10 Iconic Comic Book Characters (Without Legendary Comics)

These characters may be iconic, but they lack the seminal stories they deserve.

Blade Marvel
Marvel Comics

You would think a character becoming iconic would be a cut and dry process. Like, make a few seminal stories, a few really good runs by famous creators, and of course, make sure those comics are properly advertised, and bing bang boom, you got yourself a character everyone knows.

Well, if that were the case, Blue Beetle wouldn't keep getting cancelled, would he?

Obviously things are a little more complicated than that. Sure, Chris Claremont did a lot to put the X-Men on the map, as did Walt Simonson with his Thor series. But just as often, a character will become one of their company's most iconic characters without any initial direct input from that company. Whether it's because of another series they appear in, or getting a cool TV show/movie that boosts their popularity, comic characters can become iconic completely out of the blue.

However, when that happens, it sometimes means that fans who've discovered these characters in a different medium are left disappointed when they go hunting for their comics. There are genuinely comic characters that are iconic, despite lacking the seminal runs and stories that they rightly deserve. Here are the biggest of all...

10. Captain Atom

Captain Atom
DC Comics

The good captain began his life in Charlton comics, before that went under and Charlton's entire superhero line was bought out by DC. Since then Captain Atom has been kicking around from superhero team to superhero team, occasionally getting his own books that inevitably go nowhere.

Which is a shame for anyone who - for example - grew up on the early 2000's Justice League cartoon, where he was a prominent side character. He's also made appearances in other media such as the animated movie Superman/Batman: Public Enemies, which has resulted in him becoming a very well known character in the DC universe.

This being in spite of the fact that DC just can't get someone to work on his series that really adds that special oomph that makes a legendary comic.

Hopefully that'll happen one day, because this great character really does deserve it. His powers put him on par with superman (being basically a thermonuclear reactor that walks and talks) and that combined with his military background can make for some interesting stories.


9. Supergirl

Supergirl Comics
DC Comics

Unlike Captain Atom, it isn't as if DC has been disregarding Supergirl over the years. It's just that none of her runs have really grabbed people the same way her more famous cousin has. And that really is a shame because many argue that Kara is a superior character to Clark, and more than deserving of the same kind of brilliant stories.

Every major run of Supergirl has tired to reinvent the wheel instead of focusing on her having a consistent lore. Until she was brought back in the New 52 and Rebirth, Kara Danvers was dead due to Crisis on Infinite Earths. Before she came back it was all alternate versions of her (Linda Danvers) or computers posing as Supergirl (Matrix Supergirl) and lots of other stuff.

Supergirl's current place in the DC universe, hilariously, takes from the DCW Supergirl TV show in order to finally have a consistent inner universe. So with luck, she won't be on this list for much longer, and the woman of steel can have that perfect, legendary run she deserves.


8. Starfire

Starfire Teen Titans
DC Comics

Sometimes you run across that character who's incredibly famous despite never even getting much of a chance at a solo run in the first place. Sure, there was a Starfire solo run that lasted for about 12 issues. But let's face it, that is not why you all know who Starfire is.

The Teen Titans cartoon made by Glen Murakami is pretty much the only reason anyone cares who Cyborg, Raven, Beast Boy, and yes, Starfire even are outside of hardcore comics fandom. It's the same reason that Wally West got to stay the Flash for just a few more years before they reset that to zero.

It's too bad that Starfire's solo run didn't get that much traction, because the character is so much fun and so beloved by the comic fandom that giving her her own solo run and her own stories would make everyone happy.

It's not even a lack of material to work with that's keeping that from happening. Starfire is the lost princess of an alien planet who now has to adjust to living on Earth. That's a great hook for fun stories as well as genuine pathos.


7. Jessica Cruz

Green Lantern Jessica Cruz
DC Comics

The main difference between this entry and the others is that it's only a matter of time before Jessice Cruz gets her legendary story, seeing as how she's both incredibly new as well as already insanely popular thanks to her appearances on DC Superhero Girls and Justice League Vs The Fatal Five.

But for such a famous character right out of the gate, it's odd that the closest thing we have to a solo run for her has her teaming up with fellow Green Lantern Simon Baz (who's also awesome but not nearly as famous) and that run was mostly forgettable all things considered.

Jessica Cruz just hasn't had her version of Emerald Twilight or the Black Lantern Saga yet. Hopefully that will happen soon and the entire comic fandom can be shown what the wisest among us already knows: Jessica Cruz is the best Green Lantern.


6. Ant Man

Ant-Man Marvel Comics
Marvel Comics

Ant Man is more famous now than the character has ever been before, which makes the lack of any truly great stories featuring the guy all the more ironic.

He's a founding member of the Avengers, has been around through three different people wearing the helmet, and even been responsible for one of Marvel's most enduring villains in Ultron, and yet few if any of his solo runs and stories are actually all that memorable.

Now, the snarky among you might say that it would be rather hard to make a hard hitting, best selling, legendary comic book out of a guy who talks to ants. To which I say that if Marvel can make a big green guy who punches stuff one of the saddest and most tragic characters in fiction, and a kid from Queens wearing a red and blue body stocking so beloved that people will riot if the wrong studio is making movies about him, then they have no excuse.

Sure it would be harder to do this with some versions of Ant Man than others (Scott Lang is by far the most beloved version of this character, probably because he isn't a wife beater like Pym) it's by no means impossible. So someone should definitely give the man in the anthill a story befitting his new found fame.


5. Ghost Rider

Ghost Rider Robbie Reyes
Marvel Comics

One of Marvel's most badass superheroes, the Ghost Rider has garnered quite the reputation over the years for being one of The House Of Ideas most intense characters. Shame the same can't be said of the stories he's featured in.

Sure, Robbie Reyes' run came achingly close to reaching truly great heights, but it was cancelled due to low sales before anything truly amazing could come of it. It's a lot of fantastic setup, but no payoff. Before that, we had Johnny Blaze and Danny Ketch, who had decent lifespans, but lacked appeal beyond the base concept of being Ghost Rider. Which, granted, is a damn awesome base concept.

Despite this, though, the character of Ghost Rider has remained one of Marvel's most recognizable faces. And the idea of him has been the jumping off point to a lot of really good stories, even if they aren't quite in legendary status.

But with interest about to be renewed in the Robbie Reyes version of Ghost Rider with the upcoming Hulu series, maybe that will be what marvel needs to be convinced that this hero needs his own legendary series or story.


4. The Defenders

The Defenders Luke Jessica Daredevil Iron Fist Marvel Comics
Marvel Comics

The Defenders are an interesting bunch here, because they're pretty obscure outside of mainstream hardcore comic fandom, despite a lot of effort by Marvel to bring them to the mainstream.

Besides the Netflix show being a complete flop, writers like Brian Michael Bendis have tried working away at this superhero team to get people to care about it, but besides some decent runs here and there, there really hasn't been anything that matches the individual runs of each of its members.

Sure there are some great stories in there scattered throughout, but nothing that matches Daredevil's Born Again, the Matt Fraction run on Iron Fist, and pretty much everything Jessica and Luke get up to in Alias.

If there's any justice in this world, this small scale superhero team will get the truly legendary run that their members usually experience when they fly solo.


3. Ms Martian

Miss Martian
DC Comics

Just like with Starfire, Ms Martian has appeared in a ton of comics. But let's be honest with ourselves, you know her from either Supergirl or Young Justice. Sure she had a stint with the Teen Titans back in the early 2000's, but that wasn't one of the team's more illustrious runs, plus it's a team book so it doesn't count for her individually.

But while Starfire was at least in one of the best runs in the history of the Teen Titans to give her some fame despite low popularity when solo, Megann hasn't even had a solo run of her own. And if you know this character, you know that to be a crying shame because she's easily one of the best female DC heroes out there.

Fun, bubbly, and all while having all the power and strength of her uncle Jonn (who, mind you, is as strong as Superman).

Hopefully Young Justice Outsiders will help DC realize what an awesome heroine they've been letting go to waste and they'll give her the run she deserves.


2. Cyborg

Cyborg DC Comics
DC Comics

Cyborg sure gets around doesn't he? One minute he's on the Justice League, the next he's on the Doom Patrol. Once upon a time he was on the Teen Titans but DC seem eager to divest from that interpretation as of late.

And yet he's had very few solo runs all on his own. This goes back to what we said about Martian Manhunter, since Cyborg started off in a team book - the Marv Wolfman era of the Teen Titans - he's been written to have a personality that meshes better with a team than on his own. Sure, he had a solo run back in 2016 written by John Semper Jr. but most people have seemingly forgotten that that run even happened in the first place.

Cyborg is one of the most popular members of the original Teen Titans out there, thanks in no small part to him being shifted around to more popular teams over the years. And yet he lacks the legendary stories afforded to even more obscure characters like Animal Man, who received an Eisner winning run by Grant Morrison.


1. Blade

Avengers Blade
Marvel Comics

By far the highlight of Marvel's showing at this year's San Diego Comic Con was the reveal that they were making a new Blade movie and that legendary actor Mahershala Ali was going to be playing him. The crowd went absolutely ballistic, cheering and clapping with the force of several earthquakes.

Which, if you think about it, is peculiar. Because when is the last time you actually picked up a Blade comic?

Okay, the Blade trilogy from the nineties is the most likely reason that people are excited for this ultra obscure character from the Marvel books, but that version of Blade was specifically made to be as detached from his comic counterpart as possible, so it's unlikely that the Ali version will even resemble that original trilogy if it wants to be comic-accurate.

Blade is the most famous comic book character out there whose fame has absolutely nothing to do with the source material from which he hails. There isn't a seminal, legendary run of Blade that people look back on with any kind of fondness. Indeed you'd be hard pressed to find someone who's ever even read a Blade comic once in their lives these days.

With luck the movie will change that.


Marvel Quiz: How Well Do You Know Blade?

Blade Thumbnail
Marvel

1. What Is Blade's Real Name?

Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?