THIS Is The Same Mistake WWE Makes Every WrestleMania Season

It's a BIG show. We get it.

shayna baszler becky lynch
WWE.com

On this week's Monday Night RAW, WWE did it again.

After Becky Lynch decisively vanquished Asuka in their rubber match, she was assaulted by Shayna Baszler to resume their rivalry and set up their match at WrestleMania 36. This was the first beat of the story, and as such, it needed to be big, but not monumental. The major angle should occur deep into the second act to inform the must-see drama of the third. The story should escalate with room to escalate further. On this week's Monday Night RAW, Shayna Baszler pulled back Becky Lynch's hair, removed her own mouthguard, and sank her teeth into the back of her neck. Becky sold it as if a chunk of flesh had been torn off her, and she was placed in an ambulance she then commandeered, Steve Austin-style, to maker her heroic return to the arena.

There were three problems with this angle.

It didn't feel remotely in character nor necessary for it. Baszler is a special talent, in that she is in herself a terrifying presence. She's a former MMA fighter who has adapted that legitimacy into her deeply convincing pro wrestling work. She has made facial expressions far scarier when trapping opponents into her Kirifuda clutch. Her elbow-breaker spot is far more visceral and believable in its revulsion. This angle felt like hokey, tacked-on pro wrestling theatre.

If the principle behind the angle wasn't awful - or wasn't faithful - the execution wasn't great. The blood was practically luminous; instantly, it looked fake - which is the literally the one word that has never described anything Baszler has done in NXT - and the gravity of the situation wasn't sold, much less the attack itself.

Thirdly: where do WWE go from here?

CONT'D...(1 of 5)


becky lynch stephanie mcmahon raw promo
WWE.com

This plot development can't escalate, and under the principles of drama, it cannot be ignored nor diminished. Somehow, with this shock tactic, WWE has lessened the impact of Baszler's deadly arsenal. An expertly-applied submission hold will not hold the same visual power. A vampire is deadlier than a wrestler.

WWE did it again, and "it" in this latest specific example was WWE emphasising a story beat to the point of farce in order to enhance WrestleMania season.

The omens for Shayna Baszler Vs. Becky Lynch are not great, gauging by last year's hopelessly excessive Winner Take All storyline. The original premise of the story was simple and elevated by the enormous star power of the respective players. Reduced, Becky Lynch versus Ronda Rousey was a tale of belief versus quality. It was genuinely inspiring. And then WWE botched it by ruining the crux of Becky's character to such a backwards extent that she cut a pitiable figure. She suffered a storyline knee injury in a rote bid for sympathy, and the crutch she carried with her removed all of her zeitgeist-grabbing power. WWE surgically removed the essence of The Man and transplanted tropes where her heart once was.

Deeply unnecessary Authority interference did her in, too. She was sorry, alright; when she apologised to Triple H and Stephanie McMahon, this submissive behaviour seemed to punish everybody for drawing comparisons between Becky Lynch and Steve Austin. A sh*tty smorgasbord of WWE tropes, one, at least, was very fun.

WWE has taken the whole "Road" thing rather seriously in recent years.

CONT'D...(2 of 5)


Becky Lynch Charlotte Flair Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

The Road has become literal by positioning its key players in very contrived vehicular angles, and in 2019, with Charlotte Flair interjected in the picture, the three women kicked the sh*t out of one another in a police car fisticuffs angle on the go-home show. Loosely-plotted but well-performed, the bombast of it all just about excused its contrived premise.

Kofi Kingston was afflicted by the same odds-stacking over on SmackDown in a series of diminished Gauntlet matches. All too often, WWE arrives at the perfect WrestleMania story, the thrust of which peaks in a fantastic, early segment, and scrambling, creative proceeds to go batsh*t crazy on tropes and visuals that only serve to dilute it.

In 2018, WWE warped reality to an extent that Vince Russo couldn't conceive by promoting Roman Reigns, stigmatised as the office favourite, as the office enemy. Mr. McMahon was compelled to suspend him after a heated confrontation, in which Reigns questioned the absence of Brock Lesnar. They had the temerity to script Reigns to say that Lesnar was McMahon's "boy". A simple story of redemption and ascension was ruined - they shouldn't have ran it, and they still ran it into the ground - with the least credible attempt to blur the lines in the history of professional wrestling. It was, again, a totally unnecessary story element that must have felt, to them, in some way lurid and compelling.

These people are selectively magnetised to vehicles between February and April. It's an epidemic.

CONT'D...(3 of 5)


Dean Ambrose
WWE.com

In 2017, to build AJ Styles Vs. Shane McMahon, Styles smashed McMahon's head through a car window. This effectively built the grudge premise of their programme, but it was still cliched. What's telling is that The Miz and Maryse Vs. John Cena and Nikki Bella storyline was the most entertaining of 2017's lot, and the parody of intensity was absent altogether. Plotted with a pitch-perfect levity, Miz ethered Cena's robotic personal life in quality, genuinely funny parody segments. They served to entertain the crowd and strengthen Cena's resolve for physical retribution. WWE built anticipation for the physical meeting by not scripting Cena and Miz in extravagantly dumb and intensified scenarios that could only ever render a collar-and-elbow tie-up totally quaint and anticlimactic in comparison.

2016's theoretical blood feud was almost offensively bad and cartoonish. Terry Funk handed Chekhov's chainsaw to Dean Ambrose for use in his match with Brock Lesnar, only, he was never going to use it. WWE built a match - that people genuinely thought at the time could represent Ambrose's WrestleMania 13 moment - with a sight gag. Nobody thought Ambrose would ever use it, but the visual symbolised a sense of ghoulish excitement ahead of the match that WWE had no intention of satiating. These, ultimately, are professional wrestling matches, and WWE all too often complicate the crux of them with storytelling devices that are in no way germane to what any of this is.

Obviously, this hasn't happened during every WrestleMania season - it's f*cking WrestleMania, it didn't become a beloved, enduring institution by being sh*t - but this nonsensical, tacked-on bombast stretches back years further.

CONT'D...(4 of 5)


Triple H Randy Orton Stephanie Mcmahon
WWE.com

The build to Triple H Vs. Randy Orton at WrestleMania 25 was so overblown that the match never stood a chance, ill-advised stipulation or no. WWE ramped up the incident so high that no methodical match, even one involving weapons, could ever have cleared it. This is the company that makes movies, but Christ, even Tommy Wiseau has a better grasp of the logical order of events. In the Room, the big Johnny Vs. Mark fight doesn't happen before the argument.

Hell, the WWF almost conspired to ruin the Rock Vs. Hulk Hogan build by booking Hogan to ram Rock's ambulance with a semi truck. They didn't ruin it, obviously. It was incapable of being ruined. But Rock was back next week. There's never any serious consequence. These We're on the Road to WrestleMania! beats are plotted for the desperate sake of it.

In taking such an over-the-top forward step to drive the narrative, WWE all too often gets it backwards. WWE should remain faithful to the big stories, and not render them farcical and desperate with big, dumb beats. The whole premise of 'Mania is that the biggest stars of the preceding year are pitted against one another to create the biggest, most novel matches. Less is more is counterintuitive to the way WWE operates - particular around 'Mania season - but Ronda Rousey Vs. Charlotte Flair Vs. Becky Lynch drew little heat. Brock Lesnar Vs. Dean Ambrose drew little heat. Triple H V. Randy Orton drew little heat.

All three matches were built on - and burned out by - outrageous heat angles.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!