10 Reasons Why New 52 Batman Was The Best Ever
Reinvention isn't always a bad thing.
All comic readers, from casual newcomer to lifelong fan, acknowledge the immortal worthiness of the very best of Batman— “The Dark Knight Returns,” “Year One,” “The Killing Joke,” “Arkham Asylum,” “The Long Halloween.”
These are the classics. No other stories can hope to touch them. The point is, everyone has already read the best Batman stories of all time, and everyone’s already talked them to death.
And so it is that the New 52 “Batman” series, written by Scott Snyder and drawn by Greg Capullo, is better than any of those stories above. Yes, I said. it.
Better.
The team’s bestselling and argument-inspiring run of 52 issues (#0 to #51) is nearing its end.
Let’s look back on the ways New 52 Batman has been the best the world has ever seen...
10. The Consistent Creative Team
Think how rare it is for one writer and one artist, each so well suited for the other, to have so much uninterrupted time to explore a single character. After the final issue's release later this month, the “Batman” series as we know it will have lasted for 52 issues (#0 to #51).
In a comic landscape where writers usually have short runs on characters, and fill-in art is a fact of life, the sheer consistency of this series makes it stand apart.
In contrast to other contemporary series, “Batman” seems elemental and hard as a diamond. It’s like it has its own gravitational pull, a unique weightiness. Out of 52 issues over five years, Greg Capullo drew 47 and Scott Snyder wrote them all. That is a thing of rare beauty in this world.
9. FCO Plascencia's Colors
FCO Plascencia must be the bravest colorist in superhero comics today. Making Greg Capullo’s pencils come alive since the series’ start, FCO's colors really kicked into high gear with the coming of “Zero Year.”
Over the course of that arc, readers were treated to colors and palettes the likes of which are rarely seen on the pages of superhero comics these days. Rich pinks, queasy yellows, heavy greys, knockout purples.
If you don't think FCO’s inclusive palettes are adventurous for comics in general, they surely are for a freaking Batman comic.
8. Reader Engagement
Plenty of creators approach superhero titles with vaguely hostile intent. They use comics to talk down to their readers, or they just churn out dumb stories. By contrast, the New 52 Batman team never lost sight of one thing: on the receiving end of their labor is a human reader, a customer, who deserves a great experience.
Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo always close their interviews with a thank-you to their readers. They’re aware that their series has been untraditional, and they write and draw from a place of gratitude.
There's also a satisfying dose of fourth-wall-breaking in Snyder’s most adventurous writing. He’s used his characters to voice readers’ concerns about unusual story directions, opening up a dialogue with fans.
Think of the Gotham National Bank scene in issue #0 that opened the controversial “Zero Year" arc. The manager welcomes his team to the newly renovated bank with the assurance that “it’s modern and fresh, but it honors the rich history of Gotham National.” Or like in “Superheavy” with those kids badmouthing the bunny-eared mechanized Batman action figure, refusing to accept Jim Gordon as any kind of Batman. Time and again, Snyder acknowledged fanboy fears.
7. Big Ideas
Despite Scott Snyder’s protests that he just sets out to tell small stories with classic villains (something he’ll finally be able to tackle in the Rebirth title “All-Star Batman”) the series forms an interlocking chain of long arcs, each bigger and more emotional than the last. New 52 Batman has a sweeping hugeness to it, with different story arcs of varying tone and texture.
There’s maybe one issue of breathing room between each arc, but otherwise the series has been a continuous parade of epics— the shaking of Bruce’s confidence in “The Court of Owls,” the queasy horror and romance of “Death of the Family,” the punk update on Batman’s origin in the year-long “Zero Year,” the black valentine of Joker’s “Endgame,” and finally the destruction of Batman and reformation of Bruce Wayne in “Superheavy.” It’s been quite a ride.
6. Allies Explored
Batman’s supporting cast is as good as they come. They deserve proper attention, and the New 52 team had plenty to say about Alfred, Commissioner Gordon, Batgirl, and the Robins. They even threw in a totally great love interest for Bruce in Julie Madison. (Even in the context of Bruce’s doomed romances, somehow, Julie sold me. Maybe it’s the cool tattoos.)
In the New 52, the tension at the core of Batman’s mission comes from Alfred’s love and concern for Bruce. This depiction of Alfred is up there with Michael Caine’s portrayal for its heartbreaking intensity. You can’t help but see Bruce through Alfred’s eyes. And every time Alfred lets him disappear into the night, you realize that Alfred’s faith in him is just as heroic as Batman’s crusade. You realize that Alfred has just as much to sacrifice.
And then there’s the big controversial one, Jim Gordon: Batman. The deeply human portrait of Jim Gordon feels like a fleshing out of the noir antihero presented in Frank Miller’s “Year One.” The series has compellingly painted Gordon as the flipside of Batman, a Gotham crusader from within the lawful system, a guy worth exploring as a hero in his own right.
5. A Personal Emotional Batman
Each New 52 Batman story, no matter how sweeping and spectacular, came from a place of Scott Snyder’s personal fears and anxieties. And Snyder’s feelings are very much our own— “Zero Year” addressed the contemporary fear of terrorism, “Superheavy” dealt with urban unrest. On a smaller scale, “Death of the Family” came straight out of Snyder’s anxieties as a father about the safety of his family.
Ultimately, stringing all these threads together is the “big picture” of the series, as it can certainly be said to have one. It’s all a big Batman versus Joker story. (New 52 Batman is as focused on Joker as it is on the hero. Joker makes major appearances in every single arc in the series, with a couple devoted exclusively to him.) The overall story is about choosing to see life from Joker’s perspective as random nothingness, or choosing to see life as Batman sees it— as full of progress and meaning.
4. Iconic Villains
Scott Snyder’s roots in literary and horror fiction are well suited for Gotham’s grand rogues. In the beginning, he gave Batman a brand new yet fully realized adversary in The Court of Owls. The Court’s initial effect was maybe diluted by subsequent spinoffs, tie-ins, and follow-ups, but doesn’t that happen to all the great villains? (Imagine creators twenty years from now doing their own spins on The Court and its Talons.)
And at the series’ end, another original villain sprouted up in the ambiguous Mr. Bloom. This slender creep in skinny jeans and fishnets is a kind of anti-Joker, in that he represents the actually justifiable meanness of Gotham’s streets.
Present through it all is Snyder’s Joker, who will go down in history as one of our greatest Jokers— clingy, verbose, full of ugly questions and challenges. Plus, the Riddler here is the best iteration of the character in years. Not since the animated series has Riddler been so compelling in his own unique way (the Arkham games go too far to make him an obsessive trap-making killer).
Snyder delves into what these eccentric criminals really want, so that villains whose appeal had dulled over the years come up shining like rare gems. Also who knew forgotten guys like Dr. Death and Crazy Quilt could be so interesting?
3. Scott Snyder's Writing
How wonderful that a writer with such depth of feeling, with respect and rebelliousness in equal measure, should find the world of Batman in his hands. Call Scott Snyder wordy, but at least when you shell out for an issue you get your money’s worth. Besides that, he absolutely avoids the cardinal sin of comic writers— allowing one’s words to be made redundant by the art. His scripts add meaning to the art, and vice versa.
His tendency to end arcs with pages-long concluding speeches may be divisive. I find them satisfying in the way hearing a detective explain his conclusion is satisfying: the mystery plot you’ve spent all this time reading is imbued with significance and clarity. He’s also good at letting images speak for themselves, as at the end of “Dark City,” with a hopelessly defeated Batman intercut with the child Bruce Wayne screaming “HELP!” up at the reader.
He has a great sense for voices— Bruce Wayne’s inner monologues ring true, Gordon is self-deprecating, Alfred is emotional and florid. Interestingly, the closest we get to Snyder’s own voice seems to be through The Joker. Notice how gleefully Joker explains the meaning behind his outrageous plots, and compare that to the enthusiasm with which Snyder explains the thinking behind his stories.
2. Greg Capullo's Pencils
Greg Capullo is justifiably the new superstar of comic book artists. Capullo hits that sought-after sweet spot between realism and stylization. On the realistic side, he’s got nuanced acting chops. His faces are intense, emotive, and individualized.
And when it comes to the punch-up, his action is clean and precise. (What kind of lived experience is the very tough-seeming Capullo drawing from here? Was he a real-life brawler like Jack Kirby?) Capping off his fully realized world, Capullo’s attention to detail makes every page worth scrutinizing and rewards rereading.
When it comes to the dialed-up style required by superheroes, he’s equally skilled. His layouts are kinetic and easy to follow. (This in a time when more free-flowing page compositions, with barely distinguishable “panels,” are in vogue.) Capullo’s traditional paneling does wonders to keep momentum going through Snyder’s scripts.
Finally, Capullo leads the pack in character design. He’s shown us a punk purple-gloved Batman. He’s shown us a faceless Joker. His slender Jim Gordon Batman costume is truly astonishing, recalling the visual impact of Batman Beyond. And he made owls scarier than ever.
1. Always Innovation
In a post-“Year One,” post-“Batman Begins” world, this comic had the pluck to present its own retelling of Batman’s origin. And somehow it was fantastic. This was a slow, accumulative origin, something unique in comics. In “Zero Year,” Bruce doesn’t become Batman over night. He acquires the physical, mental, and emotional aspects of Batman piece by piece.
While some may complain that the sprawling tale doesn’t digest as easily as other superhero origins, I think that very aspect is its true strength. It gives the myth more time and space to grow. It infuses Batman's whole iconography with the breath of life.
Equally earth-shattering was when Scott Snyder revealed Gotham City’s alternate history— preyed upon by hidden Owls all along. Then, he finally addressed the question of Joker’s immortality, something only hinted at before. He followed that up by making Jim Gordon Batman for a year.
The whole series is studded by surprising developments. The Joker invades the Batcave and scatters the Bat Family. Bruce Wayne's long-lost evil brother shows up, and it's actually awesome. An amnesiac Bruce Wayne sits on a park bench with an amnesiac Joker, and they talk as strangers. These are the most exhilarating additions to the Batman legend since Damian Wayne showed up a decade ago, and they are sure to echo in the character's history for years to come.