10 Moments Marvel Have Chosen To Ignore

Not all continuity is created equally...

Nightcrawler Child Of Satan
Marvel Comics

In its 81 year history, Marvel comics has made more than few creative blunders. They have allowed prominent creators a level of control that would ultimately prove detrimental to the characters they had been entrusted with. In other instances they have relied upon shock value to increase sales and draw readers back to a flagging title, usually by "killing" a significant character, bringing another back from the dead or replacing the face behind the mask.

Regardless of fan reaction to a given creative choice, the on-going narrative of superhero comics will mean that such choices will need to be undone. In these instances, the publisher is left with no choice but to "retcon" the situation. This is basically an industry term for an often clumsy "Deus-Ex Machina" that resets the pieces on the board and allows new stories to be written from a relatively common baseline.

In some cases though, if the change is small enough or niche enough then Marvel go with the other tried and tested formula of "sweeping it under the rug" and acting as if it didn't happen. Which leads to fascinating oddities that manage to be both in and out of continuity.

It is some of these "Schrodinger's Plot-Threads" that need to be talked about now...

10. Legion Is His Own Father

x-men legion
Marvel Comics

Legion is the mutant son of Professor Charles Xavier and Gabrielle Haller. He suffers from severe mental illness, including dissociative personality disorder.

Holding Magneto responsible for the failure of his father'dream, Legion uses his mutant powers to travel back in time and kill the Master of Magnetism BEFORE he becomes his fathers greatest enemy. Only to end up killing Xavier instead and ushering in the fabled "Age Of Apocalypse".

As far as Marvel is concerned this is pretty much the events of the "Legion Quest" storyline. However, those who have read the book know this is not the case. Legion returns to Israel where a young Erik Lehnsherr and Charles Xavier first meet through a mutual friend Gabrielle Haller who is a patient at the hospital where both men work.

And here is the moment where the wheels come off.

While Xavier and Lensherr are out for the evening, Legion proceeds to take on his fathers' form and seduce his mother. As the two begin to kiss, just off the panel, we cut away to the next part of the story. Only for a group of time-displaced X-Men, Magneto and Xavier to confront Legion, who is found standing over the ravaged body of Gabrielle Haller.

The rest is pure mathematics. David Haller is not more than twenty years old at the beginning of the "Legion Quest" storyline, and the primary struggle young Charles Xavier is having is whether or not he should act upon his feelings for his patient Gabrielle Haller. The off-panel assault is never mentioned again but is never explicitly retconned either.

If the original plan was to reveal that Haller was his own father, then it was one which was never followed up on, if not then what was the point of the sequence as it has no bearing on the characters or the "Age of Apocalypse" storyline that it kickstarted?


9. Bullseye Has An Adamantium Skeleton

Bullseye Marvel
Marvel Comics

The sight of Matt Murdock dropping the psychotic hitman Bullseye to his death is the second most famous page in Frank Miller's seminal Daredevil run. It is only just behind Bullseye impaling Electra upon her own sai. Everyone has either read this storyline or has at least heard of the events. As it is one of the cornerstones of Daredevil's mythology.

But if someone was to ask you how Bullseye returned from the dead, would you know the answer? Most people would, correctly, assume it was merely another case of "Heaven's revolving door" in comics. But what most people don't know is that Bullseye didn't die that night but was instead rebuilt by a Japanese criminal know as Lord Dark Wind. A process in which, like Wolverine, he has his bones laced with Adamantium.

A casual review of Bullseye's subsequent appearances in the Marvel universe will show innumerable battles where the mercenary ends up beaten, battered and broken. Damage that a man with an Adamantium skeleton should rarely take. Still, it's also something that can be explained away by the injuries not being severe or having no effect on the bones. There could even be an argument made for his opponents showing no adverse results from striking the indestructible metal.

However, what has been established repeatedly through the ongoing narrative of the Marvel Universe is just how poisonous Adamantium is. It is so toxic in fact that any time Wolverine has "lost" his mutant healing factor, he almost instantly succumbs to its effects. Yet Bullseye, a mere human, seems to suffer no ill despite his bones also being laced with the metal.


8. Professor Xavier Was In Love With Jean Grey

Charles Xavier X-Men
Marvel Comics

Professor Charles Xavier is one of the most the questionable "heroes" in the history of comics. While presented as a benevolent father figure with a liberal dream of inclusion and integration between two separate cultures, he is also a bit of a bastard.

Some of his greatest hits include the following: The time he faked his death before running off into space with his girlfriend, leaving his adopted family grieving and lost. The time he used his incredible psychic powers to destroy the mind of his best friend, leaving him in a vegetative state. The time he killed his twin sister while they were both in the womb. Leading a team of untrained children to their deaths and then wiping everyone's minds of the event, including the brother of one of the victims and then trying again with another group.

There's more, but you get the idea.

The one event that doesn't get talked about all the much however happened just before the "Onslaught" mega-event when Jean grey entered Charles Xavier's mind to find out the true identity of the villain. To the surprise of no one, it turned out to be Xavier himself. Fortunately, for Jean and everyone else all hell broke loose moments later, and she would have no time to dwell on the dark secrets that she was shown inside the mind of her mentor and father figure.

Namely that for some time, he had been in love with Jean Grey. A woman he had lured away from her parents as a child. To his private school. Where he would explore the deepest recesses of her mind. So he could teach her how to use her "gifts". Yeah, nothing creepy there.


7. Black Cat Took Up The Mask As A Way To Get Revenge Upon Her Rapist

Black Cat Evil That Men Do
Marvel Comics

During the great Marvel "renaissance" back in the early 2000s, Hollywood came to comics. Unlike today, however, those who came weren't looking for source material for the latest billion-dollar movie franchise or TV show. They were instead life long comics fans who parlayed their success outside of the industry into high profile writing gigs. It was a win-win situation for the most part, with their names attracting a large audience to a project of lapsed fans and new readers, along with the titles monthly faithful.

The most prominent creator at the time was trendy "indy" filmmaker Kevin Smith, notable for films such as Clerks, Mallrats and Chasing Amy. His star may have dwindled since those days but even now Smith's name still carries weight in certain circles. After successful runs on Daredevil and Green Arrow, the comics world waited with baited breath for his take on Black Cat, the blonde bombshell thief in the mini-series "Spiderman/Blackcat: The Evil Men Do".

Fans where drip-fed the six issues over a number of years, it got to the point where most believed the book would never be finished much like Smiths other book at the time Daredevil: The Target. When it was finally finished, we all learned to be careful what you wish for as Smith had rewritten Felicia Hardy's origin in a most unpleasant way.

Black Cat confesses to the villain of the story, a victim of sexual abuse himself, that she was raped during college and that it was this event that changed her life. She would train her body to the peak of human perfection. Learning combat skills, acrobatics, stealth, planning, lock picking. Anything that would help in her ultimate goal - revenge upon her rapist.

Gone was the debutant heiress who took to crime for the thrill and instead were left with painful adolescent cliche at best and an offensive, mishandled act of borderline misogyny at worst.


6. Vulcan Isn't The Third Summers Brother

Vulcan Gabriel Summers
Marvel Comics

Scott Summers is one of the five founding X-Men and one of the prominent faces of the franchise since its inception. About nine years after Marvel brought his brother Alex into the X-Family. The two would move in and out of each other lives over the next twenty years, discovering the truth about what happened to their parents, falling in love with clones, turning to the dark side, and generally running the full gambit of comic-book escapades.

That all changed in the early 90s when during a confrontation with Mister Sinister, Scott would discover the existence of hither unto unmentioned "Third Summers Brother". The plot was quickly dropped with Marvel treating it as some kind of psychological manipulation by the mutant geneticist. Fans, on the other hand, were not so easily dissuaded. The identity of the missing Summers sibling was debated, speculated and argued over in comic shops around the country.

Fast forward to 2005 and Marvel publish "Deadly Genesis", a six-issue story arc detailing one of Charles Xavier's many transgressions. It would also introduce a new villain called Vulcan, an omega level mutant who had seemingly died on a mission for Xavier years earlier. The last issue also revealed Vulcan to be Scott and Alex's long lost brother.

While this is "technically" true, Vulcan Summers is NOT the third Summers brother. He is the fourth (Or third and a half if you want to split hairs). Back in the 90s, Marvel introduced a short-lived character called "Adam-X The Extreme". Let's just choose to believe his design was meant as an ironic look at the eras biggest cliches and not a genuine attempt to create something "cool" and "relevant".

Amongst the shoulder pads, swords, pouches and spikes there was a reasonably exciting backstory. Adam was the son of the Shiar Emporer D-Ken and Katherine Summers. The mother of Scott, Alex and Vulcan. In all likelihood, Marvel has chosen to ignore this particular tale of alien abduction and sexual assault for readily apparent reasons, but that doesn't mean it didn't happen.


5. Magneto Should Be A Pensioner By Now

Magneto Marvel
Marvel Comics

We are just coming off the back of the 75th Anniversary of VE Day and the end of World War Two. Readers have seen the events of this tumultuous period through the eyes of the many of Marvel's premiere characters.

These include unnaturally long-lived beings like Wolverine. People who have "leap-frogged" through time like Capitan America and Bucky Barnes. Legacy characters who had the knowledge passed down from their predecessors like Black Widow and the Carter Family. Except for Wolverine, all of these characters are rooted in the events that took place between 1939 and 1945.

Erik Lehnsherr was a small boy who survived the extermination of his entire family during the holocaust. The trauma of these events led him to swear "never again". Upon discovering he was a mutant and seeing the world turning against his genetic brethren just as others had done to his family during the war. Erik Lehnsherr would assume the identity of Magneto and use his considerable powers to gain respect for his people by any means necessary.

These events would lead him into conflict with not only the X-Men but the Avengers, SHIELD, Spider-man and any number of superhero throughout his life. A life he is still leading in the year 2020. Which would put his age around about seventy-five but judging from his appearances in various stories set during the war, he would be closer to eighty-five years old.

Wolverine doesn't seem quite so cool when you realise he is using his eternal youth, unbreakable bones and razor-sharp claws to push around an octogenarian.


4. Spider-Man Had/Has A Child

Spider-Man Todd McFarlane
Marvel Comics

The 90s was a tumultuous time for Spider-Man both creatively and commercially. His publisher was facing bankruptcy and was throwing everything but the kitchen sink at its various titles to keep them afloat. In the wall crawler's case, this included massive shifts in the status quo. From his marriage to his long term love Mary Jayne Watson to the death of his beloved Aunt May, there was no idea too far fetched that his creators wouldn't consider it.

At some point during one of their fabled "Creative Retreats," someone first mentioned the word "Clone" and Spider-Man would never be the same again. To me, it always looked like a redundant and clumsy way resetting Spider-Man's continuity. Marvel effectively introduced a duplicate Peter Parker in the form of Ben Riley who had all of the power and none of the responsibility that came with being married.

The problem was instead of just killing the original off they decided to give him a "Happily ever after". The plan was for him, Mary-Jayne and his new baby to swing off into the sunset leaving Ben Riley in the Spider-Costume to have a whole new set of adventures. The problem was the fans were having none of it, leaving Marvel with the question of what to do with the Parkers' baby.

As with everything else during this period, it was handled in the most convoluted and ridiculous way possible. The only two "facts" in that story are Mary-Jayne's labour and the babies disappearance off-panel. What happened to it? An agent of Norman Osbourne might have abducted it. It might have died during childbirth. Norman Osbourne might have murdered it. It might not have been a baby at all but a Spider-human hybrid that the Doctors burned in the incinerator.

Whatever the events of that night where pretty much the entire Marvel universe just pretended that there had never been a baby. It's never shown during the "Greatest Hits" of Peter Parker's pain that Marvel likes to trot out once a year. Mary-Jayne suffered no trauma or psychological side-effects from it. Norman Osbourne never gloated or taunted the Parkers. Everyone just forgot the child existed and this was BEFORE "One More Day"!


3. Cannonball Is Immortal

Cannonball 1
Marvel Comics

In comics, Heaven has a revolving door and nowhere is this more true than in the long-running X-Men franchise. At least 90% of the characters, either in the main book or a spin-off have died AT LEAST once. The only deaths that have any value are those that are tied directly to a significant characters origin story, but only when retconning the death would damage a piece of pop-culture folklore. Martha and Thomas Wayne aren't coming back from the grave. Ditto, Uncle Ben.

Sometimes though the notion of "Immortality" is brought up and the plot gets even stranger. Writers must come up with ways to temporarily kill a seemingly unkillable character. Look at the recently returned Wolverine as an excellent example of this particular trope. Why creators felt the need to explicitly state a character is immortal is another matter entirely; it introduces a Gordian knot into continuity.

Back in the 90s however there was an EXTREMELY popular X-Men spin-off called X-Force. They were a paramilitary mutant strike team that used Magneto tactics to make Xavier's dream a reality. The team's field commander was a young mutant from Kentucky called Cannonball, who was all down-home charm and boy next door good looks. He was a member of the New Mutants for nearly a decade. He has since served as both a fully-fledged member of the X-Men and the Avengers.

Creators have had him battle from one end of the universe to the other while showing that despite his mutant power making him temporarily invulnerable while in "flight" he could still be hurt or even killed.

The problem is that a Morlock called Masque already "killed" Cannonball back at the beginning of X-Force. Only for readers to discover that Samuel Guthrie is part of an immortal sub-set of mutants called Externals. Cable, a time traveller, tells him that he will live for thousands of years and become a "High lord" in a distant war against Apocalypse.

But that inconvenient truth only makes any sense of peril redundant and who wants that?


2. Nightcrawler's Father Is Literally The Devil

Nightcrawler X Men Roof
Marvel Comics

Apologies at this point to those of you who have had the misfortune to have read "X-Men: The Draco." It's not fair to dredge up such painful memories of something as triggering as...

...Chuck Austen.

We all have that one guy at work that everyone wonders how he got the job in the first place let alone all the plum assignments he gets handed despite his constant incompetence. During the Marvel renaissance in the early 2000s, Chuck Austen was that guy. And somehow, he "wrote" War Machine, The Avengers and THREE separate X-Men titles.

Sadly, it was not his tenure with the company that Marvel swept under the rug; it was his most significant continuity change. Up until "The Draco" storyline the mutant Nightcrawler had been portrayed as an orphan whose parents left him to the circus because of his demonic appearance. Growing up, he would find inner-peace and comfort in his faith.

Chuck Austen revealed that Nightcrawler's father was a representation of the Judeo-Christian devil who teleported into "our world" so he could sire a child that would one day grow up and free him from his imprisonment. Just take a minute to process that sentence. Chuck Austen took a positive and enlightened representation of a Christian character and have him find out his father was the devil, and he only existed as a way for his old man to escape from Hell.

There's no point trying to argue with Marvel's decision here, but why couldn't they have redacted the exploding communion wafers and the mad nurse storylines while they were at it?


1. Daredevil Got His Powers While Saving A Child Molester.

Daredevil 3 Joe Quesada
Marvel Comics

One of the defining characteristics of the blind lawyer turned vigilante Daredevil is the ever-growing mountain of crap each new writer chose to dump upon him. The situations that Matt Murdoch has endured over the years would break any lesser man, yet somehow he ends each creator run with more focus and determination than when he began.

It's hard to know where to begin listing the tragedies that have befallen him; from dead lovers to prison stints. Financial ruin to public humiliation. From maternal abandonment to intensive care. If Superman is a comic book Jesus, then Matt Murdock is Job.

Perhaps the most painful twist came in the mid naughties during Joe Quesada criminally underrated mini-series "Daredevil: Father". The story is set during a heatwave and is about a serial killer stalking the streets of Hell's Kitchen—one who seemingly has a grudge against Daredevil. Throughout the storyline, both the characters and the audience are lead to assume the killer knows Matt Murdoch's secret and is targeting him for something he has done in his guise as Daredevil.

It is only when the other shoe drops with the discovery of the killer's identity that we understand the depth and cruelty of this latest blow. The killer is, in fact, the daughter of the man Matt Murdoch saved from being run down the day he got his powers. He would end up blind, and on his way to becoming Daredevil, the man would go on to continue molesting his daughter for another decade.

Matt's greatest sacrifice resulted in a young woman driven to the point of madness and beyond. Quesada managed to weave a tale of tragedy into the very fabric of the ongoing Daredevil narrative - the ultimate bitter twist in a life full of them. Only for Marvel to ignore it and continue to re-tread the same storylines that Frank Miller wrote some forty years ago.

It is in some ways fitting that people tragically ignore one of Daredevils greatest stories.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Kevin McHugh is a code-monkey by day and a purveyor of the unpleasant by night. Having had several comics published by Future Quake Press he is now moving into prose. An avid fan of punk rock, cheap horror movies and even cheaper fast-food Kevin can be found pontificating either on Twitter or over at WhatCulture Comics where he is a regular contributor. He lives in Edinburgh with his wife and two daughters.