10 Brutal Times The Fantastic Four Lost

You can't win them all.

Sue Storm Killed
Marvel Comics

The Marvel universe is filled with all sorts of crazed supervillains who desire nothing less than absolute power. Mole Man wants to destroy the surface world. Galactus guzzles every planet he sees. Annihilus will not rest until he reigns supreme over the entire cosmos.

Fortunately, all of these deranged evildoers have been defeated countless times by the efforts of the Fantastic Four. For 60 years, Mister Fantastic, the Invisible Woman, the Human Torch, and The Thing have thwarted the Puppet Master, the Frightful Four, and Doctor Doom more times than they count.

However, there've been times where Marvel's First Family did not emerge victorious. Despite their sincerest efforts, Reed Richards, Sue Storm, Johnny Storm, and Ben Grimm have lost a few battles here and there. Occasionally, the heroic quartet have failed to stop their arch-enemies from killing civilians, reducing a planet to dust, or obliterating an entire universe. There have even been times where the FF were unable to stop a supervillain from killing one of their very own.

Even though the victories far outweigh the failures, it doesn't change the fact that the Fantastic Four have not always come out on top.

10. Doctor Doom Defeats Reed Richards - Fantastic Four #381 (1993)

Reed Richards
Marvel Comics

Fantastic Four #381 begins with Reed Richards heading to Latveria to rescue Ben Grimm, who has been imprisoned by Doctor Doom. At a glance, the story seems pretty standard and the reader assumes that Reed will vanquish his arch-nemesis, like he has done many times before.

Sure enough, the story concluded with Doom overestimating his ability and being thwarted by the Fantastic Four for the bajillionth time. Laying on the ground, the ironclad supervillain held out his hand, congratulating Reed on his victory. But as the leader of the Fantastic Four clasped Doom's hand, the armoured dictator activated an explosive device, preparing to sacrifice himself in order to destroy his long-time rival. Before Reed's comrades had a chance to intervene, Doom triggered the weapon, causing them both to vanish without a trace.

Even though it seemed like Reed and Doom had met their maker, the pair weren't dead. Instead, they were trapped in a realm ruled by Hyperstorm - Reed's grandson from another reality. However, Mister Fantastic's teammates didn't learn this for over two years and so, absolutely believed their oldest foe had murdered Reed.


9. Doom Turns Johnny Into A Literal Human Torch - Fantastic Four #36 (2021)

Human Torch
Marvel Comics

After Doctor Doom fell in love with his henchwoman, Victorious, he decided the two should be wed. Doom was so over-the-moon with his betrothed, he invited the Fantastic Four to his wedding, asked Reed to be his best man, and vowed to make peace with his sworn enemies.

But just as the wedding was drawing to a close, Victorious blurted out that she had slept with Johnny Storm the same day Doom proposed to her. Left utterly humiliated, Doom exacted his revenge by blasting the Human Torch with a cosmic ray booster. This device amplified Johnny's fire powers so it was impossible for him to 'flame off'. Not only that, the heat he dispersed was so overwhelming, he couldn't eat without melting his food. As a result, Reed had to inject him with nutrients using an adamantium needle on a daily basis to keep him alive. Unable to reverse what Doom had done to him, Johnny was forced to stay in an isolated chamber for weeks.

Although Reed is sure to find a way to cure Johnny's ailment in the future, all of his efforts in the recent comics have proven fruitless.


8. Doom Kills Susan Storm - Fantastic Four #562 (2009)

Sue Storm
Marvel Comics

In the future, Reed Richards discovered a way to extend Sue Storm's life, allowing her to live for centuries. But during the 26th century, the world was left uninhabitable, forcing Sue to time travel to the 21st century. Posing as the Fantastic Four's nanny, Future Sue tracked down Doctor Doom and used him as a power source so the eight billion people from her timeline could time travel to the present.

Thankfully, her plan was a complete success and her people travelled to the modern timeline just before their world was destroyed. Since eight billion is a LOT of people to accommodate, the Fantastic Four helped transport the time-displaced group to a separate world to live in peace.

Even though Doom was furious that Future Sue used him as a battery against his will, he understood that she was merely trying to save her people. Nevertheless, Doom felt like Future Sue had disgraced his honour and thus, electrocuted her until she was reduced to a charred skeleton. Even though Future Sue saved the world, she wasn't able to save herself.


7. Reed Died - Fantastic Four #254 (1981)

Reed Richards
Marvel

While exploring The Negative Zone, the Fantastic Four landed on the world of Mantracora, where they encountered a being called Taranith Gestal, who crash-landed there years ago. Because Taranith's ship is fuelled by thought-waves, he needed the mind of an exceptionally bright person to power it. Detecting Reed's genius, Taranith kidnapped him and prepared to use his brain to activate his ship.

After Reed's teammates broke out of their cells, they dashed towards Taranith's base to stop his evil scheme. Sadly, Sue, Johnny, and Ben were too late, as Taranith had already drained Mister Fantastic's brain of every thought. Devastated, Sue clung her husband's lifeless body, wailing to the heavens.

Luckily, Reed is so fricking smart, he was able to use his thoughts to override Taranith's ship and return his mind to his body. (It doesn't make a lick of sense but it's pretty standard in the world of comics.) Even though Reed was back to normal in the following issue, he was clinically dead for a while, making Taranith the first person to kill the leader of the Fantastic Four.


6. Doom Sends Franklin Richards To Hell - Fantastic Four #500 (2003)

Franklin Richards in Hell
Marvel Comics

Tired of tasting defeat by the Fantastic Four's hand, Doctor Doom vowed to destroy the quartet of heroes using a different strategy - magic. By mastering the dark arts, the masked menace summoned a horde of demons to kidnap Reed and Sue's son, Franklin Richards, and banish him to Hell.

After the Fantastic Four rescued Franklin, Reed cast Doom into the infernal dimension, hoping he would be rid of his mortal enemy forever. Just as the portal to Hell closed, Doom blasted Reed's face, leaving him horrifically scarred. Because of Reed's malleable skin, he knew that no technology or medical treatment on Earth was able to heal his wounds.

But that wasn't even the worst part. Despite the fact Franklin suffered no physical harm while in Hell, he was left traumatised by the experience. He was so rattled, he believed he was still trapped there even after being rescued. When Ben and Sue took him to a carnival to cheer him up, Franklin became hysterical, certain that demons were closing in on him. Doctor Doom may have been imprisoned in Hell but this moment is still regarded as one of his greatest triumphs over the Fantastic Four.


5. Galactus Eats Nu-World - Fantastic Four #584-586 (2011)

Galactus Marvel
Marvel Comics

When Ted Castle deduced the planet would become uninhabitable in the near future, he and a group of billionaires funded a program to build a replica of Earth that humanity could migrate to.

Years later, Castle's partner, Alyssa, tried to hire Reed Richards to work on this manmade planet, Nu-World, to prepare for the inevitable evacuation of Earth. At first, Reed dismissed Alyssa's claims, saying he would find a way to save the world. But after triple-checking her findings, he realised the planet would be dead in 30 years. Using his own scientific acumen, Reed ensured Nu-World was ready to be boarded by humanity in the next decade or two.

But only a few months after Nu-World was completed, Galactus discovered it. Worse still, the Devourer of Worlds was ravenous when he located the world and informed Reed that he was ready to consume it. Reed pleaded with Galactus, telling him that Nu-World was the only way to guarantee mankind's survival. Sadly, the purple-armoured entity was unmoved by Reed's pleas. Knowing that he couldn't stop Galactus, Reed stood helplessly by and watched the cosmic destroyer consume Nu-World's thermal energy before reducing the celestial body to ash.


4. Doom Murders Ben - Fantastic Four #508 (2004)

Ben Grimm Doctor Doom
Marvel Comics

After your arch-nemesis gets banished to Hell, you'd assume that's the last you would ever hear of them. But when it comes to Doctor Doom, Reed Richards always knew the relentless regent would find a way out.

Before Doom had a chance to escape from his fiery prison, Reed transported him to a purgatory-like dimension, where he would be trapped forever. To ensure Doom never broke free, Reed stayed in this reality to monitor him.

But when Sue Storm accessed this universe to locate her husband, she accidentally set Doom free, allowing him to transfer his mind into her body. As the Fantastic Four tried to subdue Doom, the maniacal monarch kept swapping bodies to avoid being sent back to Hell.

When he transferred his mind into Ben, the rock-skinned superhero managed to keep Doom's essence at bay long enough to tell Reed to shoot him. Fearing that Doom would use Ben's body to perform untold destruction, Reed blasted him with an energy cannon, killing him. Although Doom's essence returned to Hell, he was satisfied that he forced his greatest enemy to murder his best friend.


3. Annihilus Murdered The Human Torch - Fantastic Four #587 (2011)

Fantastic Four Human Torch
Marvel Comics

When the ruler of The Negative Zone, Annihilus, obtained the Opposing Force (the antithesis of the Power Cosmic), the diabolical overlord prepared to take over the cosmos. Using his newfound power, Annihilus formed the largest army in existence - the Annihilation Wave. Its numbers are so vast, no single world could combat the Annihilation Wave, including Earth.

After activating a portal in The Negative Zone, Annihilus prepared to send a billion of his minions through to decimate the Fantastic Four's homeworld. When Ben and Johnny learned this, they ventured to Annihilus' base to keep the aliens at bay. Sadly, the Fantastic Four quickly deduced that they were no match for The Negative Zone's army. Out of desperation, Johnny urged Ben and the others back to Earth through the portal. Realising the dimensional gate could only deactivated while in The Negative Zone, the Human Torch stayed behind to destroy it.

Even though Johnny put up an incredible fight, there was no way he could've stood a chance against a billion enemies. After fighting for a few seconds, Annihilus' men tore the superhero apart.


2. Griever Destroys Franklin's Realities - Fantastic Four #2 (2018)

The Griever
Marvel Comics

Just before Secret Wars, the multiverse collapsed, leaving a single universe left. But after Franklin Richards figured out how to control his reality-shaping powers, he and Molecule Man joined forces to reignite the multiverse. After he created hundreds of universes, each filled with trillions of worlds, Franklin's powers depleted.

Little did Franklin know that he was being observed beyond reality by The Griever - an entity that represents entropy. Because the Griever's purpose is to destroy, she sees Franklin as an abomination who must be stopped at all costs. When his power faded, the Griever could see he no longer posed a threat, allowing her to slaughter Molecule Man. Because Molecule Man is a conduit to reality, his death set off a chain reaction, ending nearly every universe that Franklin created. With this single act, the Griever murdered more beings than almost anyone in the entire Marvel universe.

Since Franklin was powerless, he needed the help of the Fantastic Four to face the Griever. Even though they defeated her, the team was unable to resurrect the countless worlds that Franklin created.


1. Reed Becomes A Supervillain - Ultimate Mystery #4 + Ultimate Doom #1-4 (2010-2011)

Reed Richards The Maker
Marvel Comics

In the Ultimate universe, Doctor Doom set off a chain of events that resulted in the deaths of millions of people worldwide. Despite the fact Sue Storm nearly died during this attack, Reed left her side to put a stop to his arch-nemesis. When he returned, Sue dumped him, acknowledging they weren't compatible for each other.

Upon reflection, Reed realised that millions of people would still be alive if he killed Doom when he had the chance years ago. This mentality caused Reed to take a more Machiavellian approach to his duties, believing that the end always justified the means. After killing innocent civilians to stop a greater calamity, Sue confronted Reed, telling him he had gone too far. When Reed beat Sue to the brink of death, she acknowledged that Reed had officially become a supervillain.

Even though Sue, Johnny, and Ben did all they could to stop him, Reed was too powerful. Being the world's smartest man, Reed had a contingency for every plan, allowing him to easily defeat his former teammates. Only after he destroyed the US government, defeated the Avengers, and annihilated dozens of universes did his ex-teammates finally put an end to Reed's reign of terror.


Watch Next


Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows