10 Beloved Comic Book Characters Movie Fans Hate

Green Lantern did not make the jump from page to screen as expected...

Green Lantern Love Hate
DC Comics/Warner Bros.

Adapting a popular character from comic book to film is never an easy task. From choosing the right actor to play the role, getting the setting right for their introduction into either their own story or an ensemble's, and then having to constantly worry about whether or not fans are going to find fault with anything that has been done to their beloved characters

Whilst we are more than familiar with the successful adaptations of some of the most iconic comic book characters of all time, it is easy to forget some of the films which didn't go to plan at all, and whether it be down to miscasting or misconceiving any adaptation of a popular character, it has left fans and filmgoers wishing that it had never happened at all in far too many cases.

Some filmgoers may not necessarily even have to be avid fans of the character or the original material they are watching to still end up hating them, a testament to how bad some film adaptations of comic book characters can actually end up being, so with that said, here are 10 Beloved Comic Book Characters Movie Fans Hate.

10. Steel

Shaq Steel
Warner Bros.

John Henry Irons a.k.a Steel was supposed to be introduced in a follow-up to a live-action adaptation of the Death Of Superman comic released in 1992. The project, likely the ill-fated Superman Lives starring Nicolas Cage in the leading role, was cancelled three weeks before filming was set to begin, but the producers behind Steel secured a green light for their own project and moved ahead with it as a standalone film.

Starring NBA legend Shaquille O'Neil as the titular hero, the film was released in 1997 and was a categorical misfire, panned by both critics and audiences. The character of Steel had been a fairly recent, but popular addition to DC comics during the Death Of Superman, but the film chose to remove the character from the continuity and feature the metal-clad hero in his own universe.

The resulting effort was a mess of cheesy dialogue, campy set-pieces, a woeful storyline, and an uncomfortably awkward performance from O'Neil in the lead role making it no wonder that despite having the colossal star on board, the film tanked at the box office and turned into an equally colossal misfire that literally everyone hated.


9. Elektra

Elektra Jennifer Garner
Fox

Jennifer Garner first played the Sai-wielding Assassin in the much-maligned but under-appreciated, Daredevil film back in 2003, which didn't serve as a totally accurate introduction to the character adapted from Marvel comics or seem to leave much room for a follow-up, not that anyone was chomping at the bit for one.

But in 2005 Garner was back, and the world was actually gearing up for the first-ever female-led Marvel Comics film which predictably, managed to flop hard at the Box-Office, and although some critics praised her performance and blamed other areas, the film has been seen as a career killer for Garner.

Nothing about Elektra as a film or character was satisfying for anyone who watched it, from the action sequences which looked like rip-offs of better movies, the woeful script and its handling of the Hand-Chaste conflict, and the absence of any real atmosphere or character drama all contributing to ruining not just the film, but the reputation of the character for years.

Elektra would not be seen onscreen again until the arrival of the second season of Netflix's Daredevil , more than ten years after this diabolical solo outing, but not long enough for fans to totally forget their ire at how the character was handled the first-time round.


8. The Green Hornet

Green Hornet Movie Image Seth Rogen 1
Columbia Pictures

How do you ruin one of the oldest superheroes to exist in modern media? By turning their reboot into a half-baked comedy starring Seth Rogen apparently.

The Green Hornet is a legendary figure in the world of both comics and superheroes, having first appeared as part of a radio serial during the 1930s, getting their own comic in the 1940s, and appearing in the much-loved tv-series with action legend Bruce Lee as sidekick Kato during the 60s.

The comeback for a character that's related to the friggin' Lone Ranger should have been a cause for considerable hype and celebration, but things started to look off from the moment the first trailers dropped with actor Seth Rogen playing the character.

Playing up the playboy factor of the masked hero's true identity of Britt Reid might have seemed like a great way to maximise on the comedy, but then turning the Hornet into a bumbling and cowardly moron only served as a disservice to the character, and no one in the audience was happy about that or with Rogen's performance.

Despite being relatively successful at the box office, there was absolutely no desire from anyone who watched it for a sequel, and even talks of rebooting the franchise from scratch have stalled in the wake of how poorly the film was received the first time around.


7. Judge Dredd

Judge Dredd Stallone
Hollywood Pictures

Whilst everyone's favourite judge, jury, and executioner may have found redemption in 2012's hardcore-hyper-violent reboot, fans and audiences still have not forgotten Judge Dredd's original feature-film debut from 1995.

Even having one of the biggest action stars in the world at the time attached to your project is no sure guarantee of success, as the involvement of Sylvester Stallone in the adaptation of one of Britains most successful comics would prove, seeing the Rocky actor delivering one of his all-time worst performances from his long and illustrious career.

Constantly removing his helmet was one of the biggest nopes that sent fans into fits, but combined with some serious over-acting, a weak script, and being a gigantic tonal mismatch certainly did not help him. Sly has even gone on record to apologise for how the film turned out and also commented on its shoddy development.

The memory of this film was so tainted that even the rebooted version struggled to be seen that much by viewers even 17 years after the original debacle was released, further showing that not only fans were put off by the hash that was made of the character, but regular audience goers as well.


6. Ghost Rider

Ghost Rider Spirit Of Vengeance
Columbia Pictures

The start of the new Millennium was really not the best time for a lot of Marvel heroes but none had arguably a more woeful time of things than Ghost Rider.

Actor Nicolas Cage deciding to take an approach which he insisted would give the character more "depth", at the expense of a lot of the personality which made the character so popular in the first place was a questionable decision from the off, and it would be somewhat of an understatement to say it misfired.

Despite being a modest box office success, the film was panned by critics and fans alike who felt Cage's performance was totally not what the character should have been about, and Cage himself was nominated for a Golden Raspberry award for his performance as it was just that woeful.

Somehow, the film managed to get a sequel to the screen which was impressive feat enough in itself, only for it to be even more harshly received than its predecessor and well and truly put the nail in the coffin of not only Cage's career as a leading man but all future big-screen plans for the character.


5. Mr Freeze

Mr Freeze
Warner Bros.

Mr Freeze is a Batman villain who underwent one of the biggest changes in the history of the Caped Crusaders run in popular media. Brilliantly reimagined in the amazing animated series during the 1990s Heart Of Ice storyline, which transformed Freeze into one of the most menacing, but also, more tragic of rogues the Dark Knight could face.

So to no one's surprise at all this had to be turned into a completely ham-fisted, sorry excuse for a live-action adaptation by none other than the Governator himself, Arnold Schwarzenegger in 1998's diabolical Batman & Robin.

Arnie was completely miscast in the role, delivering puns at any opportunity, wearing a campy suit that made him look more like a giant blue light-bulb then a serious villain, and displaying none of the cold-hearted detachment and villainy that really made the character stand out in the comics, or the animated series.

In a film as blatantly awful as Batman & Robin, it should be no surprise that it was panned by just about everyone and their mother who went to see it and left Mr Freeze very much out in the cold, and out of contention for any future appearances in live-action down the line.


4. Green Lantern

Green Lantern Ryan Reynolds
Warner Bros.

At the time, there may have been some seriously credible thoughts going around at Warner Brothers Studios that Ryan Reynolds was the perfect fit to bring the foremost man to where the green ring of Earth's guardian, Hal Jordan, to the big screen.

Obviously, that didn't quite work out as well they hoped...

In a fantastic case of not as planned, everything about the film turned out to be just so bad that even the eternally loveable Reynolds was not spared the rod of wrath from the fans. Delivering an okay-ish performance amidst a mess of bad CGI, poor direction and dialogue, and a thoroughly underwhelming villain, leaving almost nothing recognisable about the beloved comic book character for the fans.

The fact that this was supposed to be a crucial part of expanding the DC universe into a franchise rivalling Marvel, only added extra salt to the wound and faith in the character appearing in the future has still not fully recovered after being axed from Zac Snyder's vision of Justice League, much to the further ire of the fans.


3. Robin

Chris Odonnell Robin
Warner Bros.

The most recognisable sidekick in the history of comics, but also a bonafide hero in their own right in many cases, the role of Robin might be one of the most endearing comic book characters of all time, but adapting to the big screen has been no easy task.

It is hard to see how this could have gone any other way apart from poorly when looking back at the introduction of the character in Batman Forever. It was a questionable move from the outset getting the then 27-year-old Chris O'Donnell to play the "boy" wonder and one that wasn't lost on anyone watching in the audience.

The origin story for O'Donnell's Robin was not one that deviated from the comics massively, which made it even more jarring watching the character develop on screen and be treated more as a juvenile than his appearance might have warranted. Furthermore, doing nothing particularly noteworthy to actually see him merit being accepted by the film's Batman as a crime-fighting partner wasn't exactly a thrilling origin for fans.

Coupled with a disastrously immature showing in the sequel Batman & Robin, it's fair to say that O'Donnell and his efforts in the role were not best appreciated by fans, and the character has not yet managed to their way back into live action since.


2. Cyclops

Cyclops Death
20th Century Fox

There are few characters that have been done a greater disservice in a live-action adaptation of their source material than X-men leader Cyclops.

The key term in that sentence is leader, as that is exactly what Cyclops has often been seen as in the X-Men comics and expanded media, a fact that the film series would choose to omit and instead focus all the attention on Hugh Jackman's Wolverine.

The unfortunate soul who was given the sorry can to carry in this franchise earl on was James Marsden, but whilst it would be easy to simply chalk up the poor portrayal and reaction to the character down to the wider decisions made, Marsden was still highly unspectacular in the role.

Despite being there to act as a more straight-laced foil to Jackman's Wolverine, Marsden has been openly criticised for a particularly wooden performance as the laser-shooting mutant and although given very little to work, not making the most of what screen-time he was given seems to have only escalated in the follow-up instalments to the original Millennium outing judging by further reduced time spent on screen.

Follow-up appearances in later X-Men films have not really ranked much better with fans still yet to see a worthy performance that befits one of the greatest X-Men characters.


1. The Fantastic Four And Dr Doom

The Invasion Nicole Kidman
Warner Bros.

Yes, we cheated on this last entry, but when a group of beloved characters and their arch-nemesis are done the dirty not once but TWICE, they deserve to all be included in the same entry.

Where do you even start with the diabolical history of the Fantastic Four and Doctor Doom? A comic book property so hot, so beloved, that legendary producer Roger Corman was hired to put a sham $2 million production through filming just so the studio could keep the license for the property, a move that did not go unnoticed from 20th Century Fox later on in time.

Casting for the heroes in both films can be best described in either case as a few promising additions with an equal amount of questionable choices at the same time, and although actors like Chris Evans, Michael B. Jordan, and Miles Teller are pretty big names in the world of film nowadays, it also proved to be career tanking ventures for others like Jessica Alba and Ioan Gruffudd.

Dragging in one of Marvel's most highly rated villains in Dr Doom and then butchering everything great about the character twice, thanks to some truly woeful design and character decisions is shameful enough on its own, but the overall tone of all three of the F4 films proved just so underwhelming that fans boycotted the most recent adaption back in 2015 due to leaked studio meddling and poor opening reactions.

A petition to have the rights to all the characters given back to Marvel was bold but mercifully unnecessary as Disney's acquisition of all the Fox properties will hopefully provide some kind of redemption for the characters for fans further down the line.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Green Lantern
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Sam Ring hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.