8 Wrestlers Who HATED Their Own Gimmicks
The look of love? Not quite. It was the face of hate for these WWE stars.
When an aspiring wrestler first dreams about getting into the business they hold dear, they all aim to be the very best version of themselves, fighting for championship gold and being a hero or villain to millions of fans around the world. What many (if not all) of them don't bank on is creative having something totally different in mind for their careers.
All it takes is one bad idea or joke inside the writing room to land a little too cleanly, and any superstar can find themselves saddled with a gimmick that's going to make their lives hell. One minute you're trying to make a name for yourself with your superior wrestling skills, the next you're the butt of a thousand jokes that you never signed up for.
Try as they might to do the best job that they could, these wrestlers were saddled with God-awful gimmicks that ruined their enjoyment of the industry they adore. From clucking like a farmyard animal to farting and having to play a character from the cosmos (?!), these are 8 gimmicks that wrestlers absolutely hated trying to make work.
Hated!
8. Cody Rhodes (Stardust)
Adopting the character of Stardust was an incredibly bleak period in the life of Cody Rhodes.
He's a man who's incredibly dedicated to his craft, so he threw his all into the cosmic superstar, but time has proved this to be an unfathomable waste of his talents as a wrestler and someone who can draw waves of emotion from WWE's fanbase.
Looking at the character through the lens of the enormous success he's enjoyed since being granted his release in May 2016, this was simply an insane 2 years in Cody's life. He debuted on the 14 June 2014 episode of Raw by humping the tron, thus setting the tone for the hyperactive intergalactic menace. Cody has revealed retrospectively that his intention was to play the character like Jim Carrey's portrayal of The Riddler in Batman Forever, which he actually did to a solid standard.
There are some revisionist takes on Stardust out there, and in truth the character itself was conceptually sound. Cody lived the gimmick like a method actor, but the creative around Stardust was nonsense. Cody is now polite about those years, but Brandi Rhodes has revealed the depths of despair that her husband went through in his 2-year run as Stardust in many interviews over the years.
7. Steve Austin (The Ringmaster)
Steve Austin found himself at a crossroads (not a Cross Rhodes like the previous entry!) in 1996.
Having seen WCW fumble his considerable talents, constantly failing to deliver their promises of a serious singles run after his excellent work with Brian Pillman in The Hollywood Blonds, Austin went to ECW. He had a great feud with The Sandman and Mikey Whipwreck under Paul Heyman's creative, but (as was commonly the case in the Philadelphia promotion) the company's low-grade salary was not helping him keep the lights on.
As revealed in an episode of his WWE Network podcast with The Undertaker, Austin was called by Vince McMahon and told about his Ringmaster gimmick. He instantly thought it was hot garbage, but he needed the money a WWE contract would provide. The concept was as simple as being good in the ring, with Ted DiBiase as his manager and the Million Dollar Belt as a prop. It had no real direction, and as such, Austin feared he would drift into obscurity if he continued this dull gimmick.
Famously, after telling Vince that he no longer wanted to be The Ringmaster. Austin wanted to have a character influenced by hitman 'The Ice Man' Richard Kuklinski instead. WWE faxed no less than 3 pages of names for Steve to consider, including Fang McFrost, before Austin himself suggested 'Stone Cold'.
The rest is history.
6. Kane (Isaac Yankem)
It's well known that WWE found itself in a rough spot in the mid-90's. Trying to set up a family-friendly product in the wake of the steroid scandal of the era and no longer having Hulkamania to fall back on, Vince McMahon fell into a terrible habit of creating gimmicks that were better suited for Saturday morning cartoons than the squared circle.
Understandably, audiences began to dwindle.
One such character was Isaac Yankem, played by Glenn Jacobs. The future Kane would appear as an evil dentist with bad teeth, who was introduced to fans as Jerry Lawler's DDS and thrown into the failing feud between 'The King' and Bret Hart. Vince famously thought the pun "I. Yankem" was comedic genius, just in case you wanted a closer look at why WWE was dying on its ass.
Jacobs' main gripe with the character was that he found the maniacal tooth puller "too cartoonish". He then followed this up by playing the 'Fake Diesel' replacement when Kevin Nash departed for WCW, before finally finding the gimmick that defined him when he debuted as Kane.
5. Mike Shaw (Bastion Booger)
Staying in the mid-90s, when Vince McMahon was losing his mind more than usual, Bastion Booger was a character designed to gross out fans through his ill-fitting, ugly ring gear and being a...larger gentleman. He wore a dirty grey number that accentuated his man boobs, and his character was basically that he would gross audiences out with his uncouth antics.
Perhaps worst of all was his finisher, the 'Trip To The Bat Cave'.
Unbelievably, this move saw him drop directly onto his opponent and straddle their face for a 3-count with, basically, his balls resting on the hapless victim's face. He'd also eat trashy-looking fast food and spill it down his front in backstage promos, just in case they hadn't driven home the gross-out tactics being employed by poor Mike Shaw.
Quite unsurprisingly, this wasn't a satisfying creative endeavor for Shaw. Given that he made his name wrestling for Stu Hart in Stampede Wrestling, where he feuded with Owen Hart for the company's top title, Shaw was understandably upset that his in-ring career was basically reduced to fart jokes and fat jibes.
4. Jon Moxley (Dean Ambrose)
When The Shield arrived in WWE, attacking anyone who got in their way like a pack of rabid dogs, Jon Moxley's Dean Ambrose character shone for all of the right reasons. His promo style had shades of Heath Ledger's Joker as he threatened the entire WWE landscape with a psychotic, wide-eyed glee. If you were to place money on any of The Shield's members succeeding as a solo star based upon the character they'd created, Ambrose would have been most fans' pick for justified reasons.
Sadly, it felt as though Vince McMahon never understood Mox's concept for Ambrose.
Where Moxley saw Ambrose as an unhinged agent of chaos, McMahon seemed to have Dean pegged as some kind of wacky goofball. His 'Lunatic Fringe' nickname made no sense, and his stories got increasingly silly over time, including feuding with Chris Jericho over a potted plant.
As such, Moxley grew frustrated with what was being asked of him. Whether it was stealing local hot dog carts or mocking the audience for being infected, the original brilliance of Ambrose was replaced with a silliness that couldn't be further from what fans over in AEW have come to expect from Moxley's vision for himself.
3. Terry Taylor (The Red Rooster)
Wrestling for legendary bookers Eddie Graham and Bill Watts in the 1980s, Terry Taylor had made a name for himself as a reliable in-ring performer. Holding NWA gold on multiple occasions, Taylor began to excel in Mid-South Wrestling and eventually won the company's grand prize by defeating Ted DiBiase in 1985. After a few more years of success and with Vince McMahon eroding the territory system, it made sense that Taylor would make his way to the WWF in 1988.
Originally debuting as a heel character under the tutelage of the best manager of that era, Bobby 'The Brain' Heenan, Taylor was rebranded as 'The Red Rooster' and was treated as a rookie who needed Heenan's guidance to win matches. When he broke out of 'Brain's' grasp and struck out on his own, Terry's career plummeted faster than a falling elevator.
After turning face, The Rooster began to take his name literally, much to the disappointment of everybody. Taylor dressed in red tights, strutted and bobbed his head on the way to the ring, and had a red streak in his hair spiked up to look like a rooster. It didn't work for anyone, least of all Taylor himself.
2. Kevin Nash (Oz)
Vinnie Vegas may have been Magic Mike before such a thing existed, and the pros and cons of Diesel are well documented, but Kevin Nash deserves all the credit in the world for getting his career to that point in time. That's especially true considering his first mainstream wrestling gimmick was to look like the world's silliest wizard.
In Nash's defence, it was 1991 in WCW and the whole package was not his idea.
The usually reliable Dusty Rhodes had come up with the gimmick, and Nash was just doing a job where he'd been asked to adopt silver hair, a neon green cloak and pointy hat, and to portray a character that riffed on the Wizard Of Oz. He went on to lose pretty consistently to the company's more viable talent.
Nash has a famously good sense of humour about the gimmick, always being keen to point out the fact that Oz is the geographical setting of the story and not the character; which somehow makes the whole concept even stupider. Big Kev maintains to this day that the whole gimmick was set up as one big rib.
'Big Sexy', this was not.
1. Chad Gable (Shorty G)
Chad Gable is and always has been a wrestling machine. His in-ring work is amongst the best in the world, he's a good promo, isn't afraid to make an ass out of himself in the name of our entertainment, and he doesn't seem to have ever ruffled any feathers backstage in WWE. As far as all-around talents go, there aren't many who can carry a candle to Gable.
When Vince McMahon was in control, it was really obvious when he didn't appreciate those talents.
Gable was someone who suffered through the then boss's whims more than most. McMahon's natural love for bigger men is well documented, and so Gable's incredible wrestling ability and excellent tag-team runs were rendered moot as he was reduced to a ring name that mocked his height when going solo.
On his episode of Cody Rhodes's 'What Do You Want To Talk About?' podcast, Gable admitted that he feared it "might be the nail in the coffin" of his career. Chad is a model professional, and so he just got on with doing what was asked of him as the hapless 'Shorty G', but it's undoubtedly the lowest point of his career.