10 Times Superheroes Became Public Enemy Number One

Spidey... How COULD you?!

Spider-Man Gun
Marvel Comics

On a legal level, being a superhero is a complicated profession. The job title alone is pretty questionable - as often costumed vigilantes are technically considered illegal, but given a free pass because they decrease your chances of getting your face burnt off by a supervillain's laser.

But this doesn't mean that heroes are always given the green light, both in legal terms and in terms of public opinion. In fact, it's really easy for superheroes to suddenly appear like a huge villain to the general public, which quickly turns into them being considered a criminal whose arrest is a priority, which is understandable given that most superheroes could topple a city in the rough space of time we would consider a lunch break.

Though this is often for fair reasons, it's equally interesting when it's not, as many comics take the time to remind us how easily the public can be influenced by newspapers and the media. In short? These comics also have a handy life lesson at the same time.

Either way, seeing costumed crusaders suddenly become public enemy number one is always a treat - even if it's one that's generally quite short-lived.

10. The X-Men - Avengers Vs. X-Men

Scott Summers Avengers vs X-Men
Marvel Comics

There are plenty of times that the X-Men have found themselves on the wrong end of the law. Indeed, the very nature of their powers means that many of their members ended up in conflict with authorities pretty much as soon as they gained their special abilities.

However, some cases of the X-Men's run-ins with the law and popular public opinion are more dramatic than others. Take, for example, the case of Avengers vs. X-Men, where the the uncanny group absorb the Phoenix Force and gain even more power from it. This is more than a little unnerving for the rest of Marvel's superheroes, as the Phoenix Force essentially gives them all massive god complexes.

After the X-Men get steadily more and more out of hand, the Avengers are finally tasked to deal with them, defeating the power-drunk team with the help of Hope Summers and the Scarlet Witch. Cyclops - the team's ringleader - would be arrested and placed into a special facility equipped to deal with his powers, although the other renegade X-Men would escape capture.


9. Superman - Action Comics #556

Superman Handcuffs Arrested
DC Comics

Despite being one of the most lawful superheroes in creation, Superman has been arrested, defamed, and otherwise made public enemy number one more often than you'd initially think.

The best of these comes in Action Comics #556, which sees the Man of Steel be accused of various misdeeds by a local paper, which is revealed to be a plot created by villain Vandal Savage, in one of his weirder schemes to date. Funnier still, this plan manages to actually work, as many inhabitants of Metropolis start to regard the spaceman as less their savior, and more the reason that villains come to the city, turning many against him.

After being sabotaged while trying to save people from a burning building, this mistrust of Superman leads to him being straight up arrested, although the judge who tries him immediately has him released based on the grounds that he's sort of saved all their lives innumerable times.


8. Half Of Marvel's Superheroes - Civil War

Captain America Steve Rogers
Marvel Comics

When it comes to superheroes becoming public enemy number one, it'd be insane to not mention Civil War, wherein every hero who doesn't agree to the Superhuman Registration Act becomes a criminal in the eyes of the law - and an enemy to everyone who complied.

This naturally led to a very uncomfortable scenario wherein these renegade heroes were hunted down like dogs by their former friends, which gets actively painful at parts where you see good friends forced to turn on one another, due to being on different sides of the law. The ending is similarly painful, as it sees Captain America be arrested for leading the faction against the Registration Act - and while this is nowhere near the first or last time Steve Rogers has been arrested, there's something about seeing Cap in handcuffs that stings every time.

Hilariously, all this suffering would be made totally pointless mere years later, when Iron Man would be forced to destroy all registration records in order to prevent Norman Osborn accessing them for his own means.


7. Cable - Various

Stryker Cable
Marvel Comics

Cable is a weird example of a superhero who became public enemy number one, in that he also becomes his own biggest enemy. This is because Stryfe - the villain Cable spends much of his comic career hunting - turns out to be a clone of the hero himself, meaning that this whole time the illustrious ne'er-do-well is none other than another version of our hero.

Naturally, this gives Cable something of a small crisis, as he manages to be basically the last person to know about his secret clone, despite continually bumping into him since the pair were children.

It also made Cable himself public enemy number one a fair few times, as Stryfe would pretend to be his doppelgänger in both X-Force and the Cable series, which would convince many that Cable was also a villain.


6. Green Lantern - Green Lantern: Emerald Dawn

Green Lantern Hal Jordan Jail
DC Comics

The Emerald Dawn series is one of the weirder Green Lantern origin stories around. Part of the reason it's so dang weird is that one of its first scenes involves soon-to-be Green Lantern Hal Jordan getting in an accident while drunk driving, and then giving himself in.

This alone is weird, but weirder yet is that in between the accident and the incarceration, Hal gets the Green Lantern ring, meaning that one of his first actions under the superhero name is to turn himself in for crimes.

Though it's perhaps not the strangest superhero origin story ever, having a hero searched for by the police nonstop until they gave themselves up is a surreal way to introduce people to Hal Jordan - although it sets him up as an unpredictable character quite nicely.


5. Captain America - Captain America (Vol. 9) #10

Captain America Hiding
Marvel Comics/Alex Ross

For anyone unaware of Captain America's time in comics between 2017-2018, it can best be summed up as one of the rougher times in Steve Rogers' life. Not only did Red Skull manage to change reality itself to make the hero into a member of the villainous HYDRA organisation, but when Rogers finally manages to overcome his brainwashing, he's still blamed for actions he made as the Supreme Commander.

To top things off, after all this the good Captain is framed for the murder of Thunderbolt Ross, which lands him in prison. With both Steve and his loved ones aware that this sentence is one that may continue indefinitely, Sharon Carter then creates a plan to break the disgraced superhero out of his maximum-security prison.

While the plan succeeds, it also places Steve in hot water with pretty much every government official, which awkwardly puts him into conflict with the likes of folk such as Nick Fury.


4. Spider-Man - Peter Parker: The Spectacular Spider-Man

Spider-Man handcuffs
Marvel Comics

Though J. Jonah Jameson has made a fair play of trying to make Spider-Man out to be a villain, he generally fails to do so, as despite playing a mean game with media, most of the people of New York are aware the web-slinger has saved their bacon more times than they've had hot dinners.

Hilariously, it's actually a series of different news sites that manage to ruin Parker's life in Chip Zdarsky's Spectacular Spider-Man series, which sees a picture of Peter and his sister spread like wildfire across the internet. This would be all well and good in any normal scenario, but unfortunately said sister is reported as having stolen government secrets about how to kill superheroes, which makes Spider-Man hanging out with her look undeniably suspicious.

Or, at least, suspicious enough that secret agents are dispatched to capture the arachnid wonder, leaving Spider-Man stuck trying to redeem himself without outing his secret identity. Mercifully, it's later revealed that said secret agents are actually rogue operatives, meaning that Peter himself is safe from the cold clutches of the law - even if a bunch of people were left thinking he's some kind of war criminal.


3. Batman And Superman - Superman/Batman: Public Enemies

Lex Luthor Superman Batman Public Enemies
DC Comics

As the name suggests, Batman and Superman are not exactly on the top of everyone's Christmas list in the Public Enemies storyline, which sees Lex Luthor blame Superman for an incoming world-destroying meteor, landing him in some serious hot water, and leaving Batman guilty by association.

As you might expect, this results in a series of fights against those who now believe Superman to be some sort of extraterrestrial terrorist, including a series of people that you'd normally think would come to Kent's aid in such a scenario. Dear friends such as Power Girl and Jon Stewart all decide that they actually trust Lex Luthor much more than Superman, requiring Batman and the Man of Steel to beat them back to their senses.

While this is cleared up by the end of the series, you can't help but think Superman's trust in his allies was well and truly shaken - aside from Batman, of course.


2. Daredevil - Various

Daredevil Matt Murdock
Marvel Comics

Daredevil is a hero who is seemingly incapable of managing to protect his secret identity, leading to an almost endless amount of scenarios where his life as Matt Murdock is revealed, and then summarily threatened by all the people who dislike superheroes.

While there's an entire stash of these storylines to rifle through, the most entertaining in terms of making him public enemy number one has to be the case that occurs in volume 4, issue #15 of the main Daredevil series.

This run of the series takes place in a time where Murdock has openly revealed that he's Daredevil, only for this to be used against him when The Owl decides to air the secrets that every single person in Matt's life has ever told him, leading Daredevil to be despised by the public who had previously adored him.

The situation is so bad that Matt even resorts to trying to make deals with Kingpin to see his friends at least safe, but this ultimately falls through - which is lucky, as defeating Kingpin is exactly what helps Matt redeem his name.


1. The Watchmen - Watchmen

Watchmen Keene Act
DC Comics

One of the most crucial historical plot points of Watchmen involves the 1977 Keene Act, which outlawed 'costumed adventuring' and vigilantism. While it's often overlooked, the act essentially served to make every member of the Watchmen's actions in the series a fairly serious crime - aside from those who were government-sanctioned officials, such as Dr. Manhattan.

Interestingly, although this legally made any vigilante public enemy number one, they'd already had this reputation in the public eye for some time.

Indeed, the Watchmen themselves were feared and hated before the Keene Act. Between Rorschach's blatant and brutal murders, and the rest of the Watchmen's involvement in the Vietnam war, the public swiftly turned against superheroes in general, believing them to cause equal damage to the villains they were supposed to protect people from.

In short, Watchmen basically covers a universe where superheroes are public enemy number one both to the general public, and to the legal system - which is part of what makes the story so damn interesting.


Watch Next


MCU Quiz: How Well Do You Know Marvel's Superheroes ?

Avengers Infinity War Time Stone
Marvel Studios

1. What Character Was The Known For Being The Guardian Of The Time Stone?

Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.