10 Idiotic Mistakes That Almost Ruined Spider-Man

Marvel should've replaced Peter with Ben when they had the chance...

Scarlet Spider Replace Peter Parker
Marvel Comics

Though his status as one of the best and most popular superheroes is well and truly deserved, retaining such a position hasn't always been a web-swing in New York for Spider-Man.

There are several infamous occasions where the character and his wider mythos alike have been handled incredibly poorly by creators. These mistakes vary from minor out of character actions or dialogue to severe missteps that almost ruined the character of Spider-Man as a whole.

That may be hard to fathom with the regular supply of spot-on takes in film, video games, animation and of course comics that we receive nowadays, but it's true - the nineties did happen, after all.

These mistakes stray so far from the faithful takes of today that Marvel often responded to them with timeline clean-ups of similar ruthlessness to Deadpool's actions at the end of Deadpool 2. Further exemplifying just how damaging these stories were is the fact that most have never really been mentioned in the comics since, only being talked about in lists such as this one.

But can you blame us? Some of these decisions could've spelled nigh-on doom for the wall-crawler. It's a miracle he came out the other side intact.

10. Bringing His Parents Back As LMDs - The Amazing Spider-Man #366

Spider-Man parents LMDs
Marvel Comics

Bringing back any characters from the dead is a cheap trick. It's an especially cheap in comics, a medium which only truly sees characters die if they don't sell enough books.

One thing that tends to be a rule with comic book character resurrections though is that parents stay dead. This is even more the case when the child of said parents was primarily raised by his aunt and uncle.

Obviously the creators of issue 366 of Amazing Spider-Man forgot this rule, as Peter Parker's rarely mentioned parents were brought back as Life Model Decoy's in a mad scheme by the Red Skull.

While, yes, a villain-controlled LMD is not the same as sticking the Parkers in something like DC's Lazarus Pit, these synthetic versions retained the memories and emotions of the originals, making them, for all intents and purposes, Peter's parents.

The thing is, bringing them back in any capacity was completely unnecessary, and could have very easily ruined one of the key elements of the teenage Spidey: his relationship with Aunt May. This particular issue might be one of personal taste, but it's probably safe to assume that most readers would deem this more idiotic than not.


9. Revising Stan Lee & Steve Ditko's Origin For The Character - Spider-Man: Chapter One

Spider-Man Chapter One
Marvel Comics

Unlike, Batman, Spider-Man's origin story was basically perfect when it debuted. No grand 'Year One' stories or constant in-canon reinterpretations were needed, because what Lee & Ditko produced in Amazing Fantasy #15 more than sufficed.

Despite calling itself the House of Ideas, Marvel is ultimately a business, and so saw the opportunity to have legendary creator John Byrne (artist and co-plotter on such greats as the Dark Phoenix Saga and X-Men: Days of Future Past) write and draw a thirteen issue series to revamp ol' web-head's origin as a great commercial move.

Instead of providing a definitive origin that far surpassed the original, as Frank Miller's Batman: Year One and Daredevil: The Man Without Fear had done previously, Byrne added nothing to Lee & Ditko's creation. The book needlessly tied characters together (e.g: Norman Osborn was now responsible for Spider-Man's entire rogues gallery), and even ignored certain stories.

It's probably for the best that Chapter One is now long forgotten.


8. Making Him Ultra Rich - The Amazing Spider-Man (2014) #1

Amazing Spider-Man 1 Alex Ross
Marvel Comics/Alex Ross

Remember how Spider-Man is supposed to be a relatable, fairly average guy under his mask? Of course you do. Remember how 'fairly average guy' translates to millionaire genius CEO? No? Neither do I. Funny that.

Giving Peter a tech corporation, globe-trotting adventures and an (admittedly very cool) armoured Spidey suit may sound like a fun idea that warrants brief exploration in something like - oh, I don't know - a book that explores the infinite alternate-universe versions of the character. In his main continuity title though? It really doesn't work...

He can't be a friendly neighbourhood hero if he's flying around the world toppling governments and making trade deals; it doesn't work and takes away from one of the character's most appealing elements, that being his everyman quality.


7. Annulling The Peter/MJ Marriage - Amazing Spider-Man #545

Amazing Spider-Man 545 One More Day
Marvel Comics

Contrary to the beliefs of the editors at Marvel and DC, fans love to see characters that have been together for years eventually tying the knot. It's a traditional method to display a pair's love for one another, but also one that tells fans that a given relationship is going to be a regular thing. Comics marriages also often end up being the pay-off of years of stories, making such events satisfying as well as significant.

For these reasons, annulling a marriage is always going to anger readers - particularly if it isn't done in an organic fashion.

This is exactly what happened when Peter traded his marriage with MJ for the life of Aunt May in the infamous One More Day.

Not only did Peter trade his marriage, he also traded the life of his and MJ's future daughter - all because he trusted the devil and wanted to sure his elderly aunt May wouldn't die.


6. Bringing Back Aunt May - Amazing Spider-Man #545

Aunt May Peter Parker
Marvel Comics

One More Day was not only a mistake for annulling the Peter/MJ marriage.

Aunt May is a character that has been depicted visually as rather elderly since her introduction. Following that, there have also been a number of occasions in which she has been close to death. There was one time she even seemed to peacefully pass away (though this was later revealed to be yet another of Norman Osborn's schemes).

Therefore, when May seemed to be finally allowed to rest after dying again, the general consensus was that it was about time - she had been a crutch to the character of Spider-Man for so many years. Then they brought her back and she became a crutch again.

As well as being a crutch for the title character, keeping May alive took away from another potential layer of relatability for Spider-Man, as everyone at some point will experience the passing of someone close to them. Removing the aforementioned touching, quiet end would be a greater crime (as it's far more relatable than death by assassination), were it not for the fact that this retcon also removed Peter's marriage and future child from existence.

In trying to keep Spider-Man relatable, Marvel instead did the exact opposite.


5. Making Him Team Iron Man - Civil War #2

civil war spider man peter parker secret identity reveal
Marvel Comics

Making silly decisions is part of Peter Parker's charm - he's not perfect, he makes mistakes, it helps make him so relatable.

What isn't a part of Parker's charm is his complete lack of regard for the safety of those closest to him though. The entire reason for the character's secret identity is so his friends & family don't worry and so those same people remain as safe as possible. After all, Spider-Man has a pretty massive rogues gallery, and most of them don't have a code that prevents them from targeting innocents.

As such, it makes zero sense why the character would side with Tony Stark in Civil War - a guy who is basically advocating for a lack of responsibility by asking Peter to let every one of his foes know exactly who he is.

I mean, Aunt May dies because as a direct result of this, for crying out loud. The issues of the previous two entries would not have existed were it not for this decision - that's how big of a misstep this was.


4. Sins Past

Gwen Stacy Norman Osborn Sins Past
Marvel Comics

Another fairly predictable inclusion, the reasons for which will become immediately obvious.

Gwen Stacy is a figure in Spider-Man history that represents the character's early innocent years, her death being an obviously sombre moment that truly defined the great responsibility that comes with Peter's great powers. A death of such significance is one that should not be tampered with, and yet - once again - Marvel begged to differ.

No, instead, it seems that they believed the best course of action was to reveal Gwen had had an affair with Norman Osborn, an affair that produced two children and was also the supposed reason for her death.

It tainted a key part of the Spider-Man mythos, angered fans, and probably made a large proportion of readers feel physically sick. Idiotic doesn't quite cover it.


3. Sins Remembered

Spider Man Sins Past Gwen Stacy
Marvel Comics

The only thing worse than giving a character a maligned story? Giving that maligned story a follow-up.

While not inherently horrific as Sins Past, Sins Remembered has one element that leaves a similar bad taste in the mouth as its predecessor: Gwen Stacy and Norman Osborn's daughter tries to get with Peter.

Through some comic book logic nonsense, the genetic enhancements that Osborn made to himself caused his offspring to age rapidly, meaning that both twins are fully-grown adults by the time the Sins Past arc takes place. Both twins are tricked into thinking Spider-Man killed their mother and try to avenge her. Peter convinces one child, Sarah, of the truth, but fails to do the same for her brother, Gabriel.

The story ends with Gabriel defeated and Stacy off living a presumably normal life. Sins Remembered sees Peter check up on Sarah in Paris, do some crimefighting, and has her fall for him. There's the clichéd moment of Sarah attempting to kiss Peter as MJ walks in and everything.

It's likely best to follow Marvel's example and forget either of these stories ever happened.


2. Giving Him Five Interconnected Titles At Once - The Nineties

Spider-Man Maximum Carnage
Marvel Comics

The comic book boom of the nineties meant that many of the most popular franchises received numerous books in order to capitalise on the increased demand, and Spider-Man was no different.

Over the decade, Spidey had nine titles to his name: The Amazing Spider-Man, Spectacular Spider-Man and Spider-Man Unlimited, just to name a few. Expecting readers to keep up with all of these books was a tall order in itself, but then Marvel threw in the additional curveball of making five of the titles interconnected - each of them were necessary reading if fans wanted to keep up with the main ongoing narrative.

The worst part is times haven't changed all that much. Right now Marvel are putting out: Amazing Spider-Man, Amazing Spider-Man: Daily Bugle, Marvel's Spider-Man (Gamerverse), Miles Morales: Spider-Man and Spider-Man: Noir - not to mention tangentially related properties like Venom, Black Cat or Amazing Mary Jane.

Sure, the current books aren't all required reading to understand one another, but it's still ridiculous regardless. Just as DC have a problem with Bat-books dominating their releases, Marvel share the same issue with Spider-Man.


1. Not Replacing Peter Parker With Ben Reilly - Spectacular Spider-Man #226

Spider-Man Clone Saga Ending
Marvel Comics

Hot take alert here, so prepare yourselves.

The Clone Saga was a mess: it had some great ideas but lost all of its pace and intrigue when it was artificially dragged out because of good sales. It also lacked pay-off, which is just one of the issues that replacing Peter Parker with Ben Reilly would have solved.

The original idea was to have Peter retire from web-slinging and go live a quiet life in Portland with MJ, leaving his clone, Ben, as the new Spider-Man in New York. It was genius - fans could have their happily married Peter & MJ, and Marvel editorial could have their young, single Spider-Man.

Had Marvel followed through with their plan and made Ben the new Spidey, there would be no need for One More Day, as Peter would not be involved in the superhero Civil War, Sins Past... may have still happened, okay, but the character's relatability would've remained intact.

Plus, let's be honest, both of Ben Reilly's suits (first the Scarlet Spider costume and then the one designed by Mark Bagley), are superior to Peter's.

Fans really did get the better of themselves by responding to the move to replace Peter with outrage. It could've been a breath of fresh air. Instead, the Spider-Man status quo remains much the same today as it was prior to the Clone Saga, albeit with the added caveat of Peter and MJ's lost marriage.


Insomniac's Spider-Man Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Costumes?

003 1533217730422
Insomniac

1. First Appearance Of The Advanced Suit?

Contributor
Contributor

Lover of film and comics, and (according to a comment on this very website) a pulsating sack of worthless nothing!