10 Devastating Comic Book Deaths That Came Out Of Nowhere

Didn't see that coming...

Spider-Man Death
Marvel Comics

Because Batman, Wonder Woman, the Avengers, and Howard the Duck have been saving the day for as long as we can remember, it's easy to assume these superheroes will be here forever. Although Superman and Bucky Barnes have met their end (on more than one occasion), long-time comic fans are aware these iconic characters would return.

Nevertheless, it's always tragic to see a superhero kicking the bucket. I mean, we knew Captain Marvel was going to die in The Death of Captain Marvel, but that didn't stop readers from crying their eyes out.

However, it's more crushing to watch these spandex-sporting supes bite the dust, when you don't sees it coming. Despite the fact readers expect a major player to meet their demise during a comic event, witnessing a beloved character shuffle off their mortal coil is never easy. Even though Captain America, Jason Todd, and Jean Grey were resurrected, it didn't lessen the impact when they popped their clogs.

Although it was horrifying to see these characters die, the way it caught us off all by surprise made it so much more devastating.

10. Stephanie Brown - Batman #633 (2004)

Stephanie Brown Spoiler Robin
DC Comics

After Tim Drake hung up the Robin tights, his partner, Stephanie Brown, became Batman's new protégé. Even though it was nice to see a female Robin for once, Stephanie's tenure as the Girl Wonder didn't last long. After she used lethal force on a criminal, Bats fired her on the spot.

To prove her worth to Batman, Stephanie orchestrated a turf war between Gotham's gangs, hoping she would save the day before it got out of hand. Sadly, the situation spiralled out of control, leading to many deaths in the city.

After Black Mask seized control over Gotham, he had Stephanie kidnapped. Despite being horrifically tortured, Brown escaped and reached the clinic of Bruce Wayne's doctor, Leslie Thompkins. Sadly, Stephanie died shortly after being admitted.

To add to the tragedy, Batman discovered Leslie could've saved Stephanie but chose not to, because she wanted to prove that the Caped Crusader's methods to stop violence were making things worse.

At first, it was awful when readers were under the impression this teenage girl was murdered by a deranged supervillain. However, it was more heartbreaking when we learned Stephanie's death was caused by one of Bruce's most trusted friends, just to make a point.


9. Logan's Family - Wolverine Vol. 3 #72 (2009)

Old Man Logan
Marvel Comics

Old Man Logan takes place in a post-apocalyptic future, with our titular hero and his family trying their best to get by. Living under the brutal rule of his landlords, The Hulk Gang, Logan puts up with vicious beatings any time he's late with his rent. When the Hulks tell Logan they'll kill his family if he doesn't pay next month's rent, the old Canucklehead accepts a dangerous (but highly lucrative) job from Hawkeye.

After Logan completes the mission and receives his reward, he realises he's nearly 3,000 miles from home. Desperate to get back to his family before his deadline, he steals an Iron Man Armour, and flies from Washington, DC to Sacramento. The armour runs out of fuel before Logan reaches his destination, forcing him to drudge through the boiling desert for 36 hours straight.

When the former X-Man reaches his house, his neighbour Donovan alerts him the Hulks already killed his family. When Wolverine points out he got back in time, Donovan said the Hulks didn't care since "they got bored". Although it was awful to learn Logan's family was murdered, the fact that their demise was so utterly meaningless made it much more heartwrenching.


8. Martian Manhunter - Final Crisis: Requiem (2008)

Death Of Martian Manhunter
DC Comics

Because Final Crisis was the last part of the Crisis trilogy, it was no surprise the series kicked off with one of DC's biggest players dying.

In the opening issue, Libra confronts the Secret Society, preparing a plan to take over the world. To showcase his might, Libra brings in founding Justice League member J'onn J'onzz, who he captured earlier. Before J'onn had a chance to comprehend his surroundings, Libra incinerates him.

J'onn does everything in his power to fight back but quickly realises this is a fight he can't win. Accepting his fate, the Martian Manhunter uses his telepathic powers to broadcast a message to his teammates and friends, bidding them farewell. By the time Green Lantern, Superman, and the rest of the Justice League understood what just happened, J'onn is no more.

Even though Batman "died" in the same storyline, J'onzz's demise was a lot more impactful. Because J'onn was the heart of the Justice League, we knew the team wouldn't be the same without him. When you watch such a kind-hearted soul suffer in his final moments, it's hard not to get choked up.


7. Spider-Man - Ultimate Spider-Man #160 (2011)

Ultimate Spider-Man Death
Marvel Comics / Mark Bagley / Justin Ponsor

The modern reboot of Marvel, Ultimate Marvel, may have had its fair share of problems, but Ultimate Spider-Man's run was incredibly consistent from beginning to end.

Sadly, this made the series more tragic when we saw the Wall-crawler bow out. In the final story arc, Spidey learns the Green Goblin has broken out of prison and is leading the Sinister Six directly to Aunt May's house. As Peter Parker makes his way home, he's accidentally shot by the Punisher, leaving him badly injured.

While facing the Six, Spider-Man could barely stay conscious, forcing May and Mary Jane Watson to step in and help. Although they managed to defeat most of the supervillains, the Green Goblin was left standing, easily deflecting all of his arch-nemesis' attacks.

Knowing he couldn't beat the Goblin with his fists, Spidey crushed him to death with a truck. However, the impact caused the vehicle to explode, leaving Spider-Man gravely wounded. As MJ and May cradled Peter's body, he told him that he could finally forgive himself for failing to save Uncle Ben. Smiling one last time, Peter closes his eyes and died.


6. The Question - 52 #38 (2007)

The Question Vic Sage
DC Comics

During the 52 storyline, Batman decided he needed to retrain, compelling him to go on hiatus for a year. Knowing Gotham would need to be protected, Charles Victor Sage, aka The Question, headed to the city to assist the police force. Teaming up with Detective Renee Montoya, the pair travelled across the world after they stumbled upon a global conspiracy.

During their mission, Vic and Renee couldn't stop getting on each other's nerves. Every time Renee lit a cigarette, Vic got agitated, barraging her with smoking statistics, and detailing the poisonous chemicals that reside in tobacco.

Several months later, Renee discovered why Vic was giving her a hard time - he had lung cancer, and her smoking was exasperating his condition.

Because this is a comic book, most readers believed Sage would pull through, even though his illness was terminal. And when Montoya brought Vic to the healing city of Nanda Parbat, we safely assumed The Question would make a complete recovery.

Unfortunately, Vic passed away moments before reaching the one place where he could be cured. Although casual readers probably never heard of The Question until they read 52, his death hit hard for everybody.


5. The Sentry - Siege #4 (2010)

Sentry Siege
Marvel Comics

With the power of a million exploding suns flowing through his body, Robert Reynolds, aka The Sentry, has enough power to give Thanos a run for his money.

However, Reynolds doesn't get involved with superheroics as much as he'd like, due to his mental instability. Years ago, Robert developed a split-personality, which created a malevolent alter called The Void. Even though Reynolds buried The Void in his subconscious, it left him constantly on edge, which is why the Avengers rarely call for his aid.

But when Norman Osborn took over the Avengers, he summoned the Sentry for every mission, oblivious how his work was affecting his mind. After Osborn made Sentry destroy Asgard, his mind snapped, causing The Void to awaken.

Iron Man rammed a helicarrier into The Void, allowing Reynolds to regain control over his mind momentarily. Knowing his malevolent personality would return any second, Robert begged his friends to kill him. Left with no choice, Thor slaughtered Reynolds, before casting his remains into the Sun.

Because Robert Reynolds was a mentally ill victim, many readers assumed this story would conclude with the Avengers ensuring he sought psychological help. To watch Thor, of all people, obliterate Sentry to dust was an absolute shocker.


4. The Hulk - Civil War II #3 (2016)

Hulk Death
Marvel Comics

When the Avengers discovered an Inhuman called Ulysses could predict the future, they believed his powers could benefit all of mankind. This theory was fortified when Ulysses' visions warned the Avengers the world was about to be invaded by Thanos, giving the superheroes time to ready for the attack.

So, when Ulysses had a premonition that the Incredible Hulk would go on a murder streak, the Avengers found themselves between a rock and a hard place. Iron Man, Captain America, Spider-Man, and the other superheroes tracked down Bruce Banner to warn him of the dilemma.

Knowing that telling Bruce about Ulysses' premonition could cause him to Hulk out, S.H.I.E.L.D. director, Maria Hill, asked him to give himself up before the situation got out of control. Not wanting to take any chances, Hawkeye put an arrow between Bruce's eyes, killing him.

As sudden as his death was, it was more shocking to learn Bruce himself ordered Hawkeye to put him out of his misery if he suspected the Hulk was about to lose control. Even though Hawkeye was merely carrying out Banner's wishes, it didn't make this moment any easier to swallow.


3. Alfred - Batman #77 (2019)

Bane Alfred
DC Comics

After Bane got his hands on a nuclear bomb - which is pretty easy to do in the land of comics - he quickly took control of Gotham. To ensure Batman didn't stand in his way, the musclebound luchadore kidnapped Alfred Pennyworth and vowed to kill him if The Bat Family set foot in his city.

Refusing to back down, Bruce's son Damian entered Gotham, preparing to rescue his father's trusted butler. After being attacked by a parallel version of Bruce Wayne's father (long story), Damian was knocked out.

When the young Wayne awoke, he was surprised to see Bane in front of him, standing behind Alfred. Before Damian had a chance to react, the powerhouse grabbed Alfred's neck, snapping it like a twig.

Alfred's death was so unexpected, comic fans refused to believe it. That's not an exaggeration. Because Batman's trusted valet has been a part of comics since the 1940s, many readers were adamant he would never be killed off, especially in such an unceremonious way.

Only after we saw Batman holding his dear friend's corpse several issues later did readers finally accept Alfred Pennyworth was no more.


2. Rick Grimes - The Walking Dead #191-192 (2019)

Rick Grimes
Image Comics

The Walking Dead never had any qualms with killing off beloved characters. Having said that, readers were hoping protagonist Rick Grimes would make it to the end of the story. Because he tried more than anyone to find peace in a zombie-infested world, despite losing his hand, wife, and unborn child, no one deserved a happy ending more than Rick.

So, when he reached a zombie-free community called the Commonwealth, it felt like Rick could finally hang up his boots.

But when Rick saw the corruption of the Commonwealth leader, Pamela Milton, he couldn't help sticking his nose in. After he ended Pamela's tyrannical reign, Grimes retired to his quarters.

During the night, Pamela's son Sebastian broke into Rick's room, telling him he destroyed his mother's reputation. Although Grimes tries to calm him down, Sebastian shot him before storming off.

Even though it looked like Rick was done for, most readers hoped the deputy sheriff would pull through. I mean, Rick Grimes cheated death over a dozen times. Surely he could shrug off a bullet to the chest, right?

But that wasn't the case. When his son, Carl, opened Rick's bedroom door the following morning, he saw his father had become a zombie. Out of instinct, Carl shot him dead.

What makes Rick's death so palpable is how ironic it is. Even though he fought a million zombies, he was killed by a random man he barely knew. He died in the Commonwealth, which was the safest place in the world. Worst of all, Rick passed away immediately after the zombies no longer posed a threat.


1. Rorschach - Watchmen #12 (1987)

Watchmen Rorschach Death
DC Comics

After reading the first few pages of Watchmen, it was obvious Alan Moore's magnum opus was going against the grain. Although there had been many flawed vigilantes and adult-oriented graphic novels in the past, comics fans had never seen anything like this before or since.

As unconventional as this 12-part mini-series is, readers expected Watchmen to have a traditional superhero ending. When we see the Crimebusters march towards Adrian Veidt's lair in the second-last issue, we assumed they would defeat the nefarious supervillain, narrowly averting a global catastrophe.

Instead, Veidt alerts Rorschach and Nite Owl he has already unleashed his doomsday weapon, killing millions of people.

As shocking as this revelation is, it gets worse. Because Veidt's attack was believed to be an alien invasion, every war on Earth ends so humanity can unite against a common foe. Despite the fact Veidt's actions were deplorable, the heroes let him get away scot-free, since his masterplan brought about world peace.

Uncompromising to the end, Rorschach walks away, preparing to publicly expose Veidt. Knowing that every war would reignite if mankind learned the truth, Dr. Manhattan stops Rorschach in his tracks.

Although he knows Manhattan is too powerful to fight, Rorschach refuses to back down. Knowing his fate is sealed, Rorschach pulls off his mask, ordering his teammate to "Do it". Manhattan reluctantly agrees, obliterating Rorschach.


In this post: 
Spider-Man
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows