10 Most Questionable Comics Kickstarters

"I'll hold the project, Charlie Brown, and you come running up and Kickstart it!"

Kickstarter has changed the face of comics creation, bringing crowdfunding to the crowds. Now every cartoonist, not just the big names, can now treat their fan base as a group of investors, funding new and exciting projects together. That's the dream, anyway. And in fact, comics are one of Kickstarter's most successful divisions, with almost exactly half of all projects funded. And half that aren't. Archie Comics came down on the wrong side of the pile recently by trying to Kickstart its reboots for Jughead, Betty and Veronica, and Kevin Keller as if they were tiny indie books, only with a collective $350,000 price tag that even the company's growing fan base wasn't going to pay for. To Archie's credit, it acknowledged the negative feedback and quickly pulled the project. It also promised to continue the relaunches, just on a different schedule. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2096518612/riverdale-reborn As it turns out, Archie is far from the worst offender when it comes to misusing Kickstarter. Here are ten better examples of companies or individuals that inspire either skepticism or severe pledger's remorse.

10. Tezuka's World Release (Goal: $380,000/Pledged: $26,971)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/digitalmanga/tezukas-world-release-publishing-osamu-tezuka-mang?ref=nav_search Digital Manga, unlike Archie, has a bit more of a history with successful Kickstarters, so they had to know they were rolling some pretty big dice trying to kickstart 31 Osamu Tezuka translations at once. Tezuka's reputation in manga cannot be overstated, but his work can, apparently, be overpriced. Digital Manga regrouped and repackaged its ambitions in a set of smaller-scale Kickstarters, three so far, all successful. Note that this is not the only time a Tezuka translation led to disappointment. The translation project for The Crater has a long story, but C. Spike Trotman sums it up rather neatly. https://twitter.com/iron_spike/status/525427060572180480

9. Penny Arcade Ad-Free (Goal: $250,000... Or $1,000,000/Pledged: $528,144)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/pennyarcade/penny-arcade-sells-out?ref=nav_search People don't like ads. How much do you not like ads? Are you willing to help raise a quarter of a million dollars so that your favorite website can stop featuring ads... on some of its secondary pages, but not the page you're most likely to read? Or how about one buck shy of a million to make the site completely ad-free? For a year? Seems like a ludicrous, ridiculous waste of money, right? Well, not if you're Tycho and Gabe of Penny Arcade, circa 2012. Credit where it's due: this is the best-produced Kickstarter video you'll find here, displaying the sense of humor that made Penny Arcade a webcomics hit. And the Kickstarter was a qualified success, topping out at $528,144, enough to take HALF the ads off the site for a year. But, as Tycho himself admitted after the year was up, most people don't care about ads, and because the ads in Penny Arcade were carefully curated, many Penny Arcade fans actually missed them! You could argue that raising so much money was clear evidence that other fans wanted what Penny Arcade was offering, even if they did have to add more content-related stretch goals to get that far. But that's not the point. The point is that those loyal fans shelling out money in support of Penny Arcade would have been much happier if their money were being used to make new things, not just put the old ones into slightly less cluttered layouts. The company's second venture into crowdfunding seemed to learn from this. It had a $10 goal and far more enticing stretch goals right at the start: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/pennyarcade/penny-arcades-podcast-downloadable-content-the-ret/description

8. Queen Of Hearts (Goal: $2,200/Pledged: $121)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1685499873/queen-of-hearts-0/description In a world where genetic cloning and altering is illegal, a special government force, headed by Queen of Hearts, is empowered with the law to exterminate monsters, mad scientists and terrorists by any means necessary. So far, so good, but this pitch doesn't explain the few wildly different, distorted sketches presented in the video: Queen of Hearts and her friends look different from frame to frame. Were different artists commissioned? The real problem, though, is that Jeff Donovan Wade's long, negative rant-- paragraph after paragraph about everything from the lack of support he gets from friends and family to the use of shaky-cam in Hollywood-- will leave you thoroughly underconfident that he'll follow through on his promises. That, and his reward tiers focus on tchotchkes while leaving the comic digital only and completely free, reducing the incentive to pledge for those who simply want the comic. His backup plan, to Kickstart the project one page at a time, is pretty questionable too. Finally, while the commissioned art looks decent enough, Wade's primary experience with writing is this strange Marvel fanfic, in which Iron Man is somehow an X-Man and Professor X is pretty unconcerned about property damage and loss of life.

7. Magnificent Kaaboom (Goal: $5,000/Pledged: $0 or $15)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/magnificentkaaboom/the-magnificent-kaaboom-comic-book?ref=discovery Dean Gunnarson offered an overpriced comic book, but what about an overpriced comic book and DVD that also look terrible?
Magnificent Kaaboom!!! will mark the resurgence of the comic book. When the world has been shaven by a drunken barber, Magnificent Kaaboom!!! will grab planet earth by the throat, forcing it to heal, no longer aimlessly wondering like the last mosquito of fall attempting to flutter away and out run the season of winter. Akin to Dorothy walking through the threshold of gray into a universe of color, Magnificent Kaaboom!!! will power the elements of communication and entertainment to regain their attention spans. In a cereal bowl full of memories, Magnificent Kaaboom!!! will be the marsh mellows €“ the best part.
It takes a special kind of persistence to post virtually the same Kickstarter three times in a row, with no alterations except slightly reshuffled stretch goals and, at the end of the third try, a claim that simply buying the book will make you a part of history, effectively immortal. There's a little bit in there about the plot-- something about an accountant falling through his toilet to another dimension where he becomes a tentacle-legged great white hope-- but it's hard to retain it after seeing the end of the video, which shows you a dead, bloodied Road Runner before warning you that if you fail to read this book, you will get cancer and die. Cancer rates must have been surging that year. Zachary Whitmore finally made his project without Kickstarter's help, and then...

6. Magnificent Kaaboom Combat Models (Goal: $50,000/Pledged: $31)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/magnificentkaaboom/magnificent-kaaboom-combat-models?ref=users ...he naturally came back to Kickstarter for merchandising. By the time he made this video, a few years later, Whitmore seems to have abandoned all pretense of expecting to get funded, as evidenced by reward levels of $1,000 and $10,000 (and nothing any lower) and mentioning that his product's paint might cause birth defects. That relaxation makes the video's humor a lot more relaxed, and as entertainment, it more or less succeeds. But as an incentive to give funding, well... no.

5. The Ultimate Comic Anthology (Goal: $200,000/Pledged: $14)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/197404798/the-ultimate-comic-anthology-by-comic-bowl-and-you?ref=nav_search You've got to like this one, right? Because it's "by you!" Eric Stock seemed to have heard of "user-generated content" about five minutes before conceiving this idea and replied, "Huh, why hasn't anyone ever tried to do anything like that with comics?" While his intent not to take any rights away from artists and share profits is admirable, such basic good intentions are not nearly enough to attract talent to an anthology. Stock seems to have no plan to do so beyond calling his anthology ultimate yet guaranteeing some level of publication to anyone who bothers to submit, while relying on crowdsourcing to read and rank all the submissions too. In short, his plan amounts to hoping the Internet comes together not only to fund his project but to do almost all the work for him. And then there are the video's bizarre musical choices.

4. John Campbell's Sad Pictures For Children (Goal: $8,000/Pledged: $51,615)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/73258510/sad-pictures-for-children/ Nothing that happened during this Kickstarter to publish a second collection of the Pictures for Sad Children webcomic (not a typo: the title words were reshuffled for Volume 2) was particularly questionable. What stung was what happened after. Despite receiving funding far in excess of his original goal, Campbell apparently didn't have enough, when all was said and done, to ship every book. Struggling with depression, financial pressure, and what seems likely to be further mental illness, Campbell revolted against not only the expectations of him, but his own career and capitalism itself. He destroyed a reported 127 books in a bonfire, which he filmed. He posted the video along with a screed titled "IT'S OVER" and subtitled "AFFLUENT PEOPLE: PLEASE DEFEND YOUR DESIRE FOR AFFLUENCE AND PARTICIPATION IN CAPITALISM," in which he promised to burn another book for every email he received about books not yet shipped. https://d2pq0u4uni88oo.cloudfront.net/assets/001/685/173/b2a5646f1d80c722560f500470386fcc_h264_high.mp4 Campbell's fan Max Temkin contacted Campbell and took the situation in hand as well as one could, reportedly sending copies to all the empty-handed backers still responding to messages from the Kickstarter, some months after Campbell's meltdown. But Campbell deleted his entire body of cartooning work from the Web and has not been seen in cartooning circles since. Sadder still, actions like this have a chilling effect on other crowdfunded projects and webcomics in particular. While the market seems to have weathered this one, an action like this serves as a reminder that a Kickstarter is a promise, and promises can be broken.

3. Willem: A Graphic Novel (Goal: $1,000... Down From $10,000/Pledged: $0)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/708930135/willem-take-2-d When they say a bad Kickstarter video is worse than none at all, this is what they mean. First, the thumbnail image (what you see before you click "play") is plagiarized from a poster by Ryan North, creator of Dinosaur Comics and writer of The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl. Second, the video is flipped for some strange reason, as the writing on both the posters and William J. Abritton's jersey are reversed. Third, the video... you know what, just watch it, we'll wait. It's clear Abritton is uncomfortable asking for money and deflects that discomfort into attempts at humor, but really he just transfers that discomfort to the viewer. This was his second attempt at a Kickstarter video: his first (for far more money) included a scene of Abritton begging in an unheated cellar on Christmas Eve: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/708930135/willem-a-graphic-novel?ref=nav_search It's hard to tell who created the thumbnail image for this one, but it sure wasn't Abritton, who seems to have left in a watermark added by Netfreestuff.co.uk. As for the pitch itself... "Love, loss, time travel and zombies" isn't a bad start (zombies are a little overdone, but can still work with the right concept). But those bare few words are overwhelmed by the air of desperation that wafts around this pitch like the scent of a freshly dug grave.

2. Totally Messed Up (Goal: $8,900/Pledged: $16,599)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/fantomzero/totally-messed-up-the-graphic-novel-and-art-toys This project looks great! Seriously! Aside from a couple of very minor issues, the whole package seems extremely professional. You might be wondering how this could possibly be #2 on this list, unless you've disappeared down the rabbit hole of the 3,000+ comments. It seems the project ran afoul of shipping delays and is now over a couple of years late in delivering on its promises. And while that's certainly bad, it's all too common a problem. But when creator Haru Ruben failed and failed to deliver and backer Brett Trout took to questioning his statements (but politely), Ruben got hostile. And then more hostile: challenging Trout's sanity because of a picture of Trout dressed as Arthur Dent for Halloween and, knowing that Trout was a lawyer, filing a complaint about him to the American Bar Association. Free advice: don't pick a legal battle with a lawyer if you're not one. When John Campbell went nuclear, at least he only harmed himself and his merchandise, and at least he finally delivered it with Temkin's help. Ruben was attacking a man's reputation and career merely for wanting the merchandise he'd paid for. It went about as well as you'd expect, as Trout reported after the fact:
Fred is correct. I sued Heru. We settled the case. Heru wrote me checks and agreed to not make any further statements about me. I paid him nothing and am under no obligation regarding making further statements about him. I have the transcript of a very lengthy deposition I took of Heru that I believe would be of substantial value in any subsequent case against him in this matter. In the event anyone does file a lawsuit against Heru, I would be happy to provide your attorney with a copy of the transcript free of charge.
Ruben's failure to deliver on promises or be honest about his difficulties also cost another Kickstarter its 3D covers. And that is... wait for it... "Totally Messed Up."

1. Shaniqua-No-Ho (Goal: $2,000/Pledged: $102)

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1116321106/shaniqua-no-ho-0 Right around the 2:17 mark in this video, what seems like a totally typical Americans-making-manga project hits a penny and careens off the rails. Yu-Gi-Oh wants to be the best at card games, right? Naruto wants to be the world's greatest ninja? Well, Shaniqua wants to be the world's best ho. Isaac Shapiro and Scott Ferguson were spot on when they discussed shonen manga's usual story structure and the unrealistic way it portrayed many professions, but wrong (oh, so very wrong) when believing they could mix it with "classic tropes" about black sex workers. Supporting cast members included "Big Lips Dorothy, the trailer park ho, and Pimpsferatu, not to mention Shaniqua€™s primary antagonist, The Vice Squad, as well as the evil, drug-abusing Gold Diggers syndicate." The art is decent, but the greatest entertainment value to be had from this project is watching two well-meaning, obviously sheltered white males say "ho" repeatedly as they try to explain how their vision of a ho isn't really a ho, just something pretty analogous to a ho, only not offensive and somehow empowered. It's like the arguments in defense of skimpy, ridiculous superheroine costumes ("she's expressing her strength and sexuality!") carried to their ultimate extreme. Within days, Shapiro and Ferguson's perspective caught up to everyone else's and they cancelled the project, issuing a contrite and pretty classy apology. As some of the other examples here show, even the biggest failures can be learning experiences. Let's hope that proves true for John Campbell, too. Got a regrettable comics crowdfunding project we missed (on Kickstarter, Indiegogo or some other site)? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

T Campbell has written quite a few online comics series and selected work for Marvel, Archie and Tokyopop. His longest-running works are Fans, Penny and Aggie-- and his current project with co-writer Phil Kahn, Guilded Age.