10 Most Brutal Villain Beatdowns In All Of Comics

The most brutal times supervillains got what was coming to them.

Mysterio Beat Down
Marvel Comics

Superheroes beating up on supervillains is a tradition literally as old as comics themselves. It's a power fantasy that pretty much anyone can get behind, taking someone who is doing something objectively wrong and evil, and just wailing on them until they stop.

But sometimes things can go a bit far, even when the target is a supervillain. Beating them senseless and leaving them for the police is all well and good, but a proper superhero should make sure that they can sign their name or form coherent sentences when they do so. Even so, there are just as many times when a superhero can't take it anymore, and so must bring the hammer down hard, both figuratively and VERY literally.

This has happened a lot more than you might think, so much so that narrowing down just ten picks from Marvel and DC's history was quite a task. What that says about the medium as a whole is up for debate, but for now, let's find out which supervillain beatdown made you wince, shield your eyes, or just recoil in horror the most...

10. Spider-Man Vs Kingpin - Spider-Man: One More Day

Spider-Man Kingpin One More Day
Marvel Comics

There are many words to describe One More Day: stupid, nonsensical, horribly written, contrived, just to name a few. But one scene in particular stands out as being one of the few actually bright spots in an otherwise god awful event. Namely, the time Spider-Man takes the Kingpin apart.

To be honest, considering the kinds of feats Spidey pulls off on a regular basis, it should not surprise us when Peter comes in to savage Fisk, and ol' butterball can barely land a single punch. Spidey holds himself back so much so as to not kill anyone he fights, that he allows Fisk to beat him senseless before and after this moment.

But with his aunt's life on the line and Wilson being the one behind it, Peter suddenly has little sympathy for the crime boss, and cuts him down to size instantaneously. And in front of all of his cronies locked up there with him, just to drive in the humiliation further.

As heinous as the rest of this story might be (and by god on a unicycle is it freaking HEINOUS), it was nice to see Spidey make it clear to the so called Kingpin of crime that if you step on this spider's web, expect to be eaten alive.


9. Black Panther And Storm Vs The Skrulls - Black Panther #39-41

Black Panther Skrull invasion
Marvel Comics

While most superheroes try to avoid killing whenever possible, Black Panther for the most part cannot afford to take such risks. Being the king of a highly advanced nation that a lot of invading alien forces know needs to go first if they want to take the Earth, T'Challa needs to make it clear that this is his kingdom, and if you mean it harm he will make the ninth circle of Hell look like a theme park.

A lesson thoroughly taught to the Skrulls when they tried to take over the planet for the billionth time, starting with Wakanda. At first, T'Challa and his then wife Storm seemingly surrendered without a fuss. But this being T'Challa and Storm, it was of course part of a long con gambit to get rid of the Skrulls in one fell swoop.

After tricking the Skrulls into torturing their own men for information, the alien invaders send out their best warriors to hunt the king and queen down. And the minute the toughest warriors in their army are gone, an army of Wakandan soldiers bust in and kill everyone on the ship, leaving none alive. Meanwhile, Black Panther left barely enough behind of the Skrull warriors sent after him to fill a shoe box.

After killing all of the Skrulls who invaded his land? T'Challa used their blood to write a simple message on their bridge.

"This is what happens when you invade Wakanda."


8. Billy Butcher Vs Payback - The Boys #32

The Boys
Dynamite

If you want brutality to the point of absurdity, then you go to a Garth Ennis comic. While his work can be hit or miss at time, when a bad guy deserves to be brutalized, no one is better at coming up with the perfect method of delivering the punishment. This is the guy who wrote Preacher, after all.

And nowhere is this better displayed than in the original The Boys comics. Particularly issue #32, when Billy Butcher goes head to head with the Boys' parody of The Avengers, Payback.

Having helped the rest of The Boys escape, it's just Billy and his dog Terror against the most powerful supers in their world. But as Billy makes clear almost immediately, he's not trapped in an abandoned hospital with insanely powerful psychotic super powered fascists. They are trapped in there with HIM.

From strangling the Crimson Countess, to blinding Stormfront with a glass bottle, to impaling Swatto's skull with a pickaxe, we don't see the entirety of what the Butcher does to his enemies, but we see just enough to know that there won't be any survivors.


7. Daredevil Vs Bullseye - Daredevil #49

Daredevil Bullseye
Marvel Comics

Daredevil and Bullseye have gone head to head multiple times, after Frank Miller brought him back as a major threat back in the eighties. But nowhere did the master assassin and the Man Without Fear's rivalry blaze hotter than during Brian Michael Bendis and Alex Maleev's run on the character.

Daredevil has endured a lot from Bullseye over the years, but when the psychotic killer breaks into his home to murder his then girlfriend, Daredevil finally loses it. Bullseye has taken one woman he loved away from him, and he isn't keen on repeating that. The fight - like most Daredevil fights - is brutal and gritty, but eventually Matt gets the upper hand and just lays into Bullseye.

This isn't just Daredevil holding him down and beating him within an inch of his life - though make no mistake it is DEFINITELY that - but it's also Daredevil verbally assaulting him. As he beats him, he tells Bullseye that no one cares about him, that his mother never cared, his dad never cared, and even HE doesn't care about him. The only reason he doesn't kill Bullseye, he tells him, is because he just isn't worth the effort.

It's a savage display that makes you actually feel sorry for one of Marvel's most depraved baddies.


6. Luke Cage Vs The Purple Man - New Avengers #3

Luke Cage Purple Man Avengers
Marvel Comics

If there is any supervillain who deserves to be beaten into a bloody disgusting pulp, it's Zebediah Killgrave, The Purple Man. Hands down. And how sweet it is to watch when Luke Cage comes in to do the beating.

During a massive breakout that the New Avengers were trying to quell, Killgrave had escaped and come face to face with Luke. Seeing as how this was the man who mentally, physically and sexually abused his wife for over a year, Luke is practically giddy to have him all to himself. Killgrave seemingly gets the upper hand when he orders him to go kill the Avengers and then himself... until he realizes that he'd been drugged in jail, leaving him powerless.

Then Luke Cage tears him apart.

It's easily one of the most brutal beatings in all of comics, as Luke doesn't let up for a moment. By the time Captain America manages to stop him from killing the poor bastard, Killgrave likely wishes he had finished the job, as his face now resembled a burst grape.


5. X-23 Vs Zander Rice - X-23 #6

X23 Zander
Marvel Comics

Saying that X-23 has authority issues is like saying Shinji Ikari has daddy issues. But then, you'd be messed up too if you went through the weapon X program.

For those younger readers among us who love X-23's current adventures, it must be jarring to say the least to go back to her 2005 series or earlier appearances, because the difference in her attitude and emotional wellbeing is like night and day. And nowhere is this more evident than when she goes up against Dr. Zander Rice in X-23 #6.

Zander Rice was the lead scientist on the project that gave her her powers, so needless to say, they have a bit of unfinished business. With Rice's base minutes away from exploding, Laura is forced to choose between running away or using the time left to make sure Rice dies today. But when Rice shoots her in the back, the choice is made for her.

Laura doesn't even use her claws, sheathing them to make sure the last 11 minutes of Zander's life feel as long as possible. Zander spent so long taking out his anger at Wolverine on Laura, and all of that comes back to haunt him.


4. Daredevil Vs Kingpin - Daredevil #50

Daredevil Wilson Fisk Kingpin
Marvel Comics/Alex Maleev

If you thought that Daredevil savaging Bullseye was him at his lowest, you must be new to the world of Matt Murdock. Not even this is him at his absolute lowest (not for lack of trying).

The Kingpin is probably the only person that has earned a beating from Matt more than Bullseye, as anyone who has read the excellent Daredevil Born Again can tell you. So it only makes sense that there would come a point where the guy can't take it anymore and completely breaks under the pressure.

Since this is comic books, that break comes in the form of Daredevil absolutely savaging Wilson Fisk in front of all of his goons. While Fisk is able to put up a much better fight than he did against Spider-Man in One More Day, Daredevil takes everything Kingpin dishes out and gives twice as much back. And at the end, there's nothing but a beaten broken shell of a man once known as Wilson Fisk.

To prove how bad this was for him, Daredevil proceeds to take over all of the Kingpin's operations, realizing that if he can't stop crime in Hell's Kitchen, he might as well control it. He puts the fear of god into every criminal present and tells them to leave if they MUST continue their wrongdoing. An all new character low for Matt Murdock, but at least we finally got to see the Kingpin brought just as low in the process.


3. Harley Vs The Joker - Harley Quinn #25

Harley Quinn Joker
DC Comics

A big deciding factor of who goes where on this list is how anticipated the beatdown is. And boy howdy has the comic reading public been waiting for Harley to give Joker the business end of her mallet ever since she first appeared.

When Harley falls for and starts dating an actually somewhat stable guy (comparatively speaking) named Mason, she decides to bust him out of prison when he gets busted. Unfortunately, who should be there but the Joker, ready to put his hooks right back into Harley.

It doesn't work out for him. At all.

Harley mocks him for thinking his mind games would actually work, tells him that she has completely broken his hold on her, and then beats him within an inch of his miserable misbegotten life. And she even complains that she's doing that much, because their relationship has been defined by pain, so she feels like she's undoing a lot of the progress she's made by giving into her violent instincts when she came here with the intent of rescuing someone she actually cares for. She ends the beating by saying that she's done with him, done with all of it, and goes to find Mason.

Tragic, beautiful, brutal, and human. Words that perfectly describe both Quinn and this scene in particular.


2. Spider-Man Vs The Green Goblin - Spider-Man #40

Spider-Man Green Goblin
Marvel Comics

There are few moments in Spider-Man history that everyone agrees are true blue classics. But right there at the top is The Night Gwen Stacy Died. Obviously, such an act of murder and such a personal assault on Peter must be met with reprisal, yes? Oh dear god yes.

Before the Green Goblin can set into motion his plan to kill everyone else Spidey loves, the web-head interrupts his plans before they can begin, attacking Osborn with everything he's got. Then the Green Goblin finds a way to make his situation somehow worse by insulting Spidey's dead girlfriend and how he had failed to save her. Needless to say, Osborn doesn't last long after that life decision.

Spider-Man lays into the Goblin, screaming at him for taking away the woman he loved, how his life was finally getting back on track before he destroyed any chance of that happening again. Peter is only just barely able to stop himself from killing Osborn, realizing that killing the man would be letting him win. But Norman makes the decision for him, trying to impale Spidey with his goblin glider. And well... you all know how that ends for him.


1. Batman Vs The Joker - Batman: Hush

Batman Joker Hush
DC Comics/Jim Lee

There are more brutal villain beatdowns on this list - in fact if we were judging purely by the gore on display The Boys would win out easy - but none of them are as visceral and as frightening in its brutality as when Batman very nearly killed The Joker.

Most Batman fans know the story of Hush front to back, but let's give a refresher for those who weren't reading comics eighteen years ago. Batman's best buddy Tommy Elliot is back in Gotham, and not two minutes after he gets back does the Joker shoot and seemingly kill him. An event likely known in Gotham as "the welcome party".

This makes Bruce Wayne angry. This makes Bruce Wayne very angry indeed.

He suits up and hunts Joker down. Joker barely even gets a word in before Batman proceeds to tear the clown apart. It's only by Commissioner Gordon stepping in that Batman realizes what he's doing and manages to stop himself from breaking his one rule.

it was the first time in a long time that readers genuinely thought that this was going to be the day Batman killed the Joker. How could it not be the most savage villain beatdown in comic history?


Batman Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Joker?

Batman 1966 Joker Riddler Batman
Fox

1. Who Played The Joker In The Batman TV Show?

Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?