10 Terrible Mistakes That Almost Ruined The Avengers For Everyone

Man, maybe they should just disassemble...

The Avengers are as close as the Marvel Universe gets to celebrities. Well, most of the major superheroes tend to be pretty well known, obviously, but Earth's Mightiest Heroes are really the only ones to be universally loved, adored and respected - after everyone got bored of the Fantastic Four, anyway. Spider-Man is painted a menace, the X-Men and mutants as a whole are hated and feared, but so long as true patriot Captain America and his team are seen saving the universe, the public can't get enough of them. In a meta-textual twist this adoration has crossed over into the real world (that's Earth-1218 in the official Marvel Multiverse, True Believers!), with the movie adaptation raking in record-breaking numbers. Whilst they've been a constant within Marvel, the Avengers comics have never quite been as consistently popular as the likes of the X-Men and Spider-Man. They have kept up a steady level of quality, however, that earned them a small yet dedicated fanbase who followed them as they went from strength to strength, growing in popularity until they became the multiple-title-having, box-office-dominating behemoth they are today. Things could have been a lot different. Time and again the Avengers have faced down untold menaces, enemies to our very existence that would have destroyed all of humanity as soon as look at us, and they lived to tell the tale. Well, most of them, anyway. There have been times, though, where those threats were not ones that the Avengers themselves could face. Times when writers were responsible for crappy storylines, editors enforced changes, or characters acted...out of character, which very nearly threatened to tear the team apart. Or at least set knock them off course for the universal popularity they boast today. We've assembled the ten terrible mistakes that nearly ruined the Avengers for everyone.

10. Disassembled

We may as well go in all guns blazing, with one of the most controversial storylines in Avengers history to this day. Tired of hanging around for the Cinematic Universe to take off or just for people to actually give the Avengers book any attention full stop, Marvel made the extreme decision to just completely get rid of the team and start again. Unlike their Distinguished Competition, however, Marvel don't do reboots by totally overhauling their continuity. No, they do it by murdering a load of fan-favourite characters, cancelling their favourite book, and then expecting them to spend their money on new things instead. Drafting in the phenomenally popular Brian Michael Bendis, who had been a trustworthy captain of Ultimate Spider-Man for over a hundred issues and would go on to helm many of the company's biggest crossover events, to pen what was dubbed Avengers Disassembled. It begins with a deceased ex-Avenger, Jack of Hearts arriving at the Avengers Mansion and promptly exploding, killing Ant-Man, and sorta goes downhill from there. When the smoke cleared the Vision and Hawkeye are dead, Scarlet Witch is in a catatonic state and Tony Stark is broke. It affected the Avengers to the degree that they've only recently - some seven years on - returned to a cohesive team. With all the dead people resurrected. Phew.

9. The Force Works Reboot

In the mid-nineties, the Avengers were at their lowest ebb, commercially and creatively. In an effort to latch onto the trend for "cool" heroes - unlike those corny, pure and nice Earth's Mightiest Heroes - Marvel decided to send Iron Man off to start a new branch of the superteam from the ashes of the recently disbanded West Coast Avengers. They would differ from their predecessors in that they would be proactive in dealing with the sort of worldwide threats the Avengers tended to deal in, seeking out natural disasters and international conspiracies, and stopped them before they took effect. Oh also they would wear X-Men style uniforms with the "A" on them, because the X-Men were pretty popular in the early nineties. Besides the costume change, venue (the Avengers Mansion was swapped out for a Stark factory called, duh, The Works), and MO, the line-up was nigh unrecognisable and or. Scarlet Witch and Wonder Man made appearances but then so did the second Spider-Woman, off-brand Captain America US Agent, the none-more-nineties Century, Moonraker - who was as bad as the film - and the immensely forgettable Cybermancer. Latching onto the style of the time like an embarrassing dad in skinny jeans, Force Works took the Avengers away from what made them, well, the Avengers - they were less of a pure force for good and more EXTREME!!! Thankfully this all got forgotten in a retcon a few months later.

8. The Weathermen

Along with Ultron, the Avengers have come up against some pretty formidable villains in their time. There's been multiple run ins with both the Kree and Skrull alien races, the world-eater Galactus, and even the Incredible Hulk was essentially a recurring bad guy in the early days. Quite a temper on that one. Like any comic book that's been around for nearly half a century, however, you're going to get some duds in there. Which is certainly the case with Avengers #210, widely regarded as the worse single issue of the title ever released, and its principal antagonists The Weathermen, widely regarded as the single worst bad guys that ever turned up in the title. Having noticed an unusual amount of natural disasters around the Earth, the Avengers decide to stick their collective nose in and figure out what they're all about. Splitting up and travelling to all four corners of the glove to investigate further, our heroes discover that the planet is under threat by a team calling themselves the Weathermen, each of whom has mastery over a different form of weather. Like Storm, if she was multiple terrible people instead of one awesome X-Man. It's not the crumminess of the bad guys that has this down as such a terrible mistake for the Avengers, however, but the fact that one of these villains kills Beast's long-term girlfriend Vera by turning her into crystal. And then Beast gets summarily kicked off the team with the next issue, thus ending an interesting era in the team's roster. Thankfully the character bounced back from Vera's death and has been included on a few later Avengers rosters, but still. Pretty naff innit.

7. Excusing Starfox's Shenanigans

This one's actually more on the Avengers themselves than the people who wrote them. Actually no, that doesn't make any sense, because the actions of a bunch of fictional characters are absolutely the responsibility of the people responsible for creating them and dictating what they do every day. Because remember readers, if a comic book character does or says something objectionable and it's you're not supposed to balk at it, that's the fault of the people writing them. With that out of the way, we can lay the blame for inviting an actual sex offender onto the Avengers team at whoever the creative team is whenever Starfox turns up. Nothing to do with the star of Lylat Wars 64 (more's the pity), the Marvel Universe's Starfox is instead is an alien, member of an ancient race called the Eternals and much saner brother to cosmic despot Thanos. What with Thanos being all about the destruction of existence, Starfox - whose real name is, shudder, Eros - is his equal and opposite. He wants to create life. By which we mean his super power is to emit pheromones that make everybody want to sleep with him, and can actually physically mess with people's emotions. Starfox, even more than Gambit, is the superhero equivalent of a pick-up artist, and yet he appeared in Avengers comics for years! Thankfully these days he only shows up in a humorous context, like the time She-Hulk was his lawyer in a sexual harassment lawsuit. "Humorous".

6. Cancelling Earth's Mightiest Heroes

Having let DC be top dog of animated adaptations of their properties for the longest time, Marvel seemed to finally put together a serious contender to the throne (mixed metaphors - contender to the doghouse, or summat) in the form of Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes. Pitched as the sort of unfettered, unpretentious kid-friendly fun of Batman: The Brave And The Bold mixed with the continuity-savvy adventures of the Justice League show - and with some Bruce Timm-style designs on show too - Earth's Mightiest Heroes was possibly the most critically acclaimed Marvel adaptation. At least until the movie came along and ruined that, in more ways than one. Y'see, Earth's Mightiest Heroes had an interesting and diverse cast (including Iron Man, Wasp, Captain America, Black Panther and Ms Marvel), some top-notch voice acting and intelligent writing courtesy of a bunch of comic book veterans. Unfortunately the roster and visual style were a little too far away from the super successful Avengers film, which meant that the series was dropped in favour of the far more conventional Avengers Assemble after just two seasons. Fans got up in arms about it, but it looks like we're stuck with Assemble for now - and it's doing pretty well, so, nyeh. What do we know.

5. Sexy Lady Ultron

Hey, it's our friend Brian Michael Bendis again! And this time he's brought along Frank Cho, the artist known primarily for drawing a pretty good Wolverine and then lots of scantily clad women with unrealistic proportions. And monkeys, for some reason. This was the team who helmed Mighty Avengers (one of the aforementioned multiple Avengers titles currently being published) and whose collaboration "peaked" with a storyline that reintroduced Ultron. Probably as close as the group have gotten to having an arch nemesis, the incredibly smart and incredibly evil creation of on-again, off-again team member Hank Pym - more on him in just a sec - has something of a grudge against the Avengers. Which means just when they think they've seen the dastardly rustbucket off, he's finding a way to reconstitute himself and sneak back into the Mansion to cause more havoc. This time he had a new way of weaseling his way into the lives of the Avengers - by becoming a sexy lady! Because duh. Interfacing with some Iron Man armour and taking it over, Ultron decides to take a similar form to the Wasp because, we dunno, Tony Stark's a womaniser or something? She kills The Sentry's wife, Ares disables her with a computer virus, everything goes back to normal, and Ultron is never seen in Wasp drag ever again. Which is good, as it was stupid.

4. Inviting Hank Pym Back

Hank Pym is history's greatest monster. At least he is in the Marvel Universe, a constant thorn in the side of everybody - and yet also a long-term member of the Avengers and a super genius who has save the world and inspired new heroes numerous times. Boasting an intellect comparable (or possibly even surpassing, if you ask him) that of Reed Richards or Tony Stark, Pym has nonetheless struggled to pin down a lasting alter ego. Over the years he's been Ant-Man, Giant Man, Goliath, Yellowjacket, and even nabbed his ex-wife's moniker Wasp for himself. Oh yeah, and she's his ex-wife because he's a violent narcissist who has beaten his former spouse on numerous occasions. Plus the Ultron thing, which is perhaps his most egregious crime against his own Avengers teammates. Attempting to create the first self-aware artificial intelligence, the hubris of Pym lead him to implanting his own rampant ego into the robot that became Ultron, the recurring and most fervent enemy of the Avengers. In fact accepting Pym back despite all of his mistakes almost literally ruined the Avengers, as the Age Of Ultron miniseries showed us a future utterly destroyed by his creation - it's only with some time travelling escapades and mulling over whether they should just go back in time and murder Hank before he invents the villain that it all gets sorted.

3. Inviting Wonder Man At All

Hank Pym did a lot of heinous things in his time, it's true. The reason they keep getting brushed aside, however, is that he is still a pretty invaluable member of any team. There's the fact that he's super smart, obviously, but also he invented the Pym particles that allowed him to shrink to the size of an ant or grow to the size of a giant/goliath (depending what breakdown he's on) and then the tech to do...whatever Yellowjacket's gimmick was. The gist of it is that Hank Pym keeps getting invited back to the Avengers despite all his sins is that he offers them something. As to why Wonder Man keeps appearing alongside Earth's Mightiest Heroes? There's absolutely no explanation. Originally debuting as a villain - which should tell you a lot - the amazing powers that Simon Williams brings to the table are like the default settings on the character creation screen of a videogame. He has super strength, can fly, fire lasers, and basically all the other abilities that are already catered for by literally every other member of the Avengers. There is no reason for him to be there. Especially considering he's a douchenozzle of the highest order, who quite a job with a superhero team who save thousands of lives on a regular basis to become an actor. He didn't think he was being appreciated enough, y'see. He's a fame-obsessed jerk and we're glad that even if he keeps popping up, he's not as huge a part of Avengers teams now as he used to be.

2. The Ms Marvel Ridiculousness

We've been through this whole rigamarole before, but it bears repeating, because it is honestly one of the most controversial and rightly reviled instances in the history of the Avengers (and Marvel comics as a whole). Carol Danvers was one of the few good female characters that the team had introduced at that point, endowed with the cosmic power of Captain Marvel and doing so with gusto. That all went out the window during a totally bonkers storyline where she woke up one morning six months pregnant, with absolutely no memory of how she'd gotten that way. Then the baby was born and he disappeared too. Turns out that he was a multi-dimensional space baby called Immortus who was...also the one who impregnated her in the first place? Basically he is a villain from the future who had kidnapped Ms Marvel, seduced and impregnated her, and then wiped her memory of any of that happening. Which meant there was some confusing paradoxes, issues of consent and incest all mixed up into one horrible, horrible package! Regardless of all of these traumatic revelations the Avengers were happy that Carol Danvers was happy with her new son/lover, and gave her their blessing as they went off to another dimension to do gross incestuous non-consensual stuff. Which they promptly did, until months later Ms Marvel returned and righteously laid into her supposed friends for letting her go off with a dude who had literally brainwashed her into loving him. Thankfully they all made up and we never spoke of this again. Except all the times we did.

1. Teen Tony Stark

There's a reason we won't stop harping on about The Crossing, y'know. And that reason is because it is truly heinous, one of the worst stories ever published in a comic book or potentially any medium, a catalogue of catastrophically idiotic ideas that they every nearly ruined not only one of Marvel's most enduring characters but also the team that he's the backbone of. Having acted a little odd for a while - including during his time with Force Works - it turns out that Tony Stark has been under the control of Kang The Conqueror since as long as the Avengers have been around, but it's only thirty years later that the villain decides to strike. And strike he does, using his brainwashed Iron Man to kill a handful of Avengers second-stringers that you don't really care that much about, but it's still a little upsetting to see a superhero murder. The blood on the traitorous Iron Man's hands is pretty apparent to his shocked colleagues, but they find themselves unable to take down the combined might of Tony and Kang. So obviously the best thing to do is to go back in time, pluck the teenaged Stark out of his bedroom and get him to talk some sense into his older self, right? Well, it's working for the X-Men right now, and if it's good enough for the X-Men... Turns out it's not good enough for the Avengers, as Old Tony pretty much ignores Young Tony and carries on being evil. It's only when Kang makes to kill the Young Tony - paradoxes be damned! - that his older self intervenes, breaking the mind control for just long enough to sacrifice himself to save...himself. So the Tony Stark that we'd been reading for decades was dead, leaving a kid in his place. Which Teen Tony literally did, taking the starring role in the now inexplicably-manga-styled Iron Man title and leading the Avengers. Despite being an actual child with no experience. This was such a mess that Marvel essentially cooked up the Heroes Reborn reboot specifically to undo this clustercuss. Another bullet dodged, nice one! Let's never speak of this again (we probably will, soz).

In this post: 
The Avengers
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/