7 Times WWE Tried To Unbury Someone (& Failed!)
For those times in WWE when digging around for new ideas often just made the hole even deeper
There was a period during World Wrestling Entertainment's monopoly era where burials didn't just feel like a reality of the business model but a part of the "fun".
The market leader leader was only really leading the market by default, and though WrestleManias were filling stadiums, nothing else during the remaining 51 weeks of the year ever seemed to matter. Ratings concerns from networks were offset by repeated rolling out of whichever legends were available for a cheap pop and a payday, very few wrestlers discernibly ascended or descended, the concept of a meritocracy was long dead, and hoping for your favourites to have good days in their shoot wrestling jobs replaced fantasy booking long or short term stories for them within the fiction.
It reached such a nadir that even burials didn't mean what they'd used to. In prior years (and thankfully, once again from 2019 in All Elite Wrestling and 2022 in WWE), performers could be made and broken by big wins and losses, such was the importance of booking. By the mid-2010s and into the early 2020s, the worst week of a character's life could be erased within seven days because burials mattered as little as wins and losses. This was the lone positive - the flicker of light in the long tunnel that was being a WWE Superstar during that time.
Even those that benefitted the most from this chaotic era weren't immune...
7. Jinder Mahal
On the January 15th 2024 edition of Monday Night Raw, World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins defeated Jinder Mahal because any other finish would have been utterly preposterous. The pair were leagues apart by every metric, and Rollins disposed of 'The Modern Day Maharaja' as such, though he didn't escape unscathed. 'The Architect' suffered a torn meniscus and MCL that very nearly kept him out of a WrestleMania XL he ultimately had loads to do with.
What a disastrous bit of business this could have been, particularly when revisiting the pathetic online bubble controversy that surrounded it. Raising a point about what he perceived to be double standards from certain outlets, AEW president Tony Khan fired out a post on X about how Mahal had lost and lost for years and was getting a title shot out of the blue with nobody flagging a problem, despite him facing backlash for giving Hook - at that point one of his most winningest wrestlers - a shot at Samoa Joe's gold around the same time.
Mahal replied questioning who Hook even was, and the narrative around the bout suddenly took on a life of its own, with WWE trying in vain to ratchet up the buzz around former WWE Champion Mahal, even though his very reign reflects just how far standards had fallen in the company when he was given the gold. With Khan and WWE appearing extremely petty, Mahal gaining no momentum and Rollins actively finding his halted, this attempted unburial did more to heap dirt on literally everybody involved.
6. Pete Dunne
In 2022, Pete Dunne was a dog.
Well, that's not wholly accurate. Pete Dunne was now "Butch", a member of Sheamus' Brawlin' Brutes stable, and constantly compared to a canine in the manner at which he scampered around the ring snapping at the heels of his master's opponents. To paraphrase an infamous WWE/Michael Cole-ism, his work took on a dog-like structure.
Here's the twist though; it was the most over he'd been on WWE's main roster. The former record-setting WWE UK Champion had made a respectable living for himself in the nascent days of the company's half-hearted steamrollering of the UK indie boom, with the 'Bruiserweight' having more than enough credit in the back to exist on late 2010s NXT that mostly dined out on the talents Triple H and William Regal pilfered from a thriving US scene. Following that era's sacrifice to attempting to hobble AEW in 2019, Dunne joined many in trying to shake off a stigma on a main roster not really built for his ilk.
"Butch", for better and worse, was his attempt to prove his depth of field for a day that something better came along. It didn't, but Triple H did, and after taking the creative reins after Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace, 'The Game' tried and tried again with many of his black-and-gold favourites. The old Pete Dunne resurfaced, but fans didn't care and Hunter forgot about the bit where he gives them a reason. Alongside fellow former UK titleholder and British Strong Style partner Tyler Bate, Dunne slogged through bland tag and singles runs before the pair donned lucha hoods and finally found parodic new form as part of the El Grande Americano saga.
5. Apollo Crews
Amidst some major, major names parting ways with WWE in 2026, Apollo Crews' departure didn't generate a lot of discourse.
The former Intercontinental Champion had spent the bulk of a decade on the main roster examining the finer details of catering rather than making a mark between the ropes, and when the likes of The New Day, The Wyatt Six and Kairi Sane were all amongst those leaving, his name was deemed a little more digestible or - to be careful with the wording here - understandable.
The wrestling business doesn't ever favour wrestlers. They can do everything right, only to find out that "right" is wrong now, or at very least isn't quite what it used to be. They can do the everything right the new way, only to find themselves short on good booking or interesting creative that makes the most of their gains. The job is to "stay ready" (or insert your own hustle culture cliche here) for the opportunity, but that's incredibly difficult when the terms of readiness are themselves unclear.
This is the long way of saying that Crews never really got much support from those above him, but the one time he did, it was hard to come back from. A controversial 2021 rebranding as Nigerian Royalty led him to WrestleMania and a secondary title win over Big E, but the death of the act was effectively the death of his chances on the main roster. His bizarre NXT retooling as a man with the ability to see through time (!) completely overshadowed any casting of him as the experienced veteran amongst new developmental hands, and he found himself lapped by those he was expected to comfortably defeat.
4. Johnny Gargano
Johnny Gargano found himself as part of a quadri-burial in 2019 when he was dragged kicking and screaming to the main roster away from his beloved NXT alongside Tommaso Ciampa, Ricochet and Aleister Black ahead of both WrestleMania 35 and that April's soon-to-be-seminal TakeOver: New York.
This was as nightmarish for booker Triple H as it was the wrestlers themselves.
The four had little-to-no chance of making a significant dent in the 'Show Of Shows' card, and this put potential blockers on major payoffs at the NXT supercard. They didn't even get storyline introductions beyond a despondent 'Game' being trotted out on to the February 18th to fold their arrivals into an ego-boosting announcement that DX were going into the Hall Of Fame. It went from bad to worse when NXT Champion Ciampa got injured in a tag match on his first Raw, resulting in him having to surrender the belt he was set to defend against his former DIY partner in New York.
Gargano was inadvertently rescued by all this, with Hunter arguing for his NXT return to fill the gap now left by Ciampa, and the eventual contest with Adam Cole was so brilliant that it looked as though he'd survived the misstep unscathed. Alas - he was damaged goods for the main roster crowd.
An extended stay in what ultimately became the death knell era of the black-and-gold brand garnered mixed results (The Way - good, absolutely everything else - not), and in December 2021, he left the show and the company before even getting a second go of things. That came eight months later when Triple H had assumed control of WWE, but his misplaced insistence on using his old NXT faves and just hoping for the best undermined the supposed magic. 'Johnny Wrestling' got a nice reaction for his unannounced return, but slotted in so quickly as a lower midcarder (with and without DIY partner Ciampa) that most fans seemed to accept that the ceiling wasn't that high to begin with.
3. Zelina Vega
Zelina Vega was, at least once, an extraordinarily influential performer in WWE.
Her run alongside Andrade 'Cien' Almas in NXT transformed his run on the show to the point that it became the making of him as a star in the company, which ultimately crafted the space for him to flit between both North American majors over the subsequent decade. They were a terrific act; so much so that they earned campaign-like level of support from fans when times got tough. And creatively for Vega in particular, times got really, really tough.
In 2020, she was made boss of maybe the worst stable in company history. Never given a name and almost never given a win, her group consisting first of Andrade and Angel Garza and later Austin Theory were utterly useless. They lost, they argued, they lost some more, they drove her to such annoyance that she abandoned them to win gold alone, which served as another failed pursuit. A rotten year got worse when she was released in November, but did it? It emerged that Vega's exit was to do with a disagreement over her third-party (Twitch et al) interests, and she was at the front of a brand new discussion on unionisation in wrestling - the sort of conversation that hadn't been had since Hulk Hogan grassed Jesse Ventura up in 1986.
That went quiet when she re-signed in 2021, and winning the first "Queen's Crown" (Queen Of The Ring) looked a long way removed from her annus horribilis 12 months earlier. This dawn was the falsest yet - the hokey role got her Tag Gold and WrestleMania spots, but not even the diamonds in the crown shone as brightly as her original stint. The ups and downs in the aftermath went the same way - a Latino World Order run was fine, a dalliance with the United States Championship less so, an alliance with real life husband Aleister Black lesser still.
Her 2026 release brought about the end of her latest diminished return, and speaking of which...
2. Aleister Black
To simply read about Aleister Black's 2020s is to assume that the former Tommy End has managed to game a two-majors system for cheques, championships and the sort of gains that come from mass exposure across two companies and multiple television stations.
Those that have actually watched this play out know it not to really be the case.
He was very nearly chosen to eliminate Brock Lesnar from the 2020 Royal Rumble and become WWE Champion, but when Drew McIntyre got the spot and the belt, Black went back to being thought of as the guy that spent months in a locked room asking for a fight rather than a wrestler who might be good at winning one.
This was the headline from his main roster call-up after a quietly decent tag run with Ricochet, and it stuck like glue when he found himself surprisingly released in June 2021. Injuries had cost him time, but he had sentiment on his side when - like so many from that period - he felt more like wronged party than WWE Superstar from his time with the market leader. This fed into a spectacular debut with All Elite Wrestling, but time with the challenger brand was tarnished - ironically - by his alleged unwillingness to get involved in much with a view of returning to the newly Triple H-helmed WWE.
After more uneven stuff with AEW, he got his wish in 2025, but the less he did, the more his side-eying for the opposition looked like a major error. His character continued to not make enough sense for enough people to care about, and even when he was paired with Zelina Vega for WWE's second run at the Karrion Kross/Scarlett devil's advocate business, it wasn't engaging enough for them to avoid releases in the company's post-WrestleMania cuts.
1. Dolph Ziggler
Dolph Ziggler occupies a unique space as the shorthand wrestler for all of WWE's 2010s ills, regardless of if the reference is designed to praise or criticise his actual work.
'The Show Off' was undeniably let down by the company's creative team at the height of his powers. His body of work was consistent as he rose through the ranks, and because his ascent through secondary and tag titles mirrored that of Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels decades earlier, he was seen as a guy that would break and Land-Of-The-Giants glass ceiling in the same way. Ignoring subjective and ultra-generous comparisons between Ziggler and two of the greatest to ever lace the boots, the wider problem was the difference in landscapes. Hart and Michaels had Vince McMahon's biases to overcome, but they did so when he had no choice but to experiment, and no real reason not to. Size wasn't Dolph's problem - stubbornness was. A mentally unravelling McMahon had his Guys, and Dolph was never ever going to be one no matter how much he occasionally walked, talked and worked for the job he wanted rather than the one he had.
By 2017, every possible bit of juice had been squeezed from the fruit to such an extent that Ziggler took on the role of passive-aggressive tribute act. Mocking the likes of DX and the Ultimate Warrior as a way to rib Bobby Roode's one-note "Glorious" act and lean in on how everybody was trapped in mindless deference to the past, Ziggler saw through his mini-mission and became United States Champion in December. He immediately abandoned the belt in continued protest, but he was closing the stable door long after the push had bolted. A Royal Rumble 2018 return came too soon to maximise the drama around his exit, not least when it lasted all of 90 seconds.
Everything during the five long years between then and his 2023 release was rendered mostly pointless by the profound failure of the reboot.