NWO, WCW And When Too Suhweet Became Sour

The nWo was a concept borne out of genius. With Scott Hall and Kevin Nash having just moved to WCW, and with Hulk Hogan being there already, Eric Bischoff thought out a plan in 1996 to make WWE stars look like invaders to the WCW product, stealing a march on the WWE who were not prepared for this sort of storyline, nor the ramifications it would have on the ratings. Fast forward to 2000 and the nWo had lost its lustre. Instead of being one of the shining lights of WCW, now it seemed to be a massive millstone that the company simply could not rid itself from. WCW seemed married to the nWo, and wasn't prepared to admit that it really wasn't working anymore, with constant updates, reunions and break ups making Friends' Ross and Rachel saga seem steady in comparison. The fact remains though that for a while the nWo were the hottest thing on TV. However, for all the good they did WCW, now many look back and see the nWo to represent some of the worst excesses of selfish top card talent. While it would be part of the foundations that would make WCW a massive thorn in Vince's side, it would also be a major cog in the downfall of the company. In the 5th of these articles about the great lost opportunities of wrestling (Part one, two, three and four can be seen here), I will examine what was compelling about the nWo before looking at why it did not end on better terms. Finally I will examine if there was a better way to gracefully say goodbye to the angle.

It Seemed Real

nwo The Monday Night Wars were at their apex when Scott Hall and Kevin Nash switched sides and made their way to Atlanta. The orthodox way of doing things would have been for Hall and Nash to be introduced to great fanfare and the like and given an interview with Mean Gene- the way that Hogan and Savage were. However when Scott Hall moseyed down the stairs of the run way, the WCW universe knew that this was anything but normal. When he spoke he didn't address the other wrestlers, nor did he address titles. Instead Hall referenced Ted Turner and the Monday Night Wars- implying that he was invading the other side's territory. This was reinforced when Kevin Nash spoke to Bischoff saying that Bischoff had been talking about a war between his show and the WWE's. While Nash may have got the category of word wrong when it came to 'play' in that famous promo (it is a verb, not an adjective...) there is no doubt the message was clear: Hall and Nash were there to run roughshod over the WCW promotion. When Hogan was added a little while later at bash at the beach and the New World Order was officially formed, the conflict still seemed like one that was only half fake- with people tuning in to WCW each week to see what would happen next.

It Was New

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfQ3IH-TWVI The nWo idea was certainly lifted at least initially from an idea from Japan but the way it was presented and marketed to fans was something completely out of the box. Black and White messages cut together like a music video with an amazing guitar riff as the soundtrack allowed people to immediately see them as different from what they believed WCW was- colourful and rooted in tradition. At a time when WCW was relying on the acquisition of WWE stars, as well as NWA stalwarts such as Ric Flair and Sting, the nWo was incredibly important for WCW for identifying themselves as unique to the competition. Thanks in a large part to the nWo, when one wanted to watch a wrestling show during the Monday Night Wars, WCW became as the more innovative wrestling show- despite the fact its top stars were made up from a lot of the competition's old roster.

It Became Cool

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0keslql2jWk The nWo were supposedly heels- working to tear down the establishment of WCW. However, the more that many fans saw of the nWo, the more they liked them. WCW looked far too much boring like a family-orientated programming for many young wrestling fans who wanted their wrestling to be more rebellious and cool. The nWo catered to these fans and made the idea of heels seem cool as they didn't just try and win titles- but in fact wanted to tear down the whole boring environment of WCW, and the rules that governed it. While traditional wrestling fans may have been horrified by some of the tactics that the nWo were using, the nWo was creating controversy that in turn created attention to a demographic that seen wrestling as becoming tired and Disneyfied under the guise of Hogan and the like. It is ironic that after all the time that the family orientated WWE spent trying to cultivate some attention in the mainstream media with its squeaky clean image, that it was the too-cool-for-school nWo that allowed wrestling to really become pop culture news. So with all this going for them, why is the nWo thought of now with such mixed memories?

Evil Always Won

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WhS4ZDnRqJQ The nWo ran roughshod over the WCW for a couple of years, and while this may have seen cool to many, it did make the nWo seem less like heels and more like the cool kids on the block. So when many babyfaces came up against members of the nWo, they found themselves on the end of losing results as the creative team on WCW found themselves wanting to sustain the nWo's push for as long as it could. This would have been fine, but as more and more members joined the nWo to make them seem like more of a threat in order for more and more twists to happen, the nWo soon looked less like the anti-establishment and more like the new establishment. While groups in WWE, such as D-Generation X never got so big as to run the show- the nWo seemed to increasingly add more and more members until they just became statistics in their own stable. Furthermore, the idea of adding Eric Bischoff to the company only seemed to reinforce this. How could the owner/executive producer be working for the nWo without the nWo seeming less like rebels and more like, as Jim Cornette said, a bunch of guys hanging out in a clubhouse up a tree.

Who Was Their Breakout Star?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSRrXyrjUSk People joined the nWo in order to get a push and get their break to put their career onto the next level. As the nWo became hotter and hotter, more and more stars attempted to get on the bandwagon in order to ride it to main event success. Having, said that, it would be incredibly difficult to name a break out star that benefited from a tenure in the nWo in the long term. That's the difference between the nWo, and say Evolution who did have rising talent who they made main event stars out of in Batista and Randy Orton. Both became major parts of the WWE legacy over the next few years and are going to be Hall of Famers at the end of their career. The nWo, on the other hand, felt that if their top guys did not have the titles, then there would be no point- leaving the midcard wrestler who joined them hoping for a push being little more than a henchman. Sooner or later the wrestling product needs to move on- making new and better stars for the future. The nWo did not allow this to happen, because they could not see beyond the next PPV and so too many prospective stars either got buried by the nWo by fighting them, or chewed up and spat out by the inside politics of the stable. This led to another problem...

When Does it End?

wcw Stables have a nasty habit of just flopping out with no huge payoff because there is a lot more trouble given to construction of the stables than its eventual disintegration. Far too many times a stable that starts out like a house on fire ends up just being messy and tired by the time of its departure. The alternative was a white knight coming a destroying the stable all by their lonesome- thereby burying the stars of the stable, such as John Cena taking out the Nexus. The nWo could be filed under the messy category, with the creative team at WCW not willing to kill what they saw as the golden goose, despite the fact that their act was not getting any fresher. When the nWo got really bloated, WCW decided to split it between nWo Hollywood and nWo Wolfpac- which not made no sense as the nWo was already feuding with WCW, it increasingly marginalised the WCW as nWo stories continued to dominate the program. Then, when they should have been looking forward with new storylines and ideas, they coined the idea of an nWo 2000 with many different members- not realising that by doing so they made it almost impossible not to compare it to the amazing group that had taken the world by storm a couple of years ago. Ironically, the nWo which once was seen as railing against the nostalgia of WCW was now being used as an a nostalgia act to drum up business. So what could the nWo have done differently to make their legacy more of a untarnished one.

Conclusions

kevin nash Dutch Mantell once said that if a booker was smart he would pull out of an angle before the crowd was sick of it. That way, the product never felt forced or stale and if there was a chance you wanted to re-visit the angle some time down the road, the audience would not be drained by it. The nWo does not give the feeling that the WCW creative team ever heard of Dutch's philosophy- allowing the nWo to not only become dominating and politically poisonous in the locker room, but also repetitive. Furthermore, if they had allowed the group to end earlier, they may have had the chance for some good main events that could really created hype.If the nWo had endeavoured to push a talent to the main event scent of WCW, or allow someone to get more oxygen by joining their group, then perhaps it may have a better legacy than it does. However, the fact that Hogan, Nash and Hall spent so much time at the forefront at the group without allowing any of the talent lower down on the card (of which there was much in WCW) to attempt and set themselves apart as a potential torch bearer really is a major reason why the wheels fell of WCW entirely. Having said all this, the nWo was an incredible angle that reshaped wrestling in so many ways. It is just a shame that due to the egos of many involved, as well as the fear to take the risk to move away from the nWo when it was beginning to lag caused irreparable damage not only to the New World Order, but to WCW.


Contributor
Contributor

Gamer, Pop Culture consumer and WWE watcher, Vectron44 has been described as a prophet of truth, a pain in the proverbial and everything in between. Approach with caution lest you get sucked into his world of geek.