WWE: The Ultimate WrestleMania Ranking - From Worst To Best

29. Wrestlemania IX- Overall Score: 1.5/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fCz4Y8oTBJc OMQ: 1 CROWD: 1 STAR POWER: 2 HR: 1 FEUDS: 1 PROD. VALUE: 3 Wrestlemania IX is generally regarded as the worst Wrestlemania and you're not going to get any argument from me. From top-to-bottom a poorly booked show of awful matches that nobody gave a toss about. Even Hulk Hogan could no longer make a difference at this point. The one solace of this event is it's look. The first 'Mania to be held outdoors and in daylight, the event had a unique, previously unseen gloss to it and whilst having Jim Ross come out in a toga and Bobby Heenan enter on the back of camel might have been pushing it, it was the only decent factor to the worst Wrestlemania ever. Oh and that finish with Hogan winning the title... nope.28. Wrestlemania IV- Overall Score: 1.6/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FaMzrwqMie0 OMQ: 1 CROWD: 2 STAR POWER: 3 HR: 2 FEUDS: 1 PROD. VALUE: 1 On paper, I'm sure holding a one-night tournament to crown a new WWF Champion after the famous two Hebners finish between Hogan and Andre seemed like a swell idea. In practice, it was a disaster. 16 matches occurred during this 4-hour show, the VAST majority of them awful. Whilst Randy Savage's first World Title win might leave some fans feeling nostalgically positive in the present day, at the time it did awful business. It's been recognised that WWE fans, generally, like to know in advance what exactly they're paying for, in terms of matches. When they don't, like here or Cyber Sunday, they can become ambivalent. At only 175,000 buys, this event received the lowest buy-rate in Wrestlemania history. They didn't miss much. This event just never got off the ground.27. Wrestlemania XI- Overall Score: 1.6/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jIgyfkM276A OMQ: 2 CROWD: 2 STAR POWER: 2 HR: 2 FEUDS: 1 PROD. VALUE: 1 The mid-90s WWE was plagued with a series of uninspiring story-lines with uninspiring characters amidst the company's most bland and desperate times. This led to a selection of equally bland Wrestlemanias. You could tell Vince knew this event was in jeopardy off a lack of attractions when he centred the build-up to the show around the involvement of celebrities Pamela Anderson, Jenny McCarthy and Lawrence Taylor, whom would actually main event the show and, to his credit, bring a decent amount of mainstream exposure along with him. No disrespect meant to any of those individuals but, as it was once said, however, you can't polish a turd. Even Bret Hart had a stinker of a match at this one. Without question, the most forgettable Wrestlemania ever.26. Wrestlemania 2- Overall Score: 1.83/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SlTEUimyLSY OMQ: 1 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 3 HR: 2 FEUDS: 1 PROD. VALUE: 1 I suppose you might say that the second edition of the grandest event in pro-wrestling was like one massive botch. Held on a Monday night, rather than Sunday and across 3 different cities (New York, Chicago and Los Angeles), this event was diseased with a tonne of technical errors and dreadful celebrity guest commentary. Combine that with daft gimmick matches like Mr. T vs Roddy Piper in a boxing match and an insipid battle royale with a bunch of football players and what you have is a mess of an event that just didn't work. Thankfully, they learned from their mistakes. Seriously, a boxing match!? At WRESTLEmania!? C'mon now Vincent.25. Wrestlemania XXVII- Overall Score: 2/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sdA7PlNHXd0 OMQ: 2 CROWD: 2 STAR POWER: 3 HR: 1 FEUDS: 1 PROD VALUE: 3 WWE stock might be at a 15-year high, they might indeed be upon the back of the (relatively) successful launch of their brand spanking new network and they might well have managed to set a trilogy of Wrestlemanias- beginning here- around the feud of The Rock vs John Cena to an absolute ship load of money, all in proof that Vince McMahon and his idiotic daughter and doofus son-in-law actually know what they're doing. However, there will always stand testament the fact that one of them, at some time, under some kind of narcotic influence, decided it would be an "attraction" to promote a top feud for your biggest show around two mediocre commentators that ultimately led to Michael Cole in a bright, orange singlet on our screens. Oh and the main event ended in a double-count out. Jim Ross's commentary immediately said it sucked. He wasn't wrong. Wrestlemania 27 was crap (sans 'Taker vs Trips).24. Wrestlemania V- Overall Score: 2.16/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R2RJRTJFjBE OMQ: 2 CROWD: 1 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 2 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 1 THE MEGA POWERS EXPLODE! Actually, they didn't. Whilst possibly an attraction of a psychotic sense, seeing Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage literally explode would probably promote the wrong message about your product. It might, however, have woken the crowd up, whom seemed to be fitted with drips of ether for this event. Perhaps the dullest, quietest 'Mania ever. I dunno how much Donald Trump paid Vince to get Wrestlemania at his namesake venue in New Jersey for two years running but whatever it was, it wasn't enough! Other than that, it was another one of these early 4-hour Wrestlemanias that would've been twice as good if they'd shaved an hour and 5-6 atrocious matches off of the undercard. Not all of them were bad, though. A lad named Shawn Michaels made his 'Mania bow at the top of the show. He would go on to do quite well in subsequent 'Mania events.23. Wrestlemania 2000- Overall Score: 2.16/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R8OQ-Ygsy0k OMQ: 3 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 2 HR: 2 FEUDS: 1 PROD. VALUE: 2 'Mania 2000 should have been, by all rights, the greatest Wrestlemania of all time. When you consider WWE coming off the back of its hottest year ever in '99 and the massive influx of talent that they had just acquired: Jericho, Angle, Benoit, Guerrero; even the likes of Lita and Trish Stratus and then the tag teams of Edge & Christian, The Hardys & The Dudleys... and this was just the undercard! The Rock was as hot as he'd ever be, Trips and Foley had just torn the house down with a tremendous feud, the McMahon-Helmsely angle was in full-effect. This event should have torn the house down. Instead, it suffered from three primary factors: the injuries (and thus absence) of Stone Cold Steve Austin & The Undertaker, hosting the event at the Arrowhead Pond- they could've sold 60-70,000 easy- and a cluster-f*** of Vince Russo-esque booking, throwing tonnes of guys left and right into bizarre matches, leading to one of the most chaotic Wrestlemanias of all time. Anyone remember Al Snow and Steve Blackman as "Head-Cheese" or the logical, renowned tag-team of Kane and Rikishi? Sometimes, lesser is indeed more, WWE.22. Wrestlemania XII- Overall Score: 2.16/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LngJg_ZjVaA OMQ: 3 CROWD: 1 STAR POWER: 1 HR: 3 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 2 The debuts of Steve Austin and Triple H aside, this was quite possibly the 'Mania most lacking in star attraction in WWE history. Scott Hall & Kevin Nash were both on their way out of the company, following the likes of Hogan, Luger, Savage and others on to "greener pastures", leaving Vince scrambling for a way to populate a 3-hour 'Mania with a depleted roster. In retrospect, placing his two most prominent and promising stars into a 1-hour Ironman match was about the best he could do. The undercard thoroughly forgettable, this was a 1 match show and whilst debate can be made about the quality of the match itself, it did produce two of the most replayed moments in 'Mania history: Michaels' entrance and his title victory. It's funny watching how pissed-off Austin appeared doing his abysmal Ringmaster gimmick here.21. Wrestlemania 29- Overall Score: 2.3/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VWlnFd-bv1M OMQ: 2 CROWD: 1 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 1 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 3 Underwhelming. Lazy. Beige. Those were the first three words that came to my mind when I thought about Wrestlemania 29. It felt as if WWE did the absolute bare minimum with this event and certainly didn't go out of their way to provide the 80,000 or so fans whom convened upon MetLife Stadium last year a reason to remember it. It's telling- very telling- when the Raw event that followed the night after this has become the more noteworthy, memorable show. Not trying to disparage Raw, what a tremendous night that was but nothing and I mean NOTHING should ever shine brighter than Wrestlemania. That said, WWE got its 1 million buys, it got its record setting gate receipts and it got them on the back of two banal rematches. More power to them, I guess. Personally, I felt insulted by this event and pray tell they put a bit more pride into this year's showcase.20. Wrestlemania XXVI- Overall Score: 2.5/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rovfB38b3XY OMQ: 3 CROWD: 2 STAR POWER: 1 HR: 3 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 4 I often wonder if WWE has forgotten what it means to write Wrestlemania. In recent times, they seem to have forgone the idea that 'Mania needs moments, events or matches that defy time. That live in memory for ever. They seem to have diverted course to an idea that big stadiums, glossy lights and 15-minute guest music performances serve alone to make 'Mania unique. That and Undertaker's match. For if you take Undertaker's match out of 'Mania 25, 26, 27 and 29, what do you have? This was another one of those events that just simply didn't do enough- that passed by in an apathetic stream until 'Taker's match came along. Now that match, being Shawn Michaels' last, makes this event noteworthy but if WWE wants to create an event that stands true to the hyperbole they apply to the name of Wrestlemania again, they simply need to do more.19. Wrestlemania XXV- Overall Score: 2.5/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qk_bPTehKuM OMQ: 3 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 2 HR: 1 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 3 OK. 'Nuff of this negative lark, let's now be positive yo. The build-up to "The 25th anniversary of Wrestlemania" was, actually, not too bad. You had Michaels & 'Taker bound for an all-time classic, you had Randy Orton at the peak of his viper persona terrorising the McMahon family, even Matt Hardy's heel turn worked decent enough for a couple of months. I'll avoid talking about the whole Edge-Vickie Guerrero-Big Show love triangle débâcle- I said I'd be positive remember! This event laid the groundwork for, at least, a decent show and was ultimately let down by some poor booking decisions on the night and Mickey Rourke's 180-degree U-Turn on a supposed match with Chris Jericho. On another day, this event could've been one remembered fondly for the ages but just didn't do it on that given night. At least 'Taker and Michaels will stand the test of time.18. Wrestlemania 13- Overall Score: 2.6/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiTWsWSvnCA OMQ: 2 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 2 HR: 5 FEUDS: 2 PROD. VALUE: 2 Who would've known? Who could've known that when Steve Austin and Bret 'Hitman' Hart stepped into the squared circle the night of March 23rd 1997 that we were about to embark upon the journey of the most popular superstar and most popular era of all time? Sure Austin was getting a reaction, sure Bret was too but that kind of history? Nah man. It is true that the ultimate legacy of a moment or a match or even a whole Wrestlemania cannot be ascertained as it happens. Retrospect inevitably will play its part. Was an entire industry altered by one sharpshooter? Or is that melodramatic? What is known is that it all occurred AFTERWORDS. In retrospect, the legacy of 'Mania 13 is huge but the event itself, not so. Austin wasn't that kind of draw, yet. Michaels was hurt. The main event was terrible. It did the lowest Wrestlemania buy-rate of the last 25 years. Blame the nWo if you like but 'Mania 13 wasn't that great. Austin/Bret was but one match doesn't make a whole show- I don't care how famous it later becomes.17. Wrestlemania- Overall Score: 2.6/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8qucIIyUKw OMQ: 1 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 5 HR: 5 FEUDS: 1 PROD. VALUE: 1 There can and will for ever only be one original Wrestlemania. The event that redefined the pro-wrestling industry. Well, that's what WWE would tell you anyway. Some might argue Starrcade went there first but what the hell! This event wasn't a great show technically and is actually rather basic to watch compared to the glamour of the modern day events. What it was, however, was monumental. It was MSG, it was the first 'Mania. It was Hogan and Mr. T, Sammartino, Libarace and Muhammad Ali. It was sheer history before your eyes. It was something special and special is the lexicon of choice here. This event is unique and can never be replicated. In that, it's the model for all Wrestlemanias. Despite a roster with limited talent and primitive production values during a primitive era, this event defies time. That should be the goal every year, to create such an event. It doesn't always happen.16. Wrestlemania XV- Overall Score: 3/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fUyv5f0dwas OMQ: 2 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 2 FEUDS: 4 PROD. VALUE: 3 Ah, the Attitude Era. Heralded, championed and brilliant but boy did it lead to some daft, messy booking. 1999 was WWE's most successful year in history. Ratings reached astronomical peaks, merchandise flew off the shelves, left and right and WWE struck gold when it's biggest star ever (arguably) was joined up at the top by one of his brethren, The Rock. This main event, the first and worst of their trilogy, was what Wrestlemania was all about. Put the two top guys against each other, at the close of 'Mania where they belong. This was all about the main event. The rest of the card, from top-to-bottom, was mediocre at best and riddled with the downside of the Attitude Era: overbooking, illogical plot holes and daft, impulsive heel/face turns. Like Big Show, whom had been a heel for a mere month, after debuting, before turning on Vince McMahon at this event. High octane, fun and a little crazy, yes. However no amount of Attitude forgives placing Big Bossman inside the Hell in a Cell against Undertaker and then actually hanging him before cutting to a video package highlighting Austin and DX at a "RAGE Party" the night before. "LIMPIN' AINT EASY!" God love you Michael Foley.15. Wrestlemania XXIV- Overall Score: 3.16/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mONgYSdf5ps OMQ: 3 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 3 HR: 2 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 5 'Mania 24 is a testament to the superb quality of WWE's production team. I'm happy Stephanie McMahon gave them a shout out during a recent Raw in Chicago because they deserve it. 'Mania 24 looked and sounded amazing and was the first outdoors Wrestlemania since that infamous IX event that started this list. This was a very well-rounded Wrestlemania that ticked a lot of boxes without reaching the heady heights of some of the events yet to come. The presence of Floyd "Money" Mayweather in a special attraction fight against Big Show, a well-booked triple threat between Orton, Hunter and Cena that kept everyone guessing and a solid main event make this an overall good show. The only one black mark against it is the tarnished Ric Flair/HBK bout- supposedly a retirement match, which has since been discredited by Flair's run in TNA. Still a great moment, it's meaning has since been unfortunately lost and, thus, takes away from the prestige of this event somewhat.14. Wrestlemania VIII- Overall Score: 3.16/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMWqeV4yLZY OMQ: 3 CROWD: 4 STAR POWER: 5 HR: 2 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 3 Several times, thus far, I've discussed an event that was poor in spite of one, excellent match. Now, time for the inverse: an event that was very good, in spite of its main event and most potently promoted match: Hulk Hogan vs Sid Justice, a match which had no business closing Wrestlemania. For whatever reason, Ric Flair vs Hulk Hogan, the match which should have closed the show, didn't happen- supposedly due to a lack of in-ring chemistry between the two. As if Hogan and Sid had any. What you had, instead was an excellent undercard, involving a tremendous match between Bret Hart and Roddy Piper for the IC Title and Flair against Randy Savage for the WWF Title capped off by a dreadful match, which admittedly did lead to a hot ending to the show when Ultimate Warrior returned. 60,000 screaming fans, a much more digestible 3-hour show, rather than 4 hours and opening bouts including Shawn Michaels & The Undertaker make 'Mania VIII- the last of the first generation of Wrestlemania events- one of the best.13. Wrestlemania 22- Overall Score: 3.16/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JqyLwFw7MnI OMQ: 3 CROWD: 5 STAR POWER: 2 HR: 3 FEUDS: 2 PROD. VALUE: 4 "Big Time, oh, oh, oh oh oh-" oh, aint this just the worst f*cking theme in Wrestlemania history. Shut up. Now. I'm glad to say the rest of Wrestlemania 22 was far better than it's theme song, which legitimately makes me want to stapedoctomise myself every time I hear it (that's deafen myself, I haven't made that up). 'Mania 22 was one of the entertaining and humorous Wrestlemania's in WWE history, mostly thanks to Shawn Michaels against Vince McMahon and Jim Ross' hilarious commentary. Go look that up if you haven't seen it: "McMahon's on queer street, not that there's anything wrong with that!" Other than that, this show had some great matches and moments. The best Women's Championship match, maybe ever? An article for another time, perhaps. A great Money in the Bank Ladder Match, an excellent double main-event for both brands' World Titles, the supremely hot Chicago crowd. I have no real complaints about this event itself. Maybe chop a couple of matches, *coughBookervsBoogeymancough* and give your World Title match a bit more time. Oh, the build-up could've been better too. The way they abused Eddie's death and all but hey ho, all is not lost. They delivered "Big Time" (uh, can't believe I just did that) on that night.12. Wrestlemania VI- Overall Score: 3.3/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0-IDfNObZK4 OMQ: 3 CROWD: 4 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 4 FEUDS: 2 PROD. VALUE: 3 The first Wrestlemania in Canada- home to some of the world's most passionate pro-wrestling fans. The first (and last, lol jk) time you'd ever seen Hulk Hogan lose a match clean on PPV and the first babyface vs babyface main event pro-wrestling had known; Wrestlemania VI is historic for many reasons. It's weakest point is, perhaps, its match quality- being another 4-hour, 14-match show but they weren't all bad, unlike prior events. Dusty Rhodes making his one and only wrestling appearance at Wrestlemania in a fun, mixed tag match against Randy Savage and Sensational Sherri. You had good matches between Ted DiBiase and Jake Roberts, Roddy Piper and Bad News Brown. Mr. Perfect's 'perfect record' was ended here and the crowd lapped it all up. Wrestlemania VI is the archetypal, first generation Wrestlemania and I love it.11. Wrestlemania 23- Overall Score: 3.3/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JHh2WUMoWE4 OMQ: 3 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 3 FEUDS: 4 PROD. VALUE: 3 Nobody saw the success of Wrestlemania 23 coming. Nobody thought it would be (for a while anyway) the most purchased Wrestlemania of all time. Perhaps it was the anti-Cena movement, rolled eyes at the involvement of Donald Trump or the mere fact The Great Khali won a match on the show but 'Mania 23 wasn't supposed to do that well. Goes to show you, "an attraction-based business". People wanted to see either McMahon or Trump get their head shaved and they paid to see it. The "Battle of the Billionaires" is the template for how to book a PPV match. Whilst you cannot make a show up of those matches alone, they make the difference. The feuds between Undertaker, Batista; Shawn Michaels and John Cena were extremely well booked and both very good matches but in terms of bringing eyeballs to your show that wouldn't normally come, you need something unique and different. It comes to being objective, you can't argue with the numbers. Wrestlemania 23 hit a home run and it's one that I would think WWE are most proud of and rightfully so.10. Wrestlemania VII- Overall Score: 3.5/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2NQT6smyQ9g OMQ: 3 CROWD: 5 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 3 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 3 We kick off the top 10 with the patriotic, red, white and blue, flag-waving Wrestlemania VII, brotha! Right in the midst of the Gulf War, 1991, WWE decided to capitalise on American patriotism by making it the theme of this entire event. In doing so, they turned Sgt. Slaughter (a man whom had never competed in a Wrestlemania match before) heel, put the World Title on him and had Hulk Hogan overcome the evil, Iraqi sympathiser to tremendous American fanfare. You might think, as an Englishman, this approach might alienate me, rather than inspire me. Far from it. It worked and it worked well. The crowd for this event were fantastic- one of the best crowds in WWE history. They were hot for the whole 4-hour extravaganza which did, admittedly, have its down moments and whilst they, ultimately, downsized the venue for the event due to poor ticket sales, it worked out for the best because the audible for this event was fantastic. I encourage you to watch the whole Randy Savage vs Ultimate Warrior segment and listen to the crowd. If that match doesn't sweep you up into the emotion of being a wrestling fan, you probably should go find something else to watch. This event had it all. Oh and it was also the beginning of a little known something called The Streak. Mark Calaway has come a long, long way!9. Wrestlemania XIV- Overall Score: 3.5/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-xKaJG_lCo OMQ: 3 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 4 FEUDS: 5 PROD. VALUE: 2 "Here is the DX band, led by singer Chris Warren, to play the alternative, new wave version of the themes: America The Beautiful and our national anthem."- Howard Finkel. That's code for, "Can you all please rise whilst this group of people you've never head of sing something s**t." Seriously, go look it up. I get that WWE was trying to appear rebellious and anti-establishment at the time but there's no excuse for making people listen to that! Other than that, there's not a lot that the "X-Rated" Wrestlemania did wrong. Mick Foley, as Cactus Jack and Terry Funk, as Chainsaw Charlie, defeating the New Age Outlaws by trapping them in a Dumpster somewhere backstage was a bit random but lets look at everything else: They had Sunny, in her prime, walk out the top of the show in an outrageous outfit, check. They found a way to keep the IC Title on the up-and-coming People's Champ, The Rock, whilst making babyface Ken Shamrock look like a badass, check. They dropped Pete Rose on his face, check. They brought 8 months of one of the best booked feuds ever- Kane vs Undertaker to a climax, check. They brought Mike Tyson in to push Stone Cold Steve Austin into global superstardom and turn the tide in the Monday Night War, check. Not bad eh? Well done WWE, Wrestlemania 14 owned professional wrestling.8. Wrestlemania 21- Overall Score: 3.6/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSpz42vAhew OMQ: 4 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 3 HR: 4 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 5 By this point, Wrestlemania had absolutely no business being an arena event, so it was somewhat surprising they decided to host two more arena shows following the return to Madison Square Garden for 'Mania XX. What it did allow for, however, was one of the best promotional strategies and themes in the history of Wrestlemania: "Wrestlemania goes Hollywood", complete with a series of parodies done from famous films, such as Pulp Fiction, Forest Gump, Basic Instinct (yes, Stacy) and Taxi Driver. I don't think I'll ever get the image of Kurt Angle and Christy Hemme, spoofing When Harry Met Sally out of my mind! The show itself, overall, a success too- let down somewhat by a comparatively tame pair of main events, in which John Cena and Batista both won their first World Championships. They'd win a few more in years to come. Also noteworthy from this event: the first Money in the Bank Ladder Match- we'd see a few more of those too- the most underrated Shawn Michaels Wrestlemania match ever, in my opinion, against Kurt Angle and the Big Show in a diaper. Alright, so perhaps that last one, not so much an attraction as a deterrent but hey, let's not discriminate, they're might be someone out there, reading this, who would like to see Big Show in a sumo diaper, stranger things right? Or is that about as strange as it gets? Wrestlemania 21 was a charismatic, unique, historic Wrestlemania that doesn't get the credit it deserves sometimes. It's also the last of, what I consider to be, the "Golden Age" of Wrestlemania. Speaking of that...7. Wrestlemania XX- Overall Score: 3.6/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vZ3Q2B6JRx8 OMQ: 4 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 4 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 4 Only a '3' for Crowd Heat here, Liam? You mad? What about Brock 'n' Goldberg and all that jazz? 'Mania 20's crowd in NYC was good but not great. Had some high moments and some low, including being relatively quiet for a lot of the undercard. This event- at 4 ½ hours- being the longest in Wrestlemania history withstanding, such a state was understandable. What 'Mania XX did well was convey the sense of a milestone. "Where it all begins... again" the tag-line, we saw the likes of Undertaker's return to his classic, Deadman gimmick; we saw The Rock return to fight by the side of old ally Mick Foley in his last WWE match for almost 8 years; we saw the greatest triple-threat match in WWE history; the Wrestlemania debuts of Randy Orton, John Cena and Batista and yes, we saw Brock vs Goldberg- noteworthy for a whole different reason. The ending shot of Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit celebrating in the ring was a moving, rewarding experience at the time. It's such as shame that image has become part and parcel of so much grief, ever since. Not quite perfect, for this event to have made higher, I would've liked that extra half-hour cut and perhaps 2-3 matches, such as the random two 4-corners tag matches and that pointless Cruiserweight Open. We'll leave the Playboy Pillow Fight in, just... because.6. Wrestlemania III- Overall Score: 3.6/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EkmJxx1DsIg OMQ: 2 CROWD: 5 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 5 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 4 It's a widely quoted comment, that there wouldn't be a WWE nowadays if not for Wrestlemania. Perhaps a more astute comment might be "there wouldn't be a WWE nowadays were it not for Wrestlemania III". This is where the dynasty of 'Mania truly began. The massive crowd, those little rings that carried the superstars to the big ring, the mat classic that was Savage vs Steamboat and Hogan's slam on Andre. You all know it, you've all seen it or you're not reading this list. Wrestlemania III is like a gemstone amidst the muck of the first 5 'Manias- the comparative slackness of those events only enhancing the prestige of #3. From the opening, quite wonderful performance of 'America The Beautiful', through the Hart Foundation's victory in a tag against the British Bulldogs- a match as good as it sounds- through Steamboat, "the slam" and the ending poses, 'Mania III felt like a spectacle you'd have been mad to miss. There's a little bit of magic in 'Mania III. It's where the showcase of the immortals became just that.5. Wrestlemania X- Overall Score: 3.6/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1ftuTWRM_E OMQ: 4 CROWD: 3 STAR POWER: 2 HR: 4 FEUDS: 5 PROD. VALUE: 4 So, anyone remember anything significant happening at Wrestlemania X? I mean, besides that old Ladder Match and Bret vs Owen and the striking black and yellow ropes and the sliding 'X' doors facing the hard camera, as they often tend to do in MSG. Well, Randy Savage returned to the ring, defeating Crush in a fun, Falls Count Anywhere match and they settled the '94 Royal Rumble dispute by having Champion Yokozuna defend his strap twice- Bret Hart eventually avenging his defeat the year prior by winning the belt at the show's close. Wrestlemania X got it right. Whilst not as proficient, in terms of star power, as to previous Wrestlemanias- due primarily to it being the first ever without Hulk Hogan- it hit home where previous and subsequent 'Mania's didn't. If you comprise a list of the top ten matches in Wrestlemania history, not too many would bat and eyelid at the presence of the Ladder Match and Bret vs Owen being in that list. Wrestlemania X is a testament to the quality of good wrestling, I encourage anyone who hasn't seen it to do so. Now. Well, that is after you've finished my list, of course!4. Wrestlemania XXVIII- Overall Score: 3.83/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1IwpSFm3rGc OMQ: 3 CROWD: 4 STAR POWER: 4 HR: 3 FEUDS: 4 PROD. VALUE: 5 Hmmm, why do I sense one or two out there shaking their head at this being #4? Is it Daniel Bryan getting beat in 18 seconds by any chance? I mean, it's not as if it sent the YES! Movement into high gear, ultimately propelling his career to woozy heights. Oh, fine so he would've got their anyway! Is it the general bitterness that seems to surround the John Cena vs The Rock feud? Rock isn't here full time, he was winded, terrible sharpshooter, TWICE in a lifetime!... bah, be quiet. We're being objective here, remember? Here lies the most purchased WWE PPV of all time; only marginally beating out the tally set by 'Mania 23. Here lies an event set up by a solid calender year of promotion. Here lies an excellent Hell in a Cell match, so spit if they didn't use the cage that much. Here lies the event where CM Punk came, saw and bought the t-shirt as WWE Champion. YES, OK, Daniel Bryan lost in 18 seconds; you got to see AJ Lee in a sex-bomb emerald outfit. It wasn't all bad! On a serious note, Wrestlemania 28 seems to divide people somewhat but you can't argue with it's success. It looked great, it was built up tremendously, the matches were good overall. The Rock brought thousands of fresh eyeballs to the event. Tally it up, you get 3.83. This event is where it belongs: near the top.3. Wrestlemania X-8- Overall Score: 4/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QrPwNiT_N4 OMQ: 3 CROWD: 5 STAR POWER: 5 HR: 4 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 4 "I still want to know what a Booger Red is!"- The King, to JR. "Well, I'll tell you tomorrow," came his reply. He didn't and still hasn't. I want to know what a Booger Red is too! Heh, Booker T and Edge feuded over a shampoo commercial. I'd forgotten about that! I suppose I have been saying all article that Wrestlemania should be something unique... I'm racking my brains and I can't remember any other time two guys feuded over a shampoo commercial. It's almost like someone in creative said: "OK guys. We've got Booker T vs Edge. What kind of angle could we take in the build-up to this; let's keep it simple, what do they have in common?" "Erm, well, they both have hair. And... you know... different... styles. Like, there's conflict there." You know, I read somewhere that they first planned this feud for Hogan vs Rock but thought better of it when they remembered what Hulk Hogan looked like. Oh and wasn't that a good match! Hogan vs Rock, the crowd liked it. I did have something about the original plan being to do Austin vs Nash, rather than Austin vs Hall but changed horses because they didn't want to do a Stretcher Match but I think this point's had enough bad sarcasm already. I'll remedy it with some self-deprecation instead. C'mon guys, I'm 6000 words deep here, I could just come out and tell y'all how great this event was... but you already know that! Reckon I should reword the ending to that last paragraph into a segway to a Sean O' Haire promo video?... No? OK then.2. Wrestlemania XIX- Overall Score: 4.16/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p7tLSf4agZA OMQ: 5 CROWD: 2 STAR POWER: 5 HR: 5 FEUDS: 5 PROD. VALUE: 3 OK, serious comments now. It's one of pro-wrestling's greatest mysteries; the Wrestlemania 19 buyrate. Clocking in at just over 500,000- barely 50% of the numbers WWE has been pushing since X-Seven onwards- the lack of interest in this event defies logic. On paper, prospectively and retrospectively, this event had all it. It had bouts that guaranteed tremendous wrestling, it had huge iconic matches for the ages, it had divas, cruiserweights, a, granted, terrible, Undertaker match. It had 50,000 people in SAFECO Field, Seattle and a glossy set of graphics and a catchy Limp Biskit theme tune; who could have ever thought it would fail? Miserably. A lot of debate has been had over the buyrate through the years; I've never seen a truly satisfying explanation; I'd have bought the show on the back of The Rock's heel run alone (it was still free, believe it or not, in the UK at the time!). For those whom didn't buy it, they missed out- this event was tremendous. It ticked all the boxes. The crowd were a little quiet and disappointing at times but you can't really do anything about that. I think people have come to recognise the brilliance of this event in the subsequent years that have passed, rather than immediately, at the time. It's one of those that has aged well, like a fine wine... and like a fine wine, I'll lap it up. This is my personal favourite Wrestlemania, for those of you who care. Vince McMahon's face when he grabbed that pipe from under the ring won it on it's own.1. Wrestlemania X-Seven- Overall Score: 5/5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYpch3OBGUU OMQ: 5 CROWD: 5 STAR POWER: 5 HR: 5 FEUDS: 5 PROD. VALUE: 5 You know, I TRIED, I really, really tried not to give this event a perfect score. I'm like that, I'm one of those stubborn people who likes to defy the popular opinion just because I can. I thought, "let's just put historical relevance at '4', just to be that little bit trying" but honestly, I couldn't do it with a straight face. This event was as close to perfect as you're ever going to get, even with the Austin heel turn and the "Gimmick" Battle Royal. I remember watching this as an 11-year old kid and being pissed that I had to stop at the end of the TLC Match to go to school- it was Monday morning, after all. I remember being extremely pissed when some cocksucker at school spoiled that Austin had beaten The Rock. I cared that much, back then. It wasn't just because I was young, neither. WWE made you care with 'Mania 17. They gave you a reason to back Austin, actually gave you a reason to boo The Rock! Whenever else would you boo The Rock, back then!? I remember being so swept up in the emotion of this event that I even marked out for Bradshaw sticking The Goodfather with a clothesline and pinning him! I mean, Right To Censor were annoying but not THAT annoying! I suppose that's the biggest credit I can pay WWE regarding this event. You made me mark out for Bradshaw pinning The Goodfather. Yes, oh yes you did. One other underrated aspect of 'Mania 17: the Big Show's facial expressions in the Hardcore Title Match. At one point, Kane slammed him on a watermelon, destroying the melon, which then went flying into the air and splashing the cameraman! HA! And people always think of Edge's spear! Morons. Seriously, 'Mania 17's the best. There's no disputing it so don't bother. However, I did promise it wasn't the last page on this list and I've kept my word! So, about that...???: Wrestlemania XXX- Overall Score: 3.5/5
OMQ: 3 CROWD: 4 STAR POWER: 3 HR: 3 FEUDS: 3 PROD. VALUE: 5 So like, last night I time traveled into the future for y'all to write up this last part of the list, so I don't want any of you saying I don't go the extra mile for my readers, there's nearly 7,000 words here, m'kay and thank you for reading them! Unless of course, you've not and just skimmed the videos and ratings to see the order and I know the majority of you have so don't deny it! Anyway, here's what I got: WWE probably knew they were in for a rough ride at 'Mania 30 when Sheamus walked out at the top of the show and the partisan, vocal crowd inside Mercedes-Benz broke out into a chant of "Human Sperm Bank, clap-clap, clap-clap-clap." before he proceeded to have a thoroughly boring match against Christian. They did pick up shortly thereafter when Roman Reigns won his first singles title by defeating his former Shield brethren in a superb bout. AJ Lee surprised a few people by retaining her Divas Title before the show went into high gear when Daniel Bryan stepped out into an inferno of "YES!" chants before finally vanquishing Triple H, to enter the WWE World Title match. Hulk Hogan arrived to cut a promo in which he was quoted in saying the word "Brother" only the mere 14 times, before being interrupted by Real American's Zeb Colter and Jack Swagger whom promptly lost a buffer match to Cesaro. Hogan then posed for a while. Some random celebrities were shown in the crowd, as Michael Cole promoted #WrestlemaniaXXX as the top trend, worldwide, on Twitter before the fans popped big for the graphic displaying Undertaker vs Lesnar was up next. Lesnar pounded the hell out of 'Taker before being dropped on his head, 3 times, and defeated, at which point some stupid backstage segment was shown, in which Ron Simmons showed up and said "Damn!" to allow people to urinate before the next match. Bray Wyatt made a spectacular entrance to loud cheers before John Cena got his usual chorus of 'Mania boos. The two then had a relatively basic match in which Cena overcame the odds and stood loud and proud, as he does. The fans chanted "CM Punk" in reply. The Usos retained their titles in another popcorn match before Randy Orton and Batista made their separate ways to the ring to apathy and a round selection of boos respectively, before Daniel Bryan once again arrived to create a Wrestlemania moment, when he won the WWE World Title and 80,000 odd people chanted 'YES!". The ropes were white, the ring-posts purple; Jerry Lawler wore a constrictive bow-tie. The crowd were hot all night, the matches ranged from indifferent to intense, capping off an overall above average Wrestlemania that would've been better had it possessed a couple more diverse match types and memorable spots. At least Lesnar going through the table was cool. So there you have it. All 30 Wrestlemanias ranked in order (ahem). Here's the complete list: 29: WRESTLEMANIA IX (1.5/5) 28: WRESTLEMANIA IV (1.6/5) 27: WRESTLEMANIA XI (1.6/5) 26: WRESTLEMANIA 2 (1.83/5) 25: WRESTLEMANIA XXVII (2/5) 24: WRESTLEMANIA V (2.16/5) 23: WRESTLEMANIA 2000 (2.16/5) 22: WRESTLEMANIA XII (2.16/5) 21: WRESTLEMANIA 29 (2.3/5) 20: WRESTLEMANIA XXVI (2.5/5) 19: WRESTLEMANIA XXV (2.5/5) 18: WRESTLEMANIA 13 (2.6/5) 17: WRESTLEMANIA (2.6/5) 16: WRESTLEMANIA XV (3/5) 15: WRESTLEMANIA XXIV (3.16/5) 14: WRESTLEMANIA VIII (3.16/5) 13: WRESTLEMANIA 22 (3.16/5) 12: WRESTLEMANIA VI (3.3/5) (WRESTLEMANIA XXX: 3.3/5-- PREDICTION!) 11: WRESTLEMANIA 23 (3.3/5) 10: WRESTLEMANIA VII (3.5/5) 9: WRESTLEMANIA XIV (3.5/5) 8: WRESTLEMANIA 21 (3.6/5) 7: WRESTLEMANIA XX (3.6/5) 6: WRESTLEMANIA III (3.6/5) 5: WRESTLEMANIA X (3.6/5) 4: WRESTLEMANIA XVIII (3.83/5) 3: WRESTLEMANIA X-8 (4/5) 2: WRESTLEMANIA XIX (4.16/5) 1: WRESTLEMANIA X-SEVEN (5/5) ... and that was just about that, then.