10 Things Marvel Wants You To Forget About The Fantastic Four

...why is Sue still married to Reed again?

Fantastic Four Red
Marvel Comics

By far the most important Marvel characters of all time are the Fantastic Four. We call them the first family of comics for good reason, since without them, the Marvel universe would literally not exist and Stan Lee would have kept making tacky romance comics until he hit burnout and left. And frankly, that's not a world I wish to inhabit.

However, having such enormous shoes to fill have driven the many writers and artists that took over from Lee and Jack Kirby to make some... bold choices. Some, like the creation of the Future Foundation, are amazing and change everything about the FF for the better.

This list is not about those choices. No, this will look at the stuff that Marvel has gone out of their way to make you forget ever happened.

Whether it be because they're flat out awful or because writers just don't know what to do with the material they're continuing off from and so choose to ignore it altogether, these are the things Marvel would very much prefer you forget that the Fantastic Four were ever associated with.

10. They've Actually Been To Heaven

Fantastic Four Heaven
Marvel Comics

There is a LOT to love about Mark Waid's 2002 run on Fantastic Four, from its focus on simple, character driven narratives, to the beautiful cartoony artwork of the late great Mike Wieringo, and of course, its willingness to go where no Fantastic Four run before or since has been willing to go.

Case in point, the one adventure that the FF have been on that later books have tried to ignore. Not because it's bad, but because - well - what do you DO after "the Fantastic Four go to Heaven and meet GOD"?

After their last battle with Doctor Doom led to the death of Ben Grimm, Reed decides "ya know what? No. I'm not dealing with this! I'm gonna get my best buddy back!" and so rebuilds the machine Doom built to save his mother from Hell, but calibrates it to instead get them to the other place.

The story, particularly the scene where they meet God, who has of course taken the form of Jack Kirby, is excellent like the rest of Waid's run. But it's no surprise that future writers mostly ignore this. After all "I went to heaven and met God" is probably something you wanna keep to yourself, even if it actually happened to you.


9. Ben Once Had To Wear A Thing Suit

Thing Suit Marvel Comics
Marvel Comics

There are various points throughout the years where Ben Grimm gets his original body back, but those times usually coincide with him leaving the team for various reasons. But one time he decided to stick around, and Reed didn't want him to feel left out. So after Luke Cage ran with the team for a while, Reed constructed for Ben a high powered suit of armor that looked exactly like his original Thing form.

This, as you can imagine, did not last very long.

Let's start with the obvious reasons: it's a dumb idea. If Reed can do this, then surely he can make something sleeker and easier to move around with than The Thing's rocky shape, while still keeping the strength. And before you argue, remember that we're talking about a guy who casually decided to break into the afterlife itself, so yes, he could totally do that.

And furthermore, it completely misses the point of Ben's appearance as The Thing. It represents Reed's biggest mistake, permanently taking away his best friend's normal life because of a stupid decision he made. So why would he build him a suit that looks exactly like the thing Ben wanted to get away from in the first place?


8. Marvel Girl

Valeria Richards Marvel Girl
Marvel Comics

You might know Valeria Richards as the hyper intelligent, precocious toddler of the Richards family, and unless you're super into classic FF, you probably think that her story BEGAN with her being born with the help of Doctor Doom.

Yeah, uh, that's not what happened.

Originally, Sue had a miscarriage, losing her second baby. But young Franklin was unwilling to accept that the little sister he was so ready to meet would never come, so using his godlike reality warping powers, he transported the baby that could have been to another universe, where Reed died and Sue shacked up with a reformed Doctor Doom.

Of course, Valeria found her way to the 616 universe and joined up with the Fantastic Four she was supposed to be born to, becoming the bubblegum popping rock star wildcard of the team until she decided to give herself up to have another shot at being reborn in her original universe. This is how we got the Valeria Richards we know and love.

As great a character as Marvel Girl was - spunky, fun, and incapable of taking sh*t from anyone - if Valeria is introduced in the MCU, they'll probably just skip over this part of her origin. This is a long and winding road to just arrive at "hyper intelligent four-year old"


7. Reed's Actions During Civil War

civil war negative zone prison
Marvel Comics

Reed is one of the most brilliant minds in the entire Marvel canon, but that just means that when he DOES screw up, he screws up harder than anyone else. Case in point, the hot mess that is Civil War.

Now no one comes out of Civil War looking like anything approaching likeable, but Reed in particular screws up in two key ways, the other of which I'll get into later. For now, let's go over how he screwed up in Civil War.

First off, him being part of the illuminati was such a disastrous decision that it was later revealed that there are alternate versions of Reed who murdered the Illuminati at their first meeting because he knew that NOTHING good could come of this nonsense. Then, of course, there's the fact that he built a murderous clone of Thor, who then proceeded to kill Goliath in the first major conflict of Civil War.

And then the fact that he built a high security prison for heroes who violate the registration act stationed in the Negative Zone. Locking up people the government deems criminals is one thing, but the fact that he then renders these heroes - his friends and colleagues - refugees in another reality is a step over the line that the comics have either tried and failed to reconcile, or just straight up ignored.

But there was one other thing he did during this time, but what was it? Oh yes I remember now...


6. Reed Shot The Hulk Into Space

Planet Hulk
Marvel Comics

Yeah it wasn't SOLELY his decision but considering how thoroughly Marvel swept this under the rug after The Hulk returned to Earth (until Immortal Hulk brought it back up a decade later), I feel it counts.

Reed Richards, despite being the most genius mind in the Marvel universe and teamed up with the other biggest brainy boys in that universe, decided that the only solution to The Hulk was to shoot him into space after he levelled Las Vegas. Oh and he does this with a ship powered by fuel so explosive that, if tampered with or sabotaged, it can reduce an entire city to a crater. But surely THAT won't come back to bite him at all.

Yeah so anyway, Planet Hulk happened and at the end, the ship explodes and kills Hulk's pregnant wife.

Besides World War Hulk, which saw The Hulk air his many grievances with the Marvel Illuminati, there wasn't much in the way of confrontation of the many mistakes Reed and the others made. Writers like the late, great Dwayne McDuffie brought it up later, but the books never really committed to facing his mistakes. Probably because they were so grievous the only way to keep him likeable would be to just pretend Civil War never happened.


5. Fant4stic

Fant4stic ... 4?
Screenrant

If you want a perfect summary of everything comic book movies get wrong about adapting their source material, you need look no further than Josh Trank's abomination, Fant4stic.

It's hard to even come up with things to say about this legendary failure of a movie, as the entire internet spent the year it came out carefully dissecting it to find out just what in God's name Trank and Fox thinking when they made it.

Absolutely nothing about its story works; Miles Teller is one of the most miscast leads in cinema history, the darker, edgier, body horror vibe falls flat on its face, it just fundamentally doesn't work.

And with the acquisition of Fox, Disney now has the ability to finally break the curse of terrible Fantastic Four movies.

As time passes, the best thing that can happen to the first family of comics is getting this movie further and further out of public consciousness.


4. The Roger Corman Film Was Only Made To Retain Film Rights

Roger Corman Fantastic Four Documentary L
New Horizons

Hardcore fans of the Fantastic Four know all about the infamous and unfinished Roger Corman Fantastic Four movie. It's one of those movies that's impossible to hate despite everyone agreeing that it is terrible, because it just has this shoe string budget charm to it that makes it amazing to riff on with friends.

However, while the behind the scenes tidbit about this movie being nowhere close to being finished is common enough knowledge, what's a bit more obscure is the reason WHY it was so rushed and put together so slapdash. Turns out, they only made this thing to retain the movie rights to the Fantastic Four IP.

Now granted, this isn't COMPLETELY obscure knowledge, as there was a documentary made about this film called Doomed! The Untold Story Of Roger Corman's The Fantastic Four that details everything about this infamous production. However, Marvel Studios would likely very much prefer its loyal fanbase forget about this incredibly legally shady business move to hold onto a property they weren't doing much with to begin with.


3. Their Comic Was Canceled Due To A Dispute With Fox

Fantastic Four 4
Marvel Comics

Comic publishers and movie studios are basically gigantic fussy babies masquerading as corporations, so it should come as no surprise that someone getting to play with Marvel's toys meant that Marvel would spend several years just pretending that they never liked that toy to begin with.

This is why no one likes Ike Perlmutter.

Due to a dispute with Fox over the film rights of Fantastic Four, Perlmutter sent down a kill order on anything having to do with the Fantastic Four, while the X-Men merely got severely sidelined. All this so that Marvel wouldn't have to give "free advertising" for what they saw as a rival getting to use their stuff.

Now obviously Marvel would get the last laugh there, and that's a whole other can of worms we won't get into today, but this is also clearly an example of Ike Perlmutter being just the worst.

The Fantastic Four have since come back, but there was a solid few years where the world the Richards family built outright rejected them, and whatever metaphors you draw from that... none of them are good.


2. Their Countless Tacky Redesigns

Fantastic Four Invisible Woman Redesign
Marvel Comics

Superhero costumes all go through changes at one point or another, with some always adhering to the same basic template, and others going off in wildly different directions to either indicate a change to the hero or to suit an artist's style better.

...or because the artists wants to draw boobs. That's also another reason.

The Fantastic Four have gone through multiple redesigns over the years. Hell they didn't even HAVE uniforms at the beginning - fans had to browbeat Lee and Kirby into giving them suits. But the suits Kirby created are some of the best designs he ever crafted. Simplistic yet striking, the Fantastic Four suits are now a vital part of their identity.

But that wasn't good enough for many artists, who proceeded to needlessly tweak what wasn't broken. Sometimes you'd get a good retooling of the classic suits like Mike Wieringo's design of the suits during the Mark Waid run, or you had drastically different designs that worked like gangbusters, as seen with the ones seen in Future Foundation.

And then sometimes you got Sue basically wearing a bikini, Reed putting nineties pouches on his suit, and Ben wearing a stupid looking helmet for even stupider reasons.


1. Reed's Misogyny

Reed Richards Slap Sue Storm
Marvel Comics

Most writers these days like to portray Reed Richards as the platonic ideal of the benevolent scientist and explorer. Someone who goes out into the stars not to conquer but to understand, always fascinated with every new thing that comes his way and loves his family more than life itself.

Yeah it, uh... took us a while to get to that point.

Not to say that that wasn't always the intent with Reed, but he was also definitely a product of the times. The joke with Reed was that he was a high strung stick in the mud, "father knows best" type, with the fact that his powers were stretching and being super flexible acting as the punchline.

However, as the old saying goes, comedy is the fastest to age, and the fastest to age poorly. Nowadays, old Reed just comes off like a condescending and uncomfortably sexist, misogynistic pig. None of the enlightened genius family man of Hickman, or the geeky but always well meaning hero of Waid, but instead a man who you really just wanna kick in the nuts every time he talks to Susan - who really should've just eloped with Namor by this point - like she's anything less than the best thing in his entire life.

Marvel would love nothing more than for everyone to forget this era of Reed Richards, and honestly, obliging them might not be the worst idea.


Watch Next


The Ultimate Fantastic Four Quiz

Fantastic four
Marvel Comics

1. Who Were The Co-Creators Of The Fantastic Four?

Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?