10 Crazy Facts You Just Have To Accept To Enjoy Sin City

Wait, why are there dinosaurs there?

This past week saw the release of A Dame To Kill For, the second Sin City film, and by all accounts it was...weird. Which is befitting of its source material, a series of comic books that saw veteran writer and artist Frank Miller throw hardboiled detective stories, noir films and pulp fiction (not Pulp Fiction, crucially) in a blender along with his bombastic superhero work. At the other end spat out a highly stylised, ultra violent and sexually explicit throwback to "the good old days" of genre stories; Sin City was a playground for Miller to indulge in his love of gritty crime mysteries, with crooked cops, femme fatales and all. Also there are dinosaurs sometimes, because of course there is. Over the years Miller has weaved together a whole weird world of his own, the fictional Basin City having its own distinct geography, demographics and criminal underworld (it's the criminal underworld that gets the most airing). Despite being rendered in stark black and white the setting is populated by colourful characters befitting his influence, from cops framed for crimes they didn't commit to samurai sex workers to a yellow bastard. Literally yellow. He has a problem with his liver, or something. That's just one of the many strange aspects to Sin City you go with in order to enjoy the macabre, bonkers, bloody world Frank Miller has put together. And there are many more! Nine, in fact! Here are ten crazy facts you just have to accept to enjoy Sin City.

10. The Projects

We're not sure if you knew this, but Basin City is not a fun place. That's probably why they shorten the name, now we think about it. What's really mind-blowing, though, is that the fictional noir location has a "wrong side of the tracks". Isn't the whole thing the "wrong side of the tracks?" Apparently not, since there's an area of Sin City where not even those burly men in their trenchcoats, who are fine wandering the crime-strewn alleyways that cover the rest of the place, dare to tread. They are The Projects, and somehow they are worse than every other part of Sin City put together. It's also the place where Marv was born, and refuses to ever return to, to give you more of an idea of its awfulness. A maze of rundown, high-rise apartments that were built during a brief affluent period for the city, unfortunately The Projects never became the upper class dream world they were designed to be. Instead they were never finished, owing to labour disputes (what a magical fantasy world this is), and so they became overrun by the crazy down and outs. Like, the ones who are more crazy and down and out than our heroes. Crime runs rampant and the police have no pull, effectively making The Projects their own sovereign state with no contact to the legal system of the wider world. Again, we're not sure how this makes it any different than the rest of Sin City but shhh, just go with it.

9. The Deal With The Tar Pits

The Projects is supposed to be a distinct part of Basin City that is all but indistinguishable from the rest of it. The Santa Yolanda Tar Pits, meanwhile, totally stick out like a sore thumb and yet we're expected to just accept them. Frank Miller is a weird dude. The location has made brief appearances in the yarns Wrong Turn and The Big Fat Kill, and Miller himself has admitted that the main reason for their creation was because he wanted to draw some dinosaurs. To be fair, this is probably the least ridiculous way of getting a T-Rex into the story, but it still doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Especially when you consider the in-universe explanation for why the Tar Pits are in Sin City in the first place. Obviously an analogue of the real-life La Brea Tar Pits in LA, which actually concealed mammoth and other prehistoric skeletons beneath its sticky black surface, the Santa Yolanda Tar Pits were constructed - concrete dinos and all - to capitalise on the success of a "big-budget dinosaur movie". Then an old lady fell in and died, so they closed it down, and now it's mainly used as a place to dump dead bodies. Lots of dead bodies in Sin City. What's probably the craziest things about the tar pits is that, presumably, the "big-budget dinosaur movie" that hit during the early nineties is a thinly-veiled reference to Jurassic Park, which means Jurassic Park exists in the Sin City universe. As does Steven Spielberg. And Jeff Goldblum. And that music. And...

8. Best Hospitals In The State

We say there are a lot of dead bodies in Sin City, but there are just as many bodies that should be dead and yet somehow...aren't. Marv and John Hartigan show the scars of their should've-been-lethal injuries (or at least the latter did, woops, spoilers), but just think about the sheer number of characters throughout the series - and the films, actually - who have cheated death multiple times. Hartigan and Junior end up in hospital during That Yellow Bastard (the latter of whom has lost an ear, hand, and tackle), the teenage son of Commissioner Leibowitz recovers from a broken arm there pretty sharpish, struggling actress Esther survives multiple suicide attempts and an attempted murder, Becky winds up in hospital for a spell. It's a busy place. They've also presumably got some of the best doctors in the country, since they manage to save the lives of everybody who comes through their doors - ie the ones who don't just get dumped in the tar pits. There's no way Marv should be able to still walk around and be such a formidable presence (he probably shouldn't even be able to walk at all), and it seems a bit odd that in a city where every other emergency service is wholly corrupt, the medical types manage to do their jobs properly and piece everyone back together. Also: we guess all of these rough-and-tumble vigilante thug types have some decent health insurance? We guess so. No other explanation. Just accept it.

7. Age Is Just A Number

So Frank Miller isn't exactly well known for his progressive or non-gross view of gender roles and relationships, but he does reach new lows in Sin City. That Yellow Bastard, to be fair, begins with a pretty strident and "duh" viewpoint, as police Detective John Hartigan pursues his last case before retirement. Roark Junior, son of one of the most powerful and corrupt officials in Basin City, has a penchant for underage girls. Like, way underage girls. And it's horrific and monstrous, which is why Hartigan takes on the case, his specific mission being to rescue 11-year-old Nancy Callahan from the pederast. Then his corrupt partner messes it all up by covering for Senator Roark and framing Hartigan for kidnapping and raping the kid. So Hartigan stews in chokey for a decade or so, during which times he receives no visitors (his wife divorces him and remarries whilst he's still imprisoned), save for Nancy, who sneaks out against her parents' wishes. Eventually he gets let out, and obviously hot tails it to see how Nancy's doing. And hey, she's all grown up! And now she's a stripper! And she says she loves him! And he loves her too! Let's ignore the age difference, the deeply disturbing history between the pair and the fact that he's the most hated person in Sin City - no easy feat - and instead celebrate this star-crossed love story for the ages. Seriously, don't think about it too hard. You'll just get creeped out.

6. Super Militarised Police Are The Norm

Corruption is something that real life police forces have to deal with. Just look at, well, the news. Even worse than that, however, is a corrupt police force that has more in common with a military division than law enforcement. Just look at, well, the news. Or at the Basin City Police Department, every single member of which seems to have more in common with a SWAT team than a regular beat cop. Just a regular policeman walking down the street is clad in body armour, riot gear, a big old helmet, and one of those fun night stick things. All the better for beating people with! Mainly prostitutes. This is a Frank Miller joint, after all. They have access to a lovely bunch of even more powerful weapons than that, too, frequently seen wielding guns as big as their heads. Obviously they do have problems with crime in Sin City. They may stay out of The Projects but they have their hands full with all the scum and villainy the litters the rest of their jurisdiction; plus the majority of them are in the pocket of the local crime syndicates, so they have to do all their dirty business too. Like getting involved with gang wars, and taking down hulking, seemingly indestructible thugs like Marv. Still, that's just a heightened version of some of the more crime-ridden areas of the real world, and the police in those places aren't military-level. Still, looks cooler than a guy in a boring, normal uniform trying to slap the cuffs on Gail or Miho, right?

5. People Actually Wanna Sleep With Marv

Marv is not a good looking guy. It's probably why they got Mickey Rourke - former pretty boy actor who mucked up his looks with a botched boxing career and ensuing bad plastic surgery - to play him in the films, poor bloke. He certainly sticks out, even amongst the other uggos of Sin City, his "unique" look cropping up in the stories A Dame to Kill For, Just Another Saturday Night, and Silent Night. He never gets better looking through any of them, FYI. The story that introduced Marv - and Sin City as a whole - the world, however, was the one where you have to suspend your disbelief the most. Because The Hard Goodbye starts with Marv getting laid. That's not the entire plot of the story, although we can see how it could be. Marv is not a looker. Did we already mention that? He's a big, hulking mess of a man, with a face not even his mother could love. It's not a face a sculptor would love, either, with the sharp contours and right angles of Brutalist architecture. He's usually covered in cuts and bruises, too, owing to his thuggish, vagrant lifestyle. He's also pretty thick and easily confused, so it's not one of those "like him for his personality" deals. And yet, prostitute Goldie sleeps with Marv - for free! - only to be murdered straight after, leading to the big lug trying to find the person responsible. Yes, she chose to sleep with him. Each to their own?

4. Everyone And Everything Is Corrupt

Seriously, we know we said that in some way Sin City is more of a "heightened" version of reality, we may have been underestimating things. Just a tad. Because whilst police and political corruption is certainly a real and terrifying issue across the globe, there's (thankfully) nowhere in the continental United States that has ever gotten quite as bad as Basin City. They've certainly tried, yeah, but they've never scaled the heights of universal crookedness that exists there. We're not sure how people get by with the amount of corruption awaiting them behind every corner, with the majority of the police force in the pockets of some criminal syndicate, and those same criminal syndicates figuratively and literally running things. By which we mean, the politicians that actually run Sin City are all criminals, and the people running things from behind the scenes are criminals paying these criminals off. And none of the criminals ever get brought down by the cops, because the cops are all criminals too. It's a city where literally every citizen is a criminal, so far as we can tell. We never see any innocent bystanders. The lady who fell in the tar pits was probably involved in movie piracy at the very least. And yet somehow everything runs reasonably smoothly, the city isn't in a total state of disrepair, and life continues relatively unabashed. How does it work? We don't know. it just does. Somehow.

3. Why The Women Are There

When it comes to women, erm, Frank Miller is pretty terrible. Mostly every depiction of a female character in one of his comics involves them being in a state of undress, uncontrollably sexually promiscuous, and mostly one dimensional. This is probably owing to, as he identified in a recent interview, his desire to see a return of the "1940s-style gentleman", whom he believes had a "biological function" to protect women. Because they're all larger than women, apparently. Which certainly makes sense when you consider the other big influence on Sin City, besides hardboiled detective stories, is medieval tales of gallant and chivalrous knights saving fair maidens. Considering this is Sin City, however, all the damsels in distress can't be fair maidens - far from it. So what are they instead? Oh yeah, prostitutes. We probably spoilt that surprise by mentioning it in the list of Miller's favoured occupations for female characters. Remember when he made Catwoman one in Batman: Year One? Tsk. Could've been worse, however. Selina could have been in Basin rather than Gotham, a city where literally every woman is descended from the ladies of the night that were shipped in to entertain miners during the California Gold Rush. Women were only introduced to Sin City so they could have sex with dudes. Which is why most of the women who turn up in the comics are prostitutes. Gun-toting, badass prostitutes, true. But prostitutes nonetheless. We guess that's just how things work there.

2. Noir Is Real

Film noir is a genre that has produced some of the most infamous lines of dialogue in cinema history, some of the smokiest screen sirens (Humphrey Bogart included), and any number of evocative images harnessing the lightning techniques of German expressionism to create a foreboding, otherworldly setting. They're not supposed to be realistic. Far from it. You think that Raymond Chandler or Dashiell Hammett, the authors who wrote most of the movies' source material, had actual experience as private eyes? No! They probably never even met a gangster moll! It's all make believe innit. All larger-than-life, fictional material that are meant to exist in their own little pocket universe, where everybody wears trenchcoats and fedoras don't have an unfortunate political association. Sin City is based on the premise that that is how the world works. That is the same world than Basin City exists in, a world where all the men are either downtrodden detectives or righteous vigilantes (with trenchcoats) or else big-time gangsters. And mostly all the women are femme fatale sex objects, prostitutes, or - surprise! - the bad guys. It takes it as read that such a universe exists, and that all the tropes and cliches therein aren't hacky but just the way things are. And the sooner you deal with that the sooner you can get on with all the fun business of Marv hitting things, Hartigan crying and Miho slicing fools up. Oh and it's got even more ridiculous lighting than a film noir, even, so we suppose you also need to accept that it's perpetually nighttime in Basin City and most of the streetlights are always set to "atmospheric".

1. Basin City Could Exist

There's a lot to take on board when you start reading Sin City. There's the shaggability of its protagonists, the professions of all the women, the uniformly corrupt...everyone, the dinosaurs, the unhealthy relationships. We can just about take all of those in our stride so we can get on with reading the silly, over-the-top stories. The most unbelievable part of all of it, though, might be the setting. Not all the film noir stuff we were just waffling on about, or the people who live there, or anything like that. We mean the actual city itself. How the heck does Basin City exist? How has it not collapsed into a wasteland, a ghost town? Everyone is corrupt, and wrapped up in their own business. Shouldn't the streets be strewn with rubbish from the lack of garbage men? Who works in the supermarkets? Does anybody eat? Then there's the actual geography of the place. Sin City is apparently located in the American west, as the arid desert surroundings, mountain ranges, lizards and palm trees will attest to. But then there's a whole section of woodland on one side, and a major river runs through the city, coming out to a grand waterfront on the other end. There's also the propensity for heavy, hardboiled downfalls of rain through which anti-heroes can walk and look tragic and awesome. Or sometimes snow, if Frank Miller's feeling festive. So it has the climates of about five different parts of the United States, is a mish-mash of a half-dozen different cities, and exists outside of any other, real place. But people make references to existing pop culture, the tar pits were inspired by Jurassic Park, and we never see anyone wearing sunglasses or even t-shirts. It's a surreal, bizarre environment that couldn't possibly exist, and yet it does. And it's full of murderous psychopaths who somehow manage an existence in between all the killing. And they've somebody not killed every single member of the population yet. We don't know. It's just Sin City. It's crazy, but we accept it for what it is.

In this post: 
Sin-City
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/