7 WWE Returns That Flopped HARD!

Don't call it a comeback...or not a GOOD one anyway

By Terry Bezer /

Big returns are usually greeted with open arms by pro wrestling audiences around the world. Waves of nostalgia overcome us all, as we remember the matches and moments that made us fall in love with these heroes of the past. Only sometimes, these returns are nowhere near as fruitful the second time around.

Advertisement

It's hard for lightning to strike twice with WWE's audience. Do the same thing that worked the first time around and you'll be labeled as a nostalgia act, but stray too far from the formula that proved successful, and that can upset the apple cart just as much. It's a tricky tightrope and one that some of the biggest names in company history have fallen foul of.

From former champions to some of the most iconic names to ever grace the business, no names are safe from flopping on their return. The glories of the past can prove to be worth nothing in the present, as this group of elite names goes to show. These are some of the most disappointing returns in the history of WWE.

7. Ronda Rousey

It's hard to think of a relationship that has soured quite like Ronda Rousey and pro wrestling fans. During the years that Rousey was crushing all who stood before her as an undefeated fighter in the UFC, Rousey was one of WWE's most notable allies, who would constantly talk about her love for wrestling. Taking Roddy Piper's 'Rowdy' nickname and wearing it with pride, once she suffered two crushing defeats, it was no great surprise when Ronda decided to sign with WWE and give pro wrestling a shot.

Advertisement

Her first run with WWE did massive things for the women's division from a credibility standpoint. With Rousey recognised as a draw in sports as well as entertainment, Ronda went on an absolute tear. From arriving as a curiosity at WrestleMania 34, she then headlined wrestling's biggest event in the first (and only) all-women's main event the next year.

Rousey then disappeared entirely, returning for the first time in 9 months to win the 2022 Royal Rumble. With this echoing what all but ended her relationship with UFC fans, she was not greeted the same way by fans. Ronda then wrestled less than 13 minutes between the Rumble and WrestleMania 36, making it seem like she was being handed everything without earning it. After being welcomed with open arms in her first run, fans soon saw her as a spoiled diva during her second stint with the company, with Rousey doing little to squash those accusations. She now snipes at WWE every chance she gets to compound this radical change of fortunes.

6. Ultimate Warrior

The Ultimate Warrior is one of the biggest stars of WWE's Golden Era. His in-ring work may not have stood the test of time, but his entrance, intensity, and snarling, nonsensical promos mean that the Warrior remains a character as vital to his glory days as any of his peers. His rampant ego saw him at odds with the company about his status as a top draw, as financial disagreements with Vince McMahon led to his termination after SummerSlam 1991.

Advertisement

He had a brief return in 1992, running in to help Hulk Hogan at the climax of WrestleMania 8 on April 5th, before having disappointing feuds with Papa Shango and Randy Savage, and then being fired again in November just ahead of Survivor Series. Somehow, this was nowhere near as catastrophic as when Warrior again returned to WWE in 1996.

His 99-second squash of Triple H at WrestleMania 12 went against creative plans, as he no-sold The Pedigree in infuriating fashion, making his opponent look like a chump. In-ring standards in the company had drastically improved since Warrior's heyday, as his work with Jerry Lawler and Goldust fell well below standards. Warrior was fired again within 3 months of his comeback, leading to WWE tarnishing his legacy with the infamous 'The Self Destruction of The Ultimate Warrior' DVD.

5. Rusev

There is still time for Rusev to change the fortunes of his second run in WWE but the signs do not currently look good. During his first run in WWE, Vince McMahon clearly didn't see the high potential in the Bulgarian that fans insisted existed. After years of bad creative and WWE's decision makers overlooking gimmicks that were over with audiences (we still love you, Rusev Day), he was finally granted his release in 2020.

Advertisement

He soon jumped ship to AEW, appearing as Miro and having a superb run with the TNT championship and a great feud with Darby Allin. After he wasn't pushed into the company's main event scene, relationships soured between Tony Khan and the Bulgarian Brute, leading to his release in September, 2024.

When Rusev came back to the WWE under Paul Levesque's stewardship, expectations for him were pretty high. Nevertheless, Rusev has done little to recapture the love of WWE fans, as he languishes in WWE's lower mid-card. Despite being booked as a threat in feuds with Sheamus and Dominik Mysterio, fans have not reacted to Rusev in any meaningful way. He lasted 32 seconds in the 2026 Royal Rumble before being eliminated by Oba Femi. There's still time for Rusev to find a way to connect with fans, but it's going to take a lot more than he has shown up to this point.

4. NWO

The day that Vince McMahon bought WCW on March 23rd, 2001, the whole wrestling world began to form their dream matches and situations. Nothing topped those wishes more than seeing the NWO bring their anti-establishment mayhem to WWE. The faction may have gone through some brutally terrible rebrands in WCW's last few years, but the idea of founding members 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash, and Scott Hall terrorizing Vince McMahon and locking up with 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin, The Rock, and D-Generation X had fans all over the world salivating.

Advertisement

It took just 11 months to happen. After Vince McMahon gave an unhinged promo about injecting the WWE with "a lethal dose of poison", Hogan, Hall, and Nash made their debut at No Way Out 2002. Cutting a lukewarm promo and being outclassed in a backstage skit with The Rock, things didn't quite get off to the start everyone hoped for. 

Hogan's feud with The Rock on the run-up to their legendary match at WrestleMania X8 had some satisfying moments, but Scott Hall's feud with 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin lacked any of the greatness that saw the group rise to prominence. When you look at the NWO's continued popularity in terms of merch and influence, this short-lived and underwhelming incarnation of the group is one of the all-time WWE disappointments. Throw in them backing up their life-long enemy Sting at WrestleMania 31 for no reason beyond they worked in the same company, and it compounds WWE's misuse of this legendary faction.

3. The British Bulldog

The British Bulldog was one of the classic Intercontinental Championship holders of the early 90s. He had a slew of classic matches under his belt, with the SummerSlam 1992 Wembley Stadium bout with Bret Hart omnipresent in any 'Greatest Match Ever' list worth its salt. His identity was wrapped up in colourful nationalism, with his Union Jack tights and matching beads for his braids as his calling card.

Advertisement

When he returned in 1999 after being released amid WWE's steroid scandal at the end of 1992 and a mediocre second run from 1994-97, times and fashion had changed, and so had the WWE. However, completely disregarding everything that made the Bulldog a global icon was a massive mistake. He wrestled in jeans that made him feel like any generic guy, and he had equally uninspiring entrance music that also gave no attention to the 'British' part of his name.

These aspects paled in comparison to the sad situation Davey Boy Smith was suffering outside the ring. His injuries had seen his physical health deteriorate, leading to an addiction to pain pills. His feuds with Al Snow and The Big Bossman did nothing to endear him to an audience who once held him in high regard, and a short run with the European title also fell flat. 

2. Eva Marie

Eva Marie was never the peak of the women's division. She joined the main roster at the same time as Total Divas began in 2013, in a move which felt as much about having her as part of the WWE's new relationship with E! Entertainment as it did what she could contribute to the women's division. 

Advertisement

Having spent 4 years on the main roster and NXT, Eva Marie left the WWE in a move that was in no way unsurprising. When she was resigned in 2021, it was hard to understand why. Despite being put into stories with the Bellas, Stephanie McMahon, Carmella, and an NXT championship feud with Bayley, it didn't feel like she would be able to keep up with the massive progress the women's division had made in her time away. 

This turned out to be accurate. Her partnership with Piper Niven's Doudrop felt unnatural and forced, she couldn't keep up in the ring with Alexa Bliss during their feud, and Doudrop turning on Eva Marie did little to elevate her standing in the company. She was attacked by Shayna Baszler before being released again, to nobody's surprise. 

1. Batista

During his first run, Batista was one of the top names in WWE. After overcoming his introduction as Deacon Batista, sidekick of Reverend D-Von (formerly of the Dudleyville parish), the monster babyface enjoyed world championship reigns and formed the backbone of the Evolution stable. Things had run a little stale before he unleashed his immortal "I quit" line, but not enough to sour a potential return to WWE in the future.

Advertisement

However, the wrestling landscape was in a very different place when Batista returned in 2014. Fans and WWE creative found themselves intensely at odds, with audiences clamouring for Daniel Bryan to be the company's main character heading into WrestleMania 30. Vince McMahon planned on making Randy Orton vs Batista the main event of this landmark event, and fans told them exactly what they thought of that when Batista won the Royal Rumble in Pittsburgh. When Daniel Bryan was missing from the match altogether, the returning babyface push for Batista was booed out of the building, and that trend continued beyond that fateful evening.

More fuel to that fire was added after CM Punk quit the company the day after Dave's big Royal Rumble win. Batista became a lightning rod for fans' frustration, leading to him turning heel in an attempt to hide the reality of the situation. Bryan would have his moment at WrestleMania 30, but Batista's run continued to be mercilessly savaged by live crowds. He teamed with Orton and Triple H against The Shield at a few PPVs after WrestleMania before quitting WWE for good on the June 2nd episode of Raw.

Advertisement