10 Insane Alternate Superhero Origins You Won't Believe Exist
Alternate universe? Leave all the rules at the door.
From time to time comic book readers will find themselves jaded, looking for more eccentric takes on their favourite tales. Ones that go against the more traditional storytelling formulas their favourite superheroes are typically bound to. To cater to this interest, writers and artists will venture into alternate takes and worlds of the old favourites, enjoying breaks from the more long term narratives on offer.
Many of the most famous examples of this centre on dark, often rather miserable older versions of popular characters (Old Man Logan and The Dark Knight Returns being two more popular examples of this staple).
There are, however, times when this elseworlds trope is applied to the early years of our favourite heroes. Often times popular, sometimes downright terrible, every time imaginative, the countless alternate origins out there are rather fascinating (and hilarious) to dig up.
With the best and the brightest that Marvel and DC have to offer, let’s take a look at 10 of the most unbelievable alternate superhero origins to ever grace the page.
Feel like some others deserved a mention? Tell us your favourites in the comments below.
10. SuperBat
Baby Kal-El crash lands in Gotham City instead of Smallville here, soon being discovered by the impossibly wealthy Thomas and Martha Wayne. Adopting him as their own, they name the boy Bruce and as is always the case with those named Bruce in comics, tragedy strikes. Thomas and Martha are once again callously gunned down, prompting a traumatised Bruce to cremate the mugger with his heat vision, discovering his superpowers for the first time.
What follows is an intriguing origin tale of a super powered Batman hiring Perry White and Lois Lane for the Gotham Gazette, doing battle with Metropolis magnate Lex Luthor in the business world and finally throwing down with The Joker. The Joker here however is the cackling alter ego of Lex Luthor who suffered a severe freak accident a year prior.
Ultimately moving into the lighter, more hopeful persona of Superman, this version has the best of both worlds: Superman’s powers and Bruce Wayne’s billions.
And the actual Bruce Wayne?
Chalk it down to the butterfly effect or something equally mindblowing but he never exists, same goes for his Joker. Two of the most beloved characters in comics history never happen at all, being simply overriden by another of DC’s most enduring feuds.
9. Ben Parker: Husband, Uncle... Spider-Man?
One of the greatest, most famous and most beloved of all superhero origins goes to Peter Parker. Geeky young Pete takes a bite from an irradiated spider, grows an ego and uses his powers for profit, side steps stopping a robber leading to the tragic murder of Uncle Ben. From there Parker understands the importance of that whole great power, great responsibility thing and becomes The Amazing Spider-Man we know and love.
Great stuff. Now let’s do a little role reversal and ask, what if good old Ben Parker suffered that fateful spider bite instead?
In amongst the millions of alternate Earths of the Marvel multiverse, there’s Earth-3145 and a much older Spider-Man. Uncle Ben becomes Spider-Man much quicker than Peter Parker did after the bite being all wise and life lessoned beforehand. He protects New York much like the usual Spidey and ultimately suffers the heartbreaking losses of both his wife May and his nephew Peter when the two are murdered by his dastardly nemesis, The Emerald Elf.
Sound familiar?
Watching Old Ben websling around the joint was rather fascinating. Perhaps an inclusion in the forthcoming Spider-Verse sequel will bring this character into the limelight.
8. SuperCentaur
Legendary X-Men mastermind Chris Claremont went wild, perhaps a little too wild, for DC in 1996 with his astonishingly odd 4 part Elseworlds miniseries: Superman/Wonder Woman: Whom Gods Destroy.
To kicks things off, this tale’s got some alternate history thanks to a still kicking Third Reich ruled by the Greek God Adonis. Nazi Gods, who’d’ve thought?
It gets worse when it turns out Wonder Woman and indeed all members of the Greek Pantheon are in on this whole National Socialism thing too. From there, Lois Lane is transformed into a new Wonder Woman courtesy of Athena and Lana Lang gets some snazzy powers too via the Oracle of Delphi.
In the meantime, The Man of Steel is defeated by the evil with Circe into a Nazi Centaur. Yep, a Kryptonian, a Nazi and a centaur all walk into a bar whenever Clark Kent wants a drink these days. Fortunately, Superman’s traditionally more peaceful worldview is restored when Lana Lang, in the midst of riding him no less, manages to remind him of his true self before going all centaur in her own right.
Whatever it was Claremont was smoking the day he conjured all this up, we would like some.
7. Pope Henry McCoy
Everyone’s favourite woolly blue scientist was left badly shaken, much like every other mutant, by the events depicted in House of M. The M-Day effect, as it came to be known, involved an emotionally and psychologically shattered Scarlet Witch tearing reality apart and ultimately decimating the mutant population.
Witnessed by his regular counterpart and Dr Strange in astral form, Pope Beast showed what McCoy’s life as a man of the cloth would’ve been: both the first American and the first mutant Pope in the history of the Catholic Church.
Still a lover and champion of mutant rights, Pope McCoy received several spiritual visions in the wake of the M-Day effect. Filled with hope, he allied with the Inhumans, believing some form of mutant salvation awaited in the Terrigen Mists. Moved by his hopeful ambitions, the Inhumans treat him kindly but Medusa ultimately chooses to deny him entry to the mists. She warns him that only pain awaited mutantkind in the mists.
A poignant and heartbreaking moment during the controversial M-Day saga, Pope McCoy was a testament to the mutant’s work ethic and intellect that no matter what path he followed in life, he wound up the master of his field eventually.
6. Mrs Diana Trevor
During the Golden Age of DC comics, Wonder Woman creator William Moulton Marston filled the role of head writer too and ensured the title remained (mostly at least) a proud work of feminist pop art by the standards of the time. In the wake of his departure however, Wonder Woman comics took a very notable shift into less action and more romance with the comic world’s second favourite war veteran to go by the name of Steve.
Obsessed with locking his beloved Wonder Woman into marriage, Trevor suffers a near death experience. The incident leads in to Wonder Woman agreeing and being reborn as a peaceful homemaker at the beck and call of her military man husband.
Subsequently, it turns out Wonder Woman’s not cut out for the traditional housewife role and she’s getting distracted helping others all the time. Between endless interrupted dates and the fact that Wonder Woman can’t master the art of cooking dinner, the whole thing begins to go seriously downhill. It’s almost like Wonder Woman was meant to be the superhero rather than the love interest or something...
5. Dark Claw
When it comes to popularity, one’s in pretty good company with Batman and Wolverine.
So what about a cross between the 2?
Young Logan Wayne tragically witnesses his parents' murders and is sent away to live in Alberta, Canada with his uncle who in turn is also murdered.
Tough break.
From there he serves in the air force and hangs out with a certain Creed H. Quinn. Joining the infamous Weapon X program, Wayne discovers the extent of his mutant abilities and has his bones bonded with adamantium.
Both Logan and Creed are dropped from the program with Logan being too noble to become their ideal assassin and Creed growing way too insane to be trusted with even the simplest of assignments.
Returning to New Gotham City, Logan uses his powers and skills for good, becoming Dark Claw, the world’s greatest detective. Determined to avenge his parents and his uncle, Dark Claw fights crime and butts heads with dastardly nemesis, Hyena (Creed H. Quinn’s alter ego, confirming him as a gross amalgamation of The Joker and Sabretooth).
With trusty allies Sparrow (if Jubilee were somehow Robin) and Huntress, Dark Claw was an especially popular member of the rather bizarre Amalgam comics line during the 90s.
4. The Red Son
Is it a hammer? Is it a sickle? No, it’s Communist Superman!
Following the total annihilation of Krypton, Jor-El sends his baby son Kal-El off in a rocket ship destined to land on Earth where, thanks to a couple hours time difference to the traditional origins, he crash lands in a Soviet Union run Ukrainian collective farm instead of Smallville.
Leaving truth, justice and the American way at the door, the last son of Krypton has instead been raised to be the common workers’ champion, fighting for Stalinism, socialism and the expansion of the Warsaw Pact among other things. As Superman, he is Russia’s greatest protector, doing battle with foes such as Lex Luthor, CIA agent Jimmy Olsen, an anarchic Russian Batman, Colonel Hal Jordan, Wonder Woman and clones of himself courtesy of Luthor.
An especially entertaining and well regarded What If story, Mark Millar’s Superman: Red Son offered wild takes and fresh origins for a variety of DC’s most beloved characters whilst running through several decades of a scarily different DC Earth where the big blue boy scout quickly becomes the big grey tyrant, Look out for the animated film adaptation next year.
3. Professor M
Professor X’s split identity laden son Legion has frequently proved to be something of a walking disaster. Tragically dangerous to himself and others, Legion embarked upon a seriously misguided attempt to make right with his old man: murder Magneto.
Murder him, that is, before he ever became Magneto and caused all that grief for Xavier and his X-Men. The problem here is Legion goes way too far back in time, meeting Magneto when he was still Erik and best buds with a young Charles Xavier. In turn, Xavier tragically dies defending his best friend from this time travelling attack.
Moved and devastated, Magneto vowed to continue Xavier’s peaceful vision of the future. With mutants exposed to the masses earlier than was originally the case, Apocalypse begins his world conquest early and without the X-Men to oppose him, succeeds admirably.
In the wake of Apocalypse taking over the world, Magneto forms the X-Men to oppose the ancient evil. Marrying Rogue, being chummy with a one handed Wolverine and ultimately tearing Apocalypse in half, Magneto as a superhero was a wild ride from start to finish.
2. Mimepool
Good old Wade Wilson’s always been renowned as one of Marvel’s more eccentric figures. Strange from the get go, Deadpool’s occasional forays into the multiverse have inevitably lead to major upticks in the strangeness sector, a prime example of this: Mimepool.
During his time with the Deadpool Corps (as if one DP wasn’t enough), Wilson encounters an alternate Earth version of himself. One who lives in a world whole scale invaded by mind-controlling berets. Yep, you read that correctly.
The Avengers have been defeated by said berets, becoming zombified mimes in the process. The Wade of this world helps in the successful defeat of the Mimevengers but is tragically taken over by one of those dastardly berets in the process. Thus an all new, all silent but equally deadly Deadpool is born: Mimepool.
The Deadpool Corps do what anyone would do in this situation: they strap Mimepool to a rocket and send him hurtling into space. We never did hear from Mimepool again (or at all come to think of it) but his comically surreal origin and short lived run were unforgettably bizarre.
1. The Punisher: Vigilante, Killer...Geisha?
Marvel’s most bloodthirsty antihero is a lot of things: violent, scary, bad-ass, grim, gritty etc.
But a tickle torturing geisha, well, that’s not the most obvious application to Mr Castle. One of many bizarre Marvel figures stemming from the early noughties Marvel Mangaverse series, Frank Castle was reborn as Sosumi Brown. High school principal by day and crook spanking (literally) warrior by night, Brown’s motivation to fight crime goes all the way back to the tragic pogo stick related accident.
The booming Manga industry at the turn of the 21st century prompted Marvel to cash in by attempting an East meets West take on their heroes. Most of the results were downright weird at best and full of ill-placed Eastern stereotypes but Manga Punisher handily takes the cake. Nicknamed Tokyo’s Kinkiest Superhero, The Manga Punisher was the only figure in the series to be chock full of BDSM imagery and themes.
Exhibiting almost none of the traits that made the original character so popular and (in)famous, Sosumi Brown just about runs away with the award for the most unbelievable alternate take on a classic hero.