10 Unluckiest Comic Book Characters

When bad luck and hardship are the true villains...

Spider-Man Spot
Marvel Comics

In the arena of comics, no genre can court an audience quite like superhero stories. People around the world dip into daydreams of superpowers, fame, and being able to go to work in spandex.

Even those who aren’t so imaginative, still spend hours relaxed in front of their screens winding down to the colourful lives of comic book crusaders.

However, superheroes are rarely lucky. They end each adventure standing tall but usually at tremendous personal cost, loss, and injury. In no other medium are character’s tragedies and triumphs so acutely balanced. The over-the-top nature of comic book worlds also makes these peaks and dips starker.

Characters rarely receive a blessing without being burdened with a curse. The most notable example of this balance is Batman. He gets to be a billionaire playboy, but also carries the burden of an orphan whose effort to conceal his secret identity pushes him further and further still into isolation.

While it is true all comic characters have their share of misfortune, some seem to exist in a persistent state of tragedy, never able to catch a break.

10. Dr. Manhattan

Doomsday Clock Doctor Manhattan
DC Comics

It may seem odd listing a character who transformed from a man to a god as unlucky. However, one giant dose of misfortune changed the life of Jonathan Osterman forever.

When Osterman left his girlfriend Janey Slater’s gift (her repaired watch) inside his lab coat, he went back into the test chamber to collect it. The door’s safety feature shut him inside. Osterman was ripped apart during the commencing radioactive particle test.

Osterman materialised as Dr. Manhattan, a borderline god - however, his misfortune continued. His new life came with soul-crushing isolation. Experiencing time in a non-linear fashion, created immediate distance between his former life and the people in it. When he acted in accordance with his omnipotent knowledge, others often accused him of being callous and unsympathetic.

Dr. Manhattan’s isolation was taken to the extreme when he exiled himself to Mars after his assumed ally, Adrian Veidt (Ozymandias), tricked him into believing anyone who spent prolonged time with him would get cancer.

Though he was ultimately persuaded to return to Earth by his love interest Laurie Juspeczyk, the borough of Manhattan had been destroyed and Laurie was now happy with Daniel Dreiberg. After agreeing with Veidt’s plan to promote world peace, Dr. Manhattan left alone to find a less complicated galaxy.


9. Strong Guy

Strong Guy
Marvel Comics

Strong Guy (Guido Carosella) experienced early tragedy. His parents were unfortunate enough to be killed by falling space debris, and Guido is the heir to this misfortune.

His mutant powers were activated by a combination of bullying and being hit by a bus, the latter transformed the once skinny boy into a large, muscle-bound mutant.

Most heroes are successful in taking calculated risks, Guido is not. His honourable actions to protect his teammates always result in personal misfortune. In the field, he absorbed an alien bomb meant for his X-Factor teammates. Though he saved the team, it caused him to have a massive heart attack putting him out of action. In recovery he decided to leave the superhero life behind.

After a misadventure where Guido was enslaved by a mutant fight club, he re-joined his fellow mutants. However, he was quickly killed taking a bullet meant for J. Jonah Jameson. Though he was resurrected by Layla Miller, he came back to life sans his soul, and was forced to fight for it in Hell.

Oblivious to lessons and his own misfortune, Guido again used his body to shield his teammates from a bomb, this time it (for another brief stint) killed him.


8. Bane

Bane Killing Alfred Pennyworth
DC Comics

Bane had a harsh start to life, born in the brutal Peña Duro prison to serve his father’s sentence. Despite being created by his father to suffer, the potential link to Christ ends there.

After six years of hardship, Bane also lost his mother, who was given a crass, makeshift funeral, flung from a cliff into shark-infested waters.

Driven by rage Bane established himself as the top dog of Peña Duro. However, this brought him to the attention of the prison’s controllers, who adopted him as a test subject for a drug named Venom. Rather than kill Bane, as was the fate of previous subjects, it gave him superhuman strength.

In line with Bane’s persistent misfortune, Venom was highly addictive and resulted in severe withdrawal every twelve-hours. Bane’s addiction was seen most viscerally when Azrael, filling in for the “broken” Bruce Wayne, severed his Venom tubes. Bane was weakened to the point that his arch-nemesis’s temp beat him until he begged for death.

While imprisoned Bane detoxed from Venom. On his release he was empowered to return to his home country Santa Prisca to take on the drug cartels. In his eagerness, Bane was caught off guard and captured.

While in captivity he was drugged with a newer, stronger strain of Venom, the withdrawal from which was fatal. Bane’s misfortune again cast him as an addict.


7. Detective Martin Soap

Detective Martin Soap
Marvel Comics

Detective Martin Soap - the only list member without superpowers - was dropped on his head at birth, and abandoned at an orphanage. He grew up to be a NYPD officer and head of the Punisher Task Force. Soap is the walking embodiment of misfortune with no area of his life uneffected.

The task force was viewed as a fool’s errand and consisted of just Soap and behavioural psychologist Buddy Plugg.

However, Plugg hanged himself after Soap was dismissive of his medical discipline. Soap fell in love with his second partner Lt. Molly von Richthofen, but was crushed when he discovered she was a lesbian.

The two accidentally caught The Punisher, but he blackmailed his way to freedom with salacious photographs of the mayor and police commissioner.

Inspired by the swindling, Soap blackmailed his way to becoming Police Commissioner but was blackmailed himself with photographs of his time with a prostitute.

Soap’s sex life reached a new low when he unknowingly slept with his possible mother, cheating on her with his potential sister.

Soap crossed the line and worked alongside The Punisher, feeding him confidential information. However, he began to feel responsible for the hundreds of murders which The Punisher committed. After a failed suicide attempt, Soap moved to L.A and, taking advantage of his one lucky grace, found work as a porn star.


6. Daredevil

Daredevil Chip Zdarsky
Marvel Comics / Marco Checchetto

Much of Matt Murdock’s misfortune centres around his secret identity of Daredevil being exposed - a problem which seems to dog him more than any other superhero.

When his civilian identity was first compromised, Matt invented a twin brother, Mike, to take the flack for Daredevil. However, his receptionist and crush Karen Page fell in love with Mike.

After Matt orchestrated a death for his Mike alter-ego, Karen moved to L.A. and became a heroin-addicted porn star. Wilson Fisk took advantage of her situation to learn Daredevil’s identity, using it to destroy the life of Matt Murdock.

Matt was forced to fake his own death and adopt a street thug alias after a tabloid newspaper threatened to out him as Daredevil. Matt returned as himself only to be threatened again with another newspaper exposé. This time he used the judicial system to make the threat vanish.

Matt eventually gave in and revealed himself as Daredevil. Unable to continue his day job, he left New York to practice law in San Francisco.

However, as thanks for saving them from their villainous father Zebediah Killgrave (Purple Man), the Purple Children used their father’s mass hypnosis machine to make the world forget that Matt Murdock was Daredevil - although it'd never last.


5. Magneto

Magneto Marvel
Marvel Comics

Magneto (Max Eisenhardt) is a popular character with fans - however, in-world he is often the brunt of hatred from both sides of the human/mutant divide. Magneto deserves a spot on this list for his horrific childhood during the greatest real-world atrocity of our time, the Holocaust.

Even before his mutant powers were activated, Max was targeted as an outsider, being Jewish in pro-Nazi Germany. He was subjected to anti-Semitic abuse when he was victorious against a German boy in a javelin competition. He was accused of being a cheater, expelled from school, and savagely beaten by other pupils.

Despite the Eisenhardt’s best efforts to escape, the family were captured by Nazi soldiers. Max’s father Jakob saved him from the firing line by pushing him into a pile of corpses unseen.

However, Max was later captured and sent to Auschwitz. To survive he joined the Sonderkommando, assigned with the grim task of cleaning out the crematoria furnaces.

Max reconnected and saved his childhood love Magda. They both escaped Auschwitz and started a family together in Vinnitsa. However, after publicly displaying his mutant powers, the KGB burned down Max’s home with his daughter Anya still inside. His wife fled, leaving Max isolated and consumed with rage - explaining why he turned into the character we know today.


4. Nova

Nova Marvel Movie
Marvel Comics

Nova (Richard Rider) is the superhero equivalent of Sisyphus, the mythological Greek king doomed to eternally roll a rock up a hill only for it to repeatedly fall back down. In Rider’s case, his rock is the Nova Corps, which he must repeatedly recruit for. Nova's misfortune is the Nova Corps and its demands.

Rider had the power and responsibilities of Nova Prime forced randomly upon him by the dying alien Rhomann Dey. Superhero Rider experienced his first colossal dose of misfortune when most of the Nova Corps and the planet Xandar (birthplace to the Corps) where destroyed by the Annihilation Wave.

Instead of rebuilding the Corps, Rider endured further bad luck when he was mortally wounded after colliding with a barrier blocking Kree space from the rest of the universe.

His body was found and healed to health, however, the during the recovery process Rider was infected with the Phalanx Transmode virus, which, for a time, made him a slave of the Phalanx.

Nova eventually restored the Nova Corps to its former numbers, however, when he was otherwise occupied, the Corps were completely wiped out by the Universal Church of Truth, an alien religious empire who worship the Magnus, Adam Warlock’s evil future self.


3. X-23

X23 doing her thing
Marvel Comics

The root of X-23’s misfortune is the perception of her as less than human, which prevents her from having a normal life.

X-23 was created by splicing a sample of Weapon X’s Y chromosome with the genetic material of Dr. Sarah Kinney. As Sarah did this without permission, Martin Sutter, the head of the Facility, forced her to give birth to X-23.

Sarah made efforts to treat X-23 as a child. However, it was futile, as her Facility colleagues saw her as a lethal weapon and a lab rat. This othering was used to validate subjecting her to radiation poisoning and agonising experimentation.

Her humanity was further erased by conditioning her to a trigger scent, which caused her to become an animalistic killer. This was used to force X-23 to blindly kill Sarah. The final act of X-23’s mother was to name her Laura.

She escaped and found the normality she sought in a new life with her mother’s sisters. However, the Facility again tried to manipulate Laura using the trigger scent. She was able to save her new family, but realised staying put their lives in danger.

After a harrowing life in New York as a homeless prostitute, Laura ultimately sided with the X-Men. However, her trauma still haunts her.


2. Jason Todd

Batman Jason Todd Death
DC Comics

Jason Todd, the second Robin, is a character who has experienced bad luck so severe that his prominent origin stories are loaded with more woe than most full lives.

Pre-Crisis Todd was the son of murdered acrobats. His parents died helping original Robin Dick Grayson deal with Killer Croc, who was extorting their employer’s circus.

Post-Crisis Jason Todd was again orphaned though in a much grittier series of events. His mother died of an overdose and his father, a petty crook, was slain by Two-Face. Without Dick Grayson to act as a link between Jason Todd and Bruce Wayne, the jaded youth was left to a life of street crime.

After much struggle on the streets of Gotham, Todd came into Bruce Wayne’s life when, in a bold move with little reward, he was caught attempting to steal the Batmobile’s tires.

As the second Robin, Todd was caught in The Joker’s bomb blast and readers were able to vote for his fate. The character endured the ultimate meta-indignity when fans voted in favour of his death. Years later after Superboy-Prime’s meddling with reality resurrected Todd, he went on to become villain/anti-hero Red Hood, his misfortune meaning he could never be a clean-cut superhero.


1. Spider-Man

Spider-Man Spot
Marvel Comics

Without the advantages of superpowers, Peter Parker’s life would be an unmitigated tragedy. As a child, Peter was orphaned when his CIA agent parents, Richard and Mary Parker, were killed by Red Skull and falsely accused of treason. He was raised by his Uncle Ben and Aunt May.

Soon after gaining powers he experienced great tragedy. Wrapped up in his new-found fame as Spider-Man, Peter refused to get involved in an incident outside a TV studio, however, the criminal who escaped murdered Ben during a home invasion.

Peter’s life would continue to become complicated when his arch-nemesis the Green Goblin turned out to be Norman Osborn, his best friend Harry’s father. It was Osborn who killed Peter’s first love Gwen Stacy. It was later revealed that Gwen cheated on Peter with Osborn and had given birth to his twin children.

Peter’s enduring romantic relationship was with Mary Jane Watson. Though the geek got the girl, Peter and Mary Jane’s relationship was also laced with misfortune. The two married and tried for a child. Mary Jane became pregnant, but the couple’s child was stillborn. Peter later sacrificed his marriage, when in a bargain with Mephisto, he wiped the marriage from history to save Aunt May’s life.


Watch Next


Marvel Quiz: How Well Do You ACTUALLY Know Spider-Man?

Amazing Spider-Man 102
Marvel Comics

1. In Which Comic Did Spider-Man Make His Debut?

In this post: 
Spider-Man
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

An English Lit. MA Grad trying to validate my student debt by writing literary fiction and alternative non-fiction.