10 Things That Will Never Happen In The DC Cinematic Universe

Like Green Lantern finding his girlfriend dead in a fridge...

DC and Warner Brothers will soon be ramping up production on Zack Snyder's Batman vs. Superman (which, by now, should really just be the official title) and have recently announced that Snyder will be following the film with a Justice League title slated for as early as 2017. That film will precede a reported slew of films that will break the DC Cinematic Universe wide open, hopefully giving a select handful of DC Comic heroes their time to shine. While Man of Steel has so far been the only film released as an official part of the shared universe, the multi-movie franchise is already beginning to come into focus - there are at least 10 Things We Expect to Happen in the DC Cinematic Universe, and more casting and script news should become evident as Batman vs. Superman gets underway. But there are certain things that will never find a home on the silver screen, at least not while mega-franchising comic book movies remains a popular fad. Origin stories, major events, entire story arcs and entire characters - whether they're too dark, not dark enough, or just not a good fit for a feature film, these are things you'll be waiting for a long time to see in cinemas. Marvel and Disney continue to capitalize on the success of their film universe, and Sony and Fox are following suit. DC and Warner Brothers have their work cut out for them, but they also have a fine roster of characters and decades of material to draw from. If they get it right, we may be in for a new kind of film franchise - one of a very different variety than Marvel has given us so far. With a slight spoiler warning regarding Man of Steel and a few DC Comics arcs, let's look forward to - or not look forward to, as it were - 10 Things That Will Never Happen in the DC Cinematic Universe...

10. Golden Age Origins

Origin stories are all the rage these days. Each of the first installments of the major Marvel sub-franchises (Iron Man, Thor, Captain America, and Hulk) have been "how it all came to be" yarns, each character more or less accepting the role of hero by the end of the film. Christopher Nolan's Batman Begins may have set the bar highest in terms of superhero origins on film, and Man of Steel kicked off the DC Cinematic Universe with a coming-of-age story for the Big Blue Boy Scout. With the news that a Justice League film will follow Snyder's Batman vs. Superman - which itself will feature the two titular heroes, Wonder Woman, Cyborg, and possibly other future Leaguers - DC and Warner Brothers look to be evading the Marvel formula and diving headlong into their big team-up. Despite this, it's quite clear that many of the heroes involved will get their own origin films somewhere down the line, even if they jump back on the timeline to pre-Justice League years. And while there's certainly no shortage of material from the comics, it's highly unlikely that origin stories from the Golden Age will find any application in this more modernised universe. DC has rebooted their comics continuity several times, each complete with new origin stories, and it's much more likely that we'll see something drawn from the past 30 years than any "true" origins. Golden and Silver Age tales on the whole may not get much playing time, considering the thirst of modern audiences for gritty tragedy.

9. A Surprise In The Fridge

So Golden Age stories won't get adapted (at least not faithfully) because, frankly, they're too light and happy - but on the other side of that coin are the times when DC goes really dark, too dark for a PG-13 film. By way of example, we have a plot development that is fairly integral to Kyle Rayner's accepting of the Green Lantern mantle. Kyle comes home one day to find a note, signed by his girlfriend Alex, about a surprise in the refrigerator (Green Lantern Vol. 3 #54, 1994). To Kyle's horror, he finds the villain Major Force has brutally murdered Alex and stuffed her body in the fridge. It wasn't shown in great gory detail, but the implied event nonetheless set off a firestorm both in Kyle's world and in the real world, inciting various commentary on women's rights and the depiction of women in comics. This kind of thing would have to merit an R rating, even as an implied event shown offscreen. An R-rated flick within the DC Cinematic Universe isn't out of the question, but it's highly unlikely. Warner Brothers and DC want to tell good stories (maybe?) that are faithful to the comics (maybe not?), but most of all they want to make truckloads of money. Aside from infuriating parents across the globe by adding such a brutal scene, an R rating drastically reduces the size of a potential audience and, in this case, sends them to go see a Marvel film instead.

8. Incorporation Of Elseworlds Tales

This one is fairly obvious, but worth a mention nonetheless. Elseworlds is the now-defunct DC imprint that focused on out-of-continuity, alternative takes on classic DC heroes. Most of them are shameless money-grabs, but a handful of the titles are great comics worth reading - and seeing a feature film adaptation of these would be nothing short of awesome. Again - and on the subject of money-grabbing - there's just no way that Elseworlds adaptations will see the light of day anytime in the foreseeable future. DC and Warner Brothers, despite only having produced one film as a part of their shared universe, are clearly putting all of the superhero eggs in that franchise basket. Not only would it be counterintuitive and confusing to non-comic book fans to have a disjointed continuity, but it would jeopardize the kind of capitalization that Marvel and Disney make with each successive film. Still, who doesn't want to see a steampunk-esque Batman kicking ass in Victorian Era Gotham? Who doesn't want to find out what happens when Superman hails from Soviet Russia instead of the good ol' USA? These one-shot graphic novels can be brilliant in their execution precisely because they aren't tied down to an extended continuity, and adapting that kind of thing to a feature film could potentially make for a phenomenal standalone superhero flick.

7. Batman And The Joker Laugh Together

Alan Moore is possibly the most recognizable name in comics, having turned out such seminal classics as Watchmen, V for Vendetta, and The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. Like most comic book writers of such stature, it was only a matter of time before Moore got ahold of the Dark Knight in a book of his own: 1988's The Killing Joke. Aside from featuring a pseudo-origin for the man that would become The Joker, The Killing Joke features several of Batman's darkest moments - the most memorable of these may be the physical and emotional torture of Commissioner James Gordon and the shooting of his daughter Barbara. But the final pages of Moore's Bat-book are confoundingly ambiguous: The Joker tells a long and winding joke, and Batman slowly begins to smile. By the final page the two of them are in stitches together like old pals. Various theories hold that Batman kills Joker on the last page, or offer explanations for why Bruce would allow his cold exterior to crack in this particular instance. The entire scene is extremely uncomfortable, mainly because of the awful things we've just witnessed Joker do. Batman - our "hero" - is now sharing a fit of laughter with a homicidal maniac. There's little doubt that the Joker will eventually find his way into the DC Cinematic Universe, but Ben Affleck's Batman won't be recreating this iconic scene with him. For the same reason that Hollywood won't cause controversy with an R rating, scenes like this paint too dark a picture for mainstream audiences to handle.

6. Hal Jordan Breaks Bad

Hal Jordan, Silver Age Green Lantern and arguably the best-loved to ever wear that green ring, will almost certainly factor into DC's plans for their shared universe despite the Ryan Reynolds Green Lantern fiasco of a few years ago. Regardless of which Green Lantern appears first - considering John Stewart or even Alan Scott could pop up - Jordan will get his due soon enough. One of the more famous (or infamous, depending on who you ask) Hal Jordan storylines concerns his transformation into the villainous Parallax. Driven to insanity by the destruction of his hometown of Coast City - along with 7 million inhabitants - Jordan believes he can harness the power of the entire Green Lantern Corps and restore Coast City permanently. To attain this power, Hal basically goes on a killing spree. Like Batman's insanity revealed by a laugh with the Joker, taking Green Lantern to the brink is counterintuitive in a film universe. In comics - which have extensive, malleable continuities that are regularly reset, retconned, and sometimes forgotten - events like this are much more acceptable. When half a billion dollars, the reputation of a major film studio, and an actor's livelihood are all on the line, there's less of an inclination to essentially destroy your heroic protagonist and make way for a new one.

5. Amazons Attack!

The 2007 Wonder Woman limited series Amazons Attack! features an attack by the Amazons. Yes. It's really just that simple. It's unfortunate that Wonder Woman has so few iconic story arcs from which to draw material from for film adaptations. There's little doubt that Gal Gadot's Wonder Woman will get a solo venture following the Justice League film, provided her portrayal is well-received. While the heroine is certainly deserving of a solo movie and audiences would almost certainly flock to it, there's no sure bet that the movie will be an automatic success. One thing DC and WB should stay away from, though, is storylines like the Amazons Attack! arc. There are obvious reasons for this: Wonder Woman barely appears in the entire story, the motivation of the Amazons is ludicrous, etc. There are also reasons that are just becoming apparent with the onset of the DC Cinematic Universe: for one, Man of Steel has a plot that is not too dissimilar, featuring a lone hero from a distinct race defending humanity against his (or her) former countrymen. With cautious optimism, it's safe to say DC will take extreme care with the Wonder Woman film and ensure that ill-conceived books like this stay up on the shelf.

4. Batman Shoots A Vampire

Okay, so it doesn't take a fortuneteller to predict that Ben Affleck wasn't enlisted to breathe life into the famous Bob Kane gun-wielding Batman of the early Golden Age, nor will the October 1939 issue of Detective Comics (#32) that features Batman oh-so-nobly firing a silver bullet into the heart of a sleeping vampire find much of a home in the DC Cinematic Universe. There have been a few instances in the comics where Batman has broken his "no guns" rule, mostly employed to dramatic effect by modern writers. But the Batman who guns down slumbering bloodsuckers doesn't even need to break that rule - he doesn't even have it yet. Man of Steel made critical waves by having Superman kill Zod at the end of the film. Like Batman, Superman's "no killing" rule was only fastened down years after the character's debut, and there have been plenty of instances in the comics where Kal-El kills (and regrets it). There's a certain strength to the argument that a superhero - even Superman - wouldn't "get it right" the first time out, and hopefully we'll see some of the moral repercussions of that climactic Man of Steel event in future films. Affleck's Batman, though, isn't a greenhorn like Henry Cavill's Superman. If he resorts to killing or gun violence, you can bet it will be used purely for dramatic effect as it was in Man of Steel.

3. Batman Has An Accident

It's never really made clear whether DC considers the Batman stories written by Kevin Smith to be a part of the official Batman canon or just standalone limited series, so 2009-10 collection The Widening Gyre may be out-of-continuity. One can only hope. To state things blandly, The Widening Gyre just isn't very good. The most memorable part is memorable for all of the wrong reasons: Batman recalls an escapade early in his career - one seen in a pivotal moment in Frank Miller's iconic Year One story arc - where he sheepishly admits to having a bladder spasm. This is the Dark Knight, mind you, the one who ostensibly wears that mask in order to strike fear into various hearts across Gotham. I'm all for humor in Batman comics. This is Kevin Smith we're talking about here, so expecting the guy to loaf around in his jorts and go and write a serious Bat-book is probably expecting too much. And this instance isn't why I refer to The Widening Gyre as a failure (Batman revealing his identity to a villain who then kills his girlfriend while he's in the room€ yeah, that's pretty much why). Still, though, Widening Gyre #6 has to be one of the most glaring examples of the mischaracterization of Batman in the history of comics, and having the Caped Crusader cop to a bladder spasm is just absurd.

2. More Obscure Characters Get Their Due

Stated as part of our 10 Things We Expect to Happen in the DC Cinematic Universe, a box-office risk will come later in the game (after the Justice League gets an overdue team-up) and give DC a chance to highlight some more obscure characters. Marvel is at that point now, with Guardians of the Galaxy coming out mid-summer, and while the property itself is "risky" you can bet Guardians will make a killing as a summer blockbuster due to the groundwork Marvel has laid before it. But there are so many worthwhile characters under the Marvel and DC umbrellas, and many of these will never get feature film treatment. Regardless of how saturated the market becomes with superhero films, studios are always going to fall back on the big names and the big characters. Audiences, too, while hopefully being appreciative of some lesser-known characters, will have become comfortable seeing characters they immediately recognize. Do Deadman and Spectre deserve solo films? Absolutely. Will they get them? Probably not. If anything, DC will start by lumping more obscure characters into a team-up film (like Marvel is doing with Guardians) before letting any of them loose within the franchise. Characters like Doctor Fate have less of a chance, unfortunately - Fate spends 95% of his time under a golden helmet that entirely covers his face, and that kind of thing just isn't as bankable as Ben Affleck's mug. It will be interesting to see DC and Warner Brothers reach the point Marvel and Disney are currently enjoying, when they can afford to take a little risk. Don't hold out hope for anything more than a bit part for the second-stringers, though, at least not for a long time.

1. Lighthearted DC Heroes Get Their Due

Possibly the biggest letdown when gazing into the Official DC Cinematic Universe Crystal Ball (it comes standard with the Justice League Blu-ray!) is that the lighthearted DC Comics heroes of old will likely never get their due on the silver screen. Again, comics have changed since the Golden- and Silver Ages: Batman and Superman don't have fun fighting crime anymore, because fighting crime is serious and tragedy is compelling (or something). Sure, Marvel has an Ant-Man film slated for November 2015. It doesn't get too much more lighthearted than Ant-Man, even though there will doubtless be some modernization of the character in order to have him fit within the larger MCU. DC is not Marvel, though, and the DC Cinematic Universe is already a very different beast than the counterpart at Marvel. Man of Steel was a decidedly less humor-filled affair than anything Marvel has put out (I'm looking at you, Iron Man 3) and the DC Universe on the whole seems to work with a more serious tone, and more serious characters. But what about those heroes who are just inherently lighthearted? Elongated Man is a good example, as it's hard to imagine Ralph Dibney showing up alongside Cavill's pouty Kal-El. The only way to incorporate the character, then, is to essentially force him into seriousness; DC did this a few years ago with a book called Identity Crisis, in which Elongated Man's wife Sue is brutally murdered and a previously-minor character known as Doctor Light was revealed to be a rapist. It's unfortunate that this is the route DC and Warner Brothers will likely have to take if they want to incorporate characters like Elongated Man into the shared film universe. Like some characters who have slipped into relative obscurity, fun-loving guys like Blue Beetle and Booster Gold deserve solo films just as much as Green Lantern or Flash. At this rate, though, don't hold your breath. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Matt is a writer and musician living in Boston. Read his film reviews at http://motionstatereview.wordpress.com.