8 Times WWE Stars Couldn't Hide Their Boo-Boo Face
Wrestling's not real, but these wrestlers forgot to let their faces know
Jonathan Gresham was 15 years into the business when he became Ring Of Honor World Heavyweight Champion in 2021. It was a show of respect from the organisation for a wrestler that had paid his dues, earned the billing and even managed to sustain his popularity through a pandemic that was rough enough on wrestlers that worked for the majors let alone the extremely minor league ROH had become by then.
Staving off meat-and-potatoes workrate accusations and completely misguided/wilfully ignorant criticisms of his size, Gresham proudly ascended, and even landed a unique look with an Octopus/Cthulhu mask that became key to his entrance and aura as the organisation's top guy. Unfortunately for him, Tony Khan didn't particularly see it that way when he purchased the promotion wholesale in 2022, and decided to turn him heel on an edition of Rampage ahead of switching the belt to Claudio Castagnoli in the opener of Death Before Dishonor. It emerged that Gresham had read the tea leaves and requested his release before the match, perhaps explaining the boo-boo/disinterested that was completely visible because he'd entered without his mask and without much interest in what he had coming up.
It wasn't ideal, but it wasn't a one-off. This isn't some shot across the bow at All Elite Wrestling or Ring Of Honor having a sloppy shop on Gresham's behalf. It's just as prevalent in WWE, whether the performers have cared to admit it or not. Even vaunted locker room leaders get the lip on...
8. The Undertaker
Though not exactly a perfect encapsulation of his work and/or contributions to the wrestling industry, The Undertaker getting on his bike for a bit in 1999 before doing so literally in 2000 was the best thing that could have happened to his career, and at a crucial point.
Going full satanist had won him his third WWE Championship and kept him on top with Stone Cold Steve Austin despite their self-admitted lousy chemistry, but the injuries were piling up alongside negative reviews that were putting him out to pasture as a completely busted flush. He'd been given the remainder of his BSK mates to hang around with on television, but crucifixions turning into Russo-fixations resulted in the Corporate Ministry coalition and 'The Deadman' forming a cursed alliance with The Big Show when he was goosed less than six months into his run too.
All of this came to head on an August edition of Monday Night Raw, where Undertaker cut a promo so infamously awful about going out to the desert and wearing skin as coats that it even had Show pulling faces in the ring wondering what on earth he was on about. What many people forget is that, when Chris Jericho interrupted doing his above-it-all shtick about being what the company desperately needed, he was right. When he cut The Rock off during his debut, the fans were in disbelief at how he could come for 'The Great One'. Here, he was saying what everybody felt, and doing it so sardonically that the hot new heel was getting babyface pops.
Undertaker was not happy, and like others in the locker room, he didn't take too kindly to this Atlanta yay-hoo coming North and not respecting the business. Visibly rattled, he noted that he "had more shower time than Jericho had ring-time", but the fans cared as much about that as they did for his stand-up act.
7. CM Punk & Cody Rhodes
Double bubble boo-boo face in the main event of the second biggest show of the year?
Well, no actually. For one, SummerSlam's attendance fell so well short of expectations that it couldn't really earn the honour of being one rung below WrestleMania in terms of stadium showcases for WWE in 2026. And also, perhaps most relevant to this particular list, the WWE Championship bout between CM Punk and Cody Rhodes categorically wasn't the main event of the show. It wasn't the main event, and damningly, it wasn't even a main event.
'The Biggest Party Of The Summer' has decided to live up the billing with two-night cards since 2025, resulting in the event having familiar debate in the build about what warrants the grand billing on Night Two, and exactly what it even means to headline Night One. 'The Straight Edge Superstar' and 'The American Nightmare' were shockingly ruled out of both when it was revealed that Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins had secured top billing on Sunday, with Oba Femi and Brock Lesnar's Hell In A Cell battle getting the Night One nod.
Despite grand entrances and the contest being for the WWE-billed "richest prize", the shared sense of demotion was unavoidable before the pair hit the ring for a match that had been years (and years) in the making. It felt as though the two were just as disappointed as the audience with their spot, and a stare-down that should have defined 2020s Sports Entertainment was instead neutered by a mutual realisation between the wrestlers and the crowd that this was a weekend for the tastes of the the 2010s instead.
Both men have had impressive runs in this boom/post-boom 2020s WWE too. This sideswipe was nothing new for Cody though...
6. Cody Rhodes
Cody Rhodes "finished the story" at WrestleMania XL in a moment so utterly euphoric and gratifying that it obscured how the show and the moment was closer to the end of the boom rather than the beginning. 2024 was a joyous time to be a WWE fan, not least because the 'Show Of Shows' had played host to a payoff that proved the company once again knew how to deliver the happiest of happy endings instead of the full troll route perpetuated by Vince McMahon.
That level of faith wasn't quite in place a year earlier, and for a 48 hour-or-so period around Rhodes falling short against Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 39, a lot of hope felt lost.
As the man set to look at the lights, Cody was unfortunately the first to know. It was written across the face of 'The American Nightmare' as he entered for his bout against 'The Tribal Chief', until about half way down the aisle when he tried to snap out of it and lock back in to being the man who - for the entire first year in the company - looked as though he was a dead cert to live his new dream on WWE's 'Grandest Stage'.
Many recall Rhodes unable to mask his devastation when he briefly handed his WrestleMania spot over to The Rock in January 2024 before an all-time pivot course corrected. Those that had watched things fall apart in Los Angeles a year earlier knew they'd seen the expression before. "We Want Cody" was turbo-charged by a refusal to see him stumble once again.
5. Sasha Banks
As Mercedes Moné, the artist formerly known as Sasha Banks has been able to carve out the niche she often wanted to within a system that was simply never going to allow her to live every dream she'd set for herself.
'The CEO' might not throw her weight around any more than 'The Boss' ever did, but you wouldn't know it watching her work. She performs as if she has all the agency her persona could ever need, walking in and out of matches and programmes as if she's booking them herself and only if the money's right. Wrestling's a work of course, and she's just doing a brilliant job of playing a role. There were times in WWE where this...wasn't the case.
It was during a podcast interview with Stone Cold Steve Austin where she spoke of her dreams to run the show, let alone work on it, and perhaps nights like WrestleMania 35 are why. There, she defended and lost tag team gold alongside Bayley to comedy act The IIconics just a month or so after wishing them into existence. For those watching at home, it was all-too-clear how it was going to go from her expression.
Three years earlier, Sasha Banks had to fight back tears walking to the ring alongside Snoop Dogg, such was the emotion of the moment. Having been though the WWE meat-grinder in the time since, she knew what she wanted out of the career, and it wasn't to have one of her dreams dashed on the 'Grandest Stage'. On a Network special about her ups and downs with the company years later, she spoke through very different tears how it wasn't just the perceived injustice of the booking but how little it meant to her when it was once everything.
4. Triple H
WWE's omni-botched 'Summer Of Punk' wasn't short of embarrassing moments, but it might not have gotten any worse than the moment CM Punk marked his cards with the company by slapping Triple H in the face with his own tie.
It came during yet another head-to-head segment between the two, laced with worked shoot lines that were as nonsensical as they were narratively unnecessary. Or, they were until 'The Game' got so wound up by his ego getting checked for once that he - per Kevin Nash himself - took 'Big Sexy's spot in a planned pay-per-view match between the two just so he could pin Punk's shoulders to the match. Beyond using Hunter's suit against him, Punk also brought Stephanie McMahon up, which was enough to rattle Paul Levesque's cage for real.
The pursed lips were good enough to make the gif, but the anger carries on after the moment that became a meme. With Hunter not being able to get the last word before the music played them off (hen's-teeth rare for him, especially when getting out-witted), he can be seen doing a fake applause and mouthing "congratulations", knowing that he's about to kill The Punker's push.
There's a certain charm to it through a 2026 lens - the two men that hated each other eventually came together when the opportunity to properly do business presented itself.
3. Shawn Michaels
Is it any wonder WWE fell so far behind WCW right when Shawn Michaels happened to be the company's North Star?
Not that 'HBK' wasn't the best wrestler in the world in 1996 (he was) or that he couldn't back up his obnoxious hubris every time the bell rang (he could), but as the former market leader dropped behind a resurgent, New World Order-led opposition, Michaels' typically sour mood got even worse, threatening to destroy everything in his path.
This made a particularly bad night for WWE even worse when, following a catastrophic weather-based power outage at In Your House: Beware Of Dog, a match with the British Bulldog was on again/off again/back-on-again before limping to a lousy 50/50 finish that existed to set up the rematch rather than a brand new hot summer series. Most of the card had been viewed by the live crowd under emergency lighting as pay-per-view punters lost their feed and the building lost power, with things only getting back going again in time for Bulldog and Michaels to go out there under-prepared to try and salvage something from the night.
With goals, aims and time cues all over the shop with everything else, Michaels grew so furious with the referee and disillusioned ringsiders that he took to starting verbal spats with everybody. Even when he was selling. Michaels' backstage foibles been so out-front, and things were going to get a lot worse before they got better, for performer and promoter.
2. Bianca Belair
Bianca Belair had held the WWE Raw Women's Championship for well over a year before she did the honours for Asuka at Night Of Champions 2023, and didn't look all that thrilled to be saying goodbye to it once and for all just a month after defeating the 'Empress Of Tomorrow' at WrestleMania 39 a few weeks earlier.
Perhaps she saw the last 'Show Of Shows' as the only major hurdle in turning a long reign into a Roman-style reign? She was 420 days deep into the run having dethroned Becky Lynch at WrestleMania 38 over a year earlier, with her first title win coming in the main event of WrestleMania 37 back in 2021. Maybe 'The Grandest Stage' being such a key destination in her career made the Jeddah B-Show feel smaller time in contrast, but something took the spring out of her step as she made her trademark skipping, hair-twirling entrance for the bout. There was a lot less of both, and missing too was the smile that lit up arenas and stadiums the world over during 'The EST's iconic run.
For contrast, take a look at her entrance for what turned out to be a hugely controversial loss to the returning Becky Lynch at SummerSlam 2021. Belair has to obscure that she's losing the belt and the impending surprise comeback for 'The Man', and she makes it appear as though she's not even aware intended opponent Sasha Banks is set to miss the bout. She's the sharpest and shrewdest, but it was possible to see just about see through the act on what would go on to be one of her last nights (as of 2026) holding gold.
1. Lex Luger
There's a great clip easily found online of Lex Luger parading around with the WWE Championship belt ahead of WrestleMania X.
For years, it had been the sort of footage that only existed in write-ups from newsletters reported back by people that were in attendance, and seen through the hazy lens of a disposable camera shot from a bad angle. A curio, akin to The Last Battle Of Atlanta, Bret Hart Vs Tom Magee and other rarities that existed as much in the conversation as in the real world. Until they all arrived, neatly packaged on services such as much-missed WWE Network and WWE's Vault YouTube channel, servicing as wish fulfilment content for longstanding fans when Raw and SmackDown won't do the job.
Luger lap of honour (and that's all it ended up being) is fascinating to observe. How does he appear with the gold around his waist? How are fans taking to it? What micro-expressions can be spotted across Vince McMahon's face as he gives it one last look before making his mind up. It's quite the cheesy scene, never intended for air, with Jim Cornette selling fume as McMahon and Luger set up the preposterous scenario of announcing the former 'Narcissist' as "new World Wrestling Federation Champion", in a way that might have slotted in as real footage just fine had he got the job done against Yokozuna on 'The Grandest Stage'.
He didn't, of course, hence why the footage went back on the shelf. And wouldn't you just know it by his entrance? Looking like he'd rather be anywhere else (ironic, considering that a bus had taken him all over the shop the prior summer and he'd gotten sick of that as well), Luger knew that he wasn't getting his hands back on it after fighting Yoko, or for that matter ever again.