10 Characters Who Replaced Captain America

Steve Rogers hasn't been the only one to wield the shield.

Bucky Barnes as Captain America
Marvel Comics

Since 2011, Chris Evans has been bringing Captain America to the big screen. However, with the actor's contract set to expire after the next two Avengers movies, that time could soon be coming to a close and Steve Rogers' days look numbered.

Sure there's always the possibility that the character will just be recast, but what seems more likely is that Cap will go out in a blaze of glory and pass on the shield to someone else.

The question is who could his replacement be? Well, turning to the comics, there is a long precedent of people replacing Captain America.

Whether through death or by choice, there have been times when Steve Rogers has hung up his star-spangled tights and left a Captain America sized hole in the Marvel Universe. Usually though, one hero, or even several have stepped up to fill the void.

Here are ten characters who have replaced Steve Rogers while he's been otherwise indisposed. Some have crafted new identities inspired by Cap's legacy, others have stepped right into those cuffed red boots to carry on the Captain America name. Either way, they've all dedicated themselves to filling the Sentinel of Liberty's role.

For better or worse.

10. Roscoe Simons

captain america roscoe death
Marvel Comics

In 1974, Steve Rogers became completely disillusioned with his role as Captain America when he discovered that a high-ranking member of the U.S. government (implied to actually be President Richard Nixon) was the leader of the Secret Empire terrorist group. He hung up his shield and took the identity Nomad.

After Steve abandoned the Captain America identity, three ordinary men each tried to take up the mantle. The first two (Bob Russo and "Scar" Turpin) failed dismally, but the third was more successful.

Roscoe Simons was a mechanic and a lifelong fan of Cap. After proving he knew how to fight, Steve allowed Roscoe to become the new Captain America and handed over his shield. Falcon also began training him to fight crime, in a reversal of the earlier Cap/Falcon dynamic.

Unfortunately, Roscoe's career was cut short pretty quickly. When the Red Skull found out that someone else had dared to pretend to be his nemesis, he beat Roscoe to death and strung him up as a warning to any other "fake" Captain Americas.

On the plus side, this pushed Steve to stop messing around as Nomad and go back to being the real Captain America.


9. Danielle Cage

Dani Cage Captain America
Marvel Comics

Sadly, this is not about the time Captain America handed his shield over to a baby.

Danielle is the daughter of Luke Cage and Jessica Jones. In one timeline she grew up to find that she had both of her parent's powers and became a superhero. Once Steve Rogers retired, he passed the mantle of Captain America on to her.

This version of Danielle Cage first appeared as part of a group of Avengers plucked from various points in the timestream to fight against Ultron. She then appeared again as part of a group of future Avengers who travelled back in time to stop a demon that had possessed Wiccan before he became powerful enough to destroy the world.

More recently, the future version of Dani came to the present again while chasing after her nemesis the Golden Skull. Golden Skull had travelled back in time from their dystopian era to rob a wealthier time period of all its valuables. Dani was able to apprehend the Golden Skull with the help of the U.S.Avengers and returned to her time period.

The story also revealed that Danielle Cage becoming Captain America is a common occurrence across most timelines in the Marvel multiverse.


8. Spirit Of '76

Spirit of 76
Marvel Comics

Marvel actually published Captain America stories through the 1940's and into the 1950's. This created a bit of a problem when Steve Rogers later revealed he had spent those years frozen in ice.

Marvel's eventual solution was to retcon it so that the Captain America of the late 40's and early 50's was actually a series of other men pretending to be Steve Rogers. The first man to take up the mantle was William Naslund, the Spirit of '76.

Spirit was actually created as part of an unofficial crossover between Marvel and DC. Both companies introduced a WWII team called the Crusaders whose members were based on each other's superheroes. The DC Crusaders had obvious copies of the Invaders whereas the Marvel team was based on the Freedom Fighters. Spirit of '76 was based on their leader, the ultra-patriotic Uncle Sam.

When Captain America went missing, Naslund was asked by President Truman to take over the role so that the Nazis wouldn't know the original was gone. After the war, he helped found the All-Winners Squad with most of the other former members of the Invaders.

William Naslund fought as Captain America until his death in 1946. He was crushed to death by the robot Adam II while trying to warn the rest of his team about its plot to kill John F. Kennedy.


7. Patriot

Jeffrey Mace Patriot 4jpg F47958 765w
Marvel Comics

When Willaim Naslund was killed in action, fellow WWII hero Patriot stepped in to replace him as Captain America.

Jeffrey Mace was a reporter for the Daily Bugle who was inspired by Captain America to become a superhero. Like a lot of heroes at the time, his only power was being pretty good at punching, but he did OK for himself.

Patriot helped the All-Winners Squad stop the assassination of JFK and afterwards took up the shield as the third Captain America. Along with his sidekick Bucky (actually a man named Fred Davis who had taken up the role when Naslund replaced Cap), he formed a new team of superheroes called the Liberty Legion.

Mace served as Captain America for several years, even gaining a new partner along the way. When Bucky was shot during a mission, they were saved by Betsy Ross, a new superhero called Golden Girl. Bucky retired after that and Golden Girl became Captain America's new partner (mirroring the events of the original comics).

Jeffrey Mace retired as Captain America in 1949. He married Betsy and the two moved to the small town of Glendale. He reappeared in the 80's and reunited with the original Captain America, only to die from cancer soon after.


6. William Burnside

Grand Director
Marvel Comics

After Jeffrey Mace retired, the U.S. government tried to make their own Captain America. It didn't go well.

William Burnside was a historian who was absolutely obsessed with Captain America, even going so far as to legally change his name to Steve Rogers. Whilst researching Cap, he discovered Nazi files detailing the super-soldier process and took them to the FBI.

The agency then tried to remake Captain America, using Burnside as a willing subject. They altered his face and voice so that he perfectly resembled Steve Rogers but, before they could test the new super-soldier serum, the project was shut down.

Burnside stole the serum though and injected himself with it. The formula worked, replicating Captain America's abilities, but it was flawed and caused mental instability. Burnside's time as Captain America was short-lived as he soon snapped and started attacking innocents. He was arrested and placed in suspended animation.

Years later, he was recovered by the Red Skull's henchman Doctor Faustus and hypnotised into becoming the Grand Director of a neo-Nazi group. When the original Captain America confronted him, he broke down and set himself on fire.

It was later revealed that Burnside's death had actually been faked and he was handed over to doctors to try and restore his mind.


5. Punisher

Punisher Captain America
Marvel Comics

When Captain America was assassinated at the end of Civil War it shocked a lot of people. Surprisingly, one of the people most affected by it was the Punisher.

Before he started his lucrative career in domestic bad guy murder, Frank Castle served in the army. During Civil War he revealed that he had been inspired to serve by the stories of Cap's WWII adventures. Despite the two never seeing eye-to-eye, Punisher always idolised Captain America as a true hero.

In the wake of Steve's death, Punisher decided he would be the one to carry on Cap's legacy and incorporated elements of the Avenger's costume into his own.

Captain Punisher didn't exactly live up to his predecessors example though. Frank still stuck to his usual brutal methods of dispatching criminals, only now he did it with a star on his forehead. The new look only lasted a few issues before a more suitable candidate came along and reclaimed the mantle.

Punisher also became Captain America in an issue of What If? In one reality, Steve Rogers was badly injured in a fight with the Red Skull and Vietnam veteran Frank Castle was chosen to replace him. Frank took up the mantle, but secretly still operated as the Punisher. However, the original Cap was eventually able to convince him to give up his murderous ways.


4. Iron Patriot

Iron Patriot
Marvel Comics

After the Skrull invasion of Earth, things weren't looking good for Earth's Mightiest Heroes. Captain America was still dead, Iron Man was on the run and the rest of the Avengers had been forced underground. It was time for a new team to rise up.

Unfortunately, that team was led by Norman Osborn. After assassinating the Skrull Queen, the former Green Goblin had been made director of SHIELD. One of his first moves was to form a new team of Avengers.

The Dark Avengers mostly consisted of supervillains like Bullseye and Venom disguised as heroes like Hawkeye and Spider-Man. Osborn led the team himself as the Iron Patriot.

Iron Patriot was clearly meant to be a pastiche of Marvel's big two missing heroes, combining the advanced armour of Iron Man with the patriotism of Captain America. Much like Cap, Iron Patriot was designed to be a symbol of hope for America and an inspiration to its people.

Behind the scenes though, Osborn was just as corrupt as ever and used his suit and the Dark Avengers to consolidate and abuse his power.

The Iron Patriot armour was destroyed by Tony Stark during the Siege of Asgard. Underneath the suit, an unstable Norman Osborn was shown to the world, his face painted to look like the Green Goblin. This obvious sign of madness was enough to bring Osborn's whole regime crumbling down.


3. US Agent

US Agent Marvel
Marvel Comics

Despite being a symbol of the USA, Captain America has often clashed with its government. The main source of this conflict (when neither of them is being controlled by Hydra) is Steve Rogers' desire to represent all the citizens of America rather than just one political group.

During the 80's, this argument got so bad that Steve gave-up the Captain America identity... again. The government decided to find a replacement who would work directly for them and appointed the former ant-hero Super-Patriot as the new Captain America.

John Walker was everything the government could have asked for, a patriotic yes-man who would follow orders without question. He was also a reactionary xenophobic meathead who beat one of his enemies to death and left another two (who were also his former partners) to die in a fire, but sometimes you've got to take the rough with the smooth.

Walker's time as Captain America pushed him closer and closer towards a breakdown as the stress began to get to him. He also gained a new found respect for Steve Rogers though and, after teaming up with him to stop the Red Skull, handed the mantle back to him.

John then took up the name US Agent and joined the Avengers for a while until they kicked him off for being too much of a jerk.


2. Bucky Barnes

Bucky Barnes The Winter Soldier 1
Marvel Comics

After Bucky Barnes was freed from his programming as a Russian assassin, he felt that he needed to redeem himself. Captain America's death gave him the chance he needed.

Cap's wartime sidekick was initially thought to have died in the same explosion that caused Steve to be frozen, but he had in fact been captured by the Russians and brainwashed into becoming their assassin the Winter Soldier. Captain America was able to save his friend and restore his mind, but was then killed at the end of Civil War.

Soon after Cap's death, Bucky was approached by Tony Stark. Tony revealed that Steve had written him a letter before his death asking Stark to pass on his shield to Bucky.

Barnes accepted it and became the new Captain America. He proved to be a worthy successor to the original's legacy, saving the world on numerous occasions and even joining the Avengers. When Steve returned, he briefly became Captain America again during the Siege of Asgard, but then handed the mantle back to Barnes.

Unfortunately, Bucky's time as Captain America ended shortly after that. Details of his past as an assassin were leaked and he stepped down to avoid tainting the mantle. He then faked his death and became the Winter Soldier again.


1. Sam Wilson

Falcon Captain America Sam Wilson
Marvel Comics

The most recent Captain America, Sam Wilson fought crime for years as Cap's partner Falcon. When the super-soldier serum in his blood ran out, leaving Steve an old man, he asked his longtime friend to take over the mantle.

Sam has proved himself to be a capable hero in his new role, even leading the Avengers. However, his time as Captain America has been marked with controversy, both in and out of story.

Whereas Steve Rogers was always careful to remain politically neutral, Sam Wilson hasn't been afraid to speak up on issues like immigration and share his strongly liberal views. This has garnered a lot of criticism from those who either don't share those views, or who believe that Captain America should remain neutral.

This stance has also distanced him from Steve, especially since his youth was restored by the sentient cosmic cube Kobik. Sam is also currently unaware that Steve had his past rewritten by Kobik to turn him into a sleeper agent for Hydra. This seems to be about to change though with the upcoming even Secret Empire, which will pit the two Captain Americas against each other.

If Chris Evans does retire from playing Captain America, it seems a good bet that either Sam or Bucky will be the one to replace him.


Contributor

I was just a mild-mannered NCTJ accredited journalist until one day I found out the truth... that I could share my nerdy ramblings with people on the internet! It's just like mumbling to myself on the train, but without all the strange looks.