Every WWE NXT Call-Up In 2017: Ranked From Worst To Best
Booms, busts, and everything in between.
WWE have completely reinvented the concept of a developmental territory with NXT, creating an environment that not only fosters and builds the next wave of wrestling talent, but a viable third brand with its own distinct identity.
It has provided the main roster with an efficient conveyor belt of new blood since its birth in 2012. The Performance Center is the sport's most effective finishing school, and NXT's weekly shows and TakeOver specials are invaluable in familiarising wrestlers with WWE's presentation style without throwing them in at the deep end. The system works, and while NXT success doesn't always translate to the main roster, WWE rarely stray from the format.
2017 has seen 12 wrestlers graduate from NXT to Raw or SmackDown, and while some have floundered, others are now among their brand's biggest stars. We've made a couple of omissions, though. Austin Aries didn't wrestle on the main roster until March 2017, but was called up as 205 Live's commentator in December, while The Singh Brothers wrestled on the cruiserweight show's debut episode the month prior. These renders them ineligible.
With that in mind, let's see how the others stack up.
9. The Riott Squad
Ruby Riott, Liv Morgan, and Sarah Logan may well be the tonic required to rejuvenate the stagnant SmackDown women's division in 2018, but they've barely been around long enough to brew a cup of tea, and haven't made a convincing start.
Their debut angle was a near identical recreation of that used to introduce Paige's Absolution group the night before. The repetition isn't their fault, but it definitely took the edge off their arrival.
The trio cut a horrible, stunted promo the following week, but they've already taken out some of their brand's biggest names, with Naomi and Becky Lynch both falling by their hand. 'Injuring' these former champions give them an extra level of credibility, too.
Riott is a fantastic wrestler herself. Logan is serviceable, but packaged with a go-nowhere gimmick, while Morgan is largely unproven. There's little synergy between them with regards to character or image, so they feel like more of a ragtag bunch of misfits than a cohesive unit. Regardless, there's enough talent between them to make this work, and it wouldn't be a huge surprise to see one capture the SmackDown Women's Title within the next few months.
8. Sonya Deville & Mandy Rose
Like The Riott Squad on SmackDown, Absolution haven't been around long enough to pass meaningful judgment. This makes it impossible to place them any higher, though they've made a stronger start than their blue brand counterparts, and not just because they arrived first.
Sonya Deville and Mandy Rose benefit immensely from being positioned alongside Paige. Both are full of promise, but they're unknown quantities, and aligning with the former Divas Champion gave fans a reason to get invested in them from day one. Their lifeless second week promo suggests both still have a few rough edges to work out, though.
Absolution have been highly effective in cutting through the Raw women's roster, with Sasha Banks, Bayley, Mickie James, and Alexa Bliss all taking beatings. They've teased confrontations with Asuka, the division's new alpha, but have pulled out every time.
Regardless, it looks like we'll soon see Absolution involved in a big trios match with Banks, Bayley, and James before long. Deville and Rose will be working with the best of the best from day one, which bodes exceptionally well for their ongoing development.
7. The Revival
They're one of the best tag teams in the world, but Dash Wilder and Scott Dawson's main roster run hasn't worked out thus far.
Dash suffered a fractured jaw just 11 days after The Revival's main roster debut, putting the team on hiatus for two months. They returned in June, but disaster struck again three weeks later, when Dawson's bicep was ruptured while wrestling Sheamus and Cesaro at a live event. He'll be on the shelf until February at the earliest, leaving Wilder to circle the drain as a singles act on Main Event.
The Revival's luck has been rotten, but their pre-injury contributions were solid. They made a great debut the night after WrestleMania 33, scoring a huge victory over the record-breaking New Day in their first bout, which appeared to set them up for a monster push. Dash and Dawson were then involved in the Enzo Amore/Big Cass whodunit, and house show booking patterns hinted at a feud with The Bar. Sadly, this never materialised.
It's a shame that we'll have to wait until 2018 to see the best of The Revival, but fans shouldn't be worried. They're going to kill it.
6. Tye Dillinger
There was a time when Tye Dillinger's "10!" chants dominated arenas around the country, regardless of whether or not the former NXT man was even on the show. Sadly, those days are now long gone.
'The Perfect 10' has seen his interest levels nosedive through main roster inactivity, having barely been used since officially joining SmackDown in April. Dillinger drew a monster pop after entering the Royal Rumble at number 10. WWE should've called him up there and then, but they held off, and the buzz started cooling.
Regardless, he made a solid enough start after eventually going full-time. Tye embarked upon a textbook jobber-squashing spree, and drifted on and off television thereafter, occasionally flirting with United States Title contendership. His biggest moment came through facing Baron Corbin and AJ Styles, but their Triple Threat bout was also the last time Tye worked a televised match.
Absent since October 8th, it's clear WWE have no place for the multi-talented 'Perfect 10,' even on the midcard. A huge shame, as he's as skilled as anyone outside the company's top talent tier and people genuinely want to root for him.
5. Bobby Roode
Less than four months have passed since Bobby Roode transitioned to the main roster, but 'The Glorious One' has already fallen out of the limelight.
Dolph Ziggler was his first notable rival. Having previously derailed Shinsuke Nakamura's momentum with a needless 50/50 snoozer at Backlash, 'The Show-Off' claimed his second scalp in Roode, who triumphed in the end, but gained nothing from being made to work so competitively against such lowly opposition.
Roode was a non-entity at Survivor Series, eating a pinfall to Braun Strowman after just 13 minutes, and he has since fallen into a lifeless United States Title storyline with Ziggler and Baron Corbin. He has gone from 'The Guy' in NXT to 'a guy' on SmackDown. He could still reach the main event, but Bobby's current form will keep him rooted in the midcard, with upward mobility a pipe dream.
Part of the problem is WWE's insistence on pushing him as a babyface. Yes, that entrance theme is always going to draw pops, but Roode is outstanding as a smug, arrogant villain. Playing the good guy doesn't suit him, and it's hard to imagine his fortunes improving until he turns.
4. Shinsuke Nakamura
Shinsuke Nakamura's main roster run hasn't been good. At all.
'The King Of Strong Style's' superstar aura is dead in the water. WWE have totally failed at preserving his mystique, and while fears that Vince McMahon would ruin Nakamura as soon as he got his hands on him haven't been completely fulfilled, WWE are well on their way.
The Dolph Ziggler and Baron Corbin rivalries were duds. A potential dream match with John Cena was wasted on a random episode of SmackDown, as was Shinsuke's first-time bout with Randy Orton. He wrestled for the WWE Championship at SummerSlam and Hell In A Cell, but eating two straight pinfalls to Jinder Mahal dealt immeasurable damage, and Nakamura's misery was compounded when he was the first competitor eliminated in Survivor Series' men's 5-on-5 bout.
There are a couple of saving graces. Nakamura's popularity, while dented, is second only to AJ Styles' on SmackDown, and WWE still have a big money match between the two left in the chamber. His in-ring showings have generally been strong, too, but he has clearly lost a step or two since leaving NJPW in 2016.
A strong start to 2018 should repair much of the damage, but Nakamura's reputation is reeling.
3. Elias
He's one of the most basic wrestlers on this list, and his act isn't everybody's cup of tea, but Elias has been a complete success on WWE's main roster.
'The Drifter' isn't there to dazzle audiences with five-star matches or dominate the main event scene. His job is to draw midcard heat, put the babyfaces over, and make your skin crawl. He's excellent at all three, and that's why he's among WWE's most successful NXT graduates in 2017.
Elias is one of only a few acts capable of drawing legitimate heel heat in the social media era. As great as they are, guys like Kevin Owens, Samoa Joe, and Brock Lesnar will always be cheered, but 'The Drifter' gets nothing but pure, unfiltered bile from the moment he strums his first guitar chord. His acoustic diss tracks always get the audience riled up, making him a great opponent for anyone WWE want to build support for.
Last week's lacklustre bout with Roman Reigns showed that Elias is far from the finished article between the ropes. He may never be an elite-level worker, but he's a tremendous heat magnet, which places him among Raw's most effective performers.
2. Asuka
It speaks volumes of the way WWE have booked their NXT call-ups in 2017 that someone who's only been on the main roster since October 22nd places so highly, but here we are.
Asuka has already been established as the Raw women's division's big bad. Her actions have been simple and effective, and while those first couple of matches with Emma set 'The Empress Of Tomorrow' off to a worrying start, WWE have successfully repaired the damage by having her buzz through the competition ever since.
Two unfortunate local talents met their maker via Asuka's head-kicks after the Emma saga concluded, and the former NXT Women's Champion was soon added to Raw's Survivor Series team. She ruled the pay-per-view, eliminating Carmella halfway through the bout, before finding herself suck in a two-on-one situation towards the end. Fortunately, 'The Empress' destroyed both Tamina and Natalya in quick succession, and stood tall as the sole survivor.
Asuka has since massacred both Alicia Fox and Dana Brooke, and with Bayley, Sasha Banks, and Mickie James preoccupied with Absolution, it won't be long before she's competing for championship gold. Here's hoping WWE don't find a way to screw it up.
1. Samoa Joe
The vast majority of WWE's 2017 NXT call-ups come with at least one major downside. For the Riott Squad, Absolution, Asuka, and The Revival, it's tenure. Shinsuke Nakamura, Tye Dillinger, and Bobby Roode have suffered through momentum-less booking, and Elias, though effective in his role, lags well behind the majority of his peers from bell-to-bell.
Samoa Joe is the exception.
The former NXT Champion has been nothing but excellent since joining Raw in January, and while he has largely played a supplementary role, he's always one of the most enjoyable things on the crowded flagship brand.
Joe made an excellent start as Triple H's 'Destroyer,' and gained instant credibility by injuring Seth Rollins in his debut, before beating the mighty Roman Reigns in his very first match. The pillaging continued thereafter. He choked Sami Zayn unconscious at Fastlane, beat Bray Wyatt and Finn Balor on Raw, then starred in the chaotic Extreme Rules main event, earning a shot at Brock Lesnar's Universal Title.
The ensuing feud was a complete success. Joe was established as the most dangerous man on the main roster, and it almost didn't matter that he fell to 'The Beast.' His aura, presence, and strength of character are more than strong enough to absorb the occasional loss, and he's over as hell, too.