10 Times Comic Book Villains Became Heroes (In A Big Way)

Deadpool, Magneto, Riddler and Harley Quinn are just some of the villains who became heroes.

Riddler Private Detective
DC Comics

The vast majority of comic book villains tend to stay on the path of evil, but a select number have switched allegiances to the side of right over the years.

Whether in the Marvel or DC universes, creators have been reforming and redeeming plenty of major supervillains for decades now, and though most don't manage to make the switch permanent (curse you, superhero status-quo), that doesn't make the novelty of seeing them fight alongside their old rivals any less entertaining.

Some of the most beloved and famous heroes in both the Big Two's libraries originally had villainous roots, but a lot of the time these characters' paths towards redemption were mapped out very early on or even right from the off - such was the case with Rogue, Plastic Man and Hawkeye, to name but a few.

All those characters are great, of course, but the brief time they all spent as villains has been well and truly eclipsed by their heroic personas.

That isn't the case for some of the other notable supervillain defectors though. These characters had to wait decades to switch allegiances - however brief a switch it was - but they all managed to do so in massive and oftentimes immensely gratifying ways, leaving readers desperate to see them become heroes for good.

10. Songbird

Songbird Marvel Comics
Marvel Comics / Audrey Hotte

Songbird was originally introduced as the supervillain known as Screaming Mimi (okay.... I love the name) by Mark Gruenwald, Ralph Macchio and John Byrne in 1979's Marvel Two-in-One #54, before later switching to the Songbird identity in the 1990s.

Originally an antagonist who was a member of the evil wrestling-themed supervillain team known as the Grapplers, Screaming Mimi was subjected to a process by the Power Broker that enhanced her vocal chords, thus giving her the ability to project a deafening supersonic scream not unlike the one belonging to DC's Black Canary, albeit with a few other added perks.

Following her time with the Grapplers, Mimi rejected her old wrestling title and became known as Songbird, eventually linking up with Baron Helmut Zemo and joining his faux superhero team known as the Thunderbolts.

Unfortunately for Zemo, who had planned the Thunderbolts to be nothing more than a trojan horse for the Masters of Evil to exploit, Songbird and many of the other villains recruited for the team actually grew to love playing the hero. She and her teammates betrayed Zemo, and ultimately went on to lead the Thunderbolts in its later incarnations.


9. Magneto

Magneto Dawn of X
Marvel Comics / Marco Checchetto

While his methods can be... less than agreeable at times (okay that might be putting it lightly), Magneto's cause is ultimately just. His main priority has always been to ensure the protection of mutantkind, and having suffered horrendous discrimination since he was just a child, it's more than a little understandable as to why he'd run out of patience with both Charles Xavier and humankind.

Even so, the vast majority of Magneto's history has been spent as a supervillain. You can't get away from ripping the adamantium from Wolverine's body, trying to destroy humanity god knows how many times or whatever other evil things the character has done in the past, no matter how tortured a life he's led.

That said, the path to redemption has always been there - a space where the character's radical principles mesh with the more moderate approach optioned by Xavier and the X-Men.

With that in mind, it's no surprise that Magneto has turned to heroics with increasing frequency over the years, or that he's been able to find a place alongside his old rivals in the X-Men.

With Moira X having laid the case for mutantkind's survival hinging on Magneto allying with Xavier and the rest of Earth's mutants, the character has finally been able to achieve some of his greatest goals - unite Earth's mutants, protect them from harm, and ensure their evolutionary gifts usher in a new era across the globe.


8. M.O.D.O.K. Superior

MODOK Avengers
Marvel Comics

At a glance, the news that M.O.D.O.K. was at one point in time a good guy might seem pretty crazy. I mean, firstly the guy looks like a floating human egg. Secondly, his name stands for "Mechanised Organism Designed Only for Killing", which isn't exactly heroic either.

Although both those things are true, Marvel illustrated that being a floating egg human hybrid with a twisted title is no roadblock to embracing your inner hero in 2014's Secret Avengers, when M.O.D.O.K. Superior (a spin-off clone of the original, George Tarleton model), joined the team.

The reason for M.O.D.O.K's change of heart in this case is actually because he's fallen in love with none other than Maria Hill, one of the fiercest, most no-nonsense operatives in all of S.H.I.E.L.D. He'd originally planned to kill her as well, but changed his mind after realising his true feelings.

After saving the day along with Hawkeye, Hill and the rest of the Secret Avengers, M.O.D.O.K. had a brief vacay in Ohio. And bless him, he deserved it.


7. Riddler

Gotham City Sirens Riddler
DC Comics / Guillem March

Here we have one of the coolest reinventions of a Batman character seen to date, but one that was sadly short lived.

The Riddler is one of the Dark Knight's oldest ever adversaries, and while it's true he works better as a villain than as a hero, he's been the subject of countless stories with him in that role. It was with that in mind that, in the wake of Infinite Crisis, the Riddler legitimately reformed.

After being bopped on the head by Shining Knight, Eddie Nashton effectively had a bit of a personality reset. His love for Riddles disappeared - as did much of his memory of his time as a career criminal - but he still felt that need to prove his intellect to all. Not seeing much value in crime anymore, Edward then becomes a private investigator in Gotham, solving all kinds of cases as a celebrity detective - he was even hired by Batman and Nightwing on two separate occasions!

Honestly, 'Detective Riddler' as a concept was absolutely genius and we have Paul Dini to thank for it. Unfortunately, as is the nature of superhero comics, the status quo soon resumed and Eddie went back to being the same old Riddler as before. Booooo.


6. Venom

Venom 200
Marvel Comics / Ryan Stegman

It's hard to think of a character who's experienced more of a transformation over the last decade than Venom. I'm not talking about his status as an antihero here either, as that was largely cemented during the 1990s when Venom-fever gripped Marvel's readership. What I'm referring to is actually the history of the symbiotes at large, and the epic expansion of the character's mythology.

Starting with Rick Remender and Tony Moore's run on Venom in 2011, Spider-Man's most famous symbiote has undergone a steady but exciting transformation. Remender's book restored the symbiote to the status of antihero by giving it to Flash Thompson, who wielded it as a part of an off-the-books government black ops program.

As Flash strays more and more into heroism, he eventually finds himself joining the Guardians of the Galaxy. In that series, from Brian Bendis and Valerio Schiti, it's revealed how the symbiotes are actually an alien species known as the Klyntar, and that they're inherently noble beings.

The history of the symbiotes has been expanded even further thanks to Donny Cates and Ryan Stegman's barnstorming stint on Venom, with the end result being not just the redemption of Eddie Brock, but of the symbiotes as a whole as well.


5. Harley Quinn

Harley Quinn Injustice Gods Among Us Comic
DC Comics

The trajectory of Harley Quinn as a character is really something that's interesting. At first created by Bruce Timm and Paul Dini as a sidekick for Joker in Batman: The Animated Series, Harley grew over the years to break free of the Clown Prince's control, and has now cemented herself as a key antihero in the DC universe.

It hasn't always been smooth sailing though. The character experienced a few wacky years during the New 52, suffering some tremendously poor redesigns and creative choices in the wake of Batman: Arkham Asylum, until thankfully Jimmy Palmiotti and Amanda Conner took the reins on the character in 2013.

Harley's only gone from strength to strength from there, whether that be through her misadventures with the Suicide Squad or with Batman's resistance in writer Tom Taylor's superb Injustice: Gods Among Us comic from the same year.

Quinn's time with the Joker will always be memorable, but ultimately, it's the connections she's forged away from the Clown Prince that have cemented the character as a true DC great.


4. Starro

Starro Justice League No Justice
DC Comics / Francis Manapul

DC fans have had the pleasure of reading several great Justice League comics since DC Rebirth hit the stands in 2016, including an overlooked effort from Christopher Priest and Pete Woods, but one of the standouts has been the prelude to Scott Snyder and James Tynion IV's main Justice League comic: 2018's Justice League: No Justice.

Again co-authored by Snyder and Tynion, but this time joined by writer Joshua Williamson and artist Francis Manapul, No Justice saw the traditional Justice League split off into different teams courtesy of Braniac, who has recruited the heroes to take on the Omega Titans who have spilled into the universe following the fragmentation of the Source Wall.

The teams are comprised of mostly heroes, but a few villains make the cut as well, among them the Justice League's first ever adversary, Starro.

As readers will know, Starro is a starfish shaped alien with terrifying mind control powers who's wreaked havoc across the galaxy for untold years. However, in No Justice, a talk with Martian Manhunter and Starfire leads him to have a change of heart. He uses his immense telepathic abilities to calm a number of shrunken planets held in captivity, before taking on the Omega Titan himself.

Sadly, Starro dies in the attempt, sacrificing himself so that the other heroes could evacuate the planet the Titan was destroying. Starro does live on, however, in the form of Jarro, a spore Batman saved that grew up wanting to be the best Robin ever. And yes, it's just as wonderful as it sounds.


3. Deadpool

Deadpool Uncanny X-Force
Marvel Comics / Jerome Opeña

He might be known as a fun-loving sometimes member of the X-Men nowadays, but back when he first began? Deadpool was a stone cold killer.

In his early appearances, which took place in the New Mutants, the Merc' with a Mouth was a supervillain full-stop. His jokey personality was there, certainly, but the character had no qualms with doing villain stuff, even as he began to take the path from 'straight-up villain' to 'fourth wall-breaking antihero' in the late nineties.

What's important to remember though is that Deadpool was still an !*$% throughout all of this. He wasn't a particularly nice character and continued to get up to all sorts of morally decrepit activities; even when he was doing good, he was still, ironically, doing bad.

That principle has largely remained the same even as the character encountered mainstream success in the late 2000s, but he has been depicted in unquestionably heroic terms in a few occasions since - most notably in Rick Remender and Jerome Opeña's brilliant Uncanny X-Force.

After deciding the mercenary game was no longer fun, Wade Wilson decided to join the X-Men. That didn't work out too well, owing to Deadpool's lethal methods and... not so agreeable personality, so he ended up joining the X-Men's black ops equivalent under the watchful eye of Wolverine and Psylocke: X-Force.

And, surprise surprise, Deadpool steps up to the plate. He ends up becoming the moral conscience of the team, and goes above and beyond to ensure they make it out of their mission alive. Possibly the character's finest moment in an X-Men uniform.


2. Sandman

Sandman Avengers
Marvel Comics / Paul Ryan

It's truly one of the great big Marvel injustices that Sandman didn't get to stay a superhero. In a way, it's a microcosm of the biggest problems that have affected Marvel's Spidey books over the last three decades. Characters went from evolving over a period of years, to existing in a weird temporal quagmire where everything eventually goes back to business as usual.

Still, that doesn't make Sandman's initial arc any less compelling. The character evolved from a villain of Spider-Man and the Fantastic Four into an actual Avenger. Sandman! An Avenger! One of the greatest Silver Age Marvel villains ended up becoming one of the best Marvel heroes, and it's something that's not spoken about nearly enough.

But what set Sandman off on this path towards Avengers membership? Well, it was a couple of things. First was the character's unfortunate run-in with Hydro-Man in Amazing Spider-Man #217, which saw the two merge into the being known as Mud-Thing. The incident scarred Sandman, and following a heart-to-heart with the Thing, he decided to go straight.

A couple of team-ups with Spider-Man later, and Sandman eventually ended up joining Silver Sable's Wild Pack, and then the Avengers. Too bad the Wizard had to go ahead and ruin it by bringing back Sandman's old persona a few years later.


1. Clayface

Clayface Bat Family Detective Comics
DC Comics / Eddy Barrows

One of the best things about Batman (to me) is that even though he's doing his absolute best to stop these supervillains from tearing Gotham City apart, he's also trying to help in their recovery.

Batman: The Animated Series conveyed this better than most (and it is admittedly a case of Batman's kindness varying between depictions), but he still has a history of doing it in the comics - a trend most recently exemplified by the redemption of Basil Karlo, aka Clayface, in James Tynion IV and Eddy Barrow's Detective Comics series from 2016.

Delving into the character's tragic origins, the DC Rebirth comic picks up with Karlo at a cinema, tearfully watching the last ever film he starred in before his transformation. Batman and Batwoman then appear, and offer Clayface a place on a new team of vigilantes.

Clayface helps the Bat Family take down Hugo Strange, while Bruce uses his resources to try and cure Karlo. Like most heroic switches this one sadly didn't last for too long, but it was still extremely rewarding to see the Dark Knight fighting side by side with a villain he hadn't lost hope in.


Watch Next


DC Quiz: Can You Name These Obscure Batman Villains?

Catman Batman
DC Comics

1. Who’s This Obscure Batman Villain?

Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.