10 Most Shocking Betrayals In DC Comics
A knife in every back.
Judas Iscariot. Benedict Arnold. Saruman. Fredo Corleone.
Everything from religion to fiction to modern history is chock full of traitors and DC comic books are no exception. Many of DC’s most beloved and noble heroes have suffered on all fronts from personal to professional in this regard. From heroes succumbing to villainy to friends who were really villains all along, the superhero life is not one without ample paranoia.
The heroes of DC seem especially prone to the gut punch of betrayal and writers have often taken these golden age characters to astoundingly sad and grim territories in more recent decades.
One of the earliest betrayals of the Justice League was their honorary, super power free member Snapper Carr when he sided up with John Dough, the world’s most ordinary man. Despite his claim to being the world's most unremarkable person, Dough was out to get rid of the League with several nefarious schemes.
Dough’s ordinary facade was simply a disguise for The Joker and all was well again. It was a simpler time in the Silver Age of comics and as these next ten betrayals show, things have only gotten more brutal and more unforgivable with every passing year...
10. Aquaman Chooses Atlantis Over The League - Throne Of Atlantis
Everyone’s favourite orange and green attired sea dweller is a noble superhero for sure but it is only his second priority in life. Above all else, Aquaman’s loyalties lie with the people of Atlantis where his responsibilities as king dominate his life and decisions. Much as he may like his fellow Leaguers, Arthur Curry’s Atlantean duties will prompt him to do battle with them if need be.
In the well received Throne of Atlantis story arc, Aquaman finds himself at a crossroads with his brother’s determination to start a war between Atlantis and the surface world after malfunctioning Navy missiles hit Atlantis. Aquaman ultimately stages a brutal offence against the Justice League in the battles that follow, forsaking his old team for his homeland.
To add some insult to injury, the League discover that Aquaman’s long time pal Nuidis Vulko was behind the whole thing. He orchestrated for his beloved Atlantis to be bombed specifically to incite a war. The end goal? For the League to defeat Ocean Master and lead to the reinstatement of Arthur as king.
9. Batman Has Plans To Take Down Every Leaguer - Tower Of Babel
Batman’s paranoia here is rather understandable given that previous entry. All the same, it leads to total disaster in Mark Waid’s highly acclaimed Tower of Babel story arc. Courtesy of Ra’s Al Ghul, each member of the League falls victim to a brutal, highly personalised attack. It is quickly revealed that the architect of these beatdowns was Batman himself who was in turn robbed by his thousand year old foe.
Behind the League’s back, Batman had in fact spent years compiling data on every strength and weakness of every super powered League member. From there he devised the strategies to neutralise them should they ever turn to the dark side.
Batman himself is too distracted recovering the stolen bodies of his parents to help his teammates. While the team eventually recover enough to defeat Ra’s Al Ghul’s latest depopulating strategy, the rift between them proves too much. Holding a vote on Batman’s status, Superman ultimately decides to side with those who want Batman off the team.
Given Batman’s actions nearly cost the lives of the team and most of planet Earth, expulsion seemed a valid punishment.
8. Jean Loring Murders Sue Dibny - Identity Crisis
Brad Meltzer’s grim and controversial Identity Crisis saga revolves around a series of increasingly unpleasant reveals regarding several past mysteries haunting the Justice League. In the wake of Elongated Man’s wife Sue being found murdered while Elongated Man was on patrol, the League discover a deeply disturbing secret, Sue was raped by Doctor Light in the JLA headquarters and several major heroes subsequently had their memories of the event erased.
Filled to the brim with plot twists and B-tier character deaths, Identity Crisis ultimately reveals The Atom’s ex-wife, Jean Loring, as the culprit behind it all, irreparably damaging the League and its secrets that she had once been entrusted with. Saddest of all is that her murder of Sue Dibny was accidental and her actions were a deeply flawed (and totally insane) strategy to get her shrinking ex, The Atom, back in her arms.
The ramifications of Identity Crisis continued to be felt in numerous major DC stories to follow, including Infinite Crisis.
7. Zatanna Erases Batman's Memory - Identity Crisis
After Doctor Light’s assault on Sue Dibny, Zatanna wiped Light’s memory and reduced him to a bumbling, unthreatening buffoon. In the midst of this supernatural lobotomy, the Dark Knight himself comes walking in. Due to his protests, Zatanna goes ahead and wipes Batman’s memory of the event also.
Always one for trust issues, Batman was more than furious when he learned the truth. The revelation prompted him to create the Brother MK I satellite to closely monitor any and all superhumans moving forward.
There have been far grander tragedies to strike the Justice League than Zatanna’s actions here. What makes the cut so deep is the fact that Zatanna herself was a valued member. In using her powers to alter the mind of one of the League’s finest, she committed the cardinal sin of taking undue action against a fellow team member.
Worse still, the decision to alter Batman’s memories was green lit by other Justice Leaguers including Green Arrow, Green Lantern (Hal, adding yet another wrinkle in the ongoing disdain between Wayne and Jordan), The Flash (Barry Allen) and Hawkman.
6. Barry Allen Reboots DC Continuity - Flashpoint
Geoff Johns’ Flash-centric swan song to the pre-New 52 DC Universe wasn’t quite what many readers had hoped for. From Bruce Wayne’s parents being Batman and the Joker to Wonder Woman doing battle with Aquaman to Captain Cold being a hero and Superman a top secret prisoner, the whole thing was rather bizarre even by Elseworlds standards.
Barry Allen finds himself in this weird new continuity, disoriented and understandably confused by the world around him. Suspecting hated nemesis Eobard Thawne as the architect of the new timeline, Allen faces his old foe and is devastated by the truth of the situation.
Allen himself is responsible for the new timeline having damaged reality itself with the Speed Force when he attempted to go back in time to stop Thawne from killing his mother. While anyone can understand wanting to save one’s own mother, Allen’s actions destroyed the DC Universe irreparably and cost millions of lives, including Bruce Wayne and Hal Jordan, who never even became a Green Lantern in this timeline.
5. Atomica’s Double Double Agency - New 52
During The New 52 era of DC comic books, there were not one but two Justice Leagues; the classic one (bar Martian Manhunter) that we all know and love and a new, not so loveable one. Formed by Amanda Waller and Steve Trevor, this considerably less loveable League was designed to aid in keeping the actual League in check.
Atomica, an astoundingly sadistic figure from Earth 3, joins both Justice Leagues and frequently betrays the originals as a snitch to Waller and Trevor. Her two-faced traitor ways don’t stop there however. Rounding back to her Earth 3 residence, Atomica ultimately betrays both Leagues as well as Justice League Dark during the Forever Evil event. A proud member of the Crime Syndicate, Atomica uses Pandora’s Box (always a bad sign) to bring her actual team mates to Earth, trapping the Justice Leagues and allowing the Crime Syndicate to run rough shod over a new Earth.
A betrayal of not one, not two but three Justice Leagues, Atomica’s a three-faced piece of work. She would ultimately get her comeuppance courtesy of Lex Luthor during his brief run as a superhero.
4. Maxwell Lord Turns Evil - Infinite Crisis
Maxwell Lord IV had enjoyed ample influence over Justice League and the formation of Justice League International in the wake of Crisis On Infinite Earths. A wealthy and powerful businessman, Lord claimed to have learned nobility and compassion from his late father, Maxwell Lord III. All of this pointed to him as a genuine figure out to help keep Earth safe and its heroes strong.
Nope.
During the Invasion saga, Lord acquires the super power of mind control and things only get worse from there. The build up to Infinite Crisis saw many shocking events occur in the DC Universe including Lord’s brutal murder of Ted Kord, aka Blue Beetle II.
Lord’s betrayal continued to damage the League throughout Infinite Crisis. Lord steals Batman’s metahuman satellite to hunt down every superhuman on Earth with an army of cyborgs at his disposal; Wonder Woman straight up murders him after he mind controls Superman into his assaulting his fellow Leaguers.
As a last laugh after death, footage of Wonder Woman snapping his neck leaks worldwide, causing her to be alienated from the rest of the League.
3. Mother Of The Year - Death In The Family
Poor Jason Todd. Often the punching bag of Batman comics, Jason’s run as Robin left a lot to be desired and lead to one of DC’s more infamous eighties tales. After being relieved of his Robin duties, a cranky Jason sets off to the Middle East to find and meet his mystery mother for the first time.
Meanwhile, Batman conveniently finds himself in the same area after the Joker escapes Arkham and gets into arms dealing. Batman and Robin ride again, foiling various plots in the process.
Jason ultimately meets his mother, Sheila, an embezzling aid worker being blackmailed by the Joker. Despite her son being one half of Batman and Robin, Sheila sticks with Mr J and coldly betrays her son to him. What follows is poor Jason getting beaten to death by the Clown Prince of Crime. Where did Sheila go whilst her son’s cranium was getting pulverised? Out for a quick smoke.
Near death by this point, Jason is finished off by a time bomb in the warehouse much to Batman’s devastation. One of the grimmest moments in Batman’s long run, its ramifications are felt to this day.
2. Hal Jordan Massacres The Entire Green Lantern Corps - Emerald Twilight
When Cyborg Superman and Mongul (DC’s rip-off of Marvel’s Thanos who in turn was initially inspired by DC’s Darkseid), team up to turn Earth into Warworld, one of their initial strikes involves the total destruction of Coast City. A devastated Hal Jordan would ultimately defeat Mongul but it was too little, too late for the good people of Coast City, who were caught in the ensuing carnage.
Consumed with grief and survivors’ guilt, Jordan would use his power ring to conjure up a false city. Disturbed by his behaviour, several fellow Lanterns would attempt to stop this and in a rage, Jordan killed them all. Growing increasingly cruel and unstable, Jordan goes onto absorbing the Central Power Battery of Oa. In the process, Jordan becomes the deadly villain, Parallax, the living embodiment of fear. He would defeat fellow Earth Lantern, Guy Gardner and became a fearsome villain in DC comics for some time after.
In the meantime, Kyle Rayner became the (at that point) final Green Lantern for several years until Geoff Johns’ Rebirth story arc restored the classic Green Lantern mythos decimated by Jordan’s villainy.
1. Superman Becomes A Government Stooge - The Dark Knight Returns
Ah Superman, the epitome of decency in the DC Universe, a beacon of light and hope in a world of darkness and villainy. Frequently depicted as a saviour figure, Superman’s honour and heart prevent him ever turning cruel in main continuity. In elseworlds takes however, writers have often let their imaginations run wild with how a Superman heel turn might look.
While not the most extreme example of a bleaker Superman, Frank Miller’s classic, The Dark Knight Returns, offers one of the saddest glimpses of the red cape becoming a turncape.
Far in the future, Superman sells out the League in favour of the US Government and would ultimately destroy and dismantle the League (a good example being the one armed Oliver Queen we meet in later chapters), leading to a less super powered, far more corrupt future Earth.
While the Man of Steel believes himself to still be fighting the good fight, bringing order to a world hungry for chaos, his actions here show how devastating his betrayal of the League would be. The best and the strongest of them all, Superman’s single handed destruction of every hero in his way is a testament to his power and the heartbreak that would follow should he ever turn on his friends and allies.
Watch Next
DC Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know The Justice League?