10 Best Moments From Batman: Zero Year – Dark City

A still-very-green Batman takes on his biggest challenge yet: defeat the brilliant mind of the Riddler and save his city.

Dark City is the second act in Zero Year, the New 52 Batman origin story, set between Secret City, the first act, where Batman fought the Red Hood Gang and where the New 52 Joker seemingly gets his origin, and the forthcoming third and final act beginning next month, Savage City. And what an amazing ride it's been so far! Anyone who doubted Scott Snyder was somehow going to botch Batman's origins or that another Batman origin was pointless or that it'd somehow tarnish Frank Miller/David Mazzucchelli's Year One, have been proved wrong by the highly original, incredibly imaginative story that Snyder and Greg Capullo have created in Zero Year. In Dark City, the Riddler, aka Edward Nygma, has blacked out Gotham City and, while Batman struggles to hunt down Riddler and restore power, a mad scientist nicknamed Doctor Death is murdering Wayne Enterprises research staff. Bruce Wayne's distrust of the Gotham City Police Department (GCPD) €“ including Jim Gordon €“ is explored, and Batman is still viewed by the police as a menace in league with the likes of Riddler and Red Hood. A still-very-green Batman must take on his biggest challenge yet: defeat the brilliant mind of the Riddler and save his city. But a storm's coming (Mr Wayne) and Batman will realise that he's underestimated his opponent €“ and failed Gotham. This is a look at the best moments from Dark City, taking in Batman #25, #26, #27 and #29 €“ why not #28? Because that wasn't a Zero Year issue, it was an early look at the forthcoming Batman: Eternal series. So putting aside two obvious points like Snyder's writing and Capullo's art €“ we'll take it as given that these are highlights of any comic they do €“ here are the best moments of Batman: Zero Year €“ Dark City. Light 'em up!

10. The Leaping Batmobile

Batmobile 25 In one of the opening scenes of Dark City, Batman's being chased by the GCPD, establishing that it's early days yet and he's still looked upon as an enemy than an ally in the fight against crime. But what's that Batman's driving? It's not the sleek, dark beast of the Batmobile we're used to seeing, it's this weird... gold and blue thing? It's the amazing leaping Batmobile! So the GCPD drive Batman into a tunnel at the end of which is a police blockade €“ they've got him, they think. And then Batman hits a switch and suddenly the Batmobile starts changing until it leaps over the blockade to freedom! Capullo said in an interview what a headache it is for him sometimes when receiving a script from Snyder €“ it takes Snyder a minute to write "and then the Batmobile changes and it's able to leap/fly" and it takes him hours, if not days, to figure out the logistics of what that would conceivably look like. But the results are undeniable €“ the Leaping Batmobile has leapt into the pantheon of greatest Batmobile designs ever!

9. The First Bat Signal

Bat Signal What tends to happen when the power goes out in a major city? Looting. And that's what happens in Gotham. Looters smash their way into a store and fill their boots while a terrified mother and daughter look on helplessly as their livelihood is being taken. Then the perspective shifts to the little girl being cradled by her mother. Outside the frame of her mother's body, she sees a flash of black cape, a mugger going down, part of a cowl €“ is that a bat mask? €“ and then it's over. The looters are subdued, the store is safe again. It's such an amazing scene that's brilliantly laid out by Capullo (in a single page no less!) where you don't see Batman but you see the effects of Batman from one of the people he's sworn to protect. The coup de grace is when the little girl draws a crude bat symbol on a torch and shines it on a wall €“ the first Bat Signal!

8. Calling Doctor Death

Doctor Death New 52 Snyder goes way back into Batman history for his origin story, taking one of the first villains he ever faced and putting him into New 52 continuity as one of Batman's first villains as well. Doctor Death, aka Dr Karl Helfern, first appeared in Detective Comics #29 in July 1939. A mad scientist character, Snyder beefs him up in his story whose experiments in creating super-hard human skeletons (referring to Helfern's research, it's mentioned that one of the benefits would be a human skull being more sturdy than an army helmet, and there are flashbacks in other issues to soldiers in a desert country warzone focusing on a soldier's helmet) have turned him into a grotesque monster. Death provides the physical challenge to Batman in this part of the story which Riddler can't provide, and distracts Batman long enough for Riddler's plan of destroying Gotham can be successfully accomplished. He's also strikingly designed by Capullo €“ look at those teeth!

7. Young Harper Row

Harper Row Harper Row is one of Snyder's contributions to the ever-expanding Gotham cast. A headstrong young person with a genius intellect, strong morals, and penchant for engineering, Harper goes on to become an important ally to Batman (and if you read Batman #28 you'll know she becomes even more relevant). But in Zero Year, she's still a kid and in the backup to Batman #25 we see her standing up to her loser dad who decides to leave her and her younger brother Cullen alone at night to go drinking. It shows how quickly she had to grow up to look after her Cullen as well as Harper's precocious engineering skills that were manifesting even at that young age. If you love Harper Row as much as I do, you'll have enjoyed the little cameo she had in Zero Year €“ and that image of the Bat symbol on her window made in the rain? Stunning.

6. Year One Redux

It would've been impossible for Snyder to have written a Batman origin without referencing the classic €“ and arguably greatest €“ Batman story, Year One. But he does put his own spin on it. Whereas in Year One where Batman goes up against the SWAT team in a building and gets shot a couple times, Batman suffers much more in Batman #27. The Riddler's tipped the GCPD off about Batman's whereabouts and the kinds of tricks Batman employs, giving the GCPD the upper hand when they face him. When the GCPD surprise Batman and open fire on him, Batman's cape is riddled with holes, his cowl shatters, he desperately attempts using gas but they're prepared with their own gas-masks, when he tries to leave via the Batboat, they blow it up and force him back inside. He barely escapes after improvising and gets picked up by Gordon in a non-GCPD boat. It's an action-packed, adrenaline-pumping sequence that shows an inexperienced Batman on the ropes beginning to learn to trust others in his crusade. Like so many moments in Zero Year, this is a brilliant hat tip and a nod to an acknowledged Batman classic that Snyder/Capullo pull off majestically while underlining the core themes of their story.

5. The Goddamn Frank Miller

Batman 29 Frank Miller rightly casts a long shadow across Batman because of The Dark Knight Returns and Year One. Besides the references to Year One there are other moments in Dark City that wink at Miller's Batman legacy. There's an amazing Dark Knight Returns-esque panel of Batman watching a young Barbara playing with a puppy in Batman #27, the lightning crackling behind him, and a stunning full page visual of Batman leaping from the Batblimp to the Riddler's balloon which also uses the Miller graphic of a shadowy figure against the dramatic, storm clouds/lightning background. Full credit to Capullo for creating these wonderful images that are both reminiscent of Miller's work and Capullo's own style €“ the use of bright colours help differentiate between the two! And speaking of the Batblimp, when Batman appears in it in Batman #29, the GCPD declare "it's the (censored) Batman!" with a G and a N peeking out from behind the "censored" label. Even a piece of All-Star Batman and Robin makes it into Zero Year!

4. Riddler As A Viable Threat

Bm 23 2 Riddler One of the most remarkable accomplishments Snyder's pulled off in Zero Year is the way he's made Riddler into a genuine threat, not just to Batman, but to Gotham City as well. Riddler doesn't have superpowers and he's always been seen as a gimmicky villain, a joke even, who speaks in riddles and wears clothes covered in question marks €“ hardly someone you'd think would be a challenge to the Dark Knight. But he does have brains and Snyder employs Riddler's sharp intelligence and cunning mind to devastating effect. Riddler takes down Gotham's power, throwing the city into nocturnal chaos, gives the GCPD information to help them fight Batman, and finally, in the insanely action-packed finale to Dark City, begins blowing up the blimps Bruce donated to the GCPD, and demolishes the sea walls, causing Gotham to become flooded. Dark City ends with Riddler winning, having beaten Batman. The Riddler. Who'da thunk it? Scott Snyder that's who. And kudos to the man for taking a classic Batman villain and making him work so well in a contemporary Batman story.

3. The Supervillains Before The Bat

Villains In tons of Batman stories showcasing his early years, including Year One, the order of events goes 1) Gotham is riddled with Mafia crime and corrupt police, 2) Batman appears and defeats organised crime, 3) in the absence of organised crime, the costumed supervillains rise. This has implications on Batman's status as a hero. The idea can go: well, if Batman weren't around, we wouldn't have psychos like the Joker running around would we? The Mafia are preferable to a maniac who tries to poison the Gotham reservoir, any day of the week! This can reflect on Batman badly as it makes it seem like Batman has inadvertently caused the crime in Gotham not just to rise but to become more deadly. In Zero Year, we see that the supervillains are around before Bruce becomes Batman. The Red Hood Gang, the Riddler, these threats are present before Batman appears making him a reaction to the supervillain threat than a catalyst to creating them. This shifts the scales on the perceptions on Batman and makes him more heroic as a result. It's an inspired approach by Snyder and one that I feel should become canon because it's so right.

2. Two Great Tastes That Taste Great Together

Batman 25 Bruce Wayne Jim Gordon Dark City is a great Batman story because it's got loads of awesome Batman action but all of the fighting, gadgets and heroic acts wouldn't work unless it didn't have the character work to back it up and make it important to the reader. And one of the best things in Dark City is the way Snyder writes Bruce Wayne and Jim Gordon's relationship. Since Zero Year started Bruce and Jim haven't been sympatico, which goes back to the day Bruce's parents were murdered. Jim busts Bruce who's playing truant to go watch Zorro at the Monarch Theatre. In the back seat, Bruce watches as Gordon's squad car parks outside a clothes shop and Jim's partner, Corrigan, goes in, talks a minute and comes out with new trench coats €“ the same one Gordon still wears today. To Bruce, who didn't see what Gordon did later when he challenged Corrigan and wound up fighting, and killing, a number of dogs meant for gambling matches, it meant Gordon was part of the endemic corruption within the GCPD, rather than one of the few good cops on the force. Gordon inadvertently gets his chance to set things right when he tells Batman (not knowing he's Bruce) what the trench coat means to him: to remind the others that he hasn't forgotten that day, and neither has he. Besides the trench coat story, the other notable moment between the two that symbolises their burgeoning friendship is after Jim helps Batman, who's just barely escaped from the GCPD, into his boat and Jim hands Batman his glasses. He tells him to take off his cowl before it burns his eyes out and that he won't see his identity because he's practically blind without his glasses. Batman does remove his cowl and so begins to slowly trust Gordon. Gordon is one of Batman's greatest allies so it's important that he play a significant part in his origin story €“ his scenes in Dark City (and presumably in the forthcoming Savage City) reinforce the character's importance in the Batman mythos that Snyder crucially gets so right. Plus Gordon is a wonderful character and fans of Batman are almost always fans of Gordon so his inclusion always makes a Batman story better!

1. Batman Fails

All through Zero Year, but especially in Dark City, Snyder's been working in flashbacks from when Bruce was a kid and his parents Thomas and Martha were alive, juxtaposing these with the "present" (which is actually 6 years ago from the current New 52 timeline) showing the increasingly tough task it is for Bruce to be Batman. This isn't just done because it's an origin story and as such we need to be reminded (for what seems like the billionth time) why Bruce chose to become Batman. The point of Dark City is Batman learning to trust others after realising that he can't do this alone. What the flashbacks show is a helpless Bruce Wayne looking over his dead parents and the current Bruce Wayne who stubbornly refuses to ask for help and tries to do everything himself. This is why Batman fails at the end of the story arc. He tries to take on Doctor Death and Riddler by himself and only just manages to beat Death but fails to stop the bigger problem of Riddler and his unrelenting attack on Gotham. By the end of Dark City, Batman and Gordon have failed in saving the city €“ blimps are on fire and crashing into buildings, a storm is raging, and the sea walls break, flooding the city. If we take the analogy of Star Wars, Dark City is The Empire Strikes Back, where things look their bleakest and our heroes are losing. Snyder builds up the scenes of Bruce's past and present side by side perfectly so that by the end, when things have completely fallen apart, the very last page is the young Bruce looking up in tears and screaming "HELP!". Batman/Bruce has come full circle and his past and present have synched up in a very relevant way. It's good to see Batman fail, not just because we rarely see this, but because this is an origin story of Batman's first few months "on the job". He should fail, he's still learning how to cope with super villains and he's inexperienced. Seeing him vulnerable is completely appropriate to the story from a time before Batman learned how to perfectly be Batman and is a vital building block of the character. This is truly an origin story that enriches Batman's character enormously. * Those were the best parts of Dark City - what've you enjoyed about Zero Year so far? Let us know in the comments below!

Contributor
Contributor

I reads and watches thems picture stories. Wordy words follow. My blog is http://samquixote.blogspot.co.uk , and if you want to see all the various places I contribute to, or want to send me a message, you can find links to everything here: http://about.me/noelthorne/#