavyweight Championship that sat around the waste of the former, it stood out as another showcase for an up and coming Rated-R Superstar on his way to the top of the card.

The build was genuinely one of the best of all time for a Survivor Series match, making Trips look as vulnerable as ever during his infamous Raw reign of terror, a theme that continued throughout the match itself as he captained opposite The Viper.

Edge and Orton found themselves as two of the final three contestants in what was a highly entertaining match, with so many cogs in motion. The two of them picked off four of the seven total eliminations, arguably dominating the match for each of their sides.

The future Ultimate Opportunist picked of Chris' Benoit and Jericho, while Orton capped off the heroic comeback by pinning both Edge and Triple H as the final two to win the match.

Having been wronged by Evolution and Triple H countless times since winning the Heavyweight Title himself earlier in the year, the crowd were fully behind Orton and lost it when he finally got the pin on Triple H and stole the win from a seemingly lost cause.

Despite the momentum from this match, Orton wouldn't actually win another World Heavyweight strap for another seven years, even taking three to win a World Title of any sort.


4. Vengeance - 2004

Randy Orton Edge Vengeance 2004
WWE.com

The pairs first one-on-one PPV meeting was for the Intercontinental Championship, with the match taking place in the shadow of Evolution, but shining a bright light on two future World Champions and legends of the company.

Edge had just returned from injury, vowing to take down the dominant faction of Raw as Orton sat pretty with the IC strap, benefiting from his life inside the star-making stable. While his reign had been a lengthy one, Orton was often the beneficiary of Evolution interference or being a part of multi-man and stipulation matches.

While certainly no slouch between the ropes, at just 24 years of age, Orton still had a lot to learn and even more to prove. On the other side of the ring, Edge had already carved out his resume as a tag team trail blazer, but was yet to really hit his straps as the single star he would soon become.

This was the perfect showcase for them both.

With the match going nearly half an hour, one-on-one with no interference or gimmicks, it showed that Orton had what it takes to carry a contest - of length - and hold down a strong piece of storytelling and in-ring psychology. Edge too proving to the powers that be that he was capable of sustaining a singles match workload and excelling at it.

While it was Edge who won the belt on the day, it freed Orton up to take the World Heavyweight Championship from Chris Benoit just one month later.


3. New Years Revolution - 2005

Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

Without taking away from any of Chris Jericho, Chis Benoit or Edge, this one was all about the members of Evolution and the leading angle on Raw at the time of vengeance and underlying issues of cohesion.

The opening five minute exchange between Benoit and Jericho was wrestling poetry in motion, one for the purists as the two outgrappled, outmanoeuvred and outplayed each other. Their exchange of knife edge chops was enough to make even the hardest man wince in pain.

Edge cleaned house upon his entry but was eliminated first in a great little interaction with special guest referee Shawn Michaels, his face being on the receiving end of some Sweet Chin Music.

Batista saved the day for Triple H in a fantastic spot that saw The Game survive being in the Crippler Crossface and Walls of Jericho at the same time, holding on just long enough for The Animal to enter the fray and go on a rampage.

Orton's incredible comeback, eliminating Batista in the process, was painfully cut short by The Animal coming back into the ring, causing enough havoc for Triple H to land a Pedigree on Orton and reclaim the gold.

Unfortunately for Orton, his own story arc of redemption was quickly being overshadowed by that of Batista's ascension to usurp Triple H, meaning The Viper would miss out on the title win that had been building for months. Batista would take the WrestleMania 21 main event, while Orton was given a pretty sweet compromise by facing The Undertaker.


2. WrestleMania 23

Cm Punk Randy Orton Wrestlemania 23
WWE.com

A genuine contender for the best Money In The Bank ladder match of all time, this WrestleMania 23 car crash threatened to steal the show, and boy did they deliver.

Edge and Orton were joined by rising stars CM Punk and Mr. Kennedy, both Matt and Jeff Hardy, as well as veterans Finlay and Booker T in a barn-burner of an opening contest for The Show Of Shows.

There was no shortage of highlights across the action-packed 24 minutes. Booker T hit the Book End on Orton off the ladder, which itself was right after Orton hit a crazy RKO on CM Punk off the same ladder. Hornswoggle made a hilarious appearance as he attempted to climb the ladder himself to retrieve the briefcase, only to be on the receiving end of an incredibly nasty Green Bay Plunge from Mr. Kennedy from the top of said ladder.

Booker T even whipped out a spinaroonie in the middle of the ladder match!

Orton went on an RKO spree, hitting everyone in the match in short order, while Edge did the same with his spear as he nailed all seven of his opponents with the signature move within 60 seconds. His night would be cut short though when Jeff Hardy landed one of the most memorable leg drops of all time, crashing the Rated-R Superstar through a ladder on the outside, taking them both out of the match.

Mr. Kennedy was the right winner on the night, but it was a memorable one for all eight participants.


1. Backlash - 2007

backlash 2007
WWE.com

According to (the polarising) Dave Meltzer, this fatal 4-way between defending WWE Champion John Cena, Shawn Michaels, Randy Orton and Edge was WWE's highest rated match of the 2007, and it not only received the highest star rating in more than two years, but would not be beaten for two more years following it.

Cena and Michaels were in the middle of their golden run together, lighting up the top feud on Raw with sensational matches at WrestleMania 23, as well as their 1-hour instant classic on Raw just six days prior to the Backlash pay-per-view they found themselves on here.

Edge and Orton were similarly intertwined, both looking to move on at the end of their Rated RKO run, putting on a sensational one-on-one classic of their own on Raw the night after Backlash.

The match itself was beautifully constructed, keeping the crash and bash to a minimum in the early stages, allowing the crowd to ease into the contest having just witnessed a wild Last Man Standing match between The Undertaker and Batista moments earlier. Edge and Orton teamed up, even putting Michaels in a double Boston Crab, only to turn on each other.

Michaels and Cena picked up where they'd left off in their previous encounters, gelling beautifully to keep the match firing on all cylinders. The final three minutes that brought it all together is pure wrestling theatre at its absolute finest, with finishers coming from all directions and one of the more unique match endings in company history.


Contributor

Aussie sports fan who loves gaming, everything on the big and silver screens and quoting the entire Samuel L. Jackson 'Ezekiel 25:17' monologue from Pulp Fiction