10 Things Marvel Wants You To Forget About The X-Men

Remember when they tried to get rid of them?

magneto x-men
Marvel Comics

The X-Men have had a very long, confusing, sometimes great, and sometimes not so great history. From their quiet and humble beginnings to the constant modern-day changes, the mutant nation is a key component to the Marvel landscape.

Since Chris Claremont jumped onto the ship and sailed into uncharted waters with great success, the X-Men have often been one of the biggest sellers in Marvel. So much so that multiple spin-off teams have taken the plunge into the Marvel Universe as well. Some of those teams have gone onto be successful and boosted the mutant tapestry of lore. Some have left stains on said tapestry.

The X-Men were brought into life in 1963 by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby. With a rich history comes plenty of stories. A lot of stories have had a lasting, often positive, impact on X-Men readers. Some stories have inspired thoughts about the world we live in.

But not every story has been great. In fact, with Marvel/Disney purchasing Fox and bringing the X-Men film rights back home, there’s going to be some moments that Marvel would like us to forget about the X-Men.

10. X-Force Killing A Child

Fantomex Apocalypse X-Force
Marvel Comics

A spin-off team of the X-Men, X-Force were created in 1991 from the ashes of the New Mutants. After its original cancellation, and a couple of false restarts, the team properly arrived back in 2008. They were brought in to eliminate potential threats to mutants, with lethal force.

In 2010, Rick Remender jumped on board to write the Uncanny X-Force series. The first story arc involved Apocalypse being reborn. After the team face off against the new Horseman, they finally arrive to where Clan Akkaba are keeping Apocalypse. Only to find out Apocalypse has been reborn as a child.

Playing on the theory of whether a person could go back in time and kill Hitler as a baby, the X-Force team are split on whether to kill child Apocalypse. Due to the indoctrinated upbringing Apocalypse has had, against the fact he has yet to do anything wrong himself, made this decision difficult.

Eventually, the team can’t bring themselves to kill Apocalypse and decide to attempt to break the indoctrination by taking him back to their mutant brethren. However, a gun is fired, and Apocalypse’s body thuds onto the ground. Fantomex stands with the smoking gun.

Later in the series, we find out that Fantomex has cloned Apocalypse to try and raise him well. While this does ease the shock of the events, we still witnessed a child being murdered.


9. Xorn/Magneto - Who Is It Really?

Magneto As Xorn
Marvel Comics

Coming off the heels off the X-Men film franchise taking off, Grant Morrison was brought in as a writer for the New X-Men series in 2001. Morrison was looking to use the films to influence the series and shake up the status quo for Marvel’s ‘next step in human evolution’. One example of this was the X-Men costumes were replaced by black leather. However, another idea caused Marvel to retcon it almost immediately.

During the Planet X story arc, the newly introduced character, Xorn, removed his helmet to show he was actually Magneto. Magneto wanted to finally turn the earth into a mutant paradise… by killing almost everyone. Magneto had an addiction to Kick, a mutant-power booster, that was crumbling his sanity.

During Magneto’s rampage, he was involved in the deaths of Jean Grey, Esme and thousands of New Yorkers. Eventually he was decapitated by a berserk Wolverine.

Afterwards, Marvel changed their mind on Magneto being so brutal. They created a convoluted story that it was really a new and different Xorn’s brother that was possessed by an unknown being. Apparently, Xorn’s brother has the same powers as Magneto.

Magneto was on Genosha after the destruction of the mutant island during the beginning of Morrison’s run, so it made for a pretty confusing retcon.


8. X-Men Gold #1

X-Men Gold Kitty Pryde
Marvel Comics

In 2017, X-Men Gold was the anticipated new chapter in Marvel’s mutant collection. After years of neglect, Marvel looked as though they’d be giving their mutants some thorough love and care. Issue one got off to a rough start, however.

Ardian Syaf was the penciler responsible for the series at the time. In the first issue, the X-Men are playing baseball and Colossus steps up to bat with his t-shirt reading “QS 5:51”. This message references a passage in the Qur’an advising Muslims not to put Christians or Jewish people in places of power. Syaf is from Jakarta in Indonesia where an election was taking place for the position of governor, which Basuki Tjahaja Purnama held at the time.

Other such messages appeared in the issue as well. “212” was printed on the front of a building that references a date that a protest against Basuki Tjahaja Purnama was to take place. In the same panel, Kitty Pryde, who’s a Jewish-American leader in the mutant community, is addressing a group of civilians. Next to her on a store is a crudely placed “Jewelry” sign.

The blatantly anti-semitic messages added by Syaf became world news. The penciller was fired by Marvel immediately for using their medium to promote his political stance.


7. Professor Xavier Loves Jean Grey

Professor X Jean Grey
Marvel Comics

Charles Xavier is a wise, older, psychic, and bald mentor to the X-Men. Even though he hasn’t always led the group, Xavier is still seen as a father-figure to a lot of the heroic mutants.

In 1964, a panel showed Xavier’s inner-monologue where his thoughts confessed his love for the underage Jean Grey. Gross. No other writer touched on this until the Onslaught Saga event kicked off in 1996.

During the story arc Fatal Attractions, Xavier wiped the mind of Magneto. This would lead into the dark consciousness of the two forming Onslaught. During the Onslaught Saga, Onslaught met Jean Grey on the astral plane as he was looking for sources of power. He had hoped the avatar of the Phoenix Force, Jean Grey, would join him on his crusade. He showed her what her mentor and father-figure really felt for her in those early X-Men days.

Jean didn’t react too well and instigated a battle with Onslaught. Onslaught ended up defeating Jean and forced her astral form back into her body. He also wiped the experience of what had happened from Jean’s mind.

If Onslaught asked, Jean would have asked him to wipe that memory away anyway. A lot of readers would like to forget it as well.


6. Feral Wolverine

Feral Wolverine
Marvel Comics

In 1993, Fatal Attractions was the big X-Men event. The story resulted in Magneto causing Wolverine’s skeleton to be stripped of its’ adamantium. With the huge trauma and his healing factor working overtime, Wolverine was near death’s door.

Eventually he did recover. Fans also found out Wolverine always had claws and it wasn’t an effect of the adamantium, but they also found out something that wasn’t as fun.

The adamantium in Wolverine’s system was poisoning him, which caused his healing factor to constantly battle the metal. Once the adamantium was removed, Wolverine’s “natural mutation” could take place. This allowed Wolverine to became more animalistic. This meant he began yelling instead of talking, acting like an animal, and he was more prone to berserker rages.

After an attempt to reinsert the adamantium, Wolverine became even more feral and this meant he lost his nose… for reasons. During this time, Wolverine left Xavier’s mansion to live in the wild. This was due to feeling more animal than man.

Eventually, the feral Wolverine concept was dropped as Logan arrived back at the mansion as his old-self. No explanation was provided. It was quickly pushed under the rug as though that experience was just a fever dream.


5. Chuck Austen’s X-Men

Uncanny X-Men #433 The Draco Nightcrawler
Marvel Comics

Chuck Austen wrote for the various X-Men comics from 2002 to 2005, and his work isn’t looked on too fondly by fans.

For starters, Austen introduced Nightcrawler’s father Azazel, another Devil-like character in Marvel. Azazel was looking to escape his dimension to get to Earth 616. He decided he needed teleporting offspring that would be able to combine their powers to create a portal. Azazel achieved this by... just... coming to Earth to impregnate women. Apparently, Azazel can get to Earth just fine, making the whole scheme somewhat redundant.

Another negative element included the Purifiers attempting to trick people into believing the rapture is taking place. They also wanted to make Nightcrawler the Pope but have his image inducer fail. Thus, showing Nightcrawler’s demon-like form to the Catholic faithful.

Another fan-hated story was the Polaris, Havok, Iceman, and nurse Annie Ghazikhanian’s love square as it was mess. Finally, there was Angel and Husk deciding to have sex in the air while Husk’s family are below watching on. Needless to say, a lot of characters did not act like themselves.

Once Austen was removed from working on anything Marvel produced, there was a lot of damage control to save the mutant crew. After the work of Grant Morrison and Joss Whedon on Astonishing X-Men, Austen’s run is something fans, critics, and Marvel wants everyone to forget.


4. X-Men Wasn’t Originally A Hit

X-Men #1
Marvel Comics

In 1991, X-Men #1 became the biggest selling comic of all time. Written by Chris Claremont and art by Jim Lee, this issue sold 8.1 million times with the combination of variant covered issues. But in 1970, the original run of the series was cancelled.

After Stan Lee and Jack Kirby left their work on X-Men as sales began to fall, Roy Thomas and Neal Adams took over. After they reached issue 66, and one year on from when they joined, the series was cancelled. From issue 67 to 93, no more new stories were coming out from the land of mutants. Instead, older issues were reprinted.

As the X-Men floundered in limbo, from the shadows out stepped Len Wein and Dave Cockrum. In 1975, they rejuvenated the mutant brand with Giant-Size X-Men. They replaced most of the original team and introduced exciting and experienced mutants from around the globe.

Shortly after, newcomer Chris Claremont came into the series as a writer. Claremont used soap-opera elements in the stories that fascinated readers. The X-Men fanbase grew rapidly, and this eventually led to the series reaching its peak popularity in the 1990s.

While the X-Men haven’t quite reached those heights since, it still has a devoted fanbase. It's wild to think that, had it not been for Wein and Cockrum, that may never have been the case.


3. Flip-Flopped Origins

Cannonball death New Mutants X-Men
Marvel Comics

Retcons happen all the time in comics. It’s an aspect we the readers all have to accept. Sometimes they can be great and bring in new dynamics. Other times, they can be terrible.

To start off with, Cannonball’s mutant origin was changed. Cable informed the New Mutant/X-Force mutant and future member of the Avengers that he was an External. In short, an External is a mutant with the added benefit of immortality. Until this new element was just dropped as it turns out it was a mistake from Cable. Cannonball was JUST a regular mutant.

Northstar and his sister Aurora found out their mother was an Elf. Which resulted in Northstar going off to live with his newly discovered family. Only to find out it was all a lie from Loki. They’re JUST mutants too.

Finally, in 2007 Romulus told Wolverine he was a Lupine instead of a mutant. Lupines are a species of humans that evolved from canines instead of simians. This change did not go down too well with fans, and for 5 years, this was considered canon... Until Romulus’ sister, Remus, told Wolverine that Romulus was lying, and Lupines aren’t actually a thing. Wolverine went back to being a near-immortal mutant. Tough life.


2. The Ultimate Universe

Marvel Ultimatum
Marvel Comics

The Ultimate line was created by Marvel in 2000. The purpose was for new readers to jump in without bothering with decades' worth of convoluted continuity. It was also designed to take a more realistic approach. It didn’t take long for that to be forgotten about, and it was then treated as a place for creators to let their imaginations run free. Somewhere along the line, those imaginations got a little too carried away.

As well as the inappropriate relationship between the siblings Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver, the big event Ultimatum happened.

Marvel wanted to create a clear separation between the main universe and the Ultimate Universe. Apparently, this had to be achieved by gruesomely killing the X-Men systematically. The characters on the casualty list included Wolverine, Cyclops, Charles Xavier, Magneto, Beast, and Angel, and it was genuinely grim.

A lot of moments were out of character, such as Magneto snapping Xavier’s neck. Some were even over-the-top such as Magneto obliterating Wolverine multiple times before Wolverine died. Most of the book came across as an uncomfortable glorification of gore.


1. Inhumans Are The New Mutants

Inhumans VS X-Men #1
Marvel Comics

Inhumans are a subset of humans that have had their genes experimented on by an alien race. They’re able to get their powers with the aid of Terrigen Mist. Sounds like mutants, right? No? Well, Marvel wanted the readers to think so.

Once the MCU became the powerhouse it is today, one of their comics’ most popular teams still had their film rights locked in at Fox. Marvel - specifically Ike Perlmutter - weren't fans. So, the Inhumans were picked as the substitute, and the mutant family began to suffer as a result.

Suddenly, Avenger members Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver were no longer mutants, Inhuman numbers increased globally after the Infinity event, and X-Men related books were reduced along with the Fantastic Four, another casualty of the dispute between Marvel and Fox.

The storyline Inhumans Vs. X-Men, which kicked off in 2016, was meant to be a sort of symbolic passing of the torch. Instead, the Inhumans were turned into a kind of X-Men parody. Marvel stepped away from what made the Inhumans exclusive - that being the unique stories from their Royal status - and turned them into less compelling versions of the X-Men.

However, once the Inhumans’ TV show was cancelled, the writing was on the wall. Fans just couldn't get behind the Inhumans over Marvel’s previously adored mutants, and now the X-Men are in the midst of a major comeback.


Watch Next


Contributor

Jordy McKen hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.