10 Most Evil Versions Of Batman

The dark knight's darkest incarnations.

Batman Evil
DC Comics

Although the focus on evil versions of superheroes has of late been on Superman, his Gotham-based ally Batman has almost just as many.

Simply put, the idea of an evil Batman is too tantalizing not to broach from time to time. Whether you're doing an alternate version of Bruce Wayne, or someone else entirely who thinks they know what the cape and cowl stands for but couldn't be more wrong, seeing one of the medium's most prominent symbols of justice be turned into something altogether more ruthless and depraved is almost always intriguing.

But of course, some evil versions of Batman are more evil than others, and as comics continue to delve into darker territory with each passing year, the frequency in which these villainous Batmen have appeared on the page has continued to increase...

10. Azrael

Jean-Paul Valley Azrael Batman
DC Comics

After Bane breaks Batman's back, Azrael - the Bat-fandom's problematic fave before Jason Todd dug himself out of his grave and discovered his leather fetish - decides to take over the mantle until Bruce is feeling better.

Since we're talking about a broken back here, that recovery takes a good while, even with the best medical care Bruce can afford, so Azrael gets plenty of time in the cape and cowl to go absolutely flippin crazy with power, even redesigning the suit into a nineties monstrosity comprised of as many pointy edges as possible.

Azrael does everything that batman considers an absolute no-no while in the suit. He maims, he tortures, he rips apart every criminal he comes across, even the ones only guilty of minor offences.

In short, Azrael becomes the perfect nightmare of what Batman's detractors say he is - even if he did manage to wrest control of Gotham away from Bane.


9. Dawnbreaker Batman

Dark Nights Batman The Dawnbreaker
DC Comics

Frankly this list wouldn't be even half as long as it is without Dark Knights Metal, which introduced the Dark Multiverse, a classification given to alternate realities that represent absolute worst case scenarios - universes with no future because things really have just gone that wrong.

This event's sole reason for existence seemed to be balancing the scales on how many evil versions of Superman there were by giving us arguably too many evil Batmen for one list.

This version of Bruce Wayne - the Dawnbreaker - completely shut down emotionally in the moment his parents died, losing all emotion including fear. Which, of course, attracted the Green Lantern Corps to him.

Yeah... no surprise that giving a straight up sociopath all the power in the universe was not the smartest move on the part of the Guardians. Bruce used his power to track down Joe Chill, even overriding the Lantern Ring with his own evil willpower to make it his own, killing Chill in the process.

When the Corps tried to take his ring away, he killed all of them too, ascending into a higher being made of malice and hatred known as the Dawnbreaker.


8. Devastator Batman

Batman Devastator
DC Comics

So a few years ago the Superman comics introduced the Doomsday virus. It was basically an explanation as to why this big bony villain keeps on coming back no matter how many times Superman punches him into space. It does exactly what it says it does - it turns you into Doomsday. It even got Superman for a hot minute there.

But in Dark Knights: Metal, we're presented with a fascinating scenario: what if it got Batman instead?

When Superman of Earth -1 just completely loses his marbles and goes on a killing spree, Batman - out of pure desperation - gives one final go at stopping him by ingesting the last remaining vial of the Doomsday virus. This permanently transforms him into the Devastator, a wicked hybrid of Batman and Doomsday that easily trounces the insane Superman.

However, it's called the Doomsday VIRUS for a reason, so it's not long before everyone else is infected with the virus too. Oh, and to top it all off, the virus drives you irreparably insane.

There's barely anything of Bruce left by the time we meet him in the Dark Knights: Metal event. Merely a mad drive to make everyone see that Superman is not the boy scout everyone thinks he is.


7. The Murder Machine

Batman Murder Machine
DC Comics

Many like to accuse Bruce of being robotic in personality and behavior, but as The Murder Machine showcases, a robot Batman would be way worse than anyone could have predicted.

When Alfred is murdered by Batman's rogues gallery, he and cyborg construct an AI resembling Alfred's personality and mannerisms to both perform the duties Alfred used to, as well as help Bruce to cope with the loss of his surrogate father. However, The Alfred Protocol - programmed to help Bruce however it felt was most efficient - decided to first murder everyone in Arkham Asylum, and then take over Bruce's mind when the AI decided that Bruce was as much a danger to himself as anyone else.

His body now under the control of The Alfred Protocol, Bruce was subjected to a brutal surgical removal of everything the AI deemed weak, such as his frail human body, and any emotions that would make him hesitate in his quest.

When the Justice League protested, the Murder Machine, as it took to calling itself, proceeded to brutally massacre them.


6. Batman The Merciless

Batman: The Merciless
DC Comics

DC and Marvel make having every god of every religion exist simultaneously seem way more fun than it probably would actually be. Seems to me that such a setup would be bound to explode in everyone's collective faces at some point or another.

...And Batman The Merciless would probably agree with me on that.

On this Batman's Earth, Ares - God of war - had finally gone off the deep end, overthrown the Greek gods, and turned his warmongering on Earth, using a specially made helmet that increased his powers a hundredfold. Naturally, Batman and Wonder Woman are the last ones standing, just barely managing to get the helmet off of Ares.

And if this wasn't the Dark Multiverse, that would be the end of it. But Bruce, upon holding the helmet, feels the power within it and puts it on for himself, arrogantly believing he would be able to control it rather than the other way around.

Shock of all shocks, he wasn't, and he brutally murders Diana when she tries to get it off of him next. Also in this reality, Bruce and Diana were lovers, making it that much more of a dick move on Bruce's part.


5. The Red Death

The Flash Red Death
DC Comics

This incarnation of Batman is probably the scummiest of Barbatos' Dark Knights next to the entry you know damn well is coming in a bit.

This version of Bruce, after losing everyone he cared about in his war on crime, decided that he could make a lot more use out of the Speed Force than that wimp Barry Allen ever could, and so stole Flash's cosmic treadmill, duct taped it to his Batmobile, tied Barry to the Batmobile's hood, and drove them both into the Speed Force, fusing the two together into a single being known as The Red Death.

This Batman not only betrayed his best friend, taking away his free will and forcibly fusing their bodies together against his will, but then proceeded to use The Flash's powers in a way that goes against everything he believes in.

Oh, and Barry is still alive, screaming in Bruce's mind in a vain attempt to get him to stop.


4. Vampire Batman

Batman Crimson Mist
DC Comics

Yes, believe it or not, there were evil or at least darker versions of Batman BEFORE Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo worked their headbanging heavy metal magic. One of the most famous of these earlier examples is the elseworlds Batman and Dracula trilogy.

In it, Batman takes on the prince of darkness and, though triumphant, ends up being turned into a vampire himself. He then spends the rest of the trilogy slowly losing himself to the vampiric hunger.

In the process, Batman ends up supernaturally screwing over just about everyone in his life, sometimes just by messing with their lives with his mere vampiric presence, other times - in the case of James Gordon and most of his rogues gallery - by straight up killing them.

While this Batman isn't full on evil due to him trying as hard as possible to avoid giving into the hunger, a lot of good folks still die because of his actions due to his very nature as a vampire, so it definitely counts here.


3. Leatherwing

Batman Leatherwing
DC Comics

For those not in the know, say hello to Leatherwing, otherwise known as Nazi Batman.

We don't actually know a whole lot about him, seeing as how he hasn't appeared that many times, and has never been the focus when he did. All we do know is that the Earth he hails from, Earth 10, is the version of Earth where the Nazis won WWII, and the Justice League are the Axis Powers' personal enforcers. So it isn't hard to get him not being a cool guy from that setup.

Like all Nazis, Leatherwing is bottomlessly racist, untrustworthy, nowhere near as intelligent as he believes himself to be, ruthless, and evil to his very core.


2. Owlman

DC Comics Owlman
DC Comics

There have been lots of versions of Owlman in the many decades this character has been a thing, but the Earth-3 interpretation of him remains the best.

In it, Owlman is Thomas Wayne Jr. - the eldest son of Thomas and Martha Wayne, and Bruce's older brother. When Thomas decided as a boy that his parents weren't using their vast wealth quite the way he would, he had them killed at the hands of the much more evil Alfred.

When young Bruce - the only member of the Wayne family that Thomas genuinely loved - didn't agree with this plan, Thomas killed him himself.

Thomas would later become the villainous Owlman to secure his tyrannical hold on Gotham city in the places that his predatory capitalism couldn't reach.

Owlman is an egomaniacal nihilistic psychopath who thinks only of his own gain and has zero qualms about torturing, maiming, and murdering whoever he has to in order to get what he wants.


1. The Batman Who Laughs

The Batman Who Laughs
DC Comics

Of course it's this jerk-face - don't act shocked.

The leader of Barbatos' Dark Knights, The Batman Who Laughs has become something of an icon in and of himself, being the new super baddie that DC can whip out whenever they feel like. But in the original Dark Knights: Metal event, he was every bit as terrifying as fans say he was.

This version of Batman is probably the most nightmarish in the entire Dark Knights lineup, and that is some steep ass competition. When The Joker tore Gotham apart and killed commissioner Gordon, among MANY others, Batman finally murdered the clown by breaking his neck.

However, that was exactly what The Joker wanted, as upon his death, a spray of Joker toxin shot right at Batman's face. This, of course, not only drove him insane - it drove him JOKER levels of insane, resulting in a Batman who has the morals of The Joker (that is to say none whatsoever), and the training and intellect of Batman.

Yeah... the uhh... the Justice League doesn't last very long after this.

The Batman Who Laughs is the perfect nightmare for Bruce Wayne, literally everything he is afraid of becoming embodied in one sick, depraved madman. How could any other Batman possibly be more evil?


Watch Next


DC Quiz: How Well Do You ACTUALLY Know Batman?

Batman Robin Dick Sprang
DC Comics/Dick Sprang

1. In What Comic Did Batman First Appear?

Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?