10 Most Heartbreaking Moments In Justice League History

Even the Justice League have faced their fair share of trauma and heartbreak.

The best Flash Comics
DC Comics

The Justice League, to many, are the gold standard when it comes to superhero teams. In fact, when it comes to pop culture significance they are probably the benchmark for any kind of team-up. They are the ultimate collection of elites, an unstoppable force for good that no evil could ever bend. Except, of course, all the times evil has totally corrupted and broken them, but that's not the point.

However, given how long they have been around, it goes without saying the League has met its fair share of difficult circumstances over the years. And when something bad happens to the Justice League or its members, it usually sends shockwaves through the entire superhero fandom.

From stunning betrayals of trusted heroes to even the invincible succumbing to mortality, these are some of the most unforgettable moments in all of comics. And here I’ll be counting down the worst of them.

So enough with the huffing and puffing already, let’s dust off that blood soaked cape and fire up the destroyed Batmobile engine and get straight into the heart of it. These are the some of the most heartbreaking moments in Justice League history.

10. Red Tornado Loses His True Self

Red Tornado
DC Comics

During Infinity Crisis, Red Tornado - or his body at least - was destroyed during a mission in space. After the pieces of his former mechanical self do return to earth, they're repaired and looked after by Kathy Sutton. Unfortunately, unlike previous times, Tornado’s soul does not return to the body once it is repaired.

Then it is revealed that Solomon Grundy of all people was behind this. He, along with Professor Ivo, wanted to steal Tornado’s body and fuse it with a number of special components so as to create the ultimate vessel for housing Grundy’s soul.

In the end, the Justice League is able to overcome the bad guys of course and Zatanna undoes the spell keeping Tornado away from his mechanical body. However that is when the real tragedy strikes.

Because after re-inhabiting his old form, Red Tornado is no longer who he used to be. His consciousness appeared to have been altered, he no longer cares about his friends and family and even his powers become erratic.

To see a character that had been one of the shining examples of how kindness and heroism are always a choice and can come from anyone become a cold, heartless being was absolutely heart-shattering.


9. Nightwing's Death (Sort Of)

Nightwing Identity Forever Evil
DC Comics

The highly anticipated follow-up to Trinity War, Forever Evil saw the Justice League battle it out with the Crime Syndicate from Earth-3, led by their Alfred Pennyworth. As the storyline proceeds, it is revealed that the bad guys held Nightwing as their prisoner.

The climax sees Batman together with Lex Luthor and others arrive at the Watchtower where the Syndicate had been camped. They find Dick placed in a Murder Machine, which in turn served as the trigger switch for a bomb. The only way to prevent it from detonating was if Grayson’s heart were to stop.

Despite Batman’s best efforts, Luthor is able to prevent the Dark Knight from saving his original protégé, leaving the once Boy Wonder to die in order to save to everyone else.

Now yes, this gets overturned eventually, as Lex himself revives Dick. But the emotional trauma, the impossibly high stakes nature of this moment still makes it intensely emotional still.


8. Martian Manhunter Is Killed

Martian Manhunter
DC Comics

During Final Crisis, J’onn J’onzz - aka Martian Manhunter - who had been captured beforehand while undercover, is brought before the Secret Society of Supervillains.

There, the newcomer Libra, in reality under instructions from the Human Flame, stabs J’onn with a special staff in order to establish his villainous worth; the strike proving enough to slay the mighty Martian.

Before leaving the material world, J’onn takes up his true form one last time, and even manages to communicate with the Justice League, passing on the knowledge of his people so that it doesn’t die with him.

Afterwards the League arranges funeral on Mars, one befitting their friend, with Superman himself sharing a final tribute to their fallen comrade.


7. Sue Dibny's Murder

Sue Dibny Funeral
DC Comics

Sue Dibny’s death remains one of the most tragic and sometimes critically panned in all of comics. The wife of Elongated Man aka Ralph Dibny, Sue enjoyed a lovely marriage with her husband, and even served on the Justice League herself.

During the Identity Crisis arc, while Ralph is away on a mission, Sue is mysteriously murdered in her own room. Ralph comes home to make the heartbreaking discovery, with burn marks the only clue relating to the cause of death.

This kicks off a full blown murder mystery with the entire League determined to find the killer. In reality though, this was all about the cruel nature of her passing and the taste it left in all our mouths. Subsequently, the storyline has also been bashed by sections of the fanbase, with many calling out DC for simply using one character’s death as a means of furthering the persona of another, i.e. Ralph.

Setting aside all that however, it was heart-wrenching then, and it is still heart-wrenching now.


6. Superman Burns Out Shazam's Eyes

Superman Shazam Captain Marvel
DC Comics

The Injustice games and their tie-in comics were DC at its most violent. While superheroes losing sight of the line between right and wrong is surprisingly common, very rarely does it lead to this level of brutality.

It's worth prefacing this by explaining that the premise of Injustice is that the Joker has managed to trick Supes into killing his wife and their unborn child.

Normally, this would drive any man into despair. However, when said man is also the Man of Steel, the potential after-effects can be catastrophic. Following the killings, the Man of Steel completely flies off the handle and decides it’s time to change the world by force.

Sensing that Clark was heading towards establishing a totalitarian regime over the earth, Shazam squares up to his once brother-in-arms. Superman’s response? Burn Shazam’s eyes out with his heat vision.

It was a direction setting moment for how the rest of the story would go, and boy oh boy did it deliver on that and then some.


5. The Atom Walks Away From Jean Loring

Identity Crisis Atom Jean Loring
DC Comics

Identity Crisis was without a doubt one of the most emotionally straining comics ever created. Even aside from the central tragedy surrounding Sue Dibny’s murder, there were a number of other revelations and moments that made readers wince. None more so perhaps than this one right here.

Right at the end, the heroes are able to deduce that the Atom, i.e. Ray Palmer’s ex-wife Jean Loring is the one behind Sue’s death. The truth turns out to be more disturbing than anyone had predicted, as Sue wasn’t killed as part of some grand super villain plan designed at targeting the League - it was orchestrated by Loring to get Ray to come back to her.

It was incredibly convoluted and meant Sue’s death was even sadder than initially felt, because she didn’t in some great plot, she died for absolutely no reason at all thanks Loring’s misguided quest for love. Atom then proceeds to bring his former spouse crashing down to reality, describing her as insane and leaving her to be carted off to Arkham. A depressing affair all around.


4. Supergirl's Sacrifice

Supergirl Death
DC Comics

Crisis on Infinite Earths did not lack for brutality and sacrifices. One of the most prominent of which was the death of Supergirl, aka Superman’s dear cousin, at the hands of the Anti-Monitor.

The heroes were of course fighting to save the multiverse from annihilation and during the culmination of the iconic arc, Kara was forced to do battle with the evil cosmic entity in order to try and save her friends, ultimately resulting in them watching her die.

In terms of storyline, this was the perfect sacrifice that helped with the continuity clean-up that was the main point behind Crisis. In terms of tugging on our heartstrings, this exerted more strain than perhaps desired by us.


3. Batman Receives A Letter From His Father

Flashpoint Batman Thomas Wayne
DC Comics

The Flashpoint comics had absolutely everything you would want from a superhero story. Heroes battling their past demons, people having to redeem themselves, and the good guys overcoming insurmountable odds. The best (or saddest) was perhaps saved for last.

Right at the end, after an alternate universe Thomas Wayne is able to Barry to run back in time to change everything, he also gives the Scarlet Speedster a letter. A letter addressed to his son Bruce, who in this timeline was killed in the alley instead of his parents.

After straining every fibre of his Speed Force being, Flash is able to put the world back to the way it was (kind of). And then, he went to visit Batman.

Barry gives Bruce the letter where Thomas tells his son how much he loved him, how much he wished he could be there to see him, and how happy he was with the kind of man and the kind of hero Bruce became. I’m not crying, you’re crying.


2. The Fight Against The Black Lantern Zombies

Blackest Night DC
DC Comics

Blackest Night was a refreshing, yet brutal, update to the Green Lantern mythos and gave us one of the biggest friends-turning-into-foes storylines in comic book history. The premise focused on a mysterious presence that is awakened after two Green Lanterns interact with the Black Central Power Battery.

Then, an ominous group of asteroids appear, which release a massive number of Black Lantern rings into the universe. The Guardians on Oa see this, but before they can act, they are attacked by the evil Scar.

The rings arrive on Oa and flood the crypts. Their power reanimates the deceased Lanterns as blood thirsty zombies, powered of course by the Black Rings. Inevitably the fight reaches earth where the rings start reviving dead superheroes, as the army of zombie Lanterns continues to expand.

Eventually the League and pretty much every other superhero must unite to stand a chance. While the universal level stakes were nothing uncommon, the sight of these heroes having to battle the demonised versions of the friends whose losses they once mourned was equal parts jarring and heartbreaking.


1. The Death Of Barry Allen

Death Of Barry Allen Crisis On Infinite Earths 8
DC Comics

Crisis on Infinite Earths is seen by many as the single greatest DC crossover event in history. Sure, these days DC seems to do a continuity reboot every Sunday, but back then this was a never-before-seen kind of grand storyline. And to this day, it holds a place of its own in the pantheon of iconic comic book arcs.

The central figure in the crossover was of course the Anti-Monitor, determined to destroy all matter universes and become the sole ruler of a new antimatter multiverse/universe thing. Standing in his way is his counterpart, the Monitor, joined by a collection of the greatest heroes from across the multiverse.

After leading a successful attack on the Anti-Monitor’s base, the heroes manage to bring about a temporary end to the battles. However, Big Bad Anti-Monitor uses this time to create a new body and find himself a new weapon, the antimatter cannon. Just as he is about to use it to destroy the remaining earths, in swoops Barry Allen, aka Flash, aka the Scarlet Speedster.

Faced with impossible odds, Barry has no choice but to sacrifice himself in the process of stopping the Anti-Monitor’s plan. What makes this death so significant is that unlike most comic book demises - which typically last less time than the expiry date of sliced bread - this one actually stuck. Barry was gone from the DC continuity for twenty-three whole years.

For the sheer weight of the moment and the subsequent consequences, this was perhaps the most heartbreaking moment in Justice League history.


Watch Next


Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Remember Justice League: Unlimited?

Flash Justice League Cartoon
Warner Bros.

1. Who Provided The Voice For The Flash?

Contributor
Contributor

After battling Galactus and pinning Hulk Hogan in the main event of Wrestlemania, I've taken a break from living in fantasy worlds, to focus on writing about them. I'm a comic book geek, a wrestling mark, a break dancer, and a scientist. One of those things may not be true.