10 Best Comic Book Characters NOT From Marvel Or DC

The big two are great, but these characters offer something you just can't get from them.

Hellboy Thumbnail
Dark Horse Comics

There's a very good reason that when we talk about "the big two" in comics, we refer to Marvel and DC. They've lasted the longest out of everyone else in the game so far, and have written the book on how to make comic books, and more importantly, comic book characters.

However, their way of doing things can be restrictive, to say the very least. The lack of any permanence in their stories, for one, can be frustrating to fans, since it kinda kills investment in a story when Dick Grayson dies for the third damn time. Probably why they decided they'd be better off renaming him Rick.

Fortunately, for this, there are other comic book companies off the beaten path. Plenty of whom have the clout and character roster to rival the big two. They may not be as iconic as Batman or Superman, but they bring something to the table that's all their own.

10. X (Dark Horse Comics)

Dark Horse X
Dark Horse Comics

Have you ever wondered what would happen if you took the basic idea of Batman and brought it to about as logical an extreme as you can get?

What if the things everyone claims are problems with the idea of the Dark Knight - a masked white dude with too much time on his hands beating up the less fortunate and mentally ill - were intentionally incorporated into the character to make a point? Well for this psychotic little thought experiment, you turn to Dark Horse's X.

Created by Mike Richardson and Chris Warner, X is a superhero in the loosest sense of the term. The character's whole gimmick is that he gives criminals one chance at redemption after giving them one half of an X shaped scar. If they don't shift gears into a life of absolute sainthood, he gives them the other scar, and then kills them.

The character of X is fascinatingly insane and violent, particularly because we know nothing about the man under the mask. We see nothing of his personal life, and his mask has locks on it to prevent it from being taken off. Only a few have ever managed to see X's true face.

Unfortunately, those people aren't in a position to tell anyone what they saw, given that there isn't enough of them left to fill a shoebox.


9. Dee (Image Comics)

Rat Queens Dee
Image Comics

There are a lot of reasons to love the original run of Rat Queens from Image Comics. The fun cast of characters, the casual but no less detailed world building, and how it feels like for the script, the writers just held their own D&D campaign and left in all the out of character tangents the players go on. But out of all of the great characters that make up the moldy metropolis of Palisade, Dee reigns supreme.

Dee hails from a death cult that worships N'Rygoth, a Lovecraftian squid god who offered prosperity for the cult for the low low price of near constant blood sacrifice. As you can imagine, Dee took issue with this method of running things, slowly grew disillusioned with her faith, left her husband and people, and eventually joined up with the Rat Queens mercenary band.

Every member of the Rat Queens would be the comic relief in a traditional adventuring party, so it's no surprise that Dee's sharp wit and banter with the other queens is often hilarious. But what sets her apart is that her wit carries that tinge of world weariness that you'd expect from a backstory like her's.

However, unlike other fantasy characters in her situation, she is far from the "den mother" of the group. The other Rat Queens are all adults, and she treats them as such, letting them stew in messes of their own creation.


8. Rosie (Boom! Studios)

Lumberjanes Rosie
Boom! Studios

Have you ever wondered what would happen if you took Grunkle Stan from Gravity Falls, Bunny Bravo, and Bear Grylls, threw them all into a blender, and just hit the puree switch? Of course you have, who hasn't? And fortunately, this great question of the universe has finally found its answer in Rosie from Boom! Studios' Lumberjanes.

Rosie is the kind of character that you suspect normally spends her time fighting monsters, and just acts as camp director for Miss Quinzella Thiskwin Penniquiqul Thistle Crumpet's Camp For Hardcore Lady Types in her spare time. Neither the heroines of this story nor the audience knows that much about her, save that she's eccentric and incredibly resourceful. Not to mention a wee bit too quick to suggest an axe as a solution to interpersonal conflicts.

61 issues into this comic and we haven't learned much beyond that, which would be frustrating in any other context. But the character is just so much fun that it hardly even matters.


7. Savage Dragon (Image Comics)

Savage Dragon Vol 1
Image Comics

One of the original Image Comics superheroes, and one of the premier characters of the creator first movement led by Image back in the early to mid-90s, Savage Dragon has a place in the hearts of many older comic book fans. Though yes, the character is indicative of the tropes at the time, his creator had been trying to get him off the ground for almost a decade prior to Image picking him up, so the compromise is understandable to finally get the book published.

Besides, the true strengths of the character always shined through at the end of the day. Our favorite big green do-gooder may have lost his memory at the beginning of the story, but the man lost none of his integrity. In his first couple issues alone, he not only takes down a bunch of criminals and supervillains, but then chew out a corrupt racist cop for giving the force a bad name and only adding to the problem by scaring people.

The dragon plays no favorites, if you're doing wrong in the world, he stands against you. Sure he was big and muscle-bound and often carried large guns, like all other early Image characters. But what saved him from going the way of Youngblood was his humanity.


6. Miracleman (Eclipse Comics)

Miracleman Eclipse
Eclipse Comics

When it comes to the rise of darker, grittier superhero comics in the 80s and 90s, the usual suspects for kicking the whole thing off include Batman: The Dark Knight Returns and The Killing Joke, and Alan Moore's Watchmen. But there's another Alan Moore comic that tends to be forgotten in this lineup: Miracleman.

Originally created back in the silver age, as essentially a Shazam clone, the character eventually evolved into quite a bit more thanks to the help of writers like Alan Moore and Neil Gaiman. And since those two writers aren't exactly known for writing happy rainbow sunshine stories, you can make an educated guess for yourself as to what we mean by "evolved".

It gets dark. Like, really dark. As in, Watchmen was Moore taking it down a notch.

The violence and dark tone was often excessive, but Miracleman also took time to lay the groundwork for the "superheroes as gods" story idea that would be explored in different ways by the big two and others later on. And like with the rest of Alan Moore's early work, the violence may have been excessive, but the writing was just good enough to keep you hooked issue to issue.


5. Michelangelo (IDW Comics)

TMNT Mikey
IDW Comics

There have been as many Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles comic series as there are days in the month, but for this one, we're focusing on the IDW incarnation. Mostly because this series does the most interesting things with the character. All of the turtles are given significantly more depth in this comic than they have elsewhere, but the normally goofy comic relief Michelangelo is by far the most fleshed out.

A lot of the most important moments we can't talk about for spoiler reasons - we really want you to read this comic - but one of the most interesting changes made to the dynamic of the turtles is how Mikey reacts to how the group treats him. We all know Mikey's role in the team, he's the goof-off, the comic relief, the one everyone else makes fun of.

In this comic, that happens as well, but while Mikey is more than willing to let most of the ribbing roll off his shell since they're family, this comics shows that he's also equally willing to put his foot down. As shown in one instance where, again without spoiling, Mikey becomes so disillusioned with Leonardo's leadership, that after one particularly unpopular decision by the leader, Mikey straight up leaves the team. And he stays gone for a while.

The IDW TMNT comics are great because of how they complicate and evolve the brothers' dynamic. And Michelangelo is the prime example of this.


4. Jackie Estacado (Top Cow Productions)

The Darkness
Top Cow Productions

Definitely one of the most out-there ideas for a comic book character in a long time, Jackie Estacado is the main character of Top Cow Productions' The Darkness comics. He's a mafioso who comes to inherit an ancient demon known only as The Darkness.

The Darkness - true to its name - has nothing but contempt for humanity, and nothing but the worst planned to do with Jackie. But that would require control of his body and his soul, the latter of which Jackie is a lot more stubborn about giving up.

The great thing about Jackie is that he isn't some saint given the power of a demon, like with the various incarnations of Ghost Rider. Jackie is a mafia enforcer, with all the shades of moral grey that entails. He kills, has killed in the past, and given his profession, it stands to reason most of them didn't have it coming. But however bad Jackie may or may not be, The Darkness is worse, and manages to find - and cross - whatever moral lines Jackie has left. Making him much more sympathetic as a result.

And, of course, being a highly trained mafia enforcer with the powers of one of Hell's most powerful demons at his beck and call, Jackie is one badass dude.


3. Spawn (Image Comics)

Spawn Image Comics
Image Comics

When talking about the best - or at least the most influential - comic book characters outside of the big two, Spawn is going to come up at some point or another. And if you know even the tiniest amount about what Image Comics was up to in the early to mid-90s, you know exactly why.

At the top of his game, Spawn wasn't just famous, he was an institution. The breakout star of Image Comics, and the golden boy of the comic book indie scene. Sure his would be the groundwork upon which all of the problems with 90's era comics would be laid, but no one working on him at the time could've foreseen that.

For those not in the know, Spawn was once a hired assassin named Al Simmons. Like all hired guns, at some point he pissed off his employers and got a lovely kerosene makeover as a result. However, because the main theme of Spawn is that the universe just kinda hates our buddy Al, he's roped into a supernatural bargain by an eldritch demon. Allowing him to return to earth, only to find his enemies in power, his wife remarried, and him barely remembering anything from his previous life.

Spawn may have succumbed to the very speculator boom his creators helped to blow up, but in his prime, the hype was real. Spawn was precisely what the comic reading public needed at the time, and his best stories still hold up. Which is more than we can say for Youngblood.


2. Alana (Image Comics)

Saga Alana
Image Comics

Image may have been at their most popular back in the early 90s, but don't think they've been slacking off since then. In fact, most comic aficionados consider their best work to come after the 90s. or at least they did, until Saga came along. Now they bump that up to October 10th, 2012, when the first issue of Saga hit shelves.

The entire main cast of Saga is fantastic, but the best character overall has to be the mother of our story's narrator: Alana. Alana is a soldier in a war between two species, who in true love story fashion, fell hard for a soldier of the opposite end of the war. Problem enough already, but the hammer really came down on them when they had a child, prompting both of their races to disown them, and every bounty hunter in the galaxy to come gunning for them.

Alana is the sci-fi ideal of the term "trooper mom". While not the most badass soldier out there, even before she had Hazel, Alana can more than handle herself, especially when the alternative is letting someone take her child away from her. And yet at the same time, she can also be one of the funniest comic characters in a long time (she apparently quite likes the taste of her own breast milk) without detracting from the rest of her character.

Saga is far from over yet, seeing as how it takes hiatuses that make Steven Universe blush, so there's no telling what the universe will throw at this tiger mom when it returns.

But whatever comes, if it's coming after Alana's baby, it better bring all of its friends.


1. Hellboy (Dark Horse Comics)

Hellboy Darkness Calls
Dark Horse

The top three of this list was a brain teaser for who would be at the top. Both Spawn and Alana had more than ample reason to warrant being put at the #1 spot as the best character the big two could never make. But at the end of the day, there is only one Hellboy. Accept no substitutes.

Mike Mignola's legendary series has not only helped to put Dark Horse Comics on the map and help it become a force to be reckoned with in the late 90s and into the 2000s, but Hellboy is one of the most consistent characters in comic history. No rewrites, no retcons, no games.

And on top of that, his character is insanely compelling. Whereas other comics, even the best independent stuff, relies on a strong supporting cast (which Hellboy has), some of the best Hellboy adventures have very few, if anyone tagging along.

He is at once a gruff, world-weary soldier, a defiant would-be bringer of the apocalypse, and a quiet, contemplative, kind soul. There's a reason most of the supporting cast that makes up the B.P.R.D have the shared backstory detail of "and then Hellboy showed up and was nice to me, so now I'll follow him into hell".

His latest cinematic outing may have been the kind of bad superhero movie we foolishly believed just couldn't be made anymore, but that has not diminished what a gift to the comic book medium big red has been, and continues to be.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Hellboy
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?