10 Times Batman Won A Fight He Should Have Lost

He's just a man! Bite his head off, Killer Croc!

Batman is not Superman. Seems like a simple statement of fact - duh, they're different characters - but stick with it. Whilst the Man Of Steel wins most fights he gets into thanks to his invulnerability and super-strength, Batman is just a guy. Albeit a guy with a lot of training, a lot of resources, and a lot of forward planning. But still, just a guy. In most cases, when paired against another individual in individual, hand-to-hand combat, he could probably win. When he fights people with actual weapons or superpowers, though? Whilst the Dark Knight doesn't technically have any meta-human abilities, fans and creators like to joke that they has the superpower of forward planning. Batman is resourceful in the thick of battle, but in most cases he wins because he's prepared a lot beforehand. He's studied his enemy, or fought them countless times before, so he's already discovered their strengths and weaknesses and developed his fighting style and a new swathe of gadgets accordingly. Bully for him. In that case, though, surely there are fights he should totally lose. Even the Caped Crusader can't prepare for everything, and even when he does, he shouldn't strictly win every single fight he ever gets into. Obviously he has a heavy amount of plot armour slung over his shoulders that protects him from ever getting beat down too bad, but still. The Dark Knight isn't invincible. So why do comics treat him so? From his long-awaited rematch with Bane to every time he fights a giant crocodile monster, these are ten times Batman won a fight he should have lost.

10. His Introduction To KGBeast

KGBeast is one of the goofier members of Batman€™s otherwise glittering rogues gallery. A big, beefy Russian tooled up with several metric tonnes of armour and weaponry, he€™s as much a product of the eighties for his excess as his pandering to Cold War paranoia. A KGB weapon who, for some reason, spent most of his time fighting Batman. Eventually destined to become one of the few villains the Caped Crusader was forced to kill (at least for a little while), their first encounter was more evenly matched. Or at least, it ended with Batman winning, despite the KGBeast wearing layers of metal armour and wielding enough ammo to win a small war. Batman famously doesn€™t use guns, except for when he does, so he relies mainly on his own gadgets and kung-fu skills during the encounter. Even so, there€™s only so much punching can do against a Communist RoboCop. You don€™t see monks fighting knights in shining armour, do you? No, knights fight dragons. Batman is not a dragon.

9. Talon In The Caverns Under Gotham

Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo€™s run on Batman will surely go down as one of the best in the character€™s history. After 75 years, they€™re one of the few creative teams who actually dare to innovate, to introduce new concepts and characters to the series and not just riff on existing enemies, not content with simply skating by on past glories. Right out of the gates, they changed the whole game by revealing the existence of the Court Of Owls: a sort of underground shadow government which had been running things in Gotham City for time immemorial, unbeknownst to Batman. Given he€™s supposed to know everything about his city, he didn€™t like that. Trouble is, he couldn€™t exactly stop them, what with their army of immortal, undying Talon assassins. Throughout those first two story arcs - Court and City Of Owls - Batman manages to fight one Talon bare handed to a stand still, and then a bunch of others with a big robot suit on. Again, he€™s just a man. These are immortal beings. How did he win?

8. Against The White Martians

Grant Morrison€™s run on the Justice League of America was one of the best in DC history, but it wasn€™t without its problems. Much like his later work on Batman in his solo titles, Morrison is one of the writers guilty of turning him into the hyper-prepared, totally-unbeatable superbeing who, even lacking in real powers, cannot ever be defeated. Because he€™s smart, innit. Morrison first played with that idea during an early JLA storyline which saw a team of villainous €œWhite Martians€ arriving on Earth under the guise of being a group of new superheroes, whilst they quietly dispatch all of the existing heroes and preparing to invade and destroy the planet. Batman is the first they get rid of...or so they thought. After taking down Superman, Wonder Woman and co, the last thing they expected was Batman to return and scupper their whole plan. €œBut he€™s just a man!€ one of them whines as their best laid plans crumble beneath the Dark Knight€™s barrages. Yep, just a man. Who should€™ve been dead, but for a plot device.

7. Versus The Mutant Leader In The Dark Knight Returns

Looking back, The Dark Knight Returns actually pointed towards Frank Miller€™s fascistic tendencies long before the likes of Holy Terror! and his now-infamous blog on the Occupy movement made them explicit. This is, after all, a story where a young group of anti-establishment teens are beaten down by an old rich man. Regardless of the politics involved, the elderly Batman€™s triumph over the leader of the €œmutant€ gang is total BS. In fact, The Dark Knight Returns shows how the fight should€™ve ended, with the first confrontation between the two: the elderly Bruce Wayne gets his ass handed to him by the huge, stacked Mutant Leader. Even his newly-designed Bat-Tank can€™t take this one muscly, pale guy down, being almost torn apart with his bare hands. Batman€™s the guy whose whole power set is his gadgets and fighting prowess and, really, neither of those improve much between their two match-ups. He only won the second time so the plot could move forward.

6. Triumphing Over Prometheus

Another creation during the Grant Morrison run on JLA was Prometheus, a brand-new villain whose whole origin story was like a dark mirror version of Bruce Wayne€™s. As a young child he saw his two hippie dissident parents killed by the police, and thus dedicated his life to €œannihilating the forces of justice€. And his hair goes white from the trauma. Initially attempting to join the JLA under the codename Retro, Prometheus has all the same globetrotting training as Batman€™s origin story, with the added benefit of having access to a pocket dimension €œlimbo€ and a helmet that lets him download any information into his brain. Like they do in The Matrix, €œI know kung fu€ and all that. Which means that, having bested most of the rest of the JLA with various gadgets and gizmos, he manages to take down Batman in hand-to-hand contact because he€™s analysed and downloaded the Dark Knight€™s fighting style, countering all his best moves. He wins, but Batman wins their second fight because...the story needed to end, or something.

5. Whenever He Fights Killer Croc

During his early appearances, Killer Croc was just a colourful nickname that stuck to a burly criminal with a skin disorder which made him look a bit scaly and scary. In post-Crisis On Infinite Earths continuity, meanwhile, he€™s literally a giant mutant man with sharp teeth, impenetrable scaled skin and the like. He€™s a half-man, half-crocodile. Meanwhile, despite his name, Batman is not half-bat, half-man. He€™s just a dude, of regular size and slightly above average stature, with a belt full of Bat-Shark Repellents and the like. And yet Killer Croc is never considered anything more than a C-list villain at best, often escaping to the sewers to be quickly dispatched. There is no way Batman should be able to win any fight against Killer Croc. He is a giant crocodile man. As soon as he gets his hands on Bruce Wayne€™s frail, delicate, fleshy body, he should just bite his head off. No matter how fast Batman is, he can€™t hurt the guy with scale armour all over his body. He just shouldn€™t be able to win.

4. The One Punch Guy Gardner €œFight€

One of Batman€™s most infamous fights is also one of his shortest. In the pages of the comedy book Justice League International he dropped by to say hello to the team of second-stringers, inspiring reserve Green Lantern Guy Gardner to start running his mouth about the arrogance of The Dark Knight, how he didn€™t have any powers and sucked, etc. In response, Batman didn€™t bother with any verbal volleys back at him. He just punched Guy right in the face, knocking him out cold. Which the rest of the team mock Gardner for with for the rest of his life - €œONE PUNCH!€ In theory, though, there€™s no way Batman should be able to take down a Green Lantern. The Caped Crusader is a highly trained individual, admittedly, but one who is lacking in superpowers. All you need to be a decent Green Lantern is some imagination, since the power rings they wield can create literally anything. Like a cage around Batman. Or an image of his dead parents. Were it not for the sucker punch, Guy would€™ve won.

3. His First Re-Match With Bane

Knightfall is amongst the most famous modern Batman stories. Even before Christopher Nolan loosely adopted its major plot point for The Dark Knight Rises, most people were aware of a time when Bruce Wayne stopped being Batman - because a €˜roided-up luchadore snapped his spine in two by breaking the Dark Knight over his knee. In the interim a young upstart called Jean-Paul Valley, who believed the only way to defeat the bad guys was to beat them at their own game, which meant being as ruthless as they are. So he managed to beat Bane because he didn€™t hold back, nearly killing him. Also because Bane had already weakened Batman by releasing every villain from Arkham. Even still, when it came to their rematch, there€™s no way Batman should€™ve won. Being a purely physical contest, he didn€™t stand a chance - his other major skill is his tactical acumen, which the genius Bane has too. So when they do fight in single combat again, there€™s nothing that€™s changed that means Batman should win...and yet.

2. The Time Ra€™s Al Ghul Impaled Him On A Shovel

The most crushing blow of that second fight between Batman and Bane, with the Dark Knight reigning triumphant, is that it forced Ra€™s al Ghul to cut off his erstwhile son-in-law€™s engagement to his daughter Talia and disown Bane altogether. That was sad. Still, that€™s nothing compared to the various emotional and physical ringers he€™s put Batman through. Arguably the pair€™s greatest battle - with the Caped Crusader fighting a man who has been alive for thousands of years, accumulating more skills and fighting practice than he ever could in his single life time - was in Birth Of The Demon. The one-shot, which followed up the infamous earlier story where Batman has sex with Talia al Ghul and Ra€™s calls him a fiend from hell - sees the two going at it, before Ra€™s strikes a fatal blow: he stabs Batman in the chest with a shovel. Still, the Dark Knight keeps going, battering Ra€™s into submission and then dragging them both to a Lazarus Pit to be reborn.

1. Any Time He Fought Superman And Won

Speaking of Batman as the classic fascistic icon, what better example than the self-funded billionaire vigilante taking umbrage at an illegal alien who shows up just wanting to make a positive difference in this world? Creators and fans alike love pitting the Dark Knight and Man Of Steel against each other, the latter being a sort of underdog figure in the fights. After all, he€™s just a man. An incredibly well-equipped, well-trained man, but a man nonetheless. Superman is more akin to a god. There€™s a degree of self-insert fanfic about whenever Batman beats him up, then, with readers imagining that humanity could, one day, punch a god in the face too. Thing is, he cheats every time. In the Dark Knight Returns, he needs the juice of all of Gotham City to power his robot suit, and Green Arrow has to blast him with a Kryptonite bolt. Batman puts the bright green achilles heel in a ring, which allows him to punch out a Poison Ivy-controlled Superman during Hush. If the pair actually had a fight? Batman would be dead in, like, two seconds. The difference is that Superman wouldn€™t fight him, or choose to kill him, because he isn€™t a total jerk.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/