10 Dumbest Batman Moments You Won't Believe
Silly, dumb, and straight up stupid.
There's something a little silly baked into the genre of superheroes. All that pathos wrapped in brightly colored skintight suits. But Batman has always had an edge on the other guys. When the billionaire playboy dons his cowl and takes to the shadows of Gotham fighting crime, he's calm, collected, and definitely cool.
Which is maybe why there's something extra delightful about when Batman goes dumb. All of a sudden, the little details that work in a strong story start fitting together to form some uncomfortable questions. Is it really a good idea for a grown man to take in a twelve-year old child just to train him up on the violent streets to battle baddies? Or, why would a wealthy billionaire think the best way to solve corruption is not through even more strategic uses of his lavish funds, but with his fists? And, how exactly have so few people figured out his identity?
The best thing about the Dark Knight's stupid stories is that even at his worst he's still the goddamn Batman... and that's good enough for me.
10. Bat-Baby Begins - Batman #147
The original Batman comic series is known for having some very silly issues, but one that is particularly well remembered for its ridiculous plot is the third story of issue #147, where "Batman Becomes Bat-Baby." Despite what the name would imply, Batman is not actually transformed into a baby, instead he is struck by a ray that "reverses his growth." Giving him the appearance of a child.
Batman stubbornly decides that if he looks like a kid, he may as well lean into it, and dress like one too! That will show the villains what's what. On the plus side Batman has retained his adult intelligence and strength which helps him fight crime as Bat-Baby. What follows are some ridiculously scenes, like Batman: fighting crime on a rocking horse, convincing Kathy Kane that Bruce Wayne is a cheating bastard, and creepily hanging out at a park with other actual children.
The story ends with a cured Batman staring sadly at his old Bat-Baby costume on display, saying, "Just a reminder-- of a brief childhood." As if Bat-Baby were the only true childhood of the traumatized Dark Knight.
9. A Child Named In Honor Of Batman - Batman #108
"Batman Jones" starts with a fairly interesting idea. In a world where Batman is the city's hero, and has saved countless lives, surely there would be children named in his honor. Which is how we are introduced to Batman Jones, a baby saved by Batman who grows up to be obsessed with his namesake. He wears a Batman costume and wants to fight crime alongside the Dark Knight, insisting that he has been "training."
Strangely, Batman agrees to let the child come along, all the time complaining that Batman Jones is too young to fight crime. Considering that Robin is also there, it brings up some uncomfortable question.
Dick Grayson was somewhere between 10-12 when he started fighting alongside the mid-twenties Batman. How old is old-enough for a child to be fighting violent full-grown men?
Batman and Robin try to scare Batman Jones off the superhero life. Probably because his backstory makes him undeserving of such honors. Turns out that the kid is a natural talent and he outwits the dynamic duo. Thankfully, they needn’t have been worried. Batman Jones finds the whole fighting crime thing a bit of a bore, and picks up a new hobby: stamp collecting.
8. The Most Obnoxious Batman Fan - Detective Comics #267
The publishing of the Seduction of the Innocent (1954) had a startling effect on Batman comics. Author and psychiatrist Fredric Wertham's suggestion that Batman and Robin were gay led to an overhaul of the Batman universe: including the introduction of female love interests, the books distancing themselves from heavier crime themes, and a focus on even more comedic elements in the comics. Which likely paved the way for the creation of Bat-Mite in issue #267 of Detective Comics.
Bat-Mite is an obsessed, magical, Batman fan from a different dimension. It is absolutely as dumb as you would imagine. The new character's entire shtick is that he causes trouble for Batman and Robin: like prolonging a fight because he's having so much fun watching the two do battle.
In 1950's style, Batman suggests that he ought to "spank" the full-grown magical man for being such a jerk.
This ridiculous comic launched what would be five years of Bat-Mite team-ups in Detective Comics, Batman, and World's Finest Comics.
7. Zebra Batman And Magnets - Detective Comics #275
Batman has worn some strange versions of his costume before, but the fact that Zebra Batman has spawned a Lego Minifigure, a Mattel figurine, and three different Funko figurines shows the staying power of some silly stories. In Detective Comics #275 Batman is transformed into Zebra Batman.
While Batman's costume is indeed inspired by actual bats, his nemesis Zebra Man looks like a zebra because of "force lines" which can propel objects away from the villain.
When Batman is infused with lines of force also, things get super silly. A tree is launched from the ground because it is too near Batman's uncontrollable force; when Robin brings over a plate of food, it is flung away from a sad Batman who can't even eat. It is Batman's advanced knowledge of how magnets work that allow him to foil Zebra Man and go back to his normal crime fighting self.
6. Batman Outed As Bruce Wayne - Batman #20
A particularly dumb comic that only makes sense if Batman lives in a world where everyone already knows he's Bruce Wayne and just politely pretend they don't.
Clayface has the ability to use a person's DNA to take on their form. In front of Commissioner Gordon and a whole host of officers Batman is outed as Bruce Wayne. After trapping Clayface, Batman unconvincingly tries to play it off as a smart ploy on his part. Batman shows that he is wearing a freaky fake skin mask with Bruce Wayne's DNA, so that's why Clayface thought he was the wealthy playboy.
Clayface is not put off from the truth and goads Batman by saying that Bruce Wayne is a terrible father while taking the form of his currently dead son. Naturally, Batman flips his sh*t in a way that makes it clear this is all very personal to him. Almost like he's not just angry on behalf of his friend, but that (and hear me out here) he's actually Bruce Wayne.
Then we have a beautiful panel of all the officers looking awkward as they act like nothing is amiss.
5. Killer Whale Yacht Robber - Batman #579
Issue 579 focuses on a villain that is obscure and dumb enough to have joined the ranks of other silly villains like Condiment king and Killer Moth in the Lego Batman Movie. After an orca shaped villain called Orca starts pirate-style robbing the wealthy during yacht parties, Batman decides to research at the Gotham aquarium.
It turns out that Dr. Grace Balin, who assists Batman in his killer whale-based inquiries, is also secretly Orca. Despite not having anyone to verify her alibi Batman doesn't think she could be the one committing the crimes (not because she in no way resembles a killer whale but because she uses a wheel chair).
This issue is pretty boilerplate stupid, the thing that pushes it over the edge is the artwork. The otherwise only vaguely-humanoid killer-whale-shaped villain has tatas larger than Batman's head. They are so massive and strategically on display in every panel that it adds an extra dose of dumb to Orca's battle with Batman.
4. The Devil's Music - Batman: Fortunate Son
What would Batman be like if instead of just fighting crime he was the voice of all angry parents who hate the devil's music: rock and roll? Look no further than the stupid plot of Batman: Fortunate Son.
Taking his role as Bat-dad very seriously, Batman is concerned about Robin's interest in Rock and Roll. As he puts it: "Insanity reverberates in every chord of this music you love."
Why does the Dark Knight have such a personal grudge against an entire sweeping genre of music? Right before Batman's parents were killed, Bruce Wayne's dad apparently gave him a talk about how they don't listen to "that sort of music" in their home.
And don't get the Dark Knight started on PUNK. Or maybe do, then you can hear his beautiful rants about how Robin's musical infatuations are clouding his judgement when it comes to matters of crime fighting. That's the good stuff.
3. Bladder Spasm - Batman: The Widening Gyre #6
The final issue of The Widening Gyre miniseries is a special kind of dumb.
Batman proposes to his current beau St. Cloud. When they tell the news to Alfred (Batman's stand in father figure who raised him) she keeps it classy by giving way too many details about the first time they banged. Because Alfred surely wants to know how many times Batman's new fiancée orgasmed (eleven times, for the record).
When St. Cloud says the reason she is marrying Batman is because of the great sex, you might think she's joking. But the comic immediately shows what a horrible personality Batman has. In a fit of paranoia, he becomes convinced his fiancée is a robot. Instead of just finding a stray hair to test if she's human, he nearly causes a car collision and drags her out of the back seat by her hair, then dramatically tears out a fistful of it.
Later we get the scene that this comic is best remembered for: Batman tells a story to Baphomet about his first year as Batman. During his "first big pyro-gag" the explosion caused him to have a "bladder spasm." We then get two more panels of piss jokes to really rub in the fact that the Dark Knight wet himself, and not just during any old event either, but actually during the most famous sequence in Batman Year One.
2. Shape-Shifting Fake Joker - Batman: The Dark Knight Strikes Again
The first thing you might notice about this comic is how grunge the artwork is. It's all about the feeling the artwork evokes, not how the characters look, which results in a wonderfully stylized comic that has little care if the character's body proportions completely change between panels. Add in a whole ton of nudity and violence and you have the start of something special.
For a comic where Batman is meant to be the main character, he constantly gets shoved into the background of a convoluted story that would be hard enough to follow with consistent character designs. There's something about an asteroid heading towards Earth, superheroes held captive by an evil government, and a holographic president.
More importantly there is: crazy Superman and Wonder Woman sky sex that gets Wonder Woman instantly pregnant (talk about a terrible super power), Plastic Man killing people while in the form of a hand mixer, and Dick Grayson taking up the mantle of the Joker while being both a shape-shifter and criminally insane.
1. Rat Eater Robin - All Star Batman And Robin, The Boy Wonder
The All Star Batman and Robin, the Boy Wonder mini-series is dumb comics at their best. From it's mouthful of a name, to it's out of character cast, and grim-dark plot that feels like a parody. The thing that really sets this series above the others is how beautifully brought to life it is. Every panel a sincerely rendered gorgeous depiction of absolutely batsh*tery (pun intended).
There's a lot of causal dumb stuff going on: like Vicky Vale taking a video call with Alfred while wearing her next-to-no-nothings, or Batman and the Black Canary having public sex in front of the burning bodies of a bunch of dead and dying thugs.
Then there's the super stupid stuff: Batman has creepily had his eye on child gymnast Dick Grayson for a while. When the child's parents are shot in front of him, Batman decides to kidnap the boy: immediately being both physically and verbally abusive to the traumatized 12-year-old.
In the freezing Batcave the soon to be Robin asks for some new clothing. Batman naturally acts unhinged so the boy has to apologize for the request - it's just his dead parents "blood and stuff" all over him.
Batman does not bring him clothing and then gets pissed off at Alfred for finally feeding the kid. Batman is shocked and incensed that his butler would stand up to him and blames the child for Alfred stepping out of line. With Alfred properly chastised, the child is reduced to eating rats. Truly a beautiful fever dream of stupid.
DC Quiz: How Well Do You ACTUALLY Know Batman?