10 Most Disturbing Comics Relationships

Bringing all the sordid secrets of super-folk.

Harleen Joker Harley Quinn
DC Comics/Stjepan Sejic

If people didn't like knowing weird things about famous people's relationships, gossip tabloids would have run out literal millennia ago. Be it harmless curiosity or depraved schadenfreude, people's private lives are fascinating to most - and this is something that carries through into knowing all the hot gossip about our favourite comic characters.

Or perhaps former favourite characters might be more appropriate, as many of the more mentally scarring comic relationships have the potential to really mar a character that you would otherwise love - until their inevitable retcon, as very few comic creators actively want to portray super creepy relationships aside from the ever-popular Joker and Harley Quinn.

Although seeing messed up relationships is weird, it also makes the universe seem all the more real for its bizarreness, by showing us that even iconic heroes can have strange and often disturbing pasts.

With huge age differences, mistreatment, and the occasional lifelong brainwashing scheme being surprisingly common, some comic relationships prove that adding superpowers to volatile people is almost invariably a recipe for disaster.

That, and also the fact that superheroes are officially the last people you should go to for relationship advice.

10. Talia Al Ghul And Batman

Talia Al Ghul Damian  Wayne
DC Comics

Being the child of parents who have had a nasty break up is never going to be a pleasant experience. When your father is a superhero, and your mother is a villainous terrorist who is willing to use you as a pawn to get back at him, however, the whole thing gets even worse than it would be already - which makes Damian Wayne's life really, really rough.

Forgetting that Talia actively hid Damian's existence from the Dark Knight for thirteen years - which is a pretty awful move regardless - the fact that so many comics involve her using their son as either leverage or an outright hostage against Batman is a solid reminder of just how callous Talia is to the man she is supposedly still in love with.

Talia wasn't worlds better when the pair were actively together either, as her insistence that Bruce join her father's evil organisation involved her both totally ignoring what the hero stands for, and also what he would want.

On the plus side, Damian ended up turning out pretty well, so there's at least a silver lining to be gleaned there.


9. Emma Frost And Cyclops

New X-Men Emma Frost Scott Summers Affair
Marvel Comics

As if the team involved in making the New X-Men were solely committed to ruining the marriage between Cyclops and Jean Gray, Grant Morrison's series included the fresh moment of hell that was Jean Grey discovering that her husband, Scott, had been having a psychic affair with Emma Frost - who, just to make matters worse, was in the iconic Dark Phoenix outfit when she and Scott were caught.

Both of the pair try to argue that this affair was only telepathic, but cheating through telepathy is still cheating, and the event serves to irreparably damage Jean and Scott's marriage for the rest of the series.

All this only serves to bring up the series of questionable events that Cyclops and Gray's relationship has had; as longtime fans will remember the infamously uncomfortable moment that had Cyclops making out with Frost at the side of Jean's grave.

Is an affair between Frost and Cylcops the one consistent factor of the X-Men universe? Only time will tell!


8. Reed Richards And Susan Storm

Reed Richards Slap Sue Storm
Marvel Comics

In a suitably infamous moment, the panel of Mister Fantastic slapping his wife is a pretty good symbol of their sketchy relationship. While the slap was ironically a quasi-justifiable action - as Sue was under mind control and needed to hate Reed to break out of it - the fact is that there were a series of other ways to accomplish this instead of immediately decided to slap your supposedly beloved wife.

Worse than this, though, is something more difficult to document, in the way Reed treats his wife all the time.

Sue is seldom updated on his often dangerous plans - which wouldn't necessarily be a big deal, if not for the fact they often place the lives of Reed, Sue, and their children at risk - and Sue tends to only discover this when her husband decides it suits him.

Being a married couple who are also superheroes is a scenario that would never be easy, but Mister Fantastic's passion for science often leaves him neglecting if not outright endangering his spouse and family, which isn't really okay.


7. Harley Quinn And Joker

joker harley quinn mad love
DC Comics

The Joker and Harley Quinn are pretty much the standard by which all other disturbing relationships can be measured. The Joker has beaten, maimed, belittled and outright tried to kill and ruin Harley's life many times in the comics - and yet the two are still commonly put back together as a relationship in various media all the time.

Justifiably, this is because both villains are at their villainous peak when they're also being awful to one another.

While this can vary between the cruelty being surreally comedic - as was the case in the more cartoon series like Mad Love - or be played nightmarishly straight, there's always a vaguely disturbing element to the fact that the pair are as inseparable as they are bad for each other.

Lately Harley has featured in comics that place her further and further away from being the Joker's sidekick-slash-punching-bag (to the point where she's been in a regular relationship with Poison Ivy), and while this trend is a more than welcome one, it's a surefire thing that even her solo work will repeatedly reference the unhealthy relationship she had with the Joker.


6. Magneto And Rogue

Rogue Magneto
Marvel Comics

While - mercifully - Rogue is an adult during her relationship with Magneto, that doesn't stop their tryst from being entirely weird on several levels. Firstly, Magneto is old enough to be her grandfather, and secondly he has also known her since his childhood, and served as one of Rogue's mentors from her teens to adulthood.

As someone with a pretty paternal role in Anna Marie's life, it seems completely morally corrupt - and also super, super gross - that at no point does Magneto appear to consider how sketchy it is to have a relationship with a woman he taught practically from childhood, to the extent that he actually proposes to her in the X-Men: Legacy series.

It's more than a little surprising that none of the X-Men ever refer to how dazzlingly creepy it is that one of their oldest teachers - and occasional enemies - totally has a thing with one of his ex-students.

That said, the 1963 X-Men comic suggested that Charles Xavier was in love with Jean Grey, so maybe Magneto just hasn't gotten the rewrite he so sorely deserves.


5. Hank Pym And Janet Van Dyne

Hank Pym Wasp
Marvel Comics

There are few moments that have ruined a character for such a long time as Yellowjacket - better known as Hank Pym - than his decision to backhand his wife during her attempts to console him about being kicked out of the Avengers.

It received widespread fan backlash, and ended up being such a well-remembered moment featuring the character that it created the Irredeemable Ant-Man series, and then led to continued hate for the character that carried pretty much up until the release of the MCU Ant-Man films and related series some thirty years later.

Even then, the character required a total revamp, as few people were comfortable buying a comic starring or featuring such a controversial figure.

While hardcore fans still argue that the panel was not initially intended to show Hank purposefully and forcefully slapping Janet, as the writer intended for Hank to accidentally shove or slap her while turning to face her, the fact is it did still happen on panel - and so put a pretty sour note on the two's relationship for a long time afterwards.


4. Tarantula And Dick Grayson

Nightwing Tarantula
DC Comics

Pretty much every single comic with Tarantula in serves to further prove that Tarantula isn't a hero - because anyone who does so much genuinely terrible stuff cannot feasibly be placed under such a title.

For anyone unconvinced, Nightwing #93 covers Tarantula's murder of Blockbuster, and her subsequent sexual assault of a traumatised Dick Grayson. While Nightwing doesn't stop her from the murder, this is only because Blockbuster is literally at that moment telling him that he will 'never stop' killing his loved ones.

Realising he has broken his moral code, Nightwing breaks down, running to the roof while clearly having a full scale panic attack. Not only does Tarantula fail to even attempt to help him, she takes this moment to become the worst human ever, and decides to try and have sex with him while he mumbles apologies and requests for her to not touch him.

Although Tarantula is absolute garbage, her character does serve to emphasise an important point - that even the 'good guys' and people tasked with helping people can do some genuinely awful things at the same time.


3. Slade And Terra

Slade Terra
DC Comics

The subject of Slade's indescribably questionable relationship with the Teen Titans mole, Terra, has been the subject of much controversy and fan misery for some time.

While canonically there has always been a unsavoury element to the pair's interactions, writer vary between making this explicitly sexual, or merely a case of the villain blackmailing the girl into betraying the Titans - so there's no ideal scenario either way.

While it seemed for some time like this disturbing relationship would be written out of existence, Deathstroke #27 features Terra going through the exact same relationship as she had prior with the man, only she's sixteen, which apparently makes everything totally okay, despite the fact it forcefully reminds us of the whole terrible past the two have.

Given that DC appear to be warming towards the idea of Deathstroke becoming far more heroic, it'd probably be wise for this whole sordid affair to perhaps disappear from history - and ideally never be talked about again.


2. Purple Man And Melanie Killgrave

Melanie Killgrave
Marvel Comics

When people remember the awful, awful ways that Zebidiah Killgrave - known better as the Purple Man - used his mind control powers to force women to be with him, generally the focus is on the superhero Jessica Jones and her struggles with him.

But there is actually a relationship that is far worse than that. Melanie Killgrave was the Purple Man's wife for the majority of her adult life, and this entire time, she was only anywhere near the villain because he had used his powers to make her marry and love him.

Not only is the amount of time Melanie spent under his control terrifying, but also her inability to have any way to fight back means that the whole thing feels like a horror story more than any glimpse at romance.

Where Jessica Jones would be rescued from Purple Man's control over her, Melanie would have to wait until Killgrave released her from his control on a whim, believing that she must be in love with him. Unsurprisingly, the mental kidnap did not constitute the basis for a real relationship, and thus Melanie fled.


1. Hal Jordan And Arisia Rrab

Arisia Rrab Hal Jordan
DC Comics

The only logical reason for Arisia Rrab's character arc in Green Lantern is that someone working there must have made some secret demonic pact with Beelzebub, promising to create the single most disturbing romance in comics ever, as there's no other way for Hal Jordan to have technically ended up in a long term relationship with a thirteen year old girl.

Because, when Hal first meets Arisia, she is his 'little sister' - a young member of the Green Lanterns with a child-like crush on the hero, which Hal naturally rejects to teach her about the kind of boundaries adults need to have with children.

Then Arisia manages to use her ring to 'age her up', and Hal looses literally any and all credibility and dates her. Because apparently, all that matters is that Arisia looks like an adult - which totally ignores the fact that it's still the brain of a thirteen year old piloting the whole thing.

It's things like this that almost make us glad the DC universe has been retconned twice since.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.