10 Awful Comic Book Characters That Don't Deserve A Movie Adaptation

From the bad, the bizarre and the downright offensive, here are the characters film studios should steer clear of.

With the comic book movie craze in full swing Disney has begun to dig into Marvel's back catalogue to meet audience demand. Soon, we'll see obscure characters like Rocket Raccoon and Ant-Man on the big screen alongside icons like Iron Man and Captain America. Warner Bros doesn't want to be left in the dust and has started its own wave of DC comic crossovers beginning with the upcoming Superman vs. Batman. The first onscreen pairing of DC's two biggest superstars should ensure a massive box office, but Warner Bros doesn't seem to be satisfied with just two bankable characters. Wonder Woman will make an appearance as well and Night-wing and Green Lantern are rumored to have cameos. Disney and Warner Bros keep vacuuming up comic book characters at an alarming rate. Soon every B-list and C-list superhero and super-villain will get his or her chance to shine on the silver screen. In their quest to saturate the market with comic goodness, the two venerable studios will have to dig deeper into DC and Marvel's back-issues and what they uncover may be terrifying. Yet not all comic book characters are created equal. They run the gamut from the dated (see Vibe), to the stupid (see Matter-Eater Lad), to the jaw-droppingly racist (see Ebony White and Egg Fu). However, Warner Bros and Disney might let their greed overcome good taste and common sense when picking which characters are fit for mass consumption. So in the interest of common decency we have assembled a list of ten comic book characters that should never be adapted for the big screen under any circumstance. Brace yourself for the rollercoaster of terrible to follow.

10. Starfox

We start our list with a super-powered creep that makes Robin Thicke seem like a champion of sexual equality: Starfox. Starfox is a member of a race of super humans known as the Eternals that possess your typical super powers like flight and super strength. What sets Starfox apart and makes him a bad choice for a blind date is his ability to psionically control the pleasure centre of a person's brain. Starfox can use his special ability to make a person open to suggestion, far more so than a few too many cocktails can. What's worse, Starfox can force someone to become infatuated with him through direct contact. That's right, Starfox is a walking, talking super-powered roofie. In the comics, Starfox's powers of persuasion got him into legal hot water. A housewife accused the pervy hero of using his abilities to get into her pants against her wishes and slapped him with a charge of sexual assault. She-Hulk acted as Starfox's legal defense until she discovered that the oily hero used his powers of persuasion to sway the jury to his side. With this revelation ringing in her ears, the enraged behemoth cold-cocked Starfox and duct-taped his mouth shut to prevent him using his powers so justice could be served. This icky story line exemplifies why Starfox could be a hit with the drunken frat boy demographic but turn off everyone else. So far, Marvel movies have stayed firmly in PG territory. An unseemly guy like Starfox doesn't fit the Disney mold and would scare away general audiences. Also, Starfox is a straight-up sexist character defined by poor taste. Disney would be well advised to leave this undeserving character off the list for its next casting call.

9. Stilt-Man

When the Marvel superhero Daredevil found his way into theatres in 2003, many considered his big screen debut to be a disaster. In the years since then, the feature's reputation has only gotten worse. Actor Ben Affleck, who played the title role, went so far as to call it the only role he ever regretted playing. Coming from the man who starred in Reindeer Games, Phantoms and Forces of Nature, that's saying a lot. Considering how bad it turned out, one has to wonder €“ could Daredevil have been even worse? The answer is yes: much, much worse. Instead of Colin Ferrell's terrifically hammy villain Bullseye, the makers of Daredevil could have adapted one of the most hilariously unthreatening villains of all time: Stilt-Man. In the comics, Stilt-Man is one of Daredevil's greatest foes. This wobbly-legged terror possesses a suit of armor with telescopic legs that allows him to grow up to up to 250 feet tall, which he uses to rob high-rises. On the page this concept sounds good but audiences would have a hard time swallowing the idea Stilt-Man could conquer a flight of steps, let alone the world. Marvel recently announced that it has teamed up with Netflix to give Daredevil his own TV show. The studio could be testing the waters for Daredevil's return to the big screen. If the painful memory of Daredevil 2003 isn't enough to stop the studio from trying again then they should make sure history doesn't repeat itself and exclude Stilt-Man from the proceedings.

8. Leather Boy

S&M has always been a tough sell for mainstream audiences. Even Academy Award-winning director William Friedkin failed to make the fetish bankable when he gave it the Hollywood treatment with his 1980 thriller Cruising. Critics panned the film and gay rights groups derided it for being homophobic. The weak box office performance that followed put the kibosh on S&M as mainstream entertainment for decades afterward, which means potential S&M profits have been untapped for decades. This leaves Disney primed to try to corner the S&M market with an obscure character from the Avengers' past. Now that Marvel has begun their second phase of Avengers films it's only logical that they will look to offshoots of the superhero group to bring to the big screen. One such group, The West Coast Avengers, has a character ready and waiting to bring S&M into multiplexes everywhere, Leather Boy. Leather Boy wound up on the West Coast Avengers after misreading a personal ad and showing up for superhero tryouts. After a brief stint on the team Leather Boy disappeared, resurfacing as a super-villain who squared off against his former teammates. Leather Boy wanted revenge for being rejected when he attempted to rejoin the Avengers. Before the superhero Big Bertha ended his reign of terror by sitting on him (because that happened), Leather Boy managed to murder two of his former teammates. This storyline treads dangerously close to the plot of Cruising, where a leather daddy serial killer stalks his victims in the underground S&M scene in New York. At the time, a gay rights group found that the film conflated the killer's homosexuality and fetishism with his psychotic behavior. So, if Marvel decides to adapt Leather Boy they could face the exact same outcry that greeted the release of Cruising. Common sense would dictate that Leather Boy is better left in the dustbin of history.

7. Hypno-Hustler

While DC and Marvel duke it out at the box office, Sony has been clamoring for its own piece of the pie. In 2012 the studio threw its hat into the ring with the box office success The Amazing Spider-Man. This summer Sony will release The Amazing Spider-Man 2 and the studio seems to be following Warner Bros and Disney's lead by cramming as many characters as possible into the new film. Spider-Man will face off against his arch-nemesis Electro as well as the Rhino. Rumors abound that even more villains may show up in the form of the super-villain super group The Sinister Six and a few Easter eggs in the trailer hint at this possibility. At this rate, the well of credible Spider-Man villains could soon run dry. Sony may be forced to call up some lesser-known antagonists to fill out the roster for The Amazing Spider-Man 3. If this proves to be the case, Sony's might have to adapt one of the most hilariously dated characters of all time, Spidey-foe the Hypno-Hustler. Marvel created Hypno-Hustler to capitalize on the disco-craze that swept the world in the late 70s. Hypno-Hustler used disco warbles to hypnotize music-lovers so he could rob them blind. Spider-Man handily defeated his jive-talking foe by using his own music against him. Hypno-Hustler is as hopelessly intertwined with disco music as the Bee Gees are; so, for this character to work Sony would need to resurrect disco music for modern audiences. Hypno-Hustler could open a Pandora's box of disco-related fury. By the end of the 70s disco inspired a famous riot at Comiskey Park in Chicago when over 50,000 disco-haters united to blow up a crate full of disco albums. So should Sony bring disco back, it might have to face a hellacious onslaught of righteous disco-fueled ire.

6. Big Sir

In 2008, comedian Ben Stiller took Hollywood to task with the satirical send-up Tropic Thunder. In the picture, Stiller plays a washed up action star who tries to earn artistic credibility by playing a mentally challenged character called Simple Jack. While Stiller intended the character to skewer Hollywood actors' exploit serious issues to earn accolades, disability advocacy groups found the character insensitive and demeaning to the mentally disabled. Over 20 advocacy groups voiced their outrage over the character and activists picketed screenings of the film. Warner Bros could find itself at the centre of a similar controversy if they are foolish enough to adapt an even more offensive character, the wholly distasteful Big Sir. Unlike Simple Jack, Big Sir doesn't have the saving grace of being satirical. Big Sir was a mentally challenged young man named Dufus who possessed a massive frame due to an abnormality in a brain gland. Dufus' imposing physique made him the target of the super-villain known as The Monitor. The Monitor broke Dufus out of a mental hospital, gave him a suit of armor and an energy mace and pitted him against the Flash. This silly and egregious character eventually met his end at the hands of an exploding baby and Flash fans everywhere breathed a collective sigh of relief. The Flash is one of the founding members of the Justice League and Warner Bros will more than likely include him and his rogues gallery in the big screen Justice League. Hopefully, the studio has the good taste to sidestep the inevitable backlash Big Sir will bring with him.

5. The Wonder Twins

In the 1970s Hanna-Barbera brought the world one of pop culture's most enduring punch lines: Zan and Jayna, aka the Wonder Twins. There have been many idiotic comic book superpowers over the years like Color Kid's ability to change an object's color or Stone Boy's ability to turn into an immobile statue, but few have rivalled the hilarity of the Wonder Twins'. When they make contact Zan can transform into water of any state, e.g. liquid, solid or gas, and Jayna can transform into any animal, real or fictional. In theory this is a super-cool power that would make the twins dangerous foes, but in practice the Wonder Twins ended up creating hilarious pairings. The duo would strike fear into villains by transforming into an eagle carrying a bucket of water or a griffin brandishing an icicle. In the 2000s, Cartoon Network's Adult Swim brought back the Wonder Twins in a series of webisodes that highlighted how useless the duo's powers would be at fighting crime. Every attempt they made to save the day ended in tragic failure. The Wonder Twins could work in small doses that highlight how truly stupid their powers are, but if anyone expanded the concept to feature length the joke would get stale pretty fast. Some heroes were never meant to play in the big leagues and the Wonder Twins clearly don't stack up against the best of the best.

4. Gin Genie

We've all had a few too many pints at one time or another and started to feel like a superhero, but the Gin Genie takes this concept to the next level. Gin Genie can create seismic waves that become more powerful the higher her blood alcohol gets. This caused problems for the super-powered lush when she lashed out at her X-Statix teammates and jeopardised team missions by getting too soused. But honestly, what did they expect after teaming up with a hero who grows more powerful with each Jaeger bomb she tosses back? Gin Genie would be great fodder for a raunchy Hangover-style comedy that celebrates the highs and lows of binge drinking, but once you transplant her into the family friendly arena of Marvel superhero films things start to get problematic. According to the World Health Organization 320,000 young people between the ages of 15-29 die from alcohol-related causes each year. If this impressionable demographic sees Gin Genie triumph over evil using the power of alcohol, we could see a dramatic rise in the number of fistfights and Girls Gone Wild videos. Marvel should think twice before it makes itself the target of teetotalers and organizations like MADD. Gin Genie's tipsy antics could very well contribute to the 2.5 million worldwide alcohol-related deaths each year and leave Marvel open for a host of class action lawsuits.

3. Krypto

In the entire history of moviemaking, there's been only one decent movie made about a crime fighting dog; it was called Turner and Hooch. Every other example of the genre has been dreadful, like K-9 and Top Dog. On the other hand, the box office triumph of the Alvin and the Chipmunks proves that talking animal movies can be big business. With this in the back of its mind, Warner Bros might decide to take its own stab at the genre and green light a movie adaptation for Superman's crime-fighting pooch Krypto. Krypto was Superman's childhood pet until Superman's dad Jor-El shot Krypto into space to test out a new rocket. Eventually, Krypto found his way to Earth where he reunited with Superman. The reunion proved bittersweet after Superman found Krypto's super-powered puppy antics too much to handle and sent Krypto back into space. During the 70s, Krypto got up to his own super heroics, defeating super-villains and acquiring the power of speech. The temptation to adapt this kid friendly property could prove to great for Warner Bros to resist, and we could soon have another Marmaduke on our hands. What's worse is that it might not stop with Krypto. Krypto has a stable full of animal allies called The Legion of Super-Pets; there's Streaky the Super-Cat, Beppo the Super-Monkey and Comet the Super-Horse. DC could very well open a Pandora's box of talking super animal films that could potentially make the universe implode from an epic wave of cinematic stupidity.

2. Uncle Sam

This summer, Warner Bros' Superman reboot Man of Steel got the ball rolling on the studio's plans for a Justice League movie. Man of Steel cleaned house in the international market, hauling in $377,000,000 in international grosses €“ more than half of the feature's box office tally. Courting international sales seems to be Warner Bros' surest way to obtain box office comic book supremacy. So, in the interest of its bottom-line, the studio should steer clear of one DC character that could single-handedly put the brakes on DC's runaway freight train of success. The character in question is the ultra-patriotic Uncle Sam. Uncle Sam takes his image from the famous symbol of the USA used in American propaganda. The Founding Fathers themselves created Uncle Sam through an occult ritual and the character draws his super strength from the American ideals of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. American audiences might accept Uncle Sam with open arms but international audiences might balk at the idea of rooting for zombie America to punish evildoers with his super-powered fists. A recent Gallup poll conducted in 65 different countries found that the majority of the world believes America poses the greatest threat to world peace at the moment. If foreign markets get a glimpse of a flesh and blood representation of America dispensing justice through brute force, Warner Bros could alienate its greatest hope for winning the comic book wars.

1. Bat-Mite

Batmite

One of the most annoying comic book characters of all time lands at the top of our list. Bat-Mite debuted in 1959 and went on to be one of Batman's most enduring side characters. This elf-like creature comes from the fifth dimension where advanced technology gives him almost infinite powers. What does Bat-Mite do with his God-like abilities? He mostly spends his time stalking Batman like a hepped up Motley Crue groupie. Bat-Mite primarily serves to provide grating comic relief by continually bungling his attempts to help Batman out. In each of Bat-Mite's various incarnations over the years, there's one thing that remains constant: he's un-funny as taking a soccer kick to the groin. Despite being adapted into television on multiple occasions, big screen stardom continues to elude the character. There is a good reason for this; once audiences catch a glimpse of what looks like a lump stuffed into a Batman costume floating around Batman's head, they'll be running full steam for the exits. Bat-Mite doesn't seem like an obvious choice for DC to bring to the big screen because of how goofy he is. However, comic book icon Grant Morrison recently gave Bat-Mite a gritty update. In Morrison's take on the character, Bat-Mite is a figment of Bruce Wayne's imagination that Wayne created to help him cope with the trauma of witnessing his parents' murder. Given the gritty tone of Man of Steel, this version of Bat-Mite could fit in well with the upcoming Justice League movie. So in other words, DC has its own Jar Jar Binks warming the bench and it might be only a matter of time before he takes the field. There's our list. Any we missed? Have we been unfair to some of these characters? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

I'm YA writer who loves pulp and art house films. I admire films that try to do something interesting.