WWE Crown Jewel 2025: 8 Nightmares That Could Come True

That's not the OTC. It's not the Tribal Chief. That's...that's...the BIG DOG.

WWE Crown Jewel 2025 Roman Reigns
WWE

Jokes are already doing the rounds about the various local start times for watching this weekend's Crown Jewel PLE. Folks in the UK, for example, are laughing about the switchover from typical midnight/1am starts to a rare 1pm kick off. 'I don't know if I'll be awake that early', said someone on X. Much merriment was had in the comments, but that's nothing compared to the 8am start some in the US have to look forward to.

Will WWE's latest supershow be full of similar merriment though, or will it be a nightmare-filled morning/afternoon that leaves everybody unsatisfied or (worse) aghast? As usual, Triple H has front loaded the card with plenty of star power, but there are still just 5 bouts scheduled for the show at time of writing - the last of those was added on Monday's Raw when Roman Reigns and Bronson Reed announced an ‘Australian Street Fight’.

Questions remain about the validity of these Crown Jewel championships on the men's and women's side, and about just how much gas John Cena has left in the tank as he ticks down towards retirement. Interactions between them on recent TV suggests that all isn't well in The Vision ranks right now either. All of this is worth keeping an eye trained on heading into Saturday.

There won't be any shock title changes to write home about in Australia, but WWE might still book a few swerves. They better have some surprises in store for Perth and the watching world too, because the last thing Hunter needs is another apathetic PLE. 'The Game' needs a hit.

Here's the worst of the worst that could happen at Crown Jewel. Be warned!

8. Tiffany Stratton’s Struggles Continue

WWE Crown Jewel 2025 Tiffany Stratton Stephanie Vaquer
WWE.com

2025 started off with a bang for Tiffy, but she hasn’t really done all that much since her incendiary (and sometimes real-life) feud with Charlotte Flair peaked at WrestleMania 41. This match vs. Stephanie Vaquer is a chance for Stratton to get back on form then. She has to take it, because it looks like her title reign is ticking down and she’s really struggling as a character. Honestly? Something is going badly wrong here.

Vaquer just feels like a much bigger deal than Tiffany going into Crown Jewel, which is remarkable when both of them are riding high atop respective divisions on Raw and SmackDown. This should be a monster battle between fresh faces dominating the women's scene, and yet it's Stephanie who's towering over Stratton at the moment.

Realistically, Vaquer will take the win and become the next Women's Crown Jewel Champ, but it's vitally important that Tiffany puts in a strong in-ring performance to remind everyone behind the scenes what she's capable of. Frankly, it's bizarre that Triple H appears to have forgotten just how talented she is. Some of the nonsense 'Tiffy Time' has been getting up to since Charlotte is...unacceptable, and it's rubbish that she's been pushed so far into the background on SmackDown.

Another so-so performance on Saturday could spell disaster for Tiffany in the immediate aftermath. Her title reign has been sagging for too long, and now she's under real threat of losing her shiny status as WWE's emerging female star of the future. How did we get here?!

A heel turn might be her best bet to grab 2026 by the balls.


7. Australia Boos Roman Reigns Like It's 2019

WWE Crown Jewel 2025 Roman Reigns Bronson Reed
WWE.com

This is unlikely to happen, because Peth’s wrestle-daft masses will surely be thrilled to see WWE’s biggest stars up close and personal, but Bronson Reed wrestling on a major card in his own country is a big deal. So, there might be some scattered booing for the OTC, especially deep into this “Australian Street Fight” when Bronson’s on top and scoring a few big near falls but Reigns keeps kicking out.

Reigns winning could even get jeers, assuming that’s the finish. If that happens, then he'd be forgiven for thinking he was right back in 2019 when people were downright sick of the 'Big Dog' pre-'Tribal Chief' reinvention. Back then, it wasn't uncommon to hear booing during Roman's matches or promos, but that's been no concern at all in more recent times.

Sure, he was booed as a heel, but that was the point. Since going babyface, Reigns has been greeted favourably by pretty much everybody buying tickets to Raw, SmackDown or PLEs, and WWE won't expect that to change soon. However, they did just book an Australian wrestler who's done really well for himself in a match that's even named after his country, so this could get dicey on the night.

Roman is in a holding pattern of grand comebacks, and it's a case of diminishing returns for him heading into the final few months of the year. Is it only a matter of time before the fanbase at large grows tired of him, or will any boos heard in Perth be down to local support for Bronson and nothing else?

Let's find out.


6. IYO SKY Rejoins The Kabuki Warriors

WWE Crown Jewel 2025 Rhea Ripley IYO SKY Asuka Kairi Sane Kabuki Warriors
WWE.com

Logic dictates that this can't happen. It wouldn’t make a lick of sense, because IYO SKY has been literally fighting Asuka and Kairi Sane lately alongside Rhea Ripley. However, heels have beaten the crap out of one another to drop a babyface’s guard before. Ye olde swerve wouldn’t be anything new, but no - it shouldn’t happen.

SKY is doing fine as a babyface who relies on the strength of her in-ring performances, and there’s no need to change that for the sake of a shock result. Plus, seeing Rhea Ripley drop to defeat in Australia given the layout of this tag would just seem stupid. She should rightly be the biggest focal point in this match, and she has to score the pin on either Kabuki Warrior then celebrate with IYO.

It writes itself.

Triple H may disagree. Either that or someone on his creative team (as seen on WWE Unreal) could throw out a 'what if?' situation. It'd be silly, 'cause Rhea winning on her return home is a no-brainer and suits the story being told anyway, but swerves lurk in the back of fan minds for a reason. You just never know when one is coming, and wrestling is typically unable to resist 'the one thing you didn't expect to happen'.

It'll suck if IYO flashes a grin at Asuka or Sane early in the match then turns on Rhea for a 3-on-1 beatdown. Not only would that ruin one of only 5 matches on the card, but it'd also spit in the face of things that have been going down on Raw. Nah, surely this is an impossibility!


5. Announcers Lean On Raw vs. SmackDown

Tiffany Stratton Stephanie Vaquer Nick Aldis WWE Contract Signing
WWE.com

The brand split is dead. It has been for ages.

WWE barely has a recognisable, credible brand split to speak of in October 2025 anyway. Technically, the rosters are separate, but wrestlers show up whenever they like on rival shows without consequence so it’s flimsy. If Michael Cole and the other commentators start banging on about the importance of “brand warfare” over the weekend, then we’re in trouble. That’d likely mean some ‘Team Raw’ vs. ‘Team SmackDown’ matches would be considered for Survivor Series.

They’d mean nothing. That whole “brand warfare” hype means little to viewers tuning in, especially these days. People were getting pretty sick of it a generation ago under Vince McMahon, and there's simply no need to make it a focal point under Triple H's watch. Hell, they don't even have video games to sell with the Raw vs. SmackDown tag these days! It'd be pointless. A stupid idea from bad creative, if you like.

Unfortunately, both Crown Jewel Championship bouts have some brand business just beneath the surface. Seth Rollins is a Raw guy, and Cody Rhodes is a SmackDown guy. Stephanie Vaquer is a Raw champ, and Tiffany Stratton is a SmackDown champ. Gee, how thrilling. Thankfully, WWE has managed to find slightly more for the men's match than that. Not so for the women, sadly.

The idea that wrestlers care about which show they're tied to when they freely rock up elsewhere without consulting GMs is weak. It'd be insulting to fans if Cole and the announce crew pushed the idea of brand loyalty or the importance of being team red or team blue at this stage in the game.

Please don't even mention it, lads.


4. John Cena & AJ Styles Can’t Match Hype

WWE Crown Jewel 2025 John Cena AJ Styles
WWE

Some fans are going into this one expecting a throwback to classics at SummerSlam 2016 and Royal Rumble 2017, but times have changed. These are not the same performers they were almost a decade ago, and that could make it tough for Cena and Styles to put on a 30 minute clinic full of greatest hits without a few hiccups. Fingers crossed they knock it out of the park, but it’s OK to be worried that they won’t.

Besides, Cena's recent match history is a bit spotty. Some of his retirement tour matches have been sketchy, let's be honest about that straight away. WrestleMania 41's headliner vs. Cody Rhodes was poor, his relative squash at the hands of Brock Lesnar come Wrestlepalooza felt like a rehash of SummerSlam 2014, and then he's done some stuff with R-Truth that ultimately fell short of greatness too.

It isn’t like this has been some year long tour de force for the legend. Here's hoping this final match with AJ is closer to the quality of Cena vs. Logan Paul at Clash In Paris than some of his other bouts. Man, that statement alone might ruffle some feathers amongst those who still can't stand Logan.

Word of warning: Maybe don't watch Cena vs. Styles from yesteryear before Crown Jewel 2025. It'd be a minor miracle if they're able to pull off many of the slick exchanges they did between 2016-2017. Both guys might look at comments like that and think, 'Challenge accepted'. Good, because this writer doesn't want the match to be bad.

He's merely fretting that it won't be as great as hoped.


3. The Titles Stay Put In Australia

WWE Bad Blood 2024 Triple H Crown Jewel Championship
WWE

WWE barely mentioned the Crown Jewel Titles on TV after Cody Rhodes and Liv Morgan won them in Saudi Arabia last year. In fact, they’re not even defendable prizes that track consistently between "champions" it seems, so…what’s the point? If they're one night only belts, then they're glorified house show attractions at best; albeit house show attractions launched onto a mainline PLE.

It's a bizarre way of formatting things to effectively say: 'These titles are only important in this market, but not in any other, and they're not something you should think about as soon as *insert PLE here* is done'. It’d be better if WWE did have the winners bring each belt along on the road for a while once they’re back from Australia. Y’know, to actually give these matches some tangible sense of purpose beyond Saturday night.

The way it should be? Yes. What WWE will do? Probably not.

Keep that in mind when Seth, Cody, Stephanie or Tiffany celebrate with the titles over in Perth. They'll likely head backstage, snap a few quick pics with the thing, then hand it to a WWE staffer who will put it into storage until next year's Crown Jewel takes place in the UK or somewhere else. Then, the hype train will begin all over again, and some will pretend to care for a few weeks.

Remember Braun Strowman's Greatest Royal Rumble strap? Yeah, this is verging on that, and that's not meant as a compliment in the slightest. These titles will continue to mean sod all unless they become a larger part of the regular product, at least for a few months. That isn't much to ask.


2. Paul Heyman Splits From Seth Rollins

WWE Crown Jewel 2025 Cody Rhodes Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Aggro between Paul Heyman and Seth Rollins is one thing, but a full on split would be another entirely. Overall, it just feels far too soon to make this happen, doesn’t it? WWE have been teasing a power struggle on Raw and SmackDown recently. It’s unlikely to happen, but Triple H loves his surprises and moments, so maybe this will be slapped on the card to give Crown Jewel some headlines.

The nightmare here is that Heyman is the one who costs Seth by having Bronson Reed and Bron Breakker beat him down. That’d dump Rollins out of his own faction and leave him rudderless. Plus, he shouldn’t be a babyface again this early. Please say we aren't heading back towards the brightly-coloured outfits, all that dancing, and his obnoxious laughs. Pretty please?!

Seth is a much better character when he's serious, and he's able to do that as a heel. Turning him, or even having him exit The Vision without a proper babyface turn, would be preposterous right now. It'd send him tumbling closer to failed "Paul Heyman Guys" like Ryback or Curtis Axel than successes like Brock Lesnar, CM Punk or Roman Reigns, and no-one wants that.

WrestleMania 41's moment between Heyman and Rollins was too good to toss away after a few arguments and disagreements on TV. They must be stronger than that. WWE acts don't need to fall apart just because they're not seeing eye to eye 100% of the time. It's like tag-teams who split - why do they always need to feud rather than going their separate ways with a handshake?

Of course, Crown Jewel could use something mega to help sell it as important to 2025's story, but...


1. There’s No (Logical) PLE Making Shock

Gunther WWE
WWE.com

...it has to be logical.

Brock Lesnar’s controversial return at SummerSlam had everybody talking. Then, Wrestlepalooza didn’t have much to shout about beyond Lesnar giving John Cena a kicking and some tidy matches, but Crown Jewel is a bigger deal than that definite 'B' show by default (due to being international) and needs something monumental.

Randy Orton turning on Cody Rhodes or Gunther returning to stare down Cena. Something like that would work. The past couple of WWE PLEs have received a fair bit of apathy, so it’s in Triple H’s interest to fan some flames and get folks buzzing about the product again. Some matches taking top billing in 2025 have played before lacklustre build, then have been quickly forgotten about as soon as they're finished.

It's high time to change that, because it won't be too long until 'Mania season is here again.

Orton going after the WWE Title and showing some old 'Legend Killer'/Legacy leader evil sounds like a party this fan wants to be invited to. He can always slip back into the stalwart babyface role on the back end after feuding with Rhodes. Similarly, if reports are true and Gunther is going to be Cena's next rival, then he should at least be shown watching Cena vs. AJ Styles from a skybox before reacting to JC's win.

There has to be more to Crown Jewel than just a print out of results like, 'John Cena beats AJ Styles in their final match ever' or, 'Cody Rhodes is Crown Jewel Champ for the second year running'. Give us some drama, Hunter. This PLE deserves that, and so do fans watching worldwide.

What other nightmares could come true at WWE Crown Jewel 2025? For more wrestling, check out 10 WWE Fates Worse Than Death and 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2005! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.