10 Inappropriate Things Marvel And DC Want You To Forget
From race to domestic violence, it's tough to imagine how the writers could get it so wrong.
Comic book writers have always taken inspiration from the world around them, for better or worse. This can lead to incredible stories grounded in reality and poignant commentary. After all, Captain America wouldn’t be the iconic character he is today without punching Adolf Hitler square in the jaw. Sadly though, not every attempt has aged well. This can make going back to older tales very, very awkward.
But it’s not just the older comics that get things so badly wrong. Despite all the work put in by publishers to move away from stereotypes, attempts to make characters work in a modern setting can come off as patronising or edgy for the sake of being edgy.
Luckily for publishers, they can simply reboot a character or even an entire universe if things go wrong. However, there are times where the only reasonable action is to just never bring the offending personality or storyline up again. With the benefit of hindsight, Marvel and DC have hopefully learned valuable lessons, so don’t expect to see anything in this list hitting pages again in the future...
10. DC’s Captain Marvel Owned A Slave
Captain Marvel may have just been an attempt at making the next Superman, but that didn't stop the character from becoming one of the most popular superheroes of the 1940s. In a horrifically misguided attempt at including African American character, writers introduced a new sidekick.
Simply named Steamboat, this new character managed to portray every racist stereotype available at the time. The character design was basically a monkey and his personality was offensively dumb. As if that wasn't bad enough, Captain Marvel literally made him into a slave. After accidentally blowing up his food truck, Billy Batson gave Steamboat a job at the radio station. On the face of it, a kind gesture to try and atone, yet the job was simple and demeaning tasks. It seemed that the character was simply there for comic relief rather than any positive representation of black culture.
Thankfully - after just three years - a group of students met with Fawcett Comics' executive editor, Will Lieberman. After successfully arguing for the removal of this highly insensitive character, Steamboat was written out in 1945 and has since never returned.
9. Bat-Dong
Sometimes an idea seems really great, then the internet gets wind of it and it's suddenly not looking so good.
This was the case for DC Black Label when they set out to offer stories for more mature readers, away from the regular DC continuity. In either a terrible lack of judgement (or a brilliant marketing move), the first issue under the new brand would shock the world with one single panel.
Aside from a darker tone and uncensored swearing, DC wanted to prove the new, adults only, stories lived up to the hype in the only other way they could. Nudity. Now you have to give them credit for not just pasting their pages with naked ladies and sex scenes, but what we came away with was one of the most scarring and somewhat hilarious images in comic history. Bruce Wayne's shadowy, flaccid penis.
It didn't take long for DC to backtrack after a barrage of memes and criticisms hit the internet faster than you could turn the page. The company quickly censored the digital versions and subsequent prints of the book were altered to put little Bruce back in the Bat-Cave. Despite this, there's no removing that image from your head once you've seen the uncensored panel, and the horror fans felt proved that it's the penis Gotham deserves, but not the one it needs right now.
8. The Punisher Turns Black
In 1970, DC released what they hoped would be a thought provoking look at race relations in
“I am Curious (Black)!”. Sadly, the book fell flat - presenting itself more as a stereotypical view on African American culture - and DC have thankfully never revisited the idea. Marvel however, learnt nothing from DC's mistake and in 1992, tried to do the same thing with the Punisher.
The premise for this story was even more dubious. Frank Castle escapes prison and is taken to a former surgeon/heroin addict who specialised in plastic surgery involving melanin. He wakes up from the surgery as a black man and goes on the lam, fearing for his life. Frank drives to Chicago to lay low, but due to being on pain medication he attracts the attention of the local law enforcement. This goes about as well as could be expected. Subjected to an onslaught of racist abuse, the Punisher strikes a cop and ends the page being brutally beaten by a whole gang of white policemen.
The transformation lasted four issues and served little purpose other than to promote the upcoming Luke Cage comic. For some reason Marvel figured that to (re)introduce a black hero, they had to make a similar character change race to help draw in readers. Nearly 30 years later and that logic still makes no sense.
7. Big Bertha
On the face of it, Big Bertha is already pretty problematic. Her power is being able to be superhumanly strong and durable, by becoming obese? How many people had the opportunity to stop this idea before it made it to print and didn't see an issue there? Her superhero name is something that would normally be used as an insult behind someone's back. While the argument could be made for empowering plus size women and owning your own body, that is all thrown out of the window very quickly.
When off superhero duty, Ashley Crawford is actually a world famous supermodel. This is where things take a nose dive for the character as she isn't walking the catwalk as a plus size model. Using her ability to manipulate her bodily tissue, Crawford transforms into a stick thin "perfect" woman and is rewarded as the highest paid supermodel in the USA for a time.
As if the comparison to her two body types wasn't enough to offend everyone, Marvel took it one step further with how she loses the weight during her transformation. Not content with a regular transformation, Bertha actually purges her weight by vomiting. Intentional or not, making light of a condition as serious as bulimia is disgusting. It's incredible that Big Bertha appeared in over 100 books before disappearing in the last couple years.
6. Superman Makes A Porno
There has been no bigger WTF moment than this. In 1978, The Man of Steel was the man on the reel as an adult film star. The comic equivalent of watching your dad have sex came in Action Comics #592 and #593, which saw Superman and Mister Miracle's wife nearly do the do on camera.
Stuck in a bad part of town, things go from bad to worse as Big Barda is chasing down a thief when she runs into Sleez. The villain - who later reveals he was exiled from Apokolips for being too creepy - uses his ability to corrupt Barda and enslave her as his personal sex toy. When Superman finally comes to save her, he too is hypnotised and the couple are pimped out to a XXX producer.
Luckily for them, Mister Miracle comes to their rescue, but not before suffering his own personal dose of torture. Scott gets home to find Darksied, calmly sat in an armchair holding a glass of brandy. Before he has chance to ask questions, Darkseid plays a video tape as Scott watches in horror. Furious about his beloved wife being filmed against her will, Mister Miracle tracks down Sleez's lair and busts in just before things go too far.
5. Codpiece
Some characters are so bad that they stick with you, even after just one appearance. Codpiece doesn't even have a real name, presumably because DC took one look at the character and decided we didn't need any more information on this creep. Who knows what Rachel Pollack and Scot Eaton were thinking when they designed this character. Just look at that helmet!
The character's origin story is possibly even dumber than the design. Codpiece's main weapon - a giant cannon - was created to compensate for his inferiority complex, caused by a girl in high school telling him he wasn't big enough. While she insists she meant his height, this sociopath took it to mean his penis and became a villain.
His reign of terror was short lived after a spree of bank robberies put Codpiece on the radar. As a new addition to the Doom Patrol, Coagula's first win was against Codpiece, when she managed to dissolve his crotch-based weaponry.
4. Batman Gets High And Wets Himself
Subtlety is hardly Kevin Smith's strength, but he took it to a whole new level in the miniseries The Widening Gyre. A complete clash of styles meant the usually dark and brooding Batman was reduced to crude jokes and a very awkward retcon.
This wild story features a team up with Baphomet. Unsurprisingly, the big twist in the story is that the new hero turns out to be the villain Onomatopoeia. Aside from the predictable reveal, the story is a complete mess. In one issue, Poison Ivy creates a new "herb"and manages to dose the Bat, causing the Caped Crusader to go on a paranoia fuelled series of ridiculous events, including beating his the girlfriend, Silver St. Cloud, because he thinks she's a robot.
Not content with that dumpster fire of a story, Smith decided to go back to Frank Miller's seminal Year One story and provide the worst retcon in history. While confronting criminals, the Dark Knight sets off an explosive but misjudged it's effects. This causes what he described as "a bladder spasm", otherwise known as wetting his bat-pants.
Unsurprisingly, as is a common theme with Smith, this 12 issue run was never completed and ended at issue 6. By that point however the damage was more than done, leaving one of the Bat's best stories well and truly soiled.
3. Starfox
Everyone knows the Mad Titan, but few people know he has a brother. Growing up in the literal shadow of Thanos, Eros hasn't had the easiest life. He watched his planet be decimated, captured by multiple villains and had a friend lose the battle with cancer. This is where the sympathy ends though. When you get to know Starfox, the less you ever want to see him again..
Among his many powers, the Titanian hero is able to stimulate the pleasure centres in someone's brain. This leaves the subject more suggestible as Starfox can create a feeling of euphoria to infatuate them. The more sinister aspect of this power came to light in a sexual assault case levied against him. During the trial, the defendant was banned from attending court after he was discovered to be using his power to influence witnesses. Jessica Walters uncorked the beating of a life time after learning her relationship with John Jameson was the result of Eros' meddling. As if creepy gaslighting powers weren't enough, Starfox was written as a ladies' man, which predictably found him being more an ignorant misogynist than charming.
2019 did see Starfox return to the page, however not as the hero he once was. Guardians Of The Galaxy #2 saw a new start as the main villain, which seems more fitting for this creepy individual.
2. Marvel’s Swimsuit Specials
The nineties brought with it some amazing comics. We saw the likes of Carnage, Deadpool and Ghost Rider make their first appearances, Bane broke Batman's spine and Marvel released five years of swimsuit specials.
Created as a parody of the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Specials, this tone deaf idea is a prime example of everything wrong with nineties comic culture. Sure, we saw the likes of Punisher and Namor in some on brand skimpy pants, but the main selling point of these books were the ladies of Marvel. The covers saw the likes of Rogue and Storm in tiny bikinis, which tells you all you needed to know about the content inside the book.
Critical reception was overwhelmingly negative, pointing out that the books were more fan-service than worthwhile reads. The story was secondary to the over-sexualised portraits, though realistically no-one was reading this book for the storyline. Critics also pointed out that some of the female characters in their swimsuits were just as revealing as their regular costumes.
Attempts have been made to revisit the swimsuit specials, but unsurprisingly, Marvel have declined to publish any more of these books.
1. Egg Fu
Representation is a huge deal in comics, especially since most books have been dominated by white, male faces for a long time. Asian characters in particular have suffered a great deal in the medium, being the constant subject of racist stereotyping until relatively recently. Of these offensive characters, there's one that really stands out as the worst possible portrayal of the Chinese people specifically.
The infamous Egg Fu was introduced in Wonder Woman #157 and somehow made it all the way to DC Rebirth in 2016. A masterclass in how not to write a character, Egg Fu is to this day one of the most racist characters ever put to page. Everything about his design was just bad. The slanted eyes, the moustache, even his name was a disaster. For added yikes, the writer chose to have him speak in dreadful broken English, replacing R's with L's during his speech.
Going by Chang Tzu, the character was redesigned to be far less of a caricature in later years. The character was turned into a half robot, half sentient egg and while still horrifying to look at, at least he wasn't reflecting a long dead racist stereotype. However that didn't stop DC changing his name again during The New 52 to the absolutely dreadful Edgar Fullerton Yeung (Egg Fu for short).
DC Comics Quiz: How Well Do You Know The DC Universe?