10 Superman Fates Worse Than Death

Some fates are so nightmarishly terrifying, death would be seen as a mercy.

Superman DC Comics
DC Comics

Jerry Seigel and Joe Shuster's creation, Superman, has been entertaining readers for decades, not just with his awesome powers and quippy dialogue but by being a beacon of endless inspiration. Being the world's greatest and strongest superhero, it feels like there is nothing the Man of Tomorrow can't accomplish.

However, despite Superman's boundless strength, he is not invincible. Because he has to go up against alien warlords, cosmic deities, and sentient stars on a daily basis, pushing up the daisies is a very real possibility for the spit-curled superhero. Just ask Doomsday. Actually, don't, since he'll probably kill you.

As hard as it is to believe, there are fates far worse than meeting your maker.

Since snuffing out a bulletproof Kryptonian is quite a tall order, most supervillains find other ways to torment Superman. Throughout his adventures, villains have tricked him into committing atrocities, used his body to beat the hell out of his friends, and have imprisoned him for centuries. While enduring situations like this, there is no question the Last Son of Krypton would see death as a welcome alternative.

10. Red Kryptonite

Red Kryptonite
DC Comics

When Krypton exploded, chunks of Superman's homeworld were scattered across the cosmos. When these rocks passed through our solar system, they were exposed to radiation, rendering them lethal to Kryptonians. Even though Kryptonite usually takes on a green hue, there are many variants. White Kryptonite kills plants. Gold Kryptonite depowers Kryptonians. Blue Kryptonite weakens Bizarro the same way regular Kryptonite weakens Superman.

One of the strangest versions of this mineral is Red Kryptonite since its effects on Kryptonians are completely random. If Superman is exposed to this ruby-colour rock, he could develop amnesia, turn into a dwarf, mutate into an insect, lose his powers on one side of his body, or, god forbid, grow a beard.

The worst experience Superman has had with this form of Kryptonite was during the JLA: Tower of Babel storyline. After Talia Al Ghul forced the spandex-sporting superhero to make contact with the rock, Supes became hypersensitive to solar energy. This caused the sun's rays to incinerate Superman's organs and muscles from the inside out. In Talia's own words, "It may not kill you, but you will wish you were dead".


9. Mind Control

Superman Eclipso
DC Comics

For all the good Superman has done, there are some like Lex Luthor who fear the Big Blue will turn against humanity. Of course, Supes has reassured humanity countless times, emphasising that he would never use his power for evil since he stands for truth, justice and the American Way.

Despite Superman's intentions, Lex has a point. Even though the Boy Scout superhero can benchpress a planet and crush a diamond with his eyelid, his mind can be corrupted. Poison Ivy used her pheromone control to brainwash Superman, forcing him to attack Batman. Maxwell Lord manipulated his mind so Superman thought he was fighting Doomsday and Brainiac when he actually attacking his friends.

One of the most terrifying moments in Superman's life was when his body was possessed by Eclipso - the embodiment of God's Wrath.

Intending to use the Man of Tomorro's body to cause untold levels of destruction, Shazam intervened and tried to rip Eclipso from his friend's body. Unable to defeat the ancient demon, Shazam's mentor summoned the embodiment of God's Vengeance, The Spectre, who had Eclipso imprisoned. If it wasn't for The Spectre's appearance, Super-Eclipso could've theoretically levelled the planet in a matter of minutes.


8. Poisoned By Kryptonite For 200 Years

Superman Gog
DC Comics

After William Matthews falsely believed Superman intentionally chose not to save his parents, he vowed to destroy the Metropolitan superhero. After being endowed with the life-force of the Old Gods, Matthews, now calling himself Gog, developed many powers including time travel.

Even though Gog's newfound abilities allowed him to go toe-to-toe with Superman, he was ultimately defeated. Refusing to give up, Gog went back in time to try again but was met with the same result. However, Gog promised he would never rest until Superman was defeated and thus, travelling back in time thousands of times to face his arch-nemesis. After battling Kal-El for two centuries, Gog finally emerged victorious in Action Comics #825.

Gog believed death was too good for Superman and so, decided to break his mind and spirit instead. Since it took 200 years to defeat his enemy, Gog thought it was only fitting to torture him for the same length of time. Shackling him to a harness and dousing him in kryptonite, Gog forced his prisoner to endure pure agony for centuries.

Fortunately, Superman was rescued by, of all people, Doomsday, allowing him to undo Gog's actions and return to his original timeline.


7. Losing Krypton All Over Again

Death of New Krypton
DC Comics

Brainiac is a super-intelligent alien who shrinks sections of planets and stores them onto his ship to study. When Superman discovered the extra-terrestrial despot had shrunken the Kryptonian city of Kandor, he was thrilled to see thousands of his species had survived Krypton's destruction, including his aunt and uncle.

When Superman removed Kandor from Brainiac's ship, the city automatically grew to its original size. Superman transported it to space, turning it into a planetoid called New Krypton. Superman was exhilarated about this new terrain since he could live amongst his people for the first time - a dream he always coveted but never thought was possible.

But it was too good to be true.

Unfamiliar with Earth's customs and laws, several Kryptonians killed multiple cops, creating a rift between Earth and New Krypton. Lex Luthor fanned the flames of mistrust and eventually had New Krypton destroyed with a missile, killing most of the population.

When the surviving Kryptonians declared war on Earth, Superman had no choice but to have his people banished to the Phantom Zone. It was heartbreaking to watch Superman fulfil his greatest wish, only to have it ripped away from him only a year later.


6. Depowered And Exposed

Superman Exposed
DC Comics

When a sinister organisation called Hordr_Root discovered Superman and Clark Kent were one and the same, they blackmailed the Man of Steel to work for them or they would expose his identity. Believing his loved ones would be targeted if his identity became known, Superman reluctantly agreed. Believing the wicked corporation would make Superman commit atrocities for their benefit, Lois Lane deliberately exposed his identity to the world, freeing him from Hordr's influence.

Sadly, this revelation turned Superman's life upside-down. He was fired, sued, and had all his assets frozen. Anyone connected to Clark Kent became a target for supervillains, forcing his civilian friends to cut ties with him.

Just when Superman thought the situation couldn't possibly get any worse, the Greek gods took away most of his powers including his ability to fly. He maintained some of his superstrength but could still be overpowered by brute force. Considering Superman has defeated the likes of Doomsday, Darkseid, and Zod, it was pretty humiliating to watch him nearly get killed by a group of thugs.

Lois Lane may have had nothing but good intentions but there is no question her actions ruined Superman's life.


5. Being Corrupted By The Anti-Life Equation

Superman Darkseid
DC Comics

One of the most dangerous artefacts in the multiverse is the Anti-Life Equation. Anti-Life is a mathematical formula that allows the wielder to control all forms of sentient life. The ruler of Apokolips, Darkseid, has coveted this formula for millennia, hoping to use it to bend all living things to his will.

Because Superman has stopped Darkseid claiming his grand prize time and time again, the New God dreams of using Anti-Life to control the Kryptonian, transforming him into his righthand man. The concept of Superman being turned into Darkseid' mind has been explored in the Elseworld story, Superman: Dark Side, and the animated Justice League: Unlimited series. It was also hinted at in the climax of Zack Snyder's Justice League and was meant to be play an integral part of the plot of the sequels.

Superman is terrified of the possibility that Darkseid could use the Anti-Life to force Superman to kill his friends, enslave planets, and exterminate entire civilisations. Because of Superman's ideals, it's safe to say he would take his own life in a heartbeat to avoid becoming a pawn of Darkseid.


4. Trapped In The Phantom Zone

Speedy Mia Queen Phantom Zone Arrow Superboy-Prime
DC Comics

Superman is not the only Kryptonian to have a No-Kill Rule. His father, Jor-El, despised the concept of murder and conceived an alternative punishment for criminals. Instead of executing the worst that Krypton had to offer, Jor-El had them transported to a pocket universe called the Phantom Zone. This dimension has homed many well-known characters including Zod, Doomsday, Nuclear Man, Superboy, Mon-El, Lois Lane, and even Superman himself.

What makes this otherworldly prison so terrifying is that it exists outside of the space-time continuum, meaning time doesn't flow normally there. One second in the regular universe may feel like a million years have passed to anyone residing in the Phantom Zone. With nothing to mark the passing of time, it's no surprise than most residents of The Phantom Zone go completely insane.

Since it's impossible to die in this universe, any prisoner is condemned to remain there until the end of time if they can't find a way out. Ironically, many incarcerated prisoners on Krypton preferred to be executed, believing it to be more humane than being banished to another universe forever.


3. Living In A Universe Run By The Joker

Emperor Joker
DC Comics

After the Joker stole the reality-warping powers of Mr Mxyzptlk, the Clown Prince of Crime reshaped the universe to his liking. Crowning himself as Emperor Joker, Batman's nemesis performed all sorts of deranged acts with his godlike power including carving his sneering mug into the planet, turning Harley Quinn into a constellation, making Lex Luthor his personal jester, and eating the entire population of China. He also made everyone forget about their past lives, meaning they believed the Joker had always been the top dog.

But there was one person who still remembered the original world: Superman.

As terrifying as it is to live in a society where an omnipotent psychotic clown runs the show, it was extra frustrating for Superman since he knew the way things used to be. Supes tried his best to tell everyone they were living in a false reality but nobody believed him, not even Lois Lane.

Superman eventually returned reality to normal which is lucky since it's a safe assumption no one in their right mind would ever live in a world where the Joker was calling the shots.


2. Becoming A Supervillain

Superman Evil Injustice
DC Comics

In the Injustice video game and comic series, the Joker administers a Kryptonite-laced fear toxin into Superman's bloodstream, forcing him to see his greatest fears. When his pregnant wife, Lois Lane, was in front of him, he absolutely believed she was Doomsday and so hurled her into space, killing her and his unborn child. Because Lois' heartbeat was linked to a nuclear bomb in Metropolis placed by the Joker, her death detonated it, destroying the city.

After losing his wife, his child and his home in one fell swoop, Superman snapped and punched a hole through the Joker's chest. To ensure no one suffered like the way he did, Superman elected himself as the highest authority on Earth. When his old teammates questioned his extreme measure, Superman had them imprisoned or killed.

Although he was manipulated to kill Lois and destroy Metropolis, Superman consciously took the lives of his former allies, making him a murderer. Kal-El insists his actions are justified but he knows that Lois would be ashamed of him since he has become the very evil he swore to fight against. Because he could never undo all the damage he's caused, this version of Superman seems beyond redemption.


1. Outliving Everyone On Earth

Alex Ross Superman
DC Comics

Under a red sun, Kryptonians like Superman are indistinguishable from humans. But under a yellow sun, the solar cells charge Superman's body, giving him powers like flight, superstrength, freeze breath, and optic lasers. Even if Superman is heavily injured, he will heal at superspeed so long as he is in the proximity of a yellow star. Not only does the solar energy repair Superman's cells but it stops them from ageing, allowing him to live far beyond a regular Kryptonian's lifespan.

So, how long can Superman live for while exposed to a yellow sun? Well, depending on what comic you're referring to, it could be a century, millennia, or millions of years. In Mark Millar's Superman: Red Son, Superman lived to be over a billion!

There may be no conclusive answer but there is one thing that is for certain - Superman will outlive everyone he's ever cared about.

What's worse is that's the best case scenario! If he brings world peace, hangs up the cape and retires with Lois Lane, he's still going to outlive her and all his childhood friends, family, work colleagues, and teammates. For such an inspirational superhero, Superman is ironically set for a cripplingly depressing existence.


Watch Next


Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows