15 WWE Gimmick Changes That IMMEDIATELY Backfired
Racists, sex addicts, cosplay characters and more. WWE shouldn't have gone here!
Some WWE gimmick change ideas were so foul that the paper they were printed on should've been burned. Then burn the printer. Then set fire to the building and evacuate just to be safe. Then, the person responsible should've hopped on a plane and vanished never to be seen again. Seriously, when you see some of the tripe served up here, you've really got to wonder.
What were they thinking?!
Vince McMahon took a lot of flak creatively for his latter day decision-making before being disgraced and shuffling out of WWE offices for good, and rightly so, but McMahon's worst didn't exclusively live in the modern era. The old boss came up with (or at least slapped a green light on) some of the most putrid character switches wrestling fans are ever likely to see.
Let's do a quick stock check: This list has sex addicts, racists, gimmicks that'd only be good for a few weeks every year, guys wearing crappy Halloween costumes pretending to be famous counterparts, stalkers, workers that are called outright dull (yet expected to get over?) and even someone "vertically challenged" who isn't actually vertically challenged at all.
Phew! WWE watched these gimmicks crash and burn in a hurry. They backfired instantly, either because workers playing the part didn't believe in what they were selling, or because crowds rejected what they were being force fed by woefully out of touch promoters.
You've seen WWE returns that immediately backfired, so now check out the repackage jobs that just shouldn't have happened. Ever.
15. Ted DiBiase Knows Xanta Claus
Starting off hot. Or ice cold!
Picture this: It's In Your House 5 in December 1995, and thousands of fans in attendance are gearing up for the festive season by watching Bret Hart and Davey Boy Smith work a gritty retelling of their SummerSlam '92 classic. Before that, emerging babyface Savio Vega hands out presents with someone dressed up as Santa Claus when the vile 'Million Dollar Man' appears and says his usual “everybody’s got a price” line.
Suddenly, Santa attacks Savio, then Ted DiBiase reveals that he's actually Xanta Claus from the South Pole. Instead of giving presents to boys and girls around the globe, he steals them. The crowd goes mild. Obviously, this gimmick (handed to future ECW star Balls Mahoney) had a shelf life. That shelf life being…Christmas.
Xanta would've meant nothing for the rest of the year, so lord only knows what Vince McMahon was thinking. The immediate backfire was that Xanta could only show up in December, and for a few weeks at that. Once the holidays were over and January's sales began, the WWF's very own festive character would be put back into storage. That was hardly going to be sustainable for Mahoney.
Balls.
Realising this, McMahon ditched the 'evil Santa' gimmick and ploughed headfirst into 1996 like nothing had ever happened. The knock on effect here is that Mahoney wouldn't get another shot at WWE fame until he showed up at the first One Night Stand in 2005 then joined the runaway ECW brand in 2006. Surely, even he knew that playing Xanta put an unwanted Claus (sorry) in his WWF contract.
14. Lance Storm Is “Boring” Then “Finds Personality”
WWE are very careful to use adjectives like "fun", "exciting", "dynamic" and "engaging" when describing their wrestlers today. Sometimes, that can come across as a tad forced, especially when lead play-by-play man Michael Cole is quite blatantly reading from a sheet of paper in front of him and putting on his best 'excited announcer' voice.
Naturally, this has lessened under Triple H, and the commentary has a much looser/less over-produced feel. It's an improvement. So, mind you, is Hunter moving away from calling anybody on the WWE roster boring. That fate befell poor Lance Storm back in June 2003 - Raw GM Steve Austin called Lance’s matches exactly that, and he even brought out a pillow then snored into the microphone during bouts. This led to Storm enlisting “mentor” Goldust to bring out his personality.
He danced to the ring like someone's uncle at a wedding after a few too many beers from the bar, got new entrance music and more, but it was all so unconvincing. Honestly, alerting fans to the idea that someone on your roster is snooze-worthy? Yeah, not a great call. WWE gave up on all of this quickly and stuck Storm in a tag-team with old partner Val Venis that went nowhere fast.
The gig was up as soon as ‘Stone Cold’ called him dull as dishwater live on air. There was no coming back from that. Who thought spotlighting the fact our Lance wasn't exactly as electrifying as The Rock was the way to go?! His new gimmick was DOA as soon as that happened.
13. ‘Superstar’ Billy Graham Learns Karate
Even the most hardcore WWE fans out there might know next to nothing about 'Billy Graham: The Karate Expert Years'. The celebrated heel champion who had carried the company on his giant back for years returned to the WWF in August 1982, but he wasn't quick the slick-talking 'Superstar' of before. No, Graham had evolved into a martial artist.
Admittedly, he did briefly feud with Bob Backlund for the WWF Title before leaving in April 1983, but nobody was invested enough in the character change. It was far too drastic, and it barely made a lick of sense anyway. Maybe explaining why Graham was radically different would’ve been an idea, but the federation chose to just roll with it and hope fans would too.
No dice.
This karate idea was bizarrely tag-teamed with some fetching camouflage outfits. So, was Billy an army veteran who had learned the martial art to up his game whenever he was at war? People didn't get it, and it wasn't long until Graham started to come across as a wonky, ill-advised reimagining of his old self. Does he deserve credit for trying someone completely different? Absolutely, but it backfired on him.
Billy continued using the karate guise when he joined the AWA and NWA post-WWF, but eventually brought his old tie-dye 'Superstar' look back in 1985. By then, it was too little too late for him as a must-see headliner housed on top of cards around the country. The whole martial arts thing had been a failed experiment for Graham, and it lessened his star power almost overnight.
12. Hulk Hogan Morphs Into Mr. America
Hulk Hogan routinely borrowed from Billy Graham's playbook throughout his career. Indeed, his rise to legendary status in the WWF of the 1980s owed a lot to nabbing from what 'Superstar' had done before him, and Hulk's nWo persona even rocked many familiar outfits from Graham's prime as a heel. By 2002, Hogan had returned to past glories in the WWF, and he appeared to be cosplaying Billy as he did it.
Suddenly, a sharp left field turn happened.
Vignettes had been hyping it for weeks, but then Mr. America danced into view on the 1 May 2003 SmackDown. This character was designed to prolong Hulk's feud with Vince McMahon, but it was woefully bad and the sort of thing WCW at their worst would’ve been ashamed of. WWE announcers played along and questioned who it was, which was about as convincing as Lance Storm's dancing later in the year.
All wasn't well behind the scenes though. Hogan quit the promotion in July, but not before he gave America one last whirl on the 26 June SmackDown in a 6-man tag match. Once WWE's cameras went dark, he lifted the mask to show the fans who he was post-show (as it they didn’t know), which McMahon used as a means to fire Hogan in storyline. The whole thing was far too hokey to work, and it wasn’t a patch on anything Hulk had done since returning to the WWF in '02.
People had re-embraced Hulkamania the prior year, and it was genius of WWE to revive it, but this Mr. America malarkey wasn't what fans who had grown up with Hogan wanted to see. It was the latest example of creative tailspinning from a company struggling to find direction overall.
11. The Godfather Becomes A Goodfather
By his own admission, The Godfather couldn’t stand Stevie Richards at the time or his Right To Censor faction. He thought it sucked, so imagine his horror when WWF chiefs told him he’d be joining RTC on the 24 July 2000 Raw. In storyline, Godfather agreed to give up on his erm...vocation as a pimp if he lost to indoctrinated Richards underling Bull Buchanan, which he did. After that, colour drained from his character and he was all in on censorship.
At least in front of the cameras.
Look, Godfather was never going to crack into the main event scene or anything, but he represented raunchy levity on the midcard during an era when that was trendy, and fans loved his act. Taking it away in favour of a strait-laced ‘guy who wrestles in shirt and tie’ persona that the man himself hated was always going to be a challenge. It did generate heat, but people bemoaned the lack of Godfather overnight and his heart wasn’t in it.
If anything, the artist formerly known as Papa Shango and 'Supreme Fighting Machine' Kama fancied leaning on traits from his UFC rip off character to smack Stevie about a bit. It was his worst nightmare to become part of the dude's new group, but that's exactly what the WWF wanted to do. Like a good soldier, Godfather turned to The Goodfather and went along with it.
He was never happy though, and it showed in his mediocre performances. Eventually, returning to The Godfather and becoming more of a cameo artist proved to be the ideal trajectory for him. Internally, he could've done without the Right To Censor speed bump along the way, and most fans thought the same.
10. Pete Dunne Goes Scrappy Doo As Butch
Insert that .GIF of Scrappy Doo angling for a fight then being picked up by a monster from Scooby Doo here.
Anyone who watched either NXT UK or the core NXT brand before 11 March 2022 could tell you that 'Bruiserweight' Pete Dunne was one of the brightest in-ring prospects on the roster. All he'd need is a little backing and maybe fleshed out once he hit bigger shows like Raw and SmackDown. Then, that aforementioned 11 March date hit and Dunne was introduced as a WWE main roster full-timer.
He debuted in a new faction alongside established star Sheamus and fellow newbie Ridge Holland as the Brawling Brutes. It was certainly some call to turn Pete from credible ‘Bruiserweight’ to a teenage delinquent who was midway between Scrappy and someone from Peaky Blinders. Dunne never seemed into the role himself, but he did do his best with it. Fans, meanwhile, rejected it outright.
The Butch stink didn’t wear off until 2024 when he started teaming with Tyler Bate as the New Catch Republic, but it has badly damaged Dunne’s WWE career to the point he’s barely used these days. Way to go, eh? That's the total opposite of what giving somebody fresh direction is supposed to achieve.
Being brutally honest, Pete looked silly in his Peaky Blinders wannabe get-up. Trying to piggy back on the success of a popular TV show or movie is nothing new for wrestling, but this didn't click with fans, and neither did Sheamus claiming they were honouring his Celtic roots by eh...being thuggish street brawlers.
Butch was the worst part about the act, to be fair. It might've been more palatable had WWE not gone too cartoony with things.
9. Rusev Is A Sex Addict
What were WWE bosses hoping to achieve by outing Rusev as a "sex addict" who wanted to get busy with his wife Lana inside the tank at WrestleMania 31? Did they think people in arena audiences would be all high fives for Ru-Ru just because he could think of nothing but jumping into bed? Nobody's quite sure what this was supposed to accomplish, or how it was supposed to get the Bulgarian over as a beloved babyface.
Worse, Lana called her hubby a sex addict on the 28 October 2019 Raw, then she countered this by…having a fling with Bobby Lashley that rubbed the idea they were having sex directly in Rusev’s face. OK then. WWE never did do nuance under Vince McMahon. As if that wasn’t enough, Rusev started to deploy his sexual proclivities as a badge of honour, and he even implied that he was into the idea of Lana getting freaky with others.
This didn't even lead to anything worthwhile inside the ring, which is arguably the real creative crime. Rusev jobbed loads to Lashley, then dwindled down the card before leaving WWE in April 2020. Here’s hoping his second run in the company is a vast improvement, because that last one ended in thoroughly miserable fashion.
Rusev likes sex. YAY! Rusev likes watching Lana have sex with others. YAY! Buy his merch! It's kinda crazy when you see something written down that way, but that's the mantra WWE barked in late-2019. This didn't get Rusev over - it pushed him closer to the company exit doors and probably weirded some fans out.
8. The ‘Fake Diesel’ & ‘Fake Razor’ Debacle
It'd be easy to imagine that Shawn Michaels looked down on the WWF's cosplay version of his pal Razor Ramon's gimmick, but Rick Bognar once revealed that HBK was actually pretty helpful. In fact, at one stage, Shawn was willing to help Bognar learn some of Scott Hall's mannerisms. Who knew?! The whole concept was doomed to fail from the off, right enough.
Glenn Jacobs and Bognar became Halloween versions of famous WWF characters on the 30 September 1996 Raw. Their debut was all part of a crappy rebellious heel run for Jim Ross, and it was also Vince McMahon’s way of getting back at WCW for hiring Kevin Nash and Scott Hall. He’d show those idiots down south that anybody could play the Diesel and Razor Ramon gimmicks! Except, they couldn’t, and that became obvious within seconds of them appearing on-screen.
Meanwhile, the real deals dripped cool as part of the vibrant nWo on the other channel.
Ross looked like a moron for claiming that he’d coaxed the pair back to the fed, and fans thumbed their noses at McMahon’s hackneyed tribute show-style acts. These were the kinds of things fans expected to see from various dress-up indy feds who aimed to give families "WWF style American wrestling" on a budget, not the market leader itself.
If the WWF wanted to prove that anybody could play their characters, then that didn't say very much for their creations in the first place. Sure, why bother paying Bret Hart millions of dollars to be one of the best wrestlers on the planet when some dork in pink visor shades could become the 'Hitman' instead?
Thank God they didn't go further with this.
7. Ricky Steamboat Is…A Literal Dragon?
Speaking of guys who once ranked amongst the best pro wrestlers in the world.
Ricky Steamboat had enjoyed a successful run in the WWF between 1985-1988. Sure, it ended on a sour note and he fell out with management, but Ricky bagged immortality by working a celebrated Intercontinental Title bout vs. Randy Savage at WrestleMania III. People will be talking about that match forever. After leaving, Ricky went back to WCW, then returned for another go at the fed in 1991.
It might seem like one looking back, but Vince McMahon's decision to try and turn Steamboat into a literal dragon wasn't meant as a punishment. No, it was something the federation truly believed would take Ricky's career to the next level and make him more marketable to their young audience. Fair, but presenting 'The Dragon' as a totally fresh face fans had never seen before was flat out odd.
Dropping the Ricky Steamboat name and giving him a goofy entrance outfit might not have been as jarring had they acknowledged his prior work. 'The Dragon' re-debuted on the 20 March 1991 episode of Superstars by beating The Brooklyn Brawler. WWF officials shot themselves in the foot with fans by pretending that Ricky was a newcomer they’d never really seen before.
He was literally a key part of ‘Mania just 4 years beforehand. That'd be like Triple H repackaging AJ Styles in 2029 and kidding on he's some fresh, up and coming superstar. No wonder Ricky left the fed again for another run in WCW by the end of the year. His 1991 run was garbage.
6. DDP Goes From ‘People’s Champ’ To Stalker
Diamond Dallas Page was one of WCW’s most popular stars right up until the promotion's demise, but he'd always wanted to make a splash in the WWF. With that in mind, Page reportedly agreed to a lowball buyout on his AOL/Time Warner contract so he could become part of the fed's invasion storyline in 2001. He'd come to regret that decision once he saw what Vince McMahon had in store for him.
McMahon dreamt up a lame-brained stalker gimmick for DDP. Various vignettes showed somebody following The Undertaker’s then-wife Sara at home and on the road as a creepy voice box voiceover narrated each scene. Finally, Page revealed himself on the 18 June 2001, and he encouraged ‘Taker to “make [him] famous”. Yes, even though he was already famous and had been a top name in pro wrestling circles since 1997-ish.
If anybody needed a classic example of everything wrong with the invasion, they need look no further than the '01 King Of The Ring pay-per-view. There, Undertaker battered DDP in an unofficial match/brawl that lasted approx 5 minutes and did Page zero favours. He looked out of his depth, and his new stalker character was already rudderless.
Side note: Many fans laughed off the stalker thing, 'cause DDP was married to Kimberly Page at the time. Even ignoring real-life and suspending disbelief for wrestling characters doing "sports entertainment" things was difficult. Why was Page, who had never shown any creepy tendencies before in WCW, magically now a weirdo stalker? It made no sense.
His pop was mighty on the 18 June, but DDP's face was one of instant creative dissatisfaction.
5. Tony Atlas Gets Awkward As Saba Simba
The WWF scene had changed massively since Tony Atlas was riding high as one half of the tag champs alongside Rocky Johnson between 1983-1984 when he returned for a third stint in 1990. ‘Dark Side Of The Ring’ revealed just how dramatic and incredible Tony’s life was once his fame faded. He’d been sleeping on a park bench before getting help from his future wife and somehow finding his way back onto television.
Atlas did so as the dire Saba Simba gimmick. On commentary, Vince McMahon alleged that Tony was ‘embracing his roots’, but the whole thing felt painfully racist. Roddy Piper rubbished it straight away anyway by pointing out that it was Atlas. He was having none of the Saba Simba chat, and that was very much that.
Tony taped his first TV match back on 28 August 1990 by beating Chris Duffy. That aired on the 15 September episode of Superstars. The whole thing seemed like a humiliation ritual more than anything else, and it’s remarkable that Tony remains so upbeat about it. He even told VICE for 'Dark Side' that he was chuffed to be making money again and back on TV - everything else was fairly inconsequential to him personally.
WWF fans couldn't get in step with the character change, so it only lasted until shortly after the 1991 Royal Rumble. It was cartoonish (not always the worst thing if handled carefully, but it was awful in this case), and it's become regarded as one of the most offensive ideas McMahon ever committed to tape during his time at the helm.
4. Rikishi Is A “Bad Man”
Overnight, Rikishi went from playing a fun-loving, albeit still-credible once the bell rang, dancing babyface to a homicidal maniac who’d mowed down Steve Austin in a car. His, “I did it for The Rock” explanation was half-baked and veered into racism territory as Kish also explained that Rocky had been held down in favour of Austin because of his skin colour.
The most ridiculous thing about all of that? The Rock was already a multi-time WWF Champion by the time Rikishi made his claim, and he'd been on top of cards for at least a solid year before Survivor Series 1999 and the Austin 'whodunit' angle. The writing team were senselessly cramming race issues into their storylines when they didn't even fit or add up.
There were other problems. For some reason, despite switching up his gimmick, Rikishi kept his comedic thong look throughout this short-lived heel run. That did nothing to sell the seriousness of his shift, or for his supposed capabilities as an ice cold killer; Fans were shocked in the moment when Mick Foley outed Rikishi as the perpetrator on the 9 October 2000 Raw, but that wore off within weeks of the reveal.
People following WWF storylines just couldn’t get behind the idea whatsoever. It was too out of the blue, and there were real teething problems with presentation. A comedy babyface can't go from shaking his ample butt with Too Cool to playing the 'Stone Cold' killer (so to speak) just like that. More thought should've been put into all of this.
It wasn't, and it wrecked Rikishi's run as a popular upper-midcard good guy to boot.
3. Albert Chants Plague Lord Tensai
Hatching a brand new character on the traditionally rowdy edition of Raw after WrestleMania was always going to be tricky, but WWE thought it'd work for Lord Tensai in 2012. So, they brought Giant Bernard in from New Japan. However, instead of using his old Albert or A-Train names, they went full tilt with a fanciful repackage. Bernard became Tensai, an apparent warrior who had returned to destroy everything.
Sadly, the only thing Tensai crushed was Matt Bloom’s spirit.
Various introductory vignettes aired in the lead up his debut on the 2 April 2012 Raw. Again, that was the night after 'Mania XXVIII, and so raucous fans made Tensai’s debut hell. Immediately, they trolled him with chants of, “Albert! Albert! Albert!”, and the gimmick fizzled out from there. It was, without doubt, one of the worst nightmare debuts anybody has ever experienced.
The whole thing blew up in WWE's face as soon as Lord Tensai stepped foot through the curtain for his squash match win over Alex Riley. Fans in attendance live for Raw did not care about the match one bit, nor did they entertain thoughts that the former A-Train was some vicious new character flying in from Japan to rag doll the rest of the WWE roster.
He was Albert, formerly known as Prince Albert. In other words, he was a walking penis piercing joke, and he was there to be ridiculed. This had to be torturous for Bloom. He'd done some excellent work as part of a tag-team with Karl Anderson in New Japan, yet here he was looking like a gimmick that wouldn't have been out of place on Superstars in 1991.
2. Chad Gable Overcomes “Shorty G”
At time of writing in June 2025, Chad Gable is riding high as both himself and his devilishly brilliant 'El Grande Americano' masked offshoot. Even those who aren't digging the phoney luchador bit would have to admit that it's one million times better than what Chad was doing back between 2019-2020. Pre-COVID shutdown, he was saddled with the notoriously rotten "Shorty G" moniker.
Gable debuted that new name and persona on the 18 October 2019 SmackDown. Previously, Baron Corbin had asked the ring announcer to call Chad “Shorty Gable” at Hell In A Cell on 6 October, so seeds had already been planted. The general idea was that Gable had overcome height issues to be a success in life. There was just one problem: Most of the wrestlers poking fun at his size were either shorter or the same height.
Work that one out.
Latter-day Vince truly was putrid to sit through and stomach at times. Obviously, fans respected Chad’s in-ring skills and thought he could do more in the promotion if given the chance, so they rejected this gimmick change straight away and took it as a slap in the face. Really? They were expected to buy that Gable's 5ft 6 inches height had held him back in daily life before bumping into Vince McMahon's frankly mental thought processes?
It was preposterous. Seeing acts like Mustafa Ali and The Revival giggle at Chad's height whilst eye to eye with him (or looking up at him!) did little to sell the notion that Gable was anything other than average height. How dare he be the same height as most fans watching. What a freak!
1. Chavo Guerrero Becomes Kerwin White
Generally, unless something is obviously offensive and in poor taste, you'll find somebody who defends WWE's worst ideas. Good luck finding anybody who'll leap to the defence of Chavo Guerrero becoming Kerwin White though. It remains one of the most repulsive things WWE has ever come up with, and there's just no getting away from that.
Chavo was hastily repackaged after a last-minute leap from SmackDown to Raw during the 2005 Draft. He denounced his Hispanic heritage on the 4 July Raw, then morphed into middle-class race baiter Kerwin White. The character's actual in-person debut came on the 10 September 2005 episode of Sunday Night Heat, but vignettes had been airing for weeks, and people were far from amused by what they were watching.
Guerrero looked completely awkward playing the new character too. WWE gave up on it following the tragic death of Chavo’s uncle Eddie in November, and even WWE’s official website has gone on to call the debut “less-than-stellar”. Yeah, to say the least. Some have moaned about Guerrero turning into a 'guy who likes golf', which is really burying the lead on what the gimmick was supposed to represent.
Put it this way, WWE's racist stereotype chastised Shelton Benjamin for not having white skin. Yep. This doesn't fit into palmed off suggestions like, 'Ah, but it was a different time'. There's no excusing what Vince McMahon was up to here. It was appalling, un-entertaining and didn't have any longevity that'd turn Chavo into a bigger star anyway.
What the hell were they thinking?!
What other WWE gimmick changes backfired straight away? For more wrestling, check out 10 Times Wrestlers Blatantly Lied To Your Face and 8 New Directions For WWE After Money In The Bank 2025!