10 Things Marvel Wants You To Forget About The Thing

What a Grimm history...

Fantastic Four Thing
Marvel Comics

Everyone's favourite ever-lovin' blue-eyed Thing might be the Fantastic Four's best character, but it must be said that the hero hasn't always enjoyed a perfect history.

The subject of retcons, reboots, power-shifts and more, Benjamin Grimm has been the subject of a fair few comic book controversies throughout his time, some on live-action, others otherwise.

And while there's no getting away from the fact that he is one of Marvel's best creations, there have been occasions where Ben's featured in some rather silly moments in the past, being both the victim of comics writers and of some dubious movie-making exploits since his original comic book debut in 1961.

He’s one of Jack Kirby’s very best creations, and an icon of Marvel as much as he is of the medium more generally. That’s majorly important, so it stands to reason that Marvel would probably want you to forget about some of his most embarrassing moments, particularly when he's had so many of them over the years.

We all love you Ben, but some things are just too difficult to ignore...


10. He Had A Cartoon Block With The Flinstones

Fred and Barney Meet the Thing
Hanna-Barbera

By far one of the most bizarre cartoon blocks out there, Fred and Barney Meet the Thing was an animated series that aired in the late seventies. The reason behind its creation? Marvel was actually working with Hanna-Barbera at the time, allowing for both companies' characters to share the small screen in some way or another.

Despite the title, Fred and Barn never actually ended up meeting Ben Grimm. Instead, they only shared a title sequence, with one half devoted to the Flinstones and the other to the Fantastic Four's premier character. Thing's segments weren't all that comic-accurate though, with the series focussing on Benjy Grimm - a young teenager - as he transforms into the Thing by pressing two magic rings together.

Needless to say, the show's catchphrase of 'Thing ring, do your thing' never really caught on, with the show lasting just shy of three months with thirteen episodes to its name.

Why not use the actual Thing? Who knows. At least the catchphrase never caught on...


9. He's Only Beaten The Hulk Once Before

Hulk Thing Fight
Marvel Comics

While Thing and Hulk tend to get matched up all the time, owed to the fact they're two of the strongest earth-bound heroes in the Marvel library, Ben Grimm doesn't boast the best of records against the jolly green giant, having only bested him once in all their confrontations.

It makes sense, given that the Hulk is one of the strongest Marvel characters out there, but you'd think he'd give Ben a break, or at least that Ben would back off for a bit. But no, everyone's favourite rocky monster has had to deal with his fair share of beatdowns over the years, including a particularly fateful incident in 1971 where he came close to death.

Stan Lee even offered his own thoughts on the matter by saying Hulk would win, lest the Thing try any trickery with the help of his Fantasti-comrades.

With Stan the Man having settled the matter, it's difficult to see why they keep getting marketed as the superhero fight of the century. Just let it go, Ben. For our sake and yours.


8. His Wardrobe

Ultimate Thing
Marvel Comics

While there's a lot that can be said about the Fantastic Four's outfits (especially Sue Storm's dreadful nineties redesign), there's no denying that they're iconic. Blue, white and sometimes red, the Four's wardrobe has been imitated on countless occasions, most famously in Pixar's Incredibles.

However, there's probably a reason why Ben Grimm's outfits have never formed the inspiration for many copycats, owing to the fact that (to go full Edna Mode for just once second), they looked quite ugly. Shifting from just some undies to a full jumpsuit over the years, Ben's never been one to settle on one design, preferring the feel of the breeze on his rocky exterior rather than the confines of a blue and white jumpsuit.

And that's fine, really. The Thing's got his own style, and he can rock it anyway he rocks. It'd just be nice for him to settle on one look, y'know? Especially when he's yet to sport one definitive get-up.

Whatever he chooses, it'll be better than his Ultimate outfit, that's for sure...


7. Roger Corman's Failed Film

Roger Corman Fantastic Four Movie
New Horizons

Roger Corman's failed Fantastic Four film is the stuff of legend, with its design for the Thing taking a special level of notoriety for its horrific inflections.

While Kirby's original design for Ben Grimm was always meant to harken back to classic horror movie monsters, the Thing from Corman's project is a whole different beast altogether. Portrayed by Michael Bailey Smith prior to his transformation, stuntman Carl Ciarfalio played Grimm after his cosmic transformation, donning a rubber suit that couldn't hold a candle to the puppetry of the early Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles films, which released concurrently at the time.

No one emerged for the better from the project, with the film having been made in a last ditch attempt to retain the onscreen rights for the characters and not for commercial release, making it one of the more infamous episodes in the development of the comic book genre on film. Avi Arad even purchased the rights to the project and ordered all prints be destroyed, fearing that its release would've damaged the Marvel brand at the time.

You can still watch the whole thing though, if you're in the mood for a B-movie Four flick. Just don't expect a proper release any time soon.


6. He Hasn't Always Been A Part Of The Fantastic Four

Guardians of the Galaxy Thing
Marvel Comics

While fans may know Ben Grimm as the Fantastic Four's most iconic member, he hasn't always been on it. In fact, the Thing can boast membership for a variety of different superhero teams, including the Avengers, the West Coast Avengers and even the Guardians of the Galaxy, shattering the illusion that he's always been a mainstay of the Fantastic Four.

Various members have jumped in and out of the team, but none more frequently than Ben. She-Hulk once took his spot in the group, as did Luke Cage, and he's been in and out of the team periodically since. This isn't a new concept by any means; most X-Men have occupied a permanent spot on the Avengers roster at some point, but it is true that Ben's jumped into more teams than most people would've perhaps thought.

For the most part, these switches have worked. His time on the Avengers, for instance, made a great deal of sense, especially in light of the Four's fragmentation on account of Civil War. Given the character's cosmic roots, heading into space with the Guardians of the Galaxy also seemed like a smart move, even if it did come at a time where people were missing Marvel's first family.

Ben Grimm: Avenger, Guardian, and member of the Fantastic Four. That's a pretty impressive resumé.


5. He Was Once Killed By Reed Richards

Reed Richards kills Thing
Marvel Comics

Given the Four's image as Marvel's most wholesome family, the fact that Reed Richards actually killed the Thing probably won't sit well with everyone.

During Mark Waid's run on Fantastic Four, the team head to Latveria and take down Doctor Doom once and for all. The dictator dies, and Reed, in all his apparent wisdom, decides to run the place himself. Growing more unhinged by the day and inviting controversy at a global scale, Reed accidentally releases Doom's spirit from Hell and proceeds to track it down. Unfortunately for Reed - and Ben - Doom possesses the Thing, forcing a split-second decision from the team leader where he kills Ben to vanquish Victor, supposedly once and for all.

Obviously this moment came during one of the team's low points, but Ben's death felt bizarre then and still does now. Given Reed's actions in Civil War (which took place just a few years after this storyline), it's clear that the family have their issues like any other. Just, y'know, with the added caveat of energy-based death.

Ben soon returned thanks to some science-based shenanigans, but as far as periods go, this has to be one of the family's worst.


4. He Once Became Even More Rock-Like Than Usual

Thing Mutation Marvel
Marvel Comics

Whew, that is one spikey boy.

Although the prospect of the Thing transforming to become even Thing-ier might seem like an odd one, such a thing happened in the late eighties. Hit by further rays, Ben takes on an even rockier complexion, resembling a video game villain more than an actual comic book character. The design just looked awkward, with the character only returning to his older form out of his feelings for Ms. Marvel.

Needless to say, Ben has never returned to the spiked design, with Kirby's original vision dominating the character's subsequent appearances as should be the case.

That said, it's not the weirdest design change the character's underwent, or the silliest...


3. He Once Had To Wear A 'Thing-Suit'

Thing Suit Marvel Comics
Marvel Comics

In one of the character's stranger moments, Ben Grimm unexpectedly reverted back to human form which, as you would've probably guessed already, placed his superhero status in jeopardy.

Reed, not wanting Ben to feel left out, presumably, began to fashion a 'Thing-Suit' for him to wear - one that bore all the features of the character's original rock-like exterior. Luke Cage took his spot on the team until it was completed, but when it was, Ben fought crime just like the rest of the team, chomping on cigars and shouting catchphrases like there was no tomorrow.

The idea of a 'Thing-Suit' never really caught on though, leading Marvel's writers to bring the old Ben back out of the blue. It was probably for the best, given the significance of the character's physical change, and the suit is yet to be dusted off since.


2. He Turned Evil

Thing Evil Fear Itself
Marvel Comics

As far as comic book tropes go, seeing heroes turn evil has to be one of the worst, especially when it's temporary and out of character.

Marvel tried such a ploy with Daredevil for Shadowland, and followed it up with the Thing in the year afterwards during Fear Itself, a universe-wide comics event that featured Ben as your average, ordinary, everyday possessed hero. He's deployed as an antagonist throughout the comic as Angrir, the anointed 'Breaker of Souls', and reverts back to normal shortly after fighting Thor.

That wasn't the only time Ben's had to contend with an unfortunate event, sadly. In Original Sin, it turned out that he'd actually murdered the Puppet Master, and that Johnny had unwittingly sabotaged an experiment to bring him back to his normal form.

Event books don't seem to do ol' Ben any justice whatsoever, but at least things are looking up for him now, starring alongside Johnny in Chip Zdarksy and Jim Cheung's Marvel Two-in-One.


1. He Left His Fiancée At The Altar

Thing Debbie Green
Marvel Comics

While this speaks more to Marvel and DC's bizarre anti-marriage policy in the new millennium than it does to Ben himself, this moment bears mentioning as a reminder of just how bizarre a policy it was.

When Ben Grimm met Debbie Green in Fantastic Four #554, it looked as though it was love at first sight. Their relationship soon blossomed and, before you know it, Ben popped the question, booking a wedding for the next year and becoming the talk of the town in the process.

By the time it got to the main event, however, Ben decided to up and leave, conscious of the fact that superhero marriages tend to end in tragedy and suffixing it all by recycling the Toby Maguire monologue from Spider-Man in the process.

Much like One More Day and DC's later insistence that Kate Kane and Maggie Sawyer couldn't marry, Ben's last minute decision to call the whole thing off was emblematic of one of the weirdest editorial mandates of our time, and a moment to forget for Marvel to this day.

Know of any awkward Thing moments? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!


Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.