10 Most Controversial Superman Comics Of All Time

The all-American Boy Scout stands for Truth, Justice, and... destroying slums?

Superman Wonder Woman
DC Comics

Superman may have the power to lift a planet or crush a diamond with his bare hand but his true strength is his ability inspire hope in others. For over eighty years, the character has largely been considered to represent the purity and virtues of humanity. The emphasis is on the words "supposed to".

Due to gimmicky storylines, publicity stunts, and feuds between writers, the All-American Boyscout has also churned out some of the most ridiculous stories in the history of... well... stories.

But there are some tales that aren't just silly; they are insulting to the readers or offensive to entire cultures. Now, all the entries in this list had nothing but good intentions. The writers obviously don't want to upset their audience (usually).

Most of these comics were created because the publisher decided to go in a bold and different direction or the writing team wanted to tackle a current issue in the world, and things went wrong along the way. In one way or another, every entry on this list backfired big-time.

Here are list of the most controversial Superman moments which even die-hard comic fans still can't believe actually happened.

10. Superman Saves A City By Destroying It - Action Comics #8 + #12 (1939)

Superman Slum
DC Comics

Superman can go toe-to-toe with pretty much anyone but that doesn't mean he enjoys it. He understands you can't fix every problem by punching it.

Unfortunately, that's EXACTLY what the writers thought you could do during the 1930s. In the story, Superman in the Slums, the title hero convinces himself that people turn to crime if they were raised in a bad neighbourhood.

Instead of cleaning up the area, he destroys the poorest places he can find to "be rid of its filthy, crime-festering slums". What makes this tale more baffling is this was only a few years after the Great Depression, when millions of Americans were living in poverty.

Four issues later, Superman did pretty much the same thing. In the story, Superman Declares War on Reckless Drivers. Superman... literally does that.

After someone is killed by an oncoming car, Superman breaks into a radio station and vows that every reckless driver will answer to him. He then travels to several used-car lots and crushes all the automobiles. He then finds a car factory and rips open all of the equipment. The employees run for their lives as the whole building collapses. Thanks Supes. The world is saved.


9. Superdoom - Action Comics #9 (2012)

Super Doom
DC Comics

When DC rebooted under the New 52, visionary writer, Grant Morrison, was put in charge of the Superman series, Action Comics. Morrison may be a genius... but he also has a bit of a temper.

You see, the teaser for Man of Steel was released in July 2012. Morrison noticed the trailer used one of his quotes without his permission. He was so enraged, he wrote a comic the exact same month which encapsulated everything he hated about the movie industry.

His story, Curse of Superman, begins in a parallel universe where Clark Kent, Lois Lane, and Jimmy Olsen created a device which can manifest a physical form of their thoughts. When a corrupt corporation gets hold of the machine to try and create their own Superman, it goes insane and travels to different realities to kill all the "fake" Supermen.

Morrison couldn't have been less subtle with his metaphor. This evil Superman, which is called Superdoom, is described as “a violent, troubled, faceless anti-hero… a global market icon”. Superdoom states himself that he is “an unstoppable killer franchise”.

Readers and publishers were utterly bewildered Morrison jeopardised his run of Superman for such a petty reason.


8. Superman Abandons His Cousin - Action Comics #252-258 (1958)

Superman Supergirl
DC Comics

For years, Superman lamented how lonely it was being the only survivor of Krypton. You can imagine how exhilarated he must have been when he discovered his cousin, Kara, survived as well. When she came to Earth, Kara wanted to be a superhero just like her cousin, and took on the name Supergirl.

However, Superman believed she needed to train in order to harness her powers before she could reveal herself publicly, which does make perfect sense.

Too bad nothing else does in this story. Until Kara reveals her existence to the world, Superman left her in an orphanage. Why didn't he leave her in his house or in the Fortress of Solitude is anyone's guess.

Also, he didn't leave her there for a few weeks. She was in the orphanage for years! But it gets worse. After Supergirl revealed her powers to Superman's dog, Krypto, her cousin abandoned her on a remote asteroid.

It's odd how Superman complains how lonely he is but when he finally meets someone from his world, he does everything in his power to drive them away.


7. Lois Lane Turns Black - Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #106 (1970)

Superman S Girlfriend Lois Lane 106
DC Comics

In a particularly unusual comic issue, Lois Lane tries to write a story about an African-American ghetto in Metropolis called Little Africa. When she attempts to consult several citizens there, a black man called Dave Stevens orders his friends to ignore the "whitey".

Lois tells Superman she is frustrated that she can't write her story just because of her skin-colour. By a spectacular coincidence, Superman happens to have a pigment-changing device just lying around his home. After Lois is exposed to the machine's energy, she develops dark skin for twenty-four hours.

When she notices some of her white colleagues are ignoring her, Lois realises how different life is as an African-American. When she bumps into Dave Stephens again, she sees that he's a kind man who teaches children to stay positive when faced with racism. After Stephens is shot, Lois gives him a blood transfusion, saving his life.

When her skin reverts to normal and Stephens sees that Lois is white, he shakes her hand, realising he shouldn't have judged her for her skin. (For some reason, Stevens is completely unfazed that Lois is now white and doesn't ask how her skin changed colour.)

This story wasn't mean-spirited, but readers still found it inappropriate, patronising, and non-sensical.


6. Black Kryptonians - Superman #234 + #239 (1971)

Vathlo Island
DC Comics

Until the 1970s, characters in comic books were pre-dominantly white. For superhero film adaptions, many iconic white characters have been portrayed by African-Americans, including the Heimdall, MJ, and Baron Mordo.

After the African-American actor Colin Salmon, was cast as General Zod in the tv series, Krypton, comic fans started to wonder if black Kryptonians were totally absent in the Superman mythos.

Some avid readers scoured through comics to see if they could find any stories with dark-skinned Kryptonians... and then wish they didn't. The first black Kryptonian appeared in Superman #234 in 1971, appearing on the inked page in order to relay a message to the Kryptonian Council.

Superman #239 elaborated that the reason why dark-skinned Kryptonians were rarely seen was because they lived on a separate island called Vathlo. Although the island is rarely mentioned, Alan Moore wrote a story stating there was "racial trouble with the Vathlo Island immigrants".

When Mark Waid, who served as the studio-in-chief at DC, heard about Vathlo Island, he said it was "pretty embarrassing".


5. That Stupid Gun - Superman: At Earth's End (1995)

Earth's End
DC Comics

Superman: At Earth's End takes place in 2102AD, with the titular superhero pushing 130 years old. After witnessing human civilisation collapse for the second time, the Kryptonian must stop two Adolf Hitler clones take over the world with their army of Nazi bat-hybrids. If that sentence sounds like gibberish to you, don't worry. it doesn't make sense to anyone.

Superman teams up with a kid motorcycle gang to stop the Twin Hitlers from resurrecting history's most influential people including Albert Einstein, Lex Luthor and Elvis Presley. (No, really.)

Unsurprisingly, At Earth's End is considered one of the worst Superman stories of all time. The plot is so non-sensical, it sounds like the fan-fiction written by someone who had never read a Superman comic... or books in general.

What At Earth's End is most infamous her is the image of an elderly Superman using a quadruple mini-gun called The Expunger.

For over three-quarters of a century, Superman has been depicted as a beacon of peace and yet, the writers of this stinker thought it would be cool to give him the biggest gun in the history of guns. The artist was so proud of this image, he stuck it on the front cover.


4. Baby Superman - Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #57 (1965)

Baby Superman
DC Comics

During the 1960s, Superman couldn’t decide whether he should date Lois Lane or his first love, Lana Lang. The two women grew jealous of each other as they tried to win the heart of the Man of Steel.

One day, Lois discovers Superman has been turned into a toddler. Instead of helping him and making sure he doesn't get anyone killed, Lois and Lana try to condition him to be infatuated with them.

Lois shows the Superbaby pictures of Superman rescuing her throughout the years and hypnotises him to write, “ME LOVE LOIS” on a blackboard over and over.

Lana encourages him to put a ring on her finger over and over, believing he will instantly marry her the second he reverts to his adult form.

Since Supes is a child, he is prone to tantrums, forcing the women to discipline him when he's naughty. They spank him with a tennis racket and a hair brush, causing the utensils to shatter against his impervious body.

When the women bump into an adult Superman, they realise the baby they've been looking after was from a parallel universe, meaning all their schemes were for nothing. And, coincidentally, also incredibly disturbing, painting both women as outright villains.


3. The Power Couple

Superman Wonder Woman Kiss
DC Comics

When DC was rebooted under the New 52, the company knew they couldn't play it safe. They had to shake things up to get readers talking, so they experimented with the characters. The Flash, Wally West, went MIA. Barbara Gordon returned as Batgirl. Starfire and Lobo were redesigned (very badly).

A lot of these changes were frowned upon by readers including the decision to make Superman and Wonder Woman a couple. This idea has been explored in other stories including Kingdom Come and Injustice so readers were curious to see how The Power Couple would work in the main DC continuity.

Sadly, it just didn't fit. For years, Superman was constantly left vulnerable since supervillains kidnapped Lois Lane or used her as a pawn in their schemes. This dynamic was gone now that Supes' girlfriend was as invincible as he was. It felt like the writers forced the pair together as a gimmick, not realising their relationship works better on a platonic level.

When DC Comics was rebooted again in 2016, The Power Couple was retconned so it never happened, making the superheroes' relationship even more pointless.


2. Red/Blue Superman

Superman Redblue
DC Comics

To spice things up during the 1990s, DC Comics decided to completely change Superman’s powers. After Kal-El was deprived of solar power, he built a containment suit that granted him electronic powers, allowing him to conjure energy bolts and magnetic tractor beams. Supes could also switch his powers off and become a regular human being.

Many fans were unhappy with this change as it was not the same superhero they had followed for years. And this wasn't exactly a crime - DC had tried to do something different, and it didn't work. It was worth a try.

But what really ticked off readers was the fact that the writers refused to change Superman back. Instead, the writers gave Superman MORE powers. He split into two different Superman, one red and one blue.

After both Supermen acted rudely to Lois Lane, she kicked them out. The Supermen then fought each other to decide which of them should be for Lois. That's right, DC made a story that nobody liked - and instead of fixing it, they turned the main character into an unlikable stalker. After the comic sales continued to plummet, Superman reverted to his old self.


1. The Death Of Superman

Death of Superman
DC Comics

In the seven-part story arc, The Death of Superman, Supes encounters an unstoppable monster called Doomsday who effortlessly defeats the entire Justice League. Superman manages to kill the beast, but snuffs it immediately after due to his injuries.

This saga had the potential to be an incredibly emotional story if it wasn't clearly a publicity stunt. Supes was only in the ground for five minutes before DC Comics teased his resurrection. What's the point of killing him off if they're going to revive him immediately after? It gives his sacrifice little meaning.

Worse still, his return was milked for everything it was worth. After his funeral, four mysterious men appeared, insisting they were the real Superman. After months of speculation, it turns out the real Superman was... none of them! Well, that mystery was anti-climatic.

It turns out Superman was genuinely dead but his soul was alive (which doesn't make sense) and he was revived through Kryptonian technology.

To its credit, the story introduced great characters like Kon-El, Steel, Cyborg Superman, and Doomsday. It had terrific artwork and some of the most iconic splash panels in comics. But considering the amount of hype the story had, it could've been handled a lot better.


Watch Next


DC Quiz: How Well Do You ACTUALLY Know Superman?

Superman Batman Kryptonite
Warner Bros.

1. How Many Basic Types Of Krytponite Are There?

11

1

5

3

In this post: 
Superman
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows